Dragon Blade Blu-ray Review
天将雄师 Tian Jiang Xiong Shi
Score: 65
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Dragon Blade dazzles with superb action and top-notch A/V quality, yet stumbles with a clumsy narrative and mixed character performances, making it best for rental.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Dragon Blade's Blu-ray presentation features a sharp 1080p transfer with impressive detail, though it highlights some weak CGI and green screen work. The color grading offers a mostly natural palette, enhanced by strong contrast and black levels, but the lack of 3D depth in certain scenes results in a flat viewing experience.
Audio: 74
Dragon Blade's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track offers immersive and dynamic soundscapes with robust LFE and precise effects, although dialogue can occasionally feel flat or canned. Despite these minor drawbacks, the overall balance, clear score, and battle recreations enhance the auditory experience significantly.
Extra: 47
The Blu-ray extras for 'Dragon Blade' offer a comprehensive package with standard EPK behind-the-scenes footage (21:28), extended interviews (56:13) providing deeper insights, two music videos ('Song of Peace’ 3:14, 'Tell The Wind To Bring My Father Home’ 4:10), and the film’s trailer (2:02) all in HD.
Movie: 40
Dragon Blade offers grand battle sequences and impressive fight choreography, but its modern dialogue, frequent jump cuts, and lackluster storyline create a jarring and ultimately mediocre historical epic.
Video: 74
Dragon Blade's Blu-ray video presentation, as provided by Lionsgate Films, offers a commendable AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. Captured digitally with Red Epic cameras, the film generally boasts sharpness and clarity, although some CGI and green screen sequences appear relatively soft and lack detail. Wide vistas, presumably computer-generated, appear to lack extensive fine detail and often assume an Impressionistic look in close-up backgrounds. Despite these anomalies, the image quality stands out with fine details prominently displayed on elements such as fur textures and filigreed armor work.
The color palette adheres largely to a yellow and blue grade, though it maintains a relatively natural look that enhances the overall detail. Contrast is consistent with rich black levels that do not suffer from image instability. The digital capture results in strong clarity with facial features, costumes, and set designs appearing particularly impressive. Colors tend to skew toward warm tones without disrupting primary accuracy or altering flesh tones.
Depth, while generally well-managed, at times lacks the immersive quality typically expected from a film designed for 3D viewing, rendering some scenes oddly flat. However, the overall presentation retains a smooth motion with no noticeable blurring. Black levels achieve a rich inky tone, though certain scenes still do not fully leverage depth. Cleanliness in the encoding process minimizes noise and artifacts, further ensuring a high-quality presentation.
Audio: 74
The audio presentation of "Dragon Blade" on Blu-ray offers a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, primarily in English with occasional Mandarin elements. The soundtrack excels with its impressive low-frequency effects (LFE), immersing listeners from the outset. Action sequences are particularly engaging, with realistic sound effects such as bone crunches and clashing steel, enhancing the viewing experience. Henry Lai's score is well-rendered, maintaining clarity and precision, and the track boasts a wide dynamic range without any notable issues.
However, while the fight sequences and action moments are sonically captivating and immersive, the dialogue reproduction exhibits a slight inconsistency. While dialogue is mostly crisp and clean, some moments suffer from a flatness that detracts from the overall experience. Despite this minor drawback, the mix maintains an excellent balance between vocals, effects, and music. The surround sound presentation is effective, with rear speakers providing ambiance and occasional discrete contributions, while front speakers deliver the action with precise placement. Overall, this track provides an engaging auditory experience with only minor imperfections in dialogue clarity.
Extras: 47
The extras included in the Blu-ray of "Dragon Blade" offer an extensive look behind the scenes, featuring a standard yet informative electronic press kit (EPK) with contributions from cast and crew. The "Behind the Scenes of Dragon Blade" provides a solid 21-minute journey into the making of the film, complete with interesting proclamations from Jackie Chan. The package is complemented by two music videos, offering a musical depth to the cinematic experience. Additionally, the extended interviews delve deeper into conversations with the cast and crew, showcasing content that didn’t make it to the main EPK. Lastly, the presentation includes the official trailer, wrapping up a comprehensive suite of extras that enhance the overall viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
Behind the Scenes of Dragon Blade: A standard EPK with interviews and behind-the-scenes footage. Song of Peace Music Video: Musical performance tied to the film's theme. Please Tell the Wind to Bring My Father Home Music Video: Another thematic music video. Extended Interviews with Cast/Crew: In-depth discussions that expand on the EPK content. Dragon Blade Trailer: Official promotional trailer for the film.
Movie: 40
"Dragon Blade" presents a curious confluence of historical epic and modern cinematic sensibilities, but suffers from a narrative and technical execution that feels disjointed and, at times, forced. The film's premise, centering on the Silk Road Protection Squad led by Huo An (Jackie Chan), is compelling on paper, with Chan tasked with maintaining peace on this critical trade route. However, plot inconsistencies and underdeveloped scenes detract from the overall experience. The involvement of Roman characters, especially John Cusack's Lucius and Adrien Brody's Tiberius, introduces an anachronistic element that is neither fully embraced nor artfully integrated into the historical setting. Cusack's contemporary demeanor and dialog clash with the ancient backdrop, as does Brody's overly theatrical performance.
The opening sequences of "Dragon Blade" attempt to set the stage for a grand historical saga but fall short due to erratic editing and abrupt scene transitions. These jump cuts render the initial segments almost incomprehensible, requiring viewers to mentally juggle timelines and character motivations without sufficient context. Following Huo An's banishment to Goose Gate – a large but under-resourced fortress – the narrative stabilizes slightly, though it remains peppered with unexplained phenomena and thinly sketched relationships. For instance, Huo An's interaction with his wife lacks depth, reducing potentially pivotal emotional beats to mere footnotes.
While the film does deliver impressive battle scenes and showcases Jackie Chan’s trademark fight choreography, these highlights are overshadowed by a disjointed plot and uneven performances. The elaborate costumes and grandiose set designs initially dazzle but quickly lose their allure as narrative coherence wanes. "Dragon Blade" might have benefitted from tighter editing and a more focused storyline, particularly in elucidating the coalition between the Roman legion and the Chinese forces. Though it strives to offer a captivating historical tale, it ultimately settles into mediocrity, frustrating viewers seeking either a serious epic or a cohesive action adventure.
Total: 65
"Dragon Blade" is a film with an intriguing premise that explores the alliance between two warrior classes against a common foe. Jackie Chan's performance is commendably subdued, adding depth to his character, while John Cusack matches this restraint. Conversely, Adrien Brody's portrayal falls flat, failing to provide a believable antagonist. The film, packed with stunning visuals and meticulously staged action sequences, showcases its intent to be more than a mere spectacle, yet suffers from an erratic edit that creates narrative disjunctions.
From a technical perspective, the Blu-ray release shines materially. Lionsgate delivers a robust audio-visual experience that does justice to the film's impressive cinematography and dynamic fight choreography. The inclusion of supplemental materials, such as over an hour of interviews and additional features, provides an engaging dive into the film's production. However, it must be noted that Dragon Blade was originally designed for 3D viewing, leaving the 2D presentation feeling somewhat lacking.
In conclusion, "Dragon Blade" is entertaining but struggles to elevate beyond mediocre due to its unwieldy narrative. While martial arts enthusiasts and Jackie Chan fans might find enjoyment, it’s not an essential addition to your collection. The Blu-ray is a visual and auditory treat but recommended as a rental or stream before considering a purchase at a discounted rate.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
While sequences have been put through the color grading mill (once again yellow and blue�are no other tones available?), in terms of how many historical epics and/or action adventure films tend to look...
Audio: 90
While Dragon Blade's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is identified as being in both Mandarin and English on the Blu-ray menu, for all intents and purposes this is an English language film, with...
Extras: 40
"Song of Peace" Music Video (1080p; 3:14) "Please Tell the Wind to Bring My Father Home" Music Video (1080p; 4:10) Extended Interviews with Cast/Crew (1080p; 56:13)...
Movie: 50
While An is out on the Silk Road trying to tamp down any simmering disputes, his wife works as a teacher where a gaggle of incredibly cute children are taught to sing a song in Mandarin, evidently a gambit...
Total: 50
Dragon Blade has an admirable thesis in its depiction of two potential warrior classes working together to overcome a common enemy, but the film seems to have been almost clumsily edited at times, leaving...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
This is a film that has the look and design for 3D with objects and people flying right at the screen complete with cheap looking CGI effects to make the film look bigger and deeper along the Z axis than...
Audio: 80
Overall the track is pretty fantastic, but the hollowness to some of the dialogue really stands out for me....
Extras: 60
So there is actually a great deal of content here that didn't make it to the final version of the Behind the Scenes of 'Dragon Blade' extra feature....
Movie: 40
Jackie Chan, for a while anyway, tries to make the film feel like a formal piece of history, but by the time some kung-fu hokum is called for, all pretenses are thrown out the window....
Total: 60
The confusing story structure doesn't help, but seeing as how this film was clearly designed for 3D, I'm having a tough time saying that I've truly experienced this film with this 2D only presentation....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
There are some impressive moments of 3 dimensional looks in the film that come across quite well even in 2D. Movements are smooth and waiver between natural and cinematic....
Audio: 90
Surround Sound Presentation: Rear speakers mainly promote ambiance, but there are some moments where its allowed its own contributions....
Extras: 50
Behind The Scenes Of Dragon Blade (HD, 21:28) – A standard EPK look behind the scenes of the films with the typical generic interviews and behind the scenes footage....
Movie: 40
Which is a bummer, because the performers are pretty solid here and some of the battle scenes are actually impressive to a degree....
Total: 60
I wanted to Dragon Blade to be at least B-level entertainment…and here and there it does satisfy, but overall is a mediocre experience with three performers I enjoy....
Director: Daniel Lee
Actors: Jackie Chan, John Cusack, Adrien Brody
PlotIn ancient China during the Han Dynasty, Huo An, a commander of the Silk Road Protection Squad, is framed for a crime he didn't commit and sent to a labor camp to rebuild a deteriorating city. As Huo An and his men work to restore the city, a Roman legion led by General Lucius comes seeking shelter. The two groups initially clash, but eventually form an uneasy alliance driven by mutual respect and common interests.
The alliance faces a formidable threat as Tiberius, a treacherous Roman leader, advances with a massive force to seize control of the Silk Road. Huo An and Lucius must unite their troops and strategies to protect the region from impending doom. Their bond is tested by cultural differences, but they strive to maintain peace in the face of overwhelming odds. The fate of their respective nations hangs in the balance as their actions shape the course of history along the Silk Road.
Writers: Daniel Lee
Release Date: 04 Sep 2015
Runtime: 127 min
Rating: R
Country: China, Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin, English, Latin