Bob the Gambler 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 81
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
An essential Jean-Pierre Melville classic, 'Bob le Flambeur' shines with a stellar 4K restoration and powerful DTS-HD MA audio—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
Video: 86
Kino Lorber's 4K UHD release of "Bob le Flambeur" showcases StudioCanal's 4K restoration magnificently, revealing razor-sharp details and exceptional contrast from the original 35mm negative despite the absence of HDR or Dolby Vision. The native 4K clarity notably enhances grayscale, fluidity, and visual tightness, making it a highly recommended upgrade for large screen enthusiasts.
Audio: 89
Bob the Gambler's 4K UHD audio presentation delivers a crisp, clear French DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono mix, maintaining excellent fidelity and dialogue clarity throughout. Accompanied by a noirish jazz score and optional English subtitles, it’s an immersive yet restrained audio experience.
Extra: 57
Despite limited special features, Nick Pinkerton's detailed commentary and Dominique Maillet's engaging documentary, 'Diary of a Villain', offer insightful explorations of Melville's visual style and the era of Bob le Flambeur, supplemented by a selection of vintage trailers.
Movie: 87
Bob le Flambeur, a landmark precursor to French New Wave, artfully balances noir and realism with its stylish portrayal of a gambler's heist. The 4K UHD Blu-ray from Kino Lorber delivers an authentic experience with enhanced visuals and audio, bringing Jean-Pierre Melville's masterful merging of cinematic styles to new life.
Video: 86
Kino Lorber's 4K UHD release of "Bob le Flambeur" is a technological marvel, presenting a masterful reproduction of StudioCanal’s meticulous restoration from the original 35mm camera negative. Despite the absence of HDR or Dolby Vision grading, this 4K Blu-ray offers exceptional visual fidelity that significantly surpasses its Blu-ray predecessor. The razor-sharp details coupled with the preservation of natural film grain elevate the viewing experience, notably enhancing classical noir elements such as the stark contrast between light and shadow. Blacks are deep and inky, maintaining integrity across scenes with minimal technical aberrations. Henri Decae’s cinematography shines through with exquisite clarity, making this possibly the most visually striking iteration of the film on home video.
The absence of HDR does not detract from the UHD experience; in fact, the 4K transfer effectively captures all the nuances of the original cinematography. With a wonderfully maintained grayscale and fluid motion, the native 4K presentation offers a uniform cinematic experience devoid of encoding anomalies. Textures such as clothing are rendered with remarkable detail, while scenes involving fades and dissolves remain consistent, showing slightly increased grain to retain authenticity. Occasional shifts in gamma or dynamic range are noted but these are intrinsic characteristics of the source material rather than faults.
For aficionados of film noir or those with a penchant for Melville’s work, especially on large screens of 85 inches or more, upgrading to this 4K UHD release is highly recommended. The presentation's fidelity to the original 35mm quality, coupled with an absence of distracting visual noise, ensures that "Bob le Flambeur" looks mesmerizingly pristine and stable throughout. This release underscores the unmatched appeal of physical media through its exemplary attention to detail and respectful homage to its cinematic roots.
Audio: 89
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Bob the Gambler" presents an audio experience encapsulated in a French DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track. This mono mix is front-focused, ensuring dialogue clarity, with a rich deepness that captures the film's noirish jazz score. Despite being a 2.0 monaural mix, the sound quality is exceptional, with foley effects maintaining a solid fidelity. The subtleties of the soundscape are preserved, although dynamic intensity is naturally subdued given the original sound design of the film. The optional English subtitles are beneficial for non-French speakers, though they could benefit from a slightly larger font.
Audio performance is both clean and stable, engaging those familiar with the original soundtrack from its previous Blu-ray release. The jazz score’s haunting horn solos and rhythmic bass are well-pronounced, resonating effectively during tense sequences. The balance of sound leaves dialogue prominent and unaffected by the action elements, highlighting the careful and precise mixing that was applied. This ensures that viewers can appreciate the narrative-driven aspects without distraction from dialogues or ambient sounds.
Kino Lorber has maintained a consistent quality in their audio presentation from earlier Blu-ray editions to this 4K upgrade. Listeners can expect an immersive and authentic experience that mirrors the film's initial auditory intentions. While improvements could potentially be made in subtitle presentation, the overall audio production captures the essence and ambiance intended by the original release, lending an authentic layer to the viewing experience of "Bob the Gambler."
Extras: 57
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Bob the Gambler" offers a compelling collection of extras that enrich the viewing experience with historical and analytical perspectives. The standout feature is the audio commentary by film critic Nick Pinkerton, which is rich with factual insights into the film's locations, visual style, and enduring appeal, as well as the career of Jean-Pierre Melville and his collaborators. This commentary was originally recorded for Kino Lorber's 2019 release. Additionally, "Diary of a Villain," a documentary by Dominique Maillet, delves into the era of the film's creation and the life of Roger Duchesne, featuring a substantial interview with writer Thierry Crifo. A vintage French theatrical trailer with imposed English subtitles rounds out the offering, alongside trailers for other classic films.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Informative insights by Nick Pinkerton.
- Diary of a Villain: Documentary about the film’s creation and Roger Duchesne.
- Theatrical Trailer: Vintage French trailer with English subtitles.
- Other Trailers: Includes trailers for Le Doulos, Touchez Pas au Grisbi, Razzia sur la chnouf, and Alphaville.
Movie: 87
Jean-Pierre Melville's "Bob le Flambeur" arrives on 4K UHD Blu-ray with a compelling blend of narrative style and cinematic legacy, establishing it as a cornerstone in the evolution of French cinema. This film is lauded for its contributions to both film noir and the impending French New Wave. It showcases Melville's distinctive approach to storytelling: blending atmospheric noir elements with a handshake of realism that effectively humanizes its characters. The protagonist, Bob Montagne, played by Roger Duchesne, epitomizes Melville's concept of 'cool.' Bob's stylish veneer is crafted through impeccably tailored suits and an insatiable gambling habit that teeter between calculated risk and inevitable ruin, against the backdrop of Paris' shadowy undertones and neon-lit allure.
This cinematic work is a tapestry woven from dual narratives—on one side, Bob commands an air of success and on the other, he faces financial desolation, prompting a high-stakes plan to heist a Deauville casino. The film’s intricate planning sequences reveal Melville's mastery of tension and detail, as we watch Bob's diligent crew rehearse meticulously on a chalk-drawn floor plan. These technicalities showcase the filmmaker’s dedication to realism and narrative depth, transforming the heist into an exhilarating dance of chance and fate. Henri Decae's cinematography further enhances this dynamic by utilizing natural lighting to merge noir-ish shadows with verité footage, imbuing the film with a haunting yet immersive authenticity.
"Bob le Flambeur" sets itself apart not just through its stylistic finesse but through its influence on future filmmakers like Michael Mann and the Safdie Brothers. It's a film that thrives on its character-driven plot, exhibiting a rich, contrasting blend of tension and elegance akin to Melville’s celebrated later works. This release by Kino Lorber offers both 4K UHD and 1080p Blu-ray editions, underpinning the film's enduring stature in cinematic history while providing a pristine visual experience befitting its classic status.
Total: 81
Kino Lorber Studio Classics' 4K UHD release of "Bob le Flambeur" presents Jean-Pierre Melville's influential film in a remarkably vivid restoration. This newly available 4K Blu-ray/Blu-ray combo pack showcases StudioCanal's meticulous 4K restoration, offering cinephiles the chance to experience the film as never before. The video presentation is near immaculate, capturing the film’s noir aesthetics with exceptional clarity and depth. Colors appear rich, and the contrast is finely tuned, enhancing the film’s atmospheric visuals. Meanwhile, the audio has been encoded in DTS-HD MA, delivering dialogue and score with crisp precision.
Accompaniments to this stellar presentation include limited but meaningful supplementary materials. Though few in number, the audio commentary and documentary provide invaluable insights for both enthusiasts and newcomers. These features supplement the viewing experience by contextualizing Melville’s enduring influence on subsequent French films about gamblers, making this release as informative as it is entertaining.
Conclusively, this restored "Bob le Flambeur" fits seamlessly into the legacy of must-own classic crime films. Melville's narrative and stylistic approach laid the groundwork for countless others, typified by the signature 'cool' of his characters that continues to leave an indelible mark on cinema. With its technical brilliance and valuable supplementary contents, this Kino Lorber Studio Classics release is highly recommended for all collectors and fans of French cinema alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
Yes, this should not be surprising considering how impressive the 4K makeover looked in 1080p as well, but in native 4K the strengths of the 4K makeover become even more apparent and easier to appreciate....
Audio: 100
...
Extras: 70
There is an abundance of factual information here about the different locations that Bob le Flambeur visits, its visual style and tone (as well as the film's lasting appeal), the careers of Jean-Pierre...
Movie: 100
What this means is that Melville trades the conventional cinematic glamour and stylization for a distinctly low-key street vibe -- which by the way is the exact reason why some critics have argued in the...
Total: 90
Some tweak a few things here and there, but the influence of Melville's classic film is always incredibly easy to recognize....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Details are razor sharp and natural film grain is noticeable throughout, particularly in shots with lots of white space....
Audio: 80
This is going to be a front-only presentation on the soundstage, but it’s a great mix, frequently punctuated with a noirish jazz score, and a thumping bass pumping like a heart during the film’s more tense...
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 80
As a tweener, in between cinematic languages, it embraces both the noirish exaggeration of shadows, like a piece of German Expressionism, but also the handheld cinéma verité style cinematography to ground...
Total: 80
While the supplements themselves are small in number, the audio commentary track and documentary are great additions for this release....
Home Theater Forum review by Patrick McCartRead review here
Video: 90
Even during opticals like fades and dissolves, the image only looks a little more grainy and soft....
Audio: 100
Kino Lorber keeps the same DTS-HD MA 2.0 French monaural track from the 2019 Blu-ray, which already sounded excellent....
Extras: 70
The remaining supplements are included on the reprint of the 2019 Blu-ray: Diary of a Villain (25:45 HD) – Collection of interviews with filmmakers and writers discussing Bob le flambeur and Melville’s...
Movie: 90
While I think this is the work of someone who was about to make even greater films, this is still one of his signature films....
Total: 90
Bob Le Flambeur is one of the essential early Jean-Pierre Melville films, with a gorgeous 4K restoration now available in UHD....
Director: Jean-Pierre Melville
Actors: Roger Duchesne, Isabelle Corey, Daniel Cauchy
PlotBob, a suave and aging gambler with a code of personal honor, is well-known in the seedy underworld of Paris. Living in Montmartre, he spends his nights in casinos and his days planning his next big score. Despite his criminal past, he has an air of respectability and is admired by many in his circle. Bob's luck has been poor lately, and he finds himself needing a substantial win to maintain his lifestyle. One evening, he learns of a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity: the impending transfer of a vast sum of money at the Deauville casino. Enticed by the idea of pulling off one final heist, he begins meticulously planning the robbery with help from his loyal protégé, Paulo, and a young wayward girl named Anne, who becomes entwined in their scheme.
As Bob assembles his team and lays out the intricate details of the heist, he ensures that every aspect of the plan is flawless. However, tensions rise within the group as doubts and suspicions grow, complicating their collaboration. Unbeknownst to Bob, the police are closing in, aware of his potential involvement in criminal activities. Meanwhile, his rivals in the underworld are also keeping a close watch, eager to see him fall from grace. The pressure mounts as they approach the fateful night when everything will come to a head at the Deauville casino. The success or failure of the heist hinges on split-second decisions and trust among thieves, leading up to an inevitable confrontation governed by fate and chance.
Writers: Jean-Pierre Melville, Auguste Le Breton
Release Date: N/A
Runtime: 98 min
Rating: PG
Country: France
Language: French, English