The Orphanage Blu-ray Review
El Orfanato
Score: 68
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Orphanage: A visually stunning, genuinely creepy film acclaimed for its superb AV quality.
Disc Release Date
Video: 66
The Orphanage Blu-ray thrills with a majestic VC-1 transfer, flaunting crisp details and vibrant yet somber colors, while minor flaws barely detract from its visual glory.
Audio: 76
The Orphanage' Blu-ray elevates its chilling tale with a spellbinding Spanish DTS HD MA 7.1 soundtrack, praised for its realism, detailed ambience, and dynamic depth, setting a new standard for horror audio excellence.
Extra: 53
The Orphanage Blu-ray offers a modest array of SD extras detailing its making, effects, and design with candid insights and a plethora of stills, but lacks the depth of other New Line releases.
Movie: 80
The Orphanage is a masterful, emotionally gripping Spanish horror film that emphasizes atmosphere over gore, led by an outstanding Belén Rueda, blending classic horror with deep emotional impact.
Video: 66
The Blu-ray transfer of "The Orphanage" has been eagerly anticipated, and it certainly does not disappoint, delivering a breathtaking high-definition experience. With a meticulous 2.35:1 and 2.36 aspect ratio VC-1 encoding, the visual presentation is both lavish and striking, capturing the intricate details of the orphanage's interiors and the hauntingly beautiful Spanish countryside with a clarity that enhances the movie's atmospheric tension. Fine details, such as the texture of wood grain, stonework, and the eerie ghostly sackcloth masks, are rendered with exceptional sharpness, bringing a palpable sense of realism to the fore. The film's subdued color palette, dominated by autumnal tones, is well-saturated, ensuring that when brighter colors do appear, they pop with vitality against the generally somber backgrounds.
The Blu-ray showcases the film's deliberate cinematography exquisitely, respecting the original Kodak film source's integrity with just the right amount of fine grain to maintain its cinematic feel. The transfer excels in handling challenging lighting conditions, from the murky depths of a cave entrance to the intense darkness of the orphanage at night, without succumbing to crush or losing detail in shadows. Black levels are described as "inkily" profound, providing a solid foundation for contrast that keeps the boundary between light and dark defined and sacred.
However, no transfer is without its flaws. Minor instances of banding and slight edge enhancement were noted, particularly in scenes where the vast sky contrasts sharply with darker foreground elements. These issues are minor and likely to be noticed only by those with large displays. Despite these negligible distractions, the overall quality of this Blu-ray release is undeniable. It preserves the film’s ominous atmosphere and visual depth, making it a compelling upgrade from the standard DVD version and a must-have for fans of this suspenseful horror masterpiece.
Audio: 76
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Orphanage" stands as a testament to the auditory masterpiece this film has become, capturing the very essence of its theatrical sound design with a stunning Spanish DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track. This rendition not only matches but surpasses the original cinema experience, delivering an audial feast that borders on the surreal. The mix's clarity, sharpness, and naturalism are nothing short of breathtaking, harnessing every channel to immerse the viewer in a constant state of ambience peppered with detailed sounds ranging from ghostly whispers to thunderous roars. The soundscape is aggressive, leveraging deep, rumbling bass that adds an awe-inspiring depth, making even the most mundane actions like the closing of a door feel cataclysmic. This level of detail extends thorough, with every sound effect meticulously placed to enhance the film's haunting atmosphere.
Technically, the audio track excels in realism and three-dimensionality, with a noteworthy dynamic range that brings out fine details without ever compromising on its eerie tone. Interior scenes feature nuanced acoustics that make whispers and distant noises all the more unsettling, while outdoor scenes offer a rich tapestry of environmental sounds that build upon the film's chilling narrative. Fernando Velázquez's lush score is given the treatment it deserves, presented with warmth and clarity that complements the film's emotional heft perfectly. Dialogue remains crisp and perfectly balanced against the backdrop of this sonic marvel, ensuring that every whispered word contributes to the overall impact.
Importantly, the audio quality maintains its integrity throughout, free from any dubbed distractions, preserving the original Spanish performances that add to the authenticity and emotional gravity of the film. Subtitles are thoughtfully provided for non-Spanish speakers, ensuring that the film’s potent mix of sound and visual storytelling is accessible to all. The DTS HD MA track sets new standards for horror audio presentation, underpinning the narrative with a solid foundation of auditory cues that elevate the suspense and terror to unprecedented levels. With such a commitment to audio excellence, "The Orphanage" Blu-ray effectively becomes an essential benchmark for future releases, offering an immersive experience that is as close as one can get to reliving the movie in a theatrical setting.
Extras: 53
The Blu-ray extras for "The Orphanage" present a comprehensive, albeit not overly abundant, suite of special features that delve into various facets of the film's creation, from conception to execution. Standout components include an 18-minute making-of documentary, "When Laura Grew Up: Constructing The Orphanage," which provides insightful commentary from the cast and crew, including Guillermo del Toro, discussing the script, story, casting, and technical aspects like cinematography. "Tomás' Secret Room: The Filmmakers," split into five segments, and other features such as "Horror in the Unknown: Makeup Effects" and "Rehearsal Studio," alongside the Still Gallery in 1080p and Marketing Campaign contents, add depth to this array. While these features are mostly presented in standard definition, they enrich the viewing experience by offering behind-the-scenes looks and demonstrating the meticulous efforts behind the hauntingly beautiful film. The disc strikes a good balance between technical insights and artistic behind-the-scenes explorations, even if it doesn’t push the envelope in terms of supplemental volume or innovation.
Extras included in this disc:
- When Laura Grew Up: Constructing The Orphanage: In-depth making-of featurette with comments by cast and crew including Guillermo del Toro.
- Tomás' Secret Room: The Filmmakers: Five-part series detailing directorial vision, scoring, art direction, visual effects, and title sequence creation.
- Horror In The Unknown: Makeup Effects: A look at the prosthetics and makeup effects used in the film.
- Rehearsal Studio: Glimpses into cast read-throughs and rehearsals.
- Still Gallery: High-definition photographs covering cast, makeup effects, set design and locations, black and white photography, production, and conceptual art.
- Marketing Campaign: Includes Spanish and US teasers and trailers, plus a collection of high-definition theatrical poster designs.
Movie: 80
"The Orphanage," directed by Juan Antonio Bayona in his directorial debut and presented by the renowned Guillermo del Toro, emerges as a beacon of horror, ingeniously weaving suspense, emotion, and an atmospheric narrative that distinguishes itself in the modern cinematic landscape. Set against the haunting backdrop of a seemingly idyllic but ultimately cursed orphanage in Spain, the film traces the harrowing journey of Laura (Belén Rueda) and her family as they confront the eerie past and unsettling present of their new home. Unlike the mainstream horror genre’s recent preoccupation with gore and shock tactics, "The Orphanage" opts for a refined, character-driven approach that delves deep into psychological terror and the unyielding bond between a mother and her missing son.
Bayona's film is a masterclass in suspense-building, leveraging its rich storyline, stellar performances – particularly from Rueda – and minimalistic yet effective use of special effects to craft a deeply unsettling experience. The movie's atmosphere is thick with gloom, achieved through meticulous cinematography and a narrative that skillfully oscillates between reality and the supernatural. Geraldine Chaplin’s performance, in a particularly haunting role, further amplifies the film's ability to keep audiences on the edge of their seats. Far from relying on cheap scares, "The Orphanage" excels in creating a pervasive sense of dread that is as emotionally resonant as it is terrifying.
At its core, "The Orphanage" is not just a ghost story but a poignant exploration of loss, mourning, and maternal love. It challenges viewers by invoking real fears - the disappearance of a child, the unraveling of past mysteries, and the confrontation with what lies beyond death - all while maintaining a heartfelt connection to its characters. The nuanced portrayal of Laura’s descent into desperation transcends typical horror tropes, offering instead a narrative rich with thematic depth and visual subtleties. This cinematic venture does not seek to merely scare but to move and disturb, leaving an indelible mark on its audience through its thoughtful blend of horror and human emotion.
Total: 68
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Orphanage" combines superior audiovisual quality with a curated selection of extras to enrich the viewing experience. The centerpiece of this edition is its outstanding AV transfer, which has been universally lauded for its sublime picture quality—described as highly detailed and pin-sharp. Complementing this is the audio presentation, embodying a perfect execution of sound design that enhances the film's eerie atmosphere. While the extras, including galleries and behind-the-scenes snippets, may not break new ground, they deliver sufficient entertainment value and insight into the film's production. This release encapsulates the essence of "The Orphanage," a film that excels in reinvigorating classic horror sensibilities with modern execution, making it an indispensable addition to the collections of genre aficionados and cinephiles alike.
"The Orphanage" is more than a conventional ghost story; it elevates the narrative with its unique style, attention to detail, and a mature approach to horror that resonates with adult viewers. Its psychological depth and the haunting possibilities it explores set it apart from typical genre entries. Despite some criticism towards the Blu-ray package's extras as slightly lacking in diversity, the overall presentation ensures a riveting home cinema experience. The film's potent mix of suspense, horror, and emotional depth is rendered with technical excellence, making each viewing a delve into its meticulously crafted world.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray release of "The Orphanage" stands as a testament to how a film can be transformed into an even more immersive and enthralling experience through meticulous attention to audiovisual detail. It may not redefine the horror genre, but it elevates it through a combination of storytelling finesse and technical prowess. Whether revisiting or discovering anew, viewers are guaranteed a captivating cinematic journey into fear and beyond. This release merits strong recommendation for its ability to marry content and quality so seamlessly, ensuring "The Orphanage" endures as a staple in the realm of psychological horror.
avforums review by Chris McEneanyRead review here
Video: 90
And, thankfully, having also seen the SD edition of the film, there isn't the same element of crushing going on that the other version seems to have, with detail in the shadows readily held up for inspection...
Audio: 100
Footsteps, chinks of glass and door latches, unseen motion around the house - such as the workers at the start, for instance, with their shouting and their hammering - and, of course, the utterly marvellous...
Extras: 70
But, despite this and a large degree of both back-slapping and film clips to illustrate it, this actually covers quite a lot of ground in its brief running time....
Movie: 90
The story may not be all that original - indeed, you'd be hard-pushed to find a ghost story that is nowadays - but it is carried so successfully by mood, characterisation and such barnstorming set-pieces...
Total: 90
Wonderful movie, wonderful transfer - whether this is your genre or not, you can't deny that this is pure cinema in a style so ravishing that even a relatively smaller screen cannot diminish....
Blu-ray.com review by J.C. RiberaRead review here
Video: 90
The magic of film or cinematography brings a glow to beautiful faces, and at the same time, seeing such beautiful faces sharply delineated by the increased definition, even fine facial features that convention...
Audio: 90
I'm a believer of watching films in their original language when possible, even for ones I wouldn't understand a word of it, as that way you hear the original performances and emotion and exactly the same...
Extras: 60
Black and White Photography has 28 images in kind of an almost olive sepia which range from scenes of the movie to back stage and doing SFX, all looking artful as they're in b/w :)....
Movie: 80
I don't think it's as superlative as this might suggest, but it's a solid excellent movie, made in the classical sense, and as a serious ghost/suspense story made to horrify, it achieves its goal in a...
Total: 80
But for The Orphanage, like in sampling any variation of a theme, the glory is in the details or the style and approach it has, and the story it tells, and that makes it a totally different movie, one...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
As for the purists out there who’ve complained about New Line’s use of DNR (Digital Noise Reduction) on their previous Blu-ray releases, you’ll find the film still has a fine veneer of grain that, as best...
Audio: 100
Better still, exterior shots are filled with subtle, environmental details that enhance the tone of the story without cluttering the front channels....
Extras: 40
Tomas’ Secret Room: The Filmmakers (SD, 10 minutes) -- Divided into five chapters, this extension of the behind-the-scenes material explores the director and his crew, the film’s musical score, its art...
Movie: 80
The film oozes atmosphere from beginning to end -- the drab palette, the surreal visualizations of Simon’s imaginary friends, and the film’s fantastic cinematography all work together to generate a creepy...
Total: 80
’The Orphanage’ is a disquieting psychological thriller that delivers horror the way it was meant to be experienced....
Director: J.A. Bayona
Actors: Belén Rueda, Fernando Cayo, Roger Príncep
PlotLaura decides to reopen the old orphanage where she grew up, with the intention of turning it into a home for disabled children. Along with her husband Carlos and their adopted son Simón, she returns to the seemingly idyllic coastal property. Simón, who has a rich imagination and several imaginary friends, quickly makes a new invisible friend, Tomás. As Laura prepares for the reopening, Simón's behavior becomes more erratic and disturbing, leading to tensions within the family. The situation takes a dark turn during the orphanage's opening party, where Simón disappears under mysterious circumstances, leaving Laura distraught and desperate to find her son.
In her quest to uncover the truth about her son's disappearance, Laura delves deeper into the orphanage's past, uncovering long-buried secrets. Her investigation leads her to confront unsettling facts about the home's history and the fate of its former residents. As supernatural occurrences escalate, Laura's resolve is tested, pushing her to the edge of sanity. She becomes ensnared in a chilling mystery, where her love for her son drives her to extreme measures, blurring the lines between reality and the supernatural in her fight to uncover the truth.
Writers: Sergio G. Sánchez
Release Date: 11 Jan 2008
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: R
Country: Spain, Mexico, France, Belgium
Language: Spanish