Casualties of War Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
An emotionally raw and grim war film with strong video and audio, 'Casualties of War' showcases De Palma's deviation from his usual style, making it essential viewing.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
Sony's 1080p Blu-ray of 'Casualties of War' offers a satisfying presentation with minor issues like title wobble and initial soft-focus scenes, but overall delivers crisp detail, accurate skin tones, and balanced colors, all without excessive smoothing, making it a commendable release.
Audio: 77
Casualties of War's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack delivers clear, precise dialogue and energetic, responsive sound elements. Action scenes are immersive with tight bass and strong stage engagement, while lighter atmospheric effects offer commendable positional clarity.
Extra: 56
Sony's Blu-ray release of Casualties of War includes a comprehensive array of supplemental content, notably 'The Making of Casualties of War' and in-depth deleted scenes, all presented in 1080i upscaled quality. Despite lacking a slipcover, the technical and historical insights provided offer an engaging look into the film's production.
Movie: 66
'Casualties of War' finally receives a domestic U.S. Blu-ray release by Sony, offering 1080p video and 5.1 lossless audio with a few special features, positioned among other critically acclaimed Vietnam War films directed by top names like Kubrick and Coppola.
Video: 69
Sony's 1080p Blu-ray release of "Casualties of War" delivers a satisfying video presentation with a few minor flaws. The opening title wobble is noticeable but not particularly distracting. The introductory scene on the bus appears intentionally soft and dreamlike, reflecting Erikkson's introspective view of past events. Initial black levels tend to push blue and appear pale during the opening Vietnam sequence, but they subsequently tighten up, delivering better depth and realism. Daytime Vietnam exteriors, which dominate much of the film, are rendered with agreeable detail. The image impresses with its crispness, revealing complex textures from personal effects like military patches to larger settings such as dense jungles, open fields, and wooden constructs around American bases.
There are no significant issues with grain; the image doesn’t appear overly smoothed or de-grained, ensuring the retention of essential detailing. Colors come through slightly muted but satisfactory, with military fatigues and the various greenery of Vietnam retaining enough depth and diversity. Instances of red blood, fiery explosions, and other sporadic hues beyond the dominant greens are displayed agreeably. Skin tones remain accurate across diverse characters and varying conditions, be it sweat, grime, or stress-induced redness. Despite the absence of direct comparisons to overseas releases, Sony’s presentation stands robust overall, providing a visually pleasing experience with minimal deviations.
Audio: 77
The audio presentation of "Casualties of War" on Blu-ray, featuring a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, is both immersive and assertive, enhancing the film's intensity. The opening mortar barrage sets the stage with substantial thump and expansive spatial presence, complemented by tight, responsive bass that avoids muddiness. During the second battle, gunfire bursts through with sharp surround support, and the ensuing chaos is conveyed with relentless energy and stage engagement. Chapter 11's helicopter assault delivers intense, full-stage immersion, bolstering the film's war-time ferocity. While the action sequences ensure ample low-end impact, more subtle atmospheric effects like falling rain and thunder in chapter 8 are also impressively rendered, enhancing immersion.
Dialogue reproduction is clear and precise, consistently anchored in the front-center channel. This clarity remains unchallenged by the surrounding chaos of battle scenes, ensuring that the narrative remains intelligible. The sound design effectively complements the movie, heightening both the physical turmoil of war and the internal moral conflicts of the characters. The soundtrack may not always achieve total nuance in its lower frequencies, but it maintains a dynamic and engaging auditory landscape throughout.
In addition to the primary English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, optional Spanish and French 5.1 DTS-HD tracks are included, alongside optional English subtitles for all audio options. Collectively, this makes "Casualties of War" a highly enjoyable and technically sound listening experience that significantly augments the film's emotional and dramatic weight.
Extras: 56
Sony's Blu-ray release of "Casualties of War" offers a substantial array of extras predominantly in upscaled 1080i and 1080p formats, maintaining a high level of professional fidelity. However, it lacks a second disc for an extended cut and doesn't include DVD or digital versions. There’s no slipcover included. The supplemental content provides an in-depth exploration into the making of the film, featuring notable interviews and several deleted scenes, all presented within a well-constructed package indeed valuable for film enthusiasts and historians alike. It’s a meticulously curated selection that enhances the viewer’s understanding of the movie’s production and context.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of Casualties of War: An insightful documentary on the production process.
- Eriksson's War - A Conversation with Michael J. Fox: An engaging interview with the lead actor.
- Deleted Scenes: Several scenes that didn’t make the final cut.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer showcasing the film.
Movie: 66
"Casualties of War" has finally made its way to Blu-ray in the United States, transforming a long-awaited expectation into reality. Released by Sony as part of their updated manufactured on demand (MOD) line, the Blu-ray features 1080p high-definition video and 5.1 lossless audio. The disc also includes a few special features, providing a well-rounded media package for collectors and enthusiasts alike. This release follows several international versions, including a 'Premium Edition' in the UK and an extended cut in Germany, underscoring its global appeal and enduring relevance.
Brian De Palma, known for cinematic milestones such as "Scarface," "Dressed to Kill," and "The Untouchables," directs this gripping Vietnam War film with his signature style and directorial excellence. "Casualties of War" shares the stage with other Vietnam War films like "Full Metal Jacket," "Apocalypse Now," "Platoon," and "The Deer Hunter," all of which boast high production values, top-tier acting, and visionary directors. De Palma's foray into this genre not only aligns with these critically acclaimed titles but also stands out with its intense narrative and compelling performances, affirming his stature among the elite directors who have depicted the harrowing realities of war.
Total: 69
Brian De Palma's "Casualties of War" stands as a profound examination of the ramifications of war on both individuals and humanity as a whole. Far removed from traditional escapist cinema, this film delves into dark, emotionally wrenching territory, presenting an unflinchingly grim portrayal of the Vietnam conflict. This is not a film to enjoy in the conventional sense but rather one to appreciate for its raw and devastating depiction of wartime depravity and human suffering. De Palma branches out from his typical thriller/horror niche, delivering a relentless narrative that compels viewers to confront the disturbing realities of war.
Sony's MOD release of "Casualties of War" offers a significantly enhanced high-definition presentation that surpasses previous DVD versions in both video and audio quality. The visual fidelity captures the stark, harrowing imagery with clarity and depth, while the audio mix ensures a powerful auditory experience that complements the film’s intense atmosphere. Additionally, the release includes a modest yet informative array of bonus content, making it an indispensable addition for enthusiasts seeking comprehensive insights into the film's production and thematic elements.
In conclusion, while "Casualties of War" may not be the definitive war film, it is an essential viewing experience for those interested in the genre or in De Palma's oeuvre. The emotional gravity and relentless portrayal of human depravity provide a compelling reason to engage with this film, despite its challenging nature. Sony’s Blu Ray release does justice to this important work with its superior technical presentation, making this edition highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Skin tones appear accurate across a diverse cross-section of characters and in various conditions that render them sweaty, dirty, or red in the face with stress or anger....
Audio: 80
Falling rain is decently immersive in chapter eight, and thunder cracks and rolls with good surrounding positioning during the same scene....
Extras: 60
Clark Testifies (1080i upscaled, window boxed, 1:29), Oahn's Sister's Testimony (1080i upscaled, window boxed, 1:29), Check the Treeline (1080i upscaled, window boxed, 1:10), Hill & Erikson (1080i upscaled,...
Movie: 60
Sony has finally put the film on disc, released as part of a revamped manufactured on demand ('MOD') line of products that no longer bear the controversial 'Choice Collection' nomenclature....
Total: 70
It's difficult to watch but rewarding in terms of how the film presents the worst of war and the worst of man as the two interconnect and so often propel one another in what seems like a hopeless loop...
The Digital Bits review by David SteigmanRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 95
The lossless audio is lively with dialogue coming in loud and clear, while gunfire, explosions, and other action-oriented sounds are exceptionally potent....
Extras: 60
Movie: 80
Movies about the Vietnam War, such as Full Metal Jacket, Apocalypse Now, Platoon, and The Deer Hunter, have all proven to be both critically and financially successful....
Total: 79
While it isn’t his standard fare, which tends to be more in the cult horror/thriller vein, fans should give this one a spin to see his work outside of his usual norm....
Director: Brian De Palma
Actors: Michael J. Fox, Sean Penn, Don Harvey
PlotIn the midst of the Vietnam War, a young and principled soldier named Eriksson is deployed along with his squad in an area rife with danger and moral ambiguity. The squad, led by the hardened and volatile Sergeant Meserve, is torn between their humanity and the dehumanizing effects of prolonged warfare. During a routine patrol, the squad captures a young Vietnamese woman, and Meserve decides to kidnap her for personal gratification under the guise of military necessity. Eriksson strongly objects, sensing the profound violation of ethics, but his protests are ignored by Meserve and the other soldiers.
As tensions escalate, Eriksson finds himself increasingly isolated due to his refusal to conform to the immoral actions of his squadmates. Struggling with his conscience, he faces fierce opposition and hostile threats from his fellow soldiers who feel betrayed by his stance. The brutality of war continues to erode the moral boundaries of the platoon, pushing Eriksson into a harrowing dilemma between duty to both his country and his own moral integrity. His determination to seek justice for the atrocities he witnesses places him on a perilous path, challenging the very fabric of military brotherhood and command structures that demand obedience above all else.
Writers: Daniel Lang, David Rabe
Release Date: 18 Aug 1989
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Vietnamese