Gulliver's Travels Blu-ray Review
Score: 60
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Blu-ray of 'Gulliver's Travels' showcases impressive audio/video quality and ample bonus materials, but the movie itself is widely seen as a dumbed-down, fleeting amusement.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
"Gulliver's Travels" offers a solid 1080p/AVC-encoded Blu-ray transfer with vibrant colors and detailed images. Despite some digital noise in darker scenes and a lack of film-like texture, the visuals remain exceptionally clean with rich hues and firm sharpness. Overall, a satisfying presentation.
Audio: 69
Gulliver's Travels' Blu-ray DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 is balanced, powerful, and immersive, offering clear dialogue and excellent low-frequency effects. While the lack of a 7.1 surround mix as in theaters is noted, the sound design remains engaging with dynamic atmospherics and precise sound placement.
Extra: 50
The Blu-Ray extras for 'Gulliver's Travels' include engaging featurettes on special effects, behind-the-scenes antics with Jack Black, and deleted scenes. Highlights are the faux documentary on the Bermuda Triangle and interactive games, though some content like the gag reel falls short.
Movie: 33
"Gulliver's Travels" on Blu-ray, featuring Jack Black, diverges significantly from Jonathan Swift's satire, leaning heavily on puerile humor and broad pop-culture references. Despite fine set design and special effects, the film substitutes depth and wit for juvenile antics, disappointing fans of the original tale.
Video: 65
The visual presentation of "Gulliver's Travels" on Blu-ray is notably impressive, marked by a 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer that maximizes the vividness of the film's dynamic costumes and diverse environments. High definition detail stands out with firm resolution, crisp edges, and defining sharpness that enhances depth and dimension. The digitally captured photography ensures a whistle-clean appearance, devoid of overtly film-like textures but maintaining strong clarity and fine texture, particularly on facial details and intricate costume patterns. Colors are richly rendered with bright blue skies, vivid fire, and dense foliage greens, contributing to an engaging visual experience. Fleshtones are well-defined, exhibiting intricate gradations across the complexional spectrum of the cast.
The digital cinematography of "Gulliver's Travels" also enables seamless integration of green-screen elements, although occasional noise and some layer inconsistencies in composite shots are noticeable upon close scrutiny. Blacks exhibit a good dynamic range despite occasional spikes in noise during darker scenes, and the overall contrast remains tight with minimal instances of blown-out highlights. The film's CGI work, especially on miniature constructions like the palace and surroundings of Liliput, is showcased meticulously, ensuring it remains appealing without undermining the practical effects.
Ultimately, Fox’s Blu-ray presentation of "Gulliver's Travels" achieves a bright and vibrant visual fidelity that aligns well with the film’s fantastical style. While it occasionally succumbs to typical digital anomalies, such as slightly inconsistent blacks and minor noise levels in dark scenes, these are minimal detractors in an otherwise solid and commendable visual offering.
Audio: 69
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack for "Gulliver’s Travels" on Blu-ray delivers a solid auditory experience with clear, articulated dialogue that is well-positioned across the front channels. Detail reproduction is commendable, enhancing ambient soundscapes and textural nuances even during high action scenes. While the film does not rely heavily on surround sound, the full soundstage is effectively utilized to create an immersive environment. Sound effects are dynamic, palpable, and exhibit excellent range. Low frequency effects, when utilized, offer deep bass that resonantly fills the room.
Although the original theatrical release featured a 7.1 mix, Fox has opted for a standard DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for this Blu-ray. Despite the downgrade, the mix remains balanced and powerful, making extensive use of the rear speakers to enliven Gulliver's world. The soundtrack adeptly handles diverse audio elements, from the bustling newsroom and New York City streets to the roaring jet engine and crashing waves of the cyclone. Notable sonic moments include a naval battle and a robot duel, where vivid cross-channel effects like canon fire and zapping electricity create a highly engaging experience.
Additionally, Henry Jackman's score, while not particularly memorable, benefits from strong sound reproduction, integrating well with the film's rock and funk numbers that showcase the track's dynamic range. Dialogue remains consistently clear and intelligible with no issues of muffling or distortion. Overall, while the absence of the 7.1 mix may disappoint some audiophiles, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track provides an engrossing and dynamic audio presentation that brings "Gulliver’s Travels" to life.
Extras: 50
The Blu-ray edition of "Gulliver's Travels" offers a thorough array of extras that provide both entertainment and insight into the film's production. Highlights include the humorous "I Don't Know...with Lemuel Gulliver," hosted by Jack Black, and the highly enlightening "Little and Large" featurette on visual effects. Fans of Jack Black will appreciate the individual segments where both he and Jason Segel discuss their characters. Deleted scenes give additional context to the story, while behind-the-scenes featurettes like "Down Time" and "War Song Dance" provide an engaging peek into the filming process. For those interested in further insights, an extended interview with director Rob Letterman is included. The extras suite also features an interactive game and red carpet interviews, all complementing the robust special features package.
Extras included in this disc:
- I Don't Know...with Lemuel Gulliver: Jack Black hosts a faux discussion on the Bermuda Triangle.
- Gag Reel: Jack Black attempts to push-start a truck amid wardrobe malfunctions.
- Deleted Scenes: Eight additional scenes for more narrative depth.
- Little and Large: Featurette on the film's special effects.
- Jack Black Thinks Big: Cast discusses how Liliput is affected by Gulliver.
- Down Time: Behind-the-scenes fun on set.
- Gulliver's Foosball Challenge: Interactive remote-control game.
- War Song Dance: Insight into the War sequence choreography.
- Fox Movie Channel Presents: In Character with Jack Black: Jack Black discusses his role.
- Fox Movie Channel Presents: In Character with Jason Segel: Jason Segel on his character.
- Fox Movie Channel Presents: Life after Film School: Rob Letterman of Gulliver's Travels: Interview with director Rob Letterman.
- Fox Movie Channel Presents: World Premiere: Red carpet interviews.
- Theatrical Trailer: Official movie trailer.
- BD-Live Exclusive - Jack and Jason's Dance Class: Behind-the-scenes look at dance choreography.
Movie: 33
"Gulliver's Travels," starring Jack Black, offers an irreverent twist on Jonathan Swift's classic satirical tale. Black plays Lemuel Gulliver, a lackluster mailroom clerk at the fictitious New York Tribune, who seizes an opportunity to impress the travel editor Darcy (Amanda Peet) by taking on a Bermuda Triangle assignment. After a shipwreck, Gulliver ends up on the fantastical island of Lilliput, where his gigantic stature and exaggerated stories make him a hero among the tiny inhabitants. However, this comedy-adventure lacks the original story's sharp satirical edge, opting instead for broad humor and juvenile gags, such as Gulliver extinguishing a palace fire by urinating on it—an incident liftefrom Swift’s text but here devoid of its critical tone.
Director Rob Letterman’s film primarily targets younger audiences with its simplistic narrative and humor. The screenplay by Joe Stillman and Nicholas Stoller transforms Swift's intricate four-part story into a straightforward underdog rom-com adventure. Unfortunately, this adaptation strips away much of the source material's satirical depth, substituting it with pop-culture references and gross-out jokes. Jack Black's performance is decidedly typical, relying heavily on his characteristic humor which includes exaggerated facial expressions, physical comedy, and sporadic musical outbursts. While Black’s energetic antics may amuse pre-teens, they fail to elevate the material or resonate with adults seeking more substantial humor.
Supporting performances by actors like Emily Blunt and Jason Segel are serviceable but constrained by the script's limited scope. Billy Connolly’s portrayal of King Benjamin and Chris O'Dowd’s as General Edward add some flavor, but they ultimately serve as backdrops to Black's larger-than-life presence. Moments intended for comic relief often fall flat, highlighting the film's missed opportunity to blend humor with the biting social commentary characteristic of Swift’s novel. Despite the excellent set design and well-crafted visual effects, "Gulliver's Travels" lacks the heart and incisive wit of its literary predecessor, offering instead a superficial spectacle tailored for young viewers.
Total: 60
The 2010 film "Gulliver's Travels" starring Jack Black undeniably veers far from Jonathan Swift's revered narrative, opting instead for a more juvenile and superficial interpretation. While the movie itself may not appeal to a discerning audience due to its reliance on lowbrow humor and deficient storytelling, it does provide some fleeting moments of entertainment, particularly for younger viewers. Despite its narrative shortcomings, those with a penchant for Jack Black’s comedic style may find some enjoyment. The movie's joke sequences, often teetering on crude humor, may garner occasional chuckles but lack the depth of quality comedic writing.
Technically, the Blu-ray release does not disappoint. The video presentation is notable, with sharp details and vibrant color fidelity that enhance the film’s whimsical settings. The audio quality also stands out, providing a robust and immersive experience, though it is worth noting the absence of a theatrical 7.1 audio option, which might be expected by purists or audiophiles. The disc is complemented with an array of bonus materials, predominantly promotional content that provides additional context but little substantive insight into the making of the film.
In conclusion, while "Gulliver's Travels" may not stand up as an essential or intelligent comedy, its Blu-ray package is commendable from a technical standpoint. The high-quality video and audio elements, coupled with an assortment of special features, make it a competent purchase for households with young Jack Black fans. Otherwise, those seeking more depth or refined humor might prefer skipping this one.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 80
Clarity is generally strong, yielding an image that displays fine texture where you tend to look for it�the actors' faces, the details of the costumes, etc.�and there's never a trace of adverse edge enhancement....
Audio: 90
Jack Black fans who are also hardcore audiophiles�and I'm sure there are at least a few of you out there�may be slightly disappointed to learn that this Blu-ray release doesn't include the 7.1 surround...
Extras: 60
BD-Live Exclusive - Jack & Jason's Dance Class (720p, 3:29): Part behind-the-scenes look at the dance scene choreography, part love fest between Jack Black and Jason Segel, who sing one another's praises....
Movie: 50
Judd Apatow go-to guy Jeremy Segel is appropriately lovelorn as Horatio, and Chris O'Dowd does his best John Cleese impersonation for the angry General Edward, but Jack Black literally and figuratively...
Total: 50
This version of Gulliver's Travels is without a doubt the dumbest adaptation of Jonathan Swift's literary classic, but kids will probably get a momentary kick out of it before moving on to the next big...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The movie was shot digitally, and does contain a few of the problems we usually see with these kinds of movies....
Audio: 80
Fans of the show will most likely be enthralled by this audio presentation, but it's disappointing that Fox saw fit to not give us the true theatrical experience on this release....
Extras: 40
In Character with Jason Segel (SD, 5 min.) — Exactly the same as the Black featurette, but this time Segel is talking about being Horatio....
Movie: 20
It's sad that the new 'Gulliver's Travels,' starring Jack Black, does away with all the childlike wonder of the original story and instead thinks it would be funny if Gulliver peed on a palace fire to...
Total: 60
The video and audio are solid, but it would have been nice if Fox saw fit to include the theatrical 7.1 presentation along with this Blu-ray....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
High definition detail is notable as images are firmly resolute with crisp edges, defining sharpness, and two dimensional perspective that enhances depth and dimension....
Audio: 88
When applied low frequency effects offer excellent response that results in deep bass energy that resonated throughout the room....
Extras: 60
(HD) I don't knowwith host Lemuel Gulliver (Jack Black in character) - 5 minute feature on the Bermuda Triangle (HD) Gag reel - 1 minute (HD) 8 deleted scenes (HD) Little and large featurette - 8 minutes...
Movie: 40
Gulliver's tall tales and heroic deeds win the hearts of the tiny Lilliputians, but when he loses it all and puts his newfound friends in peril, Gulliver must find a way to undo the damage....
Total: 69
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Rob Letterman
Actors: Jack Black, Emily Blunt, Jason Segel
PlotLemuel Gulliver, a mailroom clerk with dreams of becoming a writer, is given an assignment to travel to the Bermuda Triangle. A sudden storm sweeps him off-course, and he washes ashore on the island of Lilliput, home to tiny inhabitants called Lilliputians. Initially captured by these miniature people, Gulliver impresses them with his size, and they soon consider him a hero. Utilizing his new colossal status, Gulliver helps the Lilliputians with their various challenges, from construction projects to facing off with the neighboring Blefuscudians, with whom Lilliput is at war. His knowledge of modern technology and culture fascinates the Lilliputians, who begin to idolize him.
Throughout his adventures, Gulliver befriends a commoner named Horatio and the Princess of Lilliput, who feels trapped by her royal duties. He also confronts the self-important General Edward, who views Gulliver as a threat to his own power and aspirations. As Gulliver's exaggerated tales of his life back home grow, they bring both admiration and unexpected complications. However, as truths begin to unravel and dangers escalate, Gulliver must confront the reality of his newfound hero status and figure out how to resolve the escalating conflicts. The story explores themes of self-discovery, friendship, and the impact of one's actions.
Writers: Joe Stillman, Nicholas Stoller, Jonathan Swift
Release Date: 25 Dec 2010
Runtime: 85 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English