Sergeant Ryker Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Kino Lorber's 2K master of 'Sergeant Ryker' revives Kulik's work with vivid clarity despite minor framing issues, appealing to both cinephiles and TV-film history buffs.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
The Blu-ray of "Sergeant Ryker" presents a pleasing yet flawed 1080p transfer from a 2K master. The 1.78:1 aspect ratio occasionally suffers from problematic framing, affecting shot composition. While color balance is strong, saturation could improve. Despite minor blemishes, the vintage television look is preserved, scoring 3.25/5.
Audio: 86
The Blu-ray of 'Sergeant Ryker' offers an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track with clear dialogue and stability, though dynamic contrasts are modest due to the film’s original design. Optional English SDH subtitles are included. The audio benefits from its soundstage origins but occasionally feels thin.
Extra: 59
Daniel Kremer's commentary offers a comprehensive exploration of Sergeant Ryker's production and transition from TV to cinema, enriched with biographical insights and historical context, while the vintage trailer and reversible cover with poster art enhance the Blu-ray extras, making it essential for enthusiasts and historians.
Movie: 74
Though marketed as an action-packed war film akin to The Dirty Dozen, Buzz Kulik's Sergeant Ryker unfolds as a nuanced courtroom drama, distinctively exploring moral ambiguity during the Korean War. Its theatrical transformation from a TV production features solid performances, especially Lee Marvin's, though it lacks visual flamboyance.
Video: 69
The Blu-ray presentation of "Sergeant Ryker," released by Kino Lorber, delivers a mixed viewing experience, primarily due to its technical inconsistencies. The film is presented in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, utilizing a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded transfer from a pristine 2K master. The overall image quality is commendably organic, capturing the essence of the original 35mm cinematography executed by Walter Strenge. However, the technical oversight in reframing is noticeable and occasionally problematic. Specific scenes reveal tight compositions that result in minor framing anomalies, particularly affecting close-ups and wider shots. Unintended head cropping and misframing seem to echo potential errors from an improper reframing process from the original full-frame format to widescreen ratios. These issues are sporadic and could have been better managed, given the expertise presumably backing the restoration process.
The color presentation of this Blu-ray edition exhibits both strengths and minor areas for improvement. While consistently balanced, saturation sometimes appears insufficient, affecting the overall dynamic range and leaving it slightly underwhelming. Yet, the resulting visual style retains a semblance of the original broadcast's aesthetic integrity. Despite minor flaws, such as occasional black marks, scratches, and spots of speckling, these defects do not majorly detract. The opening title sequence is noticeably rough, due to the earlier use of stock footage and optical printing. Elsewhere, a few soft optical transitions appear, alongside optically zoomed-in shots. Colors maintain a rich saturation, though at times flesh tones verge on overly ruddy—characteristics reminiscent of 1960s television cinema.
Overall, this Region-A locked Blu-ray release offers a nostalgic glimpse into vintage cinematography with a distinct balance between authenticity and minor modern technical enhancements.
Audio: 86
The Blu-ray release of "Sergeant Ryker" features a singular audio track: English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0. Accompanying the audio are optional English SDH subtitles. The presentation ensures clarity and sharpness throughout, maintaining exceptional intelligibility in the dialogue—a notable strength attributed to its television origins and soundstage production. Despite minor thinning in the audio, the track remains consistently coherent.
While stability and clarity are commendable, the dynamic contrast of the audio is modest, particularly noticeable in sequences where music and action elements like shootouts and explosions are expected to resonate more powerfully. This limitation is inherent to the original sound design of the film, likely constrained by its historical production context. Nonetheless, the audio remains free from age-induced anomalies, preserving its integrity for contemporary audiences.
The music, an early composition by the renowned John Williams, then credited as “Johnny,” demonstrates a minimalistic approach consistent with the film's made-for-TV format. The effectiveness of this score, though limited, complements the sound design. Overall, this audio offering delivers a faithful auditory experience true to the film's roots while ensuring clear and engaging listening.
Extras: 59
The extras on the "Sergeant Ryker" Blu-ray provide valuable insights into both its production and historical context. Daniel Kramer's audio commentary is a comprehensive exploration, expertly delving into the film's intricate production history. Kramer's analysis details differences between the TV version and the theatrical cut and scrutinizes Universal's strategy in repurposing television content for the cinema during that era. He enriches the discussion with biographical sketches of Director Kulik and key cast members and updates on "Johnny" Williams' career trajectory prior to this film. Kramer enhances his insights by including contemporary reviews, highlighting attempts made by Universal to downplay the film's origins as a TV production. The presence of a vintage trailer and reversible cover art further complements these additions, making this a rich package for enthusiasts eager to explore the deeper narrative fabric of "Sergeant Ryker."
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: An exclusive audio commentary by critic and filmmaker Daniel Kramer.
- Trailer: Vintage trailer for "Sergeant Ryker" in English.
- Cover: Reversible cover featuring vintage poster art for "Sergeant Ryker".
Movie: 74
Buzz Kulik's "Sergeant Ryker" is an intriguing cinema piece presented on Blu-ray by Kino Lorber. The film is primarily a courtroom drama, intricately investigating themes of heroism and betrayal against the backdrop of the Korean War. Starring Lee Marvin as the titular Sergeant Ryker and co-starring Bradford Dillman and Vera Miles, the film delves into a complex narrative that questions conventional notions of right and wrong. Dillman's portrayal of Captain David Young, initially a prosecutor and later Ryker’s defender, introduces a potent dynamic, as Young's personal and professional conflicts unfold when confronted by Ann Ryker, convincingly played by Miles.
The production origins of "Sergeant Ryker" add layers to its cinematic narrative. Originally shot for television as part of the Kraft Suspense Theatre in 1963, the film was reworked for theatrical release by Universal Studios in 1968, capitalizing on Lee Marvin's newfound fame from "The Dirty Dozen." Despite marketing efforts positioning it as a high-action war film, it remains distinctly a thought-provoking legal drama with chamber-like qualities reminiscent of theater productions. While comparisons to "Time Limit," another Korean War-themed drama, suggest both films re-evaluate heroism amidst moral ambiguity, "Sergeant Ryker" uniquely sets layers of power play and complex emotional elements, enlivened by the supporting performances from Peter Graves and Murray Hamilton.
Technically, the film may not be overwhelmingly visually spectacular, but the cinematography by Oscar-nominated Walter Strenge offers a precise and fitting simplicity that complements the storyline. The nuanced and moving musical score by young composer John Williams enhances the narrative depth, leaving audiences to ponder the real essence of heroism. Despite being overshadowed by more action-centric promotional expectations, "Sergeant Ryker" demands attention for its layered drama and refined storytelling.
Total: 73
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "Sergeant Ryker," directed by Buzz Kulik, revitalizes a classic film with its fresh 2K master. The transfer enhances the film's visual appeal, offering an organic and appealing presentation that reflects the era's aesthetic. However, some viewers noted minor framing issues, which can distract from the otherwise crisp visuals. Kulik, whose direction hasn't received the recognition it deserves, delivers an engaging narrative with compelling storytelling and strong performances.
The film showcases an impressive cast, delivering performances that underscore the film's thematic complexities and moral ambiguities. The unexpected ending leaves audiences pondering unresolved questions, enhancing the film's immersive impact. As the director successfully blends elements from television with traditional filmmaking, this release highlights the historical significance of such cross-pollination within the industry.
In conclusion, "Sergeant Ryker" is a must-watch for those interested in nuanced storytelling and vintage cinema. Fans of Buzz Kulik will appreciate the restored attention to his work, while others might find it a captivating exploration of cinematic history. For those intrigued by "Sergeant Ryker," seeking out Karl Malden's "Time Limit" is recommended for another example of exceptional vintage cinema. Kino Lorber's continued dedication to rescuing overlooked gems ensures "Sergeant Ryker" is not just remembered but celebrated.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
Saturation could be slightly better and if it is the overall dynamic range of the visuals would be improved as well, but I like how the film looks now....
Audio: 100
However, dynamic contrasts are very modest even in areas where the music is prominent and there are a few shootouts and explosions....
Extras: 50
Commentary - this exclusive new audio commentary was recorded by critic and filmmaker Daniel Kramer....
Movie: 80
As a result, while not necessarily superior, the drama that flourishes in Sergeant Ryker has more layers than the one in Time Limit....
Total: 60
If you decide to see Sergeant Ryker, I also recommend that you track down a copy of Karl Malden's Time Limit, which is a very similar, terrifically acted film....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 80
There are a few optical transitions throughout the film that are also soft, as well as a handful of optically zoomed-in shots, but the rest of the footage is reasonably sharp and detailed....
Audio: 85
While it sounds a little thin at times, the dialogue is always clear—that’s one of the advantages of the fact that it was a made-for-television production, shot almost entirely on soundstages....
Extras: 75
He expands from there to cover the way that Universal and other studios repackaged television material during that era, including a breakdown of the journey that other projects took from the small screen...
Movie: 75
Sergeant Ryker required a bit more reworking than that film did, but Universal still brought it to the big screen in 1968 in an attempt to capitalize on the success of The Dirty Dozen....
Total: 79
Kino Lorber continues to do the Lord’s work in bringing forgotten titles out of obscurity an into full high-definition glory, and Sergeant Ryker is no exception to that rule....
Director: Buzz Kulik
Actors: Bradford Dillman, Peter Graves, Vera Miles
PlotSet during the Korean War, the film follows Sergeant Paul Ryker, an American soldier accused of desertion and collaboration with the enemy. Captured by Communist forces, he returns to his own lines under mysterious circumstances, leading to doubts about his loyalty. The military swiftly charges him with treason after evidence emerges suggesting he was complicit in the Cold War enemy’s plans. His estranged wife, Ann, is convinced of his innocence and becomes his steadfast supporter despite the damning evidence. Driven by her belief in Ryker, she seeks aid from his military defense attorney, Captain David Young.
Captain Young is initially reluctant to take on the case, overwhelmed by the seemingly insurmountable proof against Ryker. However, as he delves deeper into the circumstances surrounding Ryker’s capture and supposed betrayal, he begins to uncover inconsistencies that challenge the assumptions of guilt. Young is thrust into a race against time to gather enough evidence that could sway the court-martial before an execution sentence is passed. As tensions rise and loyalties are tested, Young finds himself not only fighting to vindicate Ryker but also navigating a complex web of military and political interests that have a vested interest in seeing Ryker convicted. The narrative builds a suspenseful atmosphere as it revolves around the unfolding courtroom drama and Ryker's desperate fight for justice.
Writers: Seeleg Lester, William D. Gordon
Release Date: 01 Feb 1968
Runtime: 85 min
Rating: N/A
Country: United States
Language: English