Man with the Gun Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Man with the Gun offers a compelling Western experience with exceptional scoring and a stellar A/V presentation, despite predictable elements and limited extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
The AVC encoded 1080p transfer preserves the beautiful black and white cinematography of 'Man with the Gun,' offering practically perfect grey scales, deep blacks, and fantastic detail levels. Despite minor speckling and flicker, the 1.85:1 aspect ratio presentation showcases excellent grain management and true-to-life facial features.
Audio: 67
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA sound mix of 'Man with the Gun' delivers clear dialogue exchanges and sharp sound effects, with Alex North's score resonating effectively, though some flatness is noted; minor hiss is present, but distortions, pops, cracks, or dropouts are absent, ensuring an immersive experience.
Extra: 16
The Blu Ray extras for 'Man with the Gun' include high-definition trailers for 'The Wonderful Country' (2:56) and 'Young Billy Young' (2:15), each capturing the excitement and essence of classic Westerns, though some trailers reveal key plot points.
Movie: 71
1955's 'Man with the Gun,' directed by Richard Wilson and starring Robert Mitchum, is a concise, traditional Western that maintains tension through its depiction of lawless escalation and complex relationships, showcasing a standout performance from Mitchum as the no-nonsense enforcer, all beautifully captured in Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release.
Video: 67
The AVC encoded image (1.85:1 aspect ratio) presentation of "Man with the Gun" provides viewers with an exceptionally detailed and crisp visual experience. This 1080p transfer leverages black and white cinematography to create a grand sense of three-dimensional space, with grey scales and black levels maintaining near-perfect standards. Black levels remain inky and consistent without any troublesome dips into crush territories, ensuring true blacks and deep distances in the image. The grain structure is expertly managed throughout, giving the film a textured, fibrous feel that enhances the overall authenticity of the viewing experience.
Facial features are meticulously detailed, capturing every nuance, while wide establishing shots and medium-range shots are equally impressive in their clarity. For a movie that is over 60 years old, this transfer is near perfect, although minor source imperfections such as flicker, scratches, and speckling are present. These minor print damage flaws are generally subtle but can become noticeable during night scenes or dimly lit passages. However, these issues do little to detract from what is otherwise an exceptional visual presentation that pays homage to the film's original cinematographic brilliance.
Audio: 67
The English DTS-HD MA 2.0 sound mix on "Man with the Gun" admirably captures the essence of the picture, effectively balancing dialogue, score, and sound effects. Dialogue exchanges are notably clear and unambiguous, ensuring that every line is audible without risk of distortion. The mix reveals a mild amount of hiss, but this slight imperfection does not take away from the overall experience. Scoring by Alex North shines, providing a measured backdrop that enhances rather than detracts from the on-screen action. Instrumentation is precise and well-placed, creating a cohesive auditory backdrop.
Sound effects, particularly gunshots, are rendered with sharp clarity, adding to the immersive experience. The track does not display any unwanted hiss, pops, cracks, or dropouts, contributing to a polished listening experience. While the imaging performs adequately, it occasionally falls short of delivering a fully three-dimensional soundstage, resulting in moments that may seem somewhat flat. Nevertheless, the balance between dialogue, ambient sounds, and score provides ample space for each element to resonate effectively within the stereo field. Overall, the DTS-HD MA 2.0 track delivers an engaging and technically proficient soundtrack that complements the film well.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray release of "Man with the Gun" features a well-curated selection of extras that enhance the viewer's appreciation of this classic film. The inclusion of multiple theatrical trailers in high definition provides nostalgic value and historical context, allowing viewers to experience how films were marketed in the past. The trailers are well-preserved, offering a visually appealing and informative glimpse into the movie’s promotion. While they effectively set up the film's themes and action, it’s worth noting that some trailers contain spoilers. This collection demonstrates a commendable effort to enhance the overall viewing experience through valuable supplementary content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Theatrical Trailer: An original black and white western trailer effectively setting up the film.
- The Wonderful Country Trailer: A fun trailer capturing major events of the movie.
- Young Billy Young Trailer: Engaging trailer that highlights the action and excitement of the film.
Movie: 71
1955's Man with the Gun, directed by Richard Wilson and starring Robert Mitchum, begins with a chilling introduction as the villain shoots a barking dog, setting a tense and ominous tone for the film. Mitchum portrays Clint Tollinger, a gunfighter hired to bring order to a terrorized town. As he begins his work, the film explores the traditional Western narrative, interspersed with moments of genuine emotion, particularly through a subplot involving Tollinger and his ex-lover, Nelly Bain (Jan Sterling). The tangential relationship adds unexpected depth to an otherwise straightforward tale of lawlessness and justice.
Tollinger's mission intensifies as he enforces stringent rules, such as disarming the populace and implementing a curfew, drawing the ire of both outlaws and town officials alike. The tension crescendos when Tollinger confronts the film's primary antagonist, Dade Holman (Joe Barry), whose gang has been wreaking havoc. Though Holman is largely absent until the climax, his presence looms menacingly. This narrative choice ensures a palpable sense of threat throughout the film.
The performances are uniformly strong. Mitchum excels as the experienced and unflinching lawman, while Sterling effectively conveys the complexities of past heartbreak. Although Barry's role as Holman is relatively underdeveloped, his function as a feared leader remains impactful. Enhancing the film is Alex North's score, which intensifies key scenes. The succinct 83-minute runtime ensures efficient storytelling devoid of unnecessary exposition. Man with the Gun is a quintessential classic Western, marked by its tight narrative, strong characterizations, and gripping visual style.
Total: 57
"Man with the Gun" stands as an exemplary classic Western, boasting a compelling narrative and a gritty atmosphere. Robert Mitchum's portrayal of a lawman for hire is captivating, delivering a nuanced performance that captures both the toughness and underlying vulnerability of his character, Tollinger. Through tight direction and storytelling, the film deftly explores themes of law, order, and community dynamics. Alex North’s exceptional score further enhances the film’s atmosphere, beautifully complementing its expansive visuals and emotional depth. The script ensures that while predictable at points, the film remains engaging, digging deep into character development which is crucial for its lasting impact.
The Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber impresses with a notable A/V presentation, ensuring that both the visual and auditory aspects of the film remain pristine, transporting viewers back to the West with remarkable fidelity. However, the extras are limited, consisting only of a small set of trailers which may disappoint those seeking additional content or insights into the production. Despite this, the film's strong narrative and Mitchum's standout performance make it a worthy addition to any Western aficionado's collection.
In conclusion, "Man with the Gun" takes some compelling turns and preserves a welcome western atmosphere of remote town intimidation and interaction. Alex North's scoring is exceptional, enhancing the film's reach. Mitchum’s performance maintains a leading man presence as Tollinger embarks on a mission to restore order, pushing boundaries to generate results. While the movie might be predictable in many respects, it remains alert and tender, particularly when delving deeply into character dynamics. As such, "Man With The Gun" manages to entertain and remains recommended to Western movie fans who relish both action and character-driven plots.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
The AVC encoded image (1.85:1 aspect ratio) presentation sets a crisp mood for "Man with the Gun," offering generous detail to help explore locations, sets, and crusty supporting characters....
Audio: 80
Scoring is encouraging, with decent instrumentation and position, never stepping on the action....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 70
Wilson doesn't push hard to break "Man with the Gun" out of its comfort zone, but the feature (scripted by N.B. Stone Jr. and Wilson) captures some interesting concerns about violent escalation and lawlessness,...
Total: 70
Although it's a predictable movie in many ways, "Man with the Gun" remains alert, hoping to show some tenderness to go along with all the leathery men and their agitated concerns....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The real highlight of this transfer is that fine film grain has been retained and detail levels are absolutely fantastic throughout the run....
Audio: 80
The track is also free of any hiss, pops, cracks or drop outs making it a heck of an effective track....
Extras: 20
There's something fun about the way movies used to be marketed, this trailer does a great job of making the movie look fun however it does show a lot of the film's major events so spoilers beware....
Movie: 80
By cribbing elements of the Wyatt Earp legend, the story is able to take place on a bigger stage while keeping the scene small and tight....
Total: 60
Robert Mitchum is in his element here and gives his role as a lawman for hire plenty of weight while not overplaying his hand....
Director: Richard Wilson
Actors: Robert Mitchum, Jan Sterling, Karen Sharpe
PlotA mysterious gunslinger named Clint Tollinger rides into the lawless town of Sheridan, which is being terrorized by a ruthless land baron named Dade Holman. Hired by the desperate townspeople to restore order, Clint quickly establishes himself as a formidable presence. As he starts to clean up the town and drive out Holman's men, he encounters resistance from some citizens who question his methods. Along the way, Clint reconnects with his estranged wife, Nelly Bain, who runs the local dance hall and holds complicated feelings towards him and his mission.
As tensions escalate in Sheridan, Clint faces increasing danger from Holman's hired guns and finds himself having to make a series of tough moral decisions. These struggles force him to confront his own past and the reasons that led him to become a hired gunfighter. Balancing his desire for redemption with the harsh reality of his profession, Clint must navigate a treacherous environment where alliances constantly shift, and trust is a rare commodity. Will he succeed in bringing peace to Sheridan and perhaps find personal redemption, or will the violent forces arrayed against him prove too formidable?
Writers: N.B. Stone Jr., Richard Wilson
Release Date: 05 Nov 1955
Runtime: 84 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English