War of the Arrows Blu-ray Review
Choi-jong-byeong-gi Hwal
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'War of the Arrows' is a well-staged, visually impressive film with excellent audio, despite some compression issues and limited special features, earning it a solid recommendation.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
The Blu-ray of 'War of the Arrows' impresses with its 2.35:1 AVC encoded 1080p transfer, offering sharp, vivid detail and accurate colors, particularly in outdoor scenes. While black levels and contrast are strong, occasional banding and aliasing issues are noted, yet overall, it's a striking high-definition presentation.
Audio: 78
The War of the Arrows Blu-ray offers stellar audio with both original Korean and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks. While the English dub sounds flat and distracting, the Korean version delivers superb immersive moments, dynamic range, and lifelike effects, making it a standout example of high-quality sound mixing.
Extra: 31
The Blu-ray extras of 'War of the Arrows' include a brief 'Behind the Scenes' featurette that lacks depth, 'Highlights' that serve as an extended trailer, and two trailers with one in HD showcasing positive reviews, but overall, the content provides minimal insight into the film's innovative techniques.
Movie: 76
War of the Arrows delivers an improbable yet compelling revenge drama set against the historical backdrop of the Second Manchu Invasion, featuring exceptional archery-based action, strong character performances, and vivid location photography, making it a standout in Korean historical epics despite minimal CG and a modest budget.
Video: 68
Well Go USA provides a strong presentation of "War of the Arrows" on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in the 2.35:1 aspect ratio, despite packaging suggesting 1.78:1. The high-definition quality ensures striking sharpness and clarity throughout, especially with fine details in sumptuous sets and costumes. Outdoor scenes, which comprise most of the film, exhibit exceptional depth of field. The film employs a blue-grey cast for certain filtered scenes, contributing to a smoother ambiance. Contrast and black levels are robust and consistent, but a minor degree of black crush is noted mid-film.
The video presentation succeeds at maintaining natural flesh tones and consistent contrast, with realistic yet unsaturated color representation. While the red of blood appears particularly vivid, other colors remain balanced without oversaturation. Despite the overall high quality, minor technical flaws are present. Banding occurs frequently, and there are instances of flickering aliasing in intricate textures like hair and woven patterns. On a positive note, the transfer is free of digital noise, DNR, edge enhancement, and other artifacts, ensuring a visually pleasing experience throughout most of the runtime.
Audio: 78
The audio presentation of "War of the Arrows" on Blu-Ray delivers an impressive experience, particularly for those opting for the original Korean DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track. Though an English dub is available, it suffers from the typical drawbacks of mismatched syllabification and mouth movements, making it less preferable for audiophiles. The original Korean track excels in fidelity and immersion, offering dynamic environmental soundscapes that enhance the viewing experience. Particularly commendable is the use of ambient sounds like the gentle breeze in key scenes, which enriches the narrative and adds a layer of realism. The dynamic range is exceptional throughout, ensuring that all elements of the sound design are well-balanced.
From the opening raid to the climactic showdown, the audio mix stands out as a highlight of this release. The opening sequence serves as a demonstrative exhibit of the Blu-ray's audio capabilities, featuring a range of intense sounds: clanging armor, barking dogs, and crackling torches synchronized seamlessly to create a lifelike atmosphere. The spatial imaging during action scenes is superb, with arrows whooshing past the listener, making it feel as though they are part of the combat. The bass and LFE elements add substantial weight to the tension-filled moments, further immersing the audience in the chaos and drama.
Overall, the audio track’s blend of effects and music showcases an unfaltering dedication to high-quality sound design. Even in serene scenes, background noises are artfully integrated, contributing to both narrative depth and viewer engagement. This is, without doubt, one of the most compelling uses of sound in a Well Go USA release, ensuring that "War of the Arrows" is not just seen but felt.
Extras: 31
The Blu-ray extras for "War of the Arrows" provide a mixed bag of insightful and superficial content. The "Behind the Scenes" featurette offers a glimpse into director Kim Hanmin’s fascination with arrows but falls short of deep exploration, leaving some innovative filmmaking and stunt techniques unelaborated. Additionally, the English subtitles are poorly translated. The "Highlights" section is essentially an extended trailer, revealing substantial plot points without giving away the ending, while both the "Original Trailer" and "Trailer" provide brief promotional views of the film in different resolutions.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Scenes: Insight from director Kim Hanmin and others, brief and somewhat incomplete.
- Highlights: Extended trailer with significant plot reveals.
- Original Trailer: Short teaser in standard definition.
- Trailer: High-definition trailer featuring positive reviews from major outlets.
Movie: 76
‘War of the Arrows’ offers a riveting look into the Second Manchu Invasion of Korea circa 1636, packaged as an enthralling historical epic. The socio-political intricacies are touched upon just enough to provide context while the heart of the story remains the compelling personal mission of Nam-Yi (Park Hae-Il). This narrative choice gives profound intimacy to sweeping historical events, portraying Nam-Yi as a master archer driven to rescue his kidnapped sister Ja-In (Moon Chae-won). From the onset, the movie captivates audiences with a high-stakes prologue involving the brutal murder of Nam-Yi and Ja-In’s father, setting the stage for Nam-Yi’s eventual transformation from a troubled youth to a lethal force against the Qing invaders.
The storytelling hinges on remarkable performances and incredibly detailed location photography, capturing both the beauty and brutality of Korea’s war-torn landscapes. Director Kim Han-min sidesteps overused visual tropes by focusing on the tactical and visceral realities of archery, delivering scenes with minimal CGI, yet maintaining high tension and raw action. The film splits neatly into two halves: the establishment of character and stakes in the first part, and an adrenaline-fueled pursuit in the latter part, reminiscent of 'Apocalypto'. Han-min’s resolve to keep the intimate essence within a large-scale historical dramatization succeeds impressively.
This focus on character-driven action, alongside a minimalist yet effective use of special effects, marks ‘War of the Arrows’ as an unexpectedly poignant piece within the genre. It balances explosive action with deep familial bonds, ensuring investment from audiences despite the historical disparity. The execution is impeccably orchestrated, proving that even narratives rooted in improbable heroism can be conveyed with gripping realism and emotional depth. This meticulous filmmaking approach highlights the strengths of Asian cinema’s daring creativity and attention to detail, which often transcend the constraints faced by their Western counterparts.
Total: 65
"War of the Arrows" is a compelling addition to the epic movie genre, distinguished by its unique focus on archery rather than the more familiar martial arts. The film is meticulously produced, visually sumptuous, and bolstered by strong performances and expert staging. Unlike many films in its category, "War of the Arrows" places emphasis on a personal narrative over broader sociopolitical commentary, making it accessible to audiences without requiring an extensive background in the historical tensions between China and Korea. While some plot elements may stretch credibility, the underdog story at its core is engaging and encourages viewers to root for the protagonist against immense odds.
Technically, the Blu-ray presentation of the film excels in both video and audio quality. The image boasts extremely sharp and crisp definition, although some issues such as banding and aliasing due to compression are present. Despite these minor drawbacks, the visual experience remains highly satisfying. The audio track is particularly impressive, with a lossless 5.1 mix that delivers an immersive experience both in the quieter moments and during intense battle sequences. This high-quality audio presentation significantly enhances the overall viewing experience.
Despite the limited supplementary material available on this release, "War of the Arrows" stands out due to its enthralling story, strong production values, and technical excellence. Its emphasis on character-driven narrative over special effects and blockbuster sequences is a testament to its creative approach. Overall, this Blu-ray comes highly recommended for its ability to captivate audiences both emotionally and technically.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
This is a beautifully sharp and consistent looking high definition presentation that offers striking fine detail (especially with regard to the film's sumptuous sets and costumes, which pop magnificently...
Audio: 90
While the English dub isn't outright horrible, it suffers from the usual mismatch of syllabification and mouth movement, though the translations are relatively close to the subtitles that accompany the...
Extras: 50
Behind the Scenes (SD; 4:14) has director Kim Hanmin talking about his fascination with arrows, as well as several other cast and crew members offering some short comments....
Movie: 80
In fact it wasn't really a unified nation at all, but a series of territories, many of which found themselves repeatedly invaded by China, as that immense country sought to absorb neighboring areas to...
Total: 80
With a well reasoned emphasis on a personal story, rather than indulging in a sociopolitical screed, War of the Arrows doesn't require its audiences to be well schooled in the background between China...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Despite the black levels being very strong, there's a small amount of crushing that occurs in the middle of the film....
Audio: 100
All channels are constantly in use with well-mixed effects and music, making this the very best and most dynamic use of sound in a Well Go USA release that I've seen to date....
Extras: 20
Featuring praising quotes from large domestic reviewing outlets, this is the trailer that was seen stateside....
Movie: 80
Considering how much the U.S. was bombarded with and burned out by expensive epic movies in the last decade, 'War of the Arrows' is a refreshing outsider's take on the genre that returns us to pre-CG epic...
Total: 60
The extremely sharp and crisp definition of the video is only lacking because of compression issues – banding and aliasing, to be specific....
Director: Han-min Kim
Actors: Park Hae-il, Ryu Seung-ryong, Kim Mu-yeol
PlotIn 1636, during the Second Manchu invasion of Korea, a skilled archer named Nam-Yi loses his father to political intrigue and flees with his younger sister, Ja-In. Resettling in a remote village under the care of a family friend, they try to live quietly away from turmoil. Years later, on the morning of Ja-In's wedding, Nam-Yi's peaceful life is shattered when a ruthless Manchu army attacks their village, capturing the young bride-to-be and slaughtering many villagers. Bent on rescuing his sister, Nam-Yi arms himself with his bow and sets off to face an army equipped with firearms and elite soldiers skilled in martial arts.
On the journey, Nam-Yi confronts numerous dangers, relying on his superior agility, extensive knowledge of the terrain, and remarkable archery skills to evade and outsmart his pursuers. The pursuit escalates into a deadly game of cat and mouse, where Nam-Yi uses the landscape to his advantage, setting traps and employing guerrilla tactics against overwhelming odds. As he narrows the distance to the enemy camp, tensions rise, showcasing his unwavering courage and determination to save Ja-In from the ruthless Manchu forces while uncovering unexpected alliances and challenges along the way.
Writers: Han-min Kim
Release Date: 10 Aug 2011
Runtime: 122 min
Rating: R
Country: South Korea
Language: Korean