Morgan 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Morgan" disappoints with weak script & direction; decent 4K but lacks compelling visuals.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
The 4K UHD presentation of 'Morgan' offers subtle enhancements over Blu-ray, with improved details and HDR effects, yet maintains a dark, stylistic visual tone.
Audio: 75
Morgan's 4K UHD presentation boasts a crisp DTS-HD MA 7.1 audio that finely balances dialogue and environmental sounds, though lacking next-gen formats like Atmos. Image detail and color grading enhance its mood, with effective use of surround sound for an immersive experience.
Extra: 53
Morgan's 4K UHD & 1080p Blu-ray set features director Luke Scott's commentary, a documentary, deleted scenes, and 'Loom'—a standout short film, all exploring the nuanced ethics of genetic engineering.
Movie: 49
Morgan, a bioengineered humanoid, challenges human-synthetic boundaries, facing creators' errors and existential threats in a Ridley Scott thriller.
Video: 70
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Morgan", courtesy of 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment, offers a discernibly improved viewing experience over its Blu-ray counterpart, albeit with some caveats. The film, initially captured using Arri Alexa XT cameras and reportedly completed with a 2K Digital Intermediate, benefits from an upscale to 2160p. This results in somewhat enhanced texture detail in close-up shots, where the intricacies of facial features, clothing textiles, and the natural environment gain clarity. The High Dynamic Range (HDR) contributes to refined shadow details in the film’s predominantly dark scenes set within the confines of a house and laboratory, bringing out subtleties in the dimly lit areas that were previously lost. Additionally, HDR accentuates the color grading, presenting a unique palette that enriches earthy tones while adding depth to the visuals. Despite these improvements, the increase in resolution and HDR effects provides only a moderate uplift in overall picture quality, with occasional instances of aliasing detracting from the visual fidelity.
The HEVC H.265 encode in HDR10 proffers deeper blacks and more nuanced color rendition compared to its Blu-ray counterpart. This makes darker scenes more legible without sacrificing detail, thanks to better gradational handling and enriched black levels, leading to a more immersive viewing experience. Metallic objects and various textures around the house and Morgan’s cell project more prominently with a polished sheen, bringing a slight but noticeable vibrancy to the otherwise bleak and sterilized setting. However, this increased clarity and depth don't drastically alter the film’s visual impact, as most enhancements are subtle and do not dramatically redefine the viewer's engagement with the narrative's visual tone.
The chosen color scheme under the HDR enhancement leans towards desaturation, particularly in outdoor sequences, granting the film an illusory vibrancy amidst its somber narrative. Indoor scenes maintain a sterile atmosphere, while natural settings outside showcase a broader spectrum of muted greens, browns, and golds. Despite notable improvements in shadow detail and texture clarity—especially in close-ups where facial details and subtle hues are more perceptible—the image occasionally succumbs to minor aliasing issues. Regardless, this 4K UHD version stands as the definitive way to watch "Morgan", offering viewers the closest approximation to the filmmakers’ vision. Depth of field is expounded in exterior shots, enabling a more profound appreciation for the film's cinematographic choices, albeit within a marginally brighter picture that remains faithful to its originally intended aesthetics.
Audio: 75
"Morgan" arrives on 4K UHD Blu-ray with a DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 soundtrack that excels in delivering a comprehensive audio experience, despite not featuring the next-gen spatial audio formats like Dolby Atmos or DTS:X. Dialogue, the crown jewel of the film's sound design, is presented with crystal-clear transparency, offering realism and texture well-suited to the narrative's demands. The front soundstage is broad and warm, ensuring vocals are distinct and well-prioritized without overshadowing the film's score or ambient details. The absence of advanced audio formats does limit the potential elevation of certain scenes, particularly noticeable in action sequences or during moments that would benefit from overhead sound placement.
The soundscape skillfully utilizes the full range of its 7.1 channels to immerse viewers in its setting, from the claustrophobic confines of underground bunkers to the expansive outdoor environments. Ambient sounds and musical scores are neatly layered across the surround and rear channels, providing a sense of depth and movement that complements the onscreen action. Despite a few quieter scenes displaying a noticeable lack of atmospheric detail, the overall mix manages to maintain balance and immersion. Additionally, the LFE channel impresses with its subtle yet potent presence, punctuating key moments with impactful depth that enhances the film's emotional and narrative stakes without overwhelming the balance between dialogue and ambient sound.
Technical aspects aside, "Morgan" demonstrates a commendable use of its audio track to create a satisfying soundfield that supports both its quieter, dialogue-driven sequences and its more dynamic, action-oriented segments. The mix achieves an impressive dynamic range, allowing for nuanced differences in volume and intensity that keep viewers engaged. Max Richter's score benefits greatly from this treatment, with music that envelops audiences without detracting from the surrounding sound effects or dialogue clarity. Despite some missed opportunities due to format limitations, the presentation remains robust, expertly navigating the challenges of creating an auditory experience as compelling as its visuals.
Extras: 53
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Morgan" boasts a respectable collection of extras, albeit primarily housed on the accompanying 1080p disc rather than the UHD format itself. Most notable among these is "Loom," a visually captivating short film by Luke Scott featuring Giovanni Ribisi, which delves into themes of genetic engineering mirroring the main feature's narrative and sharing an aesthetic reminiscent of "Blade Runner." Additionally, the disc features "Modified Organism: The Science Behind Morgan," a documentary that explores the scientific and ethical dimensions of genetic engineering, serving both as an insightful complement to the film and an intriguing stand-alone piece. Director Luke Scott's audio commentary, though at times tends toward the monotonous, sporadically offers fascinating glimpses into the creative process behind his directorial debut. Deleted scenes with optional director commentary and a still gallery further enrich the package, alongside a redeemable Digital HD copy for added value. Despite most extras not exploiting the UHD format's potential, their inclusion significantly enhances the viewing experience for fans and newcomers alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Modified Organism: The Science Behind Morgan: A documentary examining the scientific background and ethical implications of genetic engineering.
- Deleted Scenes with optional Director Commentary: Offers insights into the filmmaking process and decisions behind scene exclusions.
- Loom – Short Film with Commentary by Director Luke Scott: An engaging short film exploring themes similar to Morgan, accentuated by directorial insights.
- Feature Length Director Audio Commentary: Luke Scott provides narration and occasional behind-the-scenes anecdotes.
- Gallery: A collection of stills from the film.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original promotional trailer for the film.
- Digital HD Copy: A digital version of the film redeemable online.
Movie: 49
"Morgan," a tale of bioengineering and synthetic evolution, plunges viewers into a narrative brimming with promise yet fraught with predictable pitfalls. At its core, Morgan represents an unparalleled leap in human ingenuity, a synthetic being forged from the dreams of her creators. With the capacity for rapid development and an emotional depth that blurs the lines of her humanity, she embodies the zenith of artificial intelligence research. However, this premise, while intriguing, unfolds in a terrain well-trodden by predecessors like "Ex Machina," offering a familiar exploration of AI in a 4K UHD format that yearns, but struggles, to set itself apart.
Directed by Luke Scott in a debut that echoes the thematic ambitions of his father Ridley Scott's works, the film attempts to navigate the murky ethics of creation and control within the sterile walls of a high-tech lab. Kate Mara stars as Lee Weathers, a consultant tasked with evaluating Morgan's viability after a series of unsettling incidents. The narrative positions itself on the cusp of innovation, yet stumbles into the trappings of genre clichés—a critique not just of its characters' decisions but of the script itself. Despite its aspirations for depth, the film often succumbs to predictable narrative arcs and underutilized talent, squandering the potential richness of its speculative foundation.
Technical aspects aside, "Morgan" does offer moments of reflection on the nature of consciousness and humanity through the lens of its titular character, portrayed with nuance by Anya Taylor-Joy. Yet, the film's exploration is hampered by its adherence to conventional storytelling and lackluster character development. The ensemble cast, replete with seasoned actors, is relegated to roles that offer little room for deviation from archetype or complexity. In essence, "Morgan" presents a missed opportunity to delve deeper into the ethical quandaries it superficially addresses, leaving viewers with a narrative that, while visually compelling in 4K UHD, ultimately fails to resonate beyond its surface-level intrigue.
Total: 66
"Morgan," a science fiction thriller directed by Luke Scott in his debut, receives a rather lukewarm reception as it makes its way to the Ultra HD Combo Pack. Presented by 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment, this addition to the genre not only fails to deliver on the script and direction but also struggles with making a strong case for its 4K UHD presentation. The film, which superficially explores themes similar to those in "Ex Machina," fails to captivate, with its story and character arcs drawing criticism for predictability and a lack of depth. Despite featuring some recognizable talents, the performances are undercut by the film's overall uninspired narrative and dull execution. Nevertheless, the release boasts of a solid lossless DTS-HD soundtrack that may appeal to audiophiles and a modest collection of supplements that fans might find worth exploring.
From a technical standpoint, the 4K UHD disc does offer subtle yet appreciable enhancements in video quality, including improved detail levels, shadow definition, and a more nuanced color palette, especially benefiting from High Dynamic Range (HDR) imaging. These improvements, however minor, present "Morgan" in a slightly better light than its standard Blu-ray counterpart, possibly appealing to those deeply interested in the visual aspects of home cinema. However, the film's overall presentation suffers from a lack of visual innovation and a compelling aesthetic that could have lifted it beyond its narrative shortcomings—an area where comparisons to more visually and thematically accomplished films only exacerbate its deficiencies.
In conclusion, while "Morgan" stumbles in several key areas—ranging from storytelling to directorial vision—the 4K UHD release does offer redeeming qualities through its audiovisual presentation, particularly for genre enthusiasts or collectors. The incremental improvements in video quality and a strong soundtrack might warrant attention for fans committed to experiencing the film in its best possible home format. However, for the average viewer or those seeking a truly remarkable science fiction experience, this release may not justify the investment, ultimately serving as a cautionary tale for both filmmakers and audiences about the challenges of blending high concepts with high-definition media.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Though as I mentioned in my Morgan Blu-ray review the IMDb once again omits any technical data about this shoot, Panavision's site states it was shot with Arri Alexa XT cameras and a couple of secondary...
Audio: 80
However, as tends to be the case with Fox UHD releases, the audio options on the 4K UHD disc differ from those on the included 1800p Blu-ray disc, so those interested should compare the specs listed on...
Extras: 90
The other supplements listed in our Morgan Blu-ray review are available on the 1080p Blu-ray also included in this package....
Movie: 50
Ex Machina hasn't been graced with a 4K UHD release (yet), so those jonesin' for a tale about AI might be interested in this tale in this format....
Total: 20
That said, the 4K UHD disc offers some subtle but noticeable improvements in detail levels, shadow definition, and especially palette, and so those intrigued by the film may well want to check out this...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 90
Colors are desaturated just a bit, which adds a coolness to the image, and yet most of the hues that have been desaturated were warm to start – browns, greens, golds, yellows....
Audio: 85
Colors are desaturated just a bit, which adds a coolness to the image, and yet most of the hues that have been desaturated were warm to start – browns, greens, golds, yellows....
Extras: 60
It stars Giovanni Ribisi and is actually somewhat interesting, though it has a very obvious Blade Runner vibe....
Movie: 70
Lee Weathers (Kate Mara) is risk-management consultant for high technology firm, sent to a remote lab where a team of scientists has been working to create a synthetic human being....
Total: 76
Still, at just ninety-two minutes, it’s short enough, pretty enough (especially with HDR), and mildly interesting enough to be worth a look if you appreciate this genre....
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 70
Specular highlights give metallic objects and the edges of other random items a nice polished, glistening glow, but the image still looks similar to its 1080p counterpart....
Audio: 80
Even at its loudest, which really are the couple moments of guns being fired, the lossless mix maintains excellent detailed clarity thanks to a room-penetrating, extensive dynamic range....
Extras: 30
Modified Organism (HD, 20 min) — With interviews from experts and the filmmakers, the piece examines the science behind the plot, and some even superficially dive into the ethical and moral issues surrounding...
Movie: 10
Although it doesn't follow any recognizable formula, which could have been to its advantage in the hands of a better-skilled filmmaker, the plot nonetheless follows a predictable order of chaos from these...
Total: 50
Starring some familiar faces alongside bigger named stars, the sci-fi thriller cautioning the dangers of genetically engineering human hybrids is neither suspenseful, thought-provoking or cautionary, leaving...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 70
On occasion, discernible improvements in depth could be seen in wide angle shots such as those taking place in the woods, or later at the lake, but in most respects I saw only incremental differences in...
Audio: 86
This is primarily a dialog driven film however there are elements in the film that require use of the entire system so its ability to clearly render them is essential....
Extras: 30
Disc 1: Morgan Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: Morgan Ultra HD Blu-ray (HD) Modified Organism: The Science Behind Morgan – 19 minute documentary (HD) 4 Deleted Scenes with optional Director Commentary (HD) “Loom”...
Movie: 50
Morgan is enigmatic and unpredictable—a lab-created being with emotional capacity and conflicting traits that blur the line between being human and synthetic....
Total: 59
It comes to Blu-ray in the Ultra HD Combo Pack from 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment featuring unremarkable video quality, solid lossless sound and a bland supplemental package....
Why So Blu? review by Brian WhiteRead review here
Video: 90
Black Levels: The black levels are deep and inky and thankfully the HDR shines through here with fine details in the shadows because like I said multiple times now this is a very dark show....
Audio: 90
Rather the rear channels are very subtle and when called upon very responsive putting you in the middle of all the drama....
Extras: 60
To round out the extras here there is a redeemable Digital HD version of the film good towards either iTunes or UltraViolet use, but not both....
Movie: 70
What made this scream Ex Machina for me was the fact that this secret base or lair as I like to call it in Morgan practically looked from the outside like it actually was from the former film....
Total: 70
Director: Luke Scott
Actors: Kate Mara, Anya Taylor-Joy, Rose Leslie
PlotIn a remote, top-secret lab, a group of scientists led by Dr. Simon Ziegler has created a synthetic being named Morgan, who, despite being just five years old, has the physical appearance of a teenage girl. Morgan embodies the pinnacle of artificial biological engineering, a next-generation leap in evolution with the potential to revolutionize the world. However, an unexpected and violent incident involving Morgan prompts corporate troubleshooter Lee Weathers to visit the facility to conduct a risk assessment. Lee is a no-nonsense and calculating consultant whose sole focus is to evaluate whether the project should continue or be terminated.
Inside the facility, Lee observes the complex emotional attachments between Morgan and her caretakers, including behaviorist Dr. Amy Menser, who treats Morgan like a human child, and Dr. Kathy Grieff, who has formed a maternal bond with the creation. The team's dynamics are complicated by their diverse reactions to the incident, with some arguing for empathy and understanding, while others stress caution due to Morgan's unpredictable nature. As Lee delves deeper, she encounters a web of desires, fears, and moral compromises among the staff, which raises serious questions about the capacity for artificial entities to possess human-like traits and the ethical boundaries of such scientific experimentation.
Writers: Seth W. Owen
Release Date: 02 Sep 2016
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Mandarin