The Incredible Melting Man Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "The Incredible Melting Man" by Scream Factory is commendable for its impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer, formatted in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. This release excels in showcasing vibrant color saturation, particularly during daytime scenes, where fine details are vividly captured. Close-ups reveal impeccable facial textures and costume details, though occasionally making the delineation of makeup effects apparent. The film elements used are in commendable condition, displaying minimal damage and maintaining a polished clean presentation for much of the film. However, certain stock footage segments stand out with noticeable grain and softness compared to the overall high-quality transfer.

Despite the solid restoration, there are some noted issues in the low light scenes. Shadow detail can be lacking, occasionally resulting in shadow crushing and motion blur. Additionally, minor dirt and scratches are sporadically present but do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. The consistency of skin tones and overall visual clarity during daylight sequences, such as those depicted in the opening space scenes, highlight every intricate texture vividly, contributing to an overall captivating visual experience.

Scream Factory's effort is praiseworthy given the original low-budget constraints and vintage special effects of "The Incredible Melting Man." The remastering efforts significantly enhance the film's presentation without compromising its original essence. This Blu-ray release by Shout! Factory provides an excellent visual treat for fans and collectors, ensuring the movie's practical effects and nostalgic charm are meticulously showcased.

The audio presentation of "The Incredible Melting Man" on Blu-ray is delivered through a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix, which presents a faithful yet unremarkable replication of the film’s original mono track. While the dialogue is generally clean and easy to discern, it tends to feel somewhat flat and soft at times. Foley effects come through adequately, providing some clarity, though none are particularly impactful. The sound design isn’t highly ambitious, sticking closely to the film's source material, which results in a serviceable audio experience that lacks depth and directionality.

Despite some front-channel action that moves between speakers, the track does not exhibit significant dynamic range or bass impact, often essential in the horror genre to elevate suspense and immersion. The fidelity of the audio is consistently good, but the lack of a punchier soundscape leaves much to be desired for audiophiles and horror aficionados alike. While there are no glaring issues or damage present in the mix, it remains a sub-par audio presentation that doesn’t quite enhance the film’s chilling atmosphere effectively.

The Blu-ray extras for "The Incredible Melting Man" offer a delightful deep dive into the film's production and legacy. The Commentary with William Sachs is a must-listen for enthusiasts, blending technical insights and candid reflections, often tinged with humor and irony. Another highlight is the Interview with Writer/Director William Sachs and Makeup Effects Artist Rick Baker, where both discuss production challenges and personal anecdotes separately, adding depth to the understanding of the film's creation. Additionally, the Interview with Makeup Effects Artist Greg Cannom provides brief but enjoyable insights into his contribution during reshoots. The package is rounded out by nostalgic Theatrical Trailers, a Photo Gallery, and a vintage Radio Spot.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary with William Sachs: Entertaining and informative commentary about the film's troubled production.
• Interview with Writer/Director William Sachs and Makeup Effects Artist Rick Baker: Separate interviews discussing the film’s creation and challenges.
• Interview with Makeup Effects Artist Greg Cannom: Brief insights into reshoot contributions.
• Theatrical Trailers: Nostalgic trailers for the film.
• Photo Gallery: Collection of stills, behind-the-scenes images, posters, and lobby cards.
• Radio Spot: Vintage audio radio spot for the film.

"The Incredible Melting Man" showcases a fascinating yet flawed journey from a director's vision to a studio-mandated product. William Sachs' initial concept aimed for a mysterious and humor-infused homage to EC Comics’ horror tales, but was vastly altered by producers seeking broader appeal. The result is a film that lays out all its narrative cards too early, sacrificing any sense of intrigue or suspense. The final version feels predictable and campy, a sequence of uneven, disconnected scenes where the titular character, astronaut Steve West, melts due to radiation exposure and sporadically kills people.

While Sachs envisioned a more enigmatic and comedic narrative, the producers opted for a pseudo-serious tone that backfired, leading to unintentional humor. This disconnect is most apparent in the dialogue, laden with unearned gravitas, and the overall lack of cohesive storytelling. Despite its narrative faults, "The Incredible Melting Man" finds some redemption in Rick Baker’s practical effects, which remain awe-inspiring even by modern standards. Baker’s grotesque makeup work provides a visceral thrill that stands out amidst the otherwise lackluster plot and performances.

The acting is notably subpar, with Burr DeBenning’s portrayal of Dr. Ted Nelson serving as a highlight mainly for its unintentional comedic value due to his wooden performance. The film’s structure becomes monotonous as new characters are introduced solely for their imminent deaths. However, for enthusiasts of 'so-bad-it's-good' cinema and vintage practical effects, this film offers an odd charm. It may have missed its mark as a horror-comedy masterpiece due to studio interference, but it has found its niche in the annals of cult cinema, appealing particularly to fans in midnight screenings and festival circuits.

"The Incredible Melting Man," despite falling short of its potential due to executive meddling, remains an intriguing watch for specific audiences. Originally intended as a more suspenseful film by director William Sachs, its early plot reveal diminishes much of the tension, rendering it more of a campy monster flick. The film's makeup and special effects by the legendary Rick Baker are unquestionably its highlight, showcasing some of his best work and adding a layer of credibility to an otherwise uneven production.

The Blu-ray release by Scream Factory is commendable in its technical execution. The video remastering is impressive, significantly enhancing the visual experience with sharp, detailed images that surpass expectations for a film of this era. The audio quality, though not exceptional, is serviceable and complements the improved visual presentation. The Blu-ray comes with a selection of entertaining extras that provide deeper insight into the film’s production, which fans of the genre and Rick Baker will particularly appreciate.

In conclusion, "The Incredible Melting Man" is a worthwhile addition for collectors of Scream Factory releases and enthusiasts of practical effects. However, for the general viewer, it may serve better as a rental or a fun time shared with friends for its "so bad it's good" charm. While it may not fulfill its original artistic vision, it stands as an amusing homage to classic monster films that warrants at least one viewing.