Macbeth Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of Orson Welles' "Macbeth," presented in an aspect ratio of 1.33:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, features a 1080p transfer from new digital restorations. The film's visual presentation includes both the 1948 and 1950 versions, offering unique insights into the restoration processes performed. Notably, despite improvements, some source limitations such as density fluctuations and grain exposure persist across both versions. Comparisons with a prior French release reveal that any additional cleanup has retained the fundamental characteristics of the original footage. The brightness settings show minor discrepancies; the new restorations appear slightly darker yet maintain a balanced presentation given the condition of the surviving elements.

Technically, the film benefits from a clean high definition transfer, exhibiting good clarity and detail. Despite the noir-like, haunting atmosphere, intricate details like backdrop cloth folds and scratches are vividly portrayed, adding to the film's charm. Depth work is commendable, giving characters a smooth and cinematic presence separate from the background. Black levels are deep and rich, enhancing overall picture quality while maintaining texture details in clothing, hair follicles, and rock formations. Although color reproduction is not specified, flesh tones adhere to a consistent white/gray look congruent with the film's lighting. The presence of inherent grain along with occasional dirt specs and light streaks preserves the film's classic aesthetic without detracting from viewing pleasure.

In summary, the Blu-ray release delivers a visual experience that remains true to Orson Welles' artistic vision. While minor source limitations and artifacts are present, they do little to undermine the significant improvements brought about by the new restorations, providing an engaging and high-quality look at this classic film.

Both versions of the film, "Macbeth," are presented with English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 tracks, accompanied by optional yellow English SDH subtitles. The inclusion of subtitles is particularly beneficial given the occasionally thick highland accents, which, while adding authenticity, can impede comprehension. The audio presentation showcases commendable clarity and depth, though a slight "thinness" may sporadically manifest. However, there are no reported audio dropouts or distortions, further solidifying the high-quality audio experience.

The mono audio track is notably well-executed, capturing the essence of "Macbeth" with precision. The dynamic range is impressive, particularly during lower frequency moments such as storms, where depth and clarity are truly highlighted. The balance between score, effects, and vocals is expertly managed, allowing each element to be distinct without overshadowing the others. Dialogue reproduction stands out for its clarity and fullness, with voices coming through in a well-rounded and layered presentation. This ensures that the legendary voice of Welles, or any actor’s delivery, is rendered effectively and authentically.

Although there is a slight audible hiss owing to the film's analog roots, it imbues the presentation with a sense of authenticity rather than detracting from the auditory experience. Therefore, this audio presentation provides a robust and genuine listening experience that complements the film’s historical and dramatic weight.

The Blu-ray release of "Macbeth" offers a well-rounded suite of extras that delve deeply into the intricacies of the film and Orson Welles’ relationship with Shakespeare’s works. Expert analyses and personal anecdotes provide unique insights, making these features particularly valuable for film historians and enthusiasts. Highlights include a compelling audio commentary by Welles biographer Joseph McBride, in-depth interviews with notable scholars and filmmakers, and restorative insights from former UCLA Film & Television Archive Preservation Officer Robert Gitt. This curated collection of extras enhances the viewing experience, providing context and depth to Welles' cinematic adaptation.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: Joseph McBride discusses Macbeth’s production history, visual style, and reception.
• Welles and Shakespeare: Prof. Michael Anderegg on Welles’ Shakespeare films.
• Adapting Shakespeare on Film: Directors Carlo Carlei and Billy Morrissette on their appreciation for Macbeth.
• We Walk Again: Excerpt from a 1937 WPA documentary featuring Welles.
• That Was Orson Welles: Interview with Peter Bogdanovich on Welles' methods and friendship.
• Restoring Macbeth: Robert Gitt on challenges in restoring the film's original version.
• Free Republic: Marc Wanamaker discusses Republic Pictures' history.
• Orson Welles's Macbeth: An essay by Jonathan Rosenbaum.

Orson Welles’ "Macbeth" is a remarkably distinctive adaptation of William Shakespeare's classic tragedy, echoing both noir and Expressionist influences in its visual and thematic execution. Notably shot at CBS Studio Center with cinematographer John L. Russell, known for his work on Hitchcock’s "Psycho," the film presents an evocative and hauntingly surreal atmosphere. The film's economical production budget did not hinder its visual spectacle; Welles and his team utilized generic costumes and reappropriated Western sets to striking effect, creating a moody, gothic environment that feels more like a haunted dreamscape than a traditional theatrical adaptation.

This adaptation diverges from Shakespeare’s original text, both through its visual style and narrative embellishments. Emphasizing Macbeth's internal angst and tragic ambition, Welles' portrayal is imbued with a bleak, melancholic aura. While the film introduces fictional characters and variances in event significance, it retains the essential framework of the play. The witches' scenes are particularly iconic, providing an eerie prelude and conclusion that resonate through the entire narrative. The pervasive fog and shadowy cinematography serve to amplify the ominous tone, transforming the dialogue into almost secondary elements.

The supporting cast delivers commendable performances, with Janet Nolan’s debut as Lady Macbeth often highlighted for her manipulative intensity. Similarly, Dan O'Herlihy's Macduff and an intriguingly young Roddy McDowall as Malcolm add depth to the ensemble. Musical contributions from French composer Jacques Ibert further underscore the film’s dark ambiance.

Overall, the film remains a polarizing piece among critics and viewers due to its unconventional approach, but ardent fans of Welles and film history buffs will find much to appreciate in its audacious stylistic choices and dramatic reinterpretations. With this Blu-ray release including restored versions of both the 1948 and 1950 cuts, enthusiasts have an excellent opportunity to explore Welles' innovative vision in enhanced detail.

Olive Films' Signature Edition Blu-ray of Orson Welles' "Macbeth" impressively combines high-quality restoration with enriching educational extras. The digital restorations of both versions of the film offer viewers an outstanding visual experience, made even more exceptional by the terrific mono audio track. Every detail of Welles' innovative cinematography is brought to life beautifully in this release.

The supplementary features added to this edition provide valuable insights into Welles' creative process and the historical context of the film. These extras, alongside optional subtitles, ensure that audiences can fully appreciate and understand Welles' approach to this classic Shakespearean text. The inclusion of these features makes this release an educational asset and a comprehensive viewing experience.

There are plenty of good reasons to recommend this upcoming two-disc set of Orson Welles' Macbeth. The most obvious ones are these: It has both versions of the film sourced from recent digital restorations and a good selection of supplemental features. Unlike the first release, this release also has optional subtitles for viewers that might need them -- and there are probably quite a few that will appreciate them. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.