White Material Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"White Material" from the Criterion Collection offers superb video and audio with excellent interviews, though more special features would enhance it.
Disc Release Date
Video: 67
Criterion’s Blu-ray of 'White Material,' in 1080p with MPEG-4 AVC encoding and supervised by Claire Denis and Yves Cape, offers exceptional clarity, natural lighting, and rich color saturation. Subtle differences from Artificial Eye’s release include better compression and marginally superior black levels, making it the definitive version.
Audio: 67
The French DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on the Blu-ray of 'White Material' is exceptional, delivering a crisp and stable dialog alongside a dynamic and atmospheric soundtrack. The lossless audio mix employs detailed environmental sounds and an intense score that effectively enhance the film's tension.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras for 'White Material' offer a comprehensive view into the film's creation with exclusive Criterion interviews featuring Claire Denis, Isabelle Huppert, and Isaach De Bankolé, a deleted scene, a 2010 Ecrans Noirs Film Festival documentary, and an insightful booklet by Amy Taubin, all presented in high-definition.
Movie: 81
Claire Denis' 'White Material' is a visually stunning, deeply personal film set in an unnamed African nation amidst political chaos, offering a haunting narrative that intertwines Maria Vial's harrowing determination to harvest her coffee plantation, with sharp cinematography by Yves Cape and a compelling soundtrack by Stuart Staples. The Criterion Blu-ray excels with exclusive interviews, a short film, deleted scenes, and an insightful illustrated booklet.
Video: 67
Criterion's Blu-ray release of "White Material" is presented in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, providing a 1080p transfer that sets a benchmark for the film's video quality. This new high-definition transfer was meticulously supervised and approved by director Claire Denis and cinematographer Yves Cape, created from a 35 mm interpositive using a Spirit Datacine. The restoration process involved the careful removal of thousands of instances of dirt, debris, scratches, warps, jitter, and flicker through Anti Scratch and MTI's DRS system. The telecine process was closely overseen by Denis and Cape, with color correction executed by Eddy Nakaa at Eclair Labs, Paris.
The Criterion transfer holds up exceptionally well when juxtaposed against the British Artificial Eye release. While both versions are quite similar, the Criterion version presents a slightly superior saturation of reds, browns, and blacks. Fine object detail is extraordinary; close-ups of Isabelle Huppert are impressive in their clarity while panoramic vistas display tighter compression with no visible edge-enhancement or macroblocking. Stability remains flawless throughout the viewing experience, with zero evidence of noise reduction or stability issues.
Visually, "White Material" benefits immensely from its natural lighting cinematography. The image retains a nice amount of film grain which adds to its authentic and raw aesthetic. Individual details, such as rogue strands of hair or numerous coffee beans in a vat, are clearly distinguishable, highlighting the transfer's sharpness and detail. The color palette is rich and naturalistic, with heavy reds standing out against verdant greens. Black levels are generally excellent, maintaining depth without losing detail in shadows, save for minor exceptions at the 54th and 99th-minute marks. Aliasing is nearly non-existent, aside from a subtle instance around the 72nd minute. Overall, Criterion's Blu-ray release of "White Material" offers outstanding video quality that keenly enhances its visual storytelling nuances.
Audio: 67
The Blu-ray edition of "White Material" boasts a French DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that significantly enhances the overall viewing experience. The soundtrack, mastered at 24-bit from the original digital audio files using Pro Tools HD, ensures a rich and immersive audio presentation. Stuart Staples' mood-laden score benefits immensely from this lossless format, offering a wide range of nuanced dynamics that amplify the film's tension. The dialogue is consistently clear, crisp, and easily comprehensible, with no detectable anomalies such as pops, cracks, hissings, or audio dropouts.
Besides the music, the environmental sound effects are meticulously detailed and layered. This is evident in sequences featuring the distant chirping of bugs, the smoldering of fires, and other ambient noises. These acoustic elements are spread thoughtfully throughout the surround channels, adding depth to scenes and frequently contributing to the film's tense atmosphere. Imaging is utilized masterfully in sequences such as a military helicopter flying over a plantation, where precise positioning and movement of audio elements heighten the realism and urgency.
While the mix knows when to be subtle, it equally knows when to deliver impactful moments that elevate the overall auditory experience. Every detail, from insect sounds to the rumbling bass notes of the score, is presented with a purpose, transforming "White Material" into not just a visual but a deeply auditory cinematic experience. Optional English subtitles are available and are conveniently placed within the video frame for non-French speakers, ensuring accessibility while maintaining the film's immersive qualities.
Extras: 66
The Blu-ray extras for "White Material" by Criterion provide a comprehensive and insightful look into the film's production and the motivations behind its characters. The in-depth interviews with director Claire Denis, lead actress Isabelle Huppert, and actor Isaach De Bankolé offer valuable context, detailing Denis' inspiration, Huppert's character analysis, and Bankolé's perspectives on his role and working with the director. The deleted scene gives a glimpse into an intense, albeit unfinished, moment which adds emotional weight but slightly impacts the pacing of the climactic sequence. The documentary short captures the director's poignant return to Cameroon for the film's challenging premiere at the Écrans Noirs Film Festival. The original theatrical trailer and a beautifully designed booklet featuring an essay by Amy Taubin further enrich the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interviews: Three exclusive interviews featuring insights from Claire Denis, Isabelle Huppert, and Isaach De Bankolé.
- Deleted Scene: An unfinished yet powerful scene illustrating critical events.
- Écrans Noirs Film Festival, 2010: A documentary short on the film's premiere in Cameroon.
- Trailer: The original theatrical trailer.
- Booklet: An illustrated booklet with an essay by Amy Taubin.
Movie: 81
Claire Denis' White Material takes place in an unnamed African country on the brink of collapse, capturing a vivid, unsettling atmosphere reminiscent of Johnny Mad Dog. The narrative centers around Maria Vial (Isabelle Huppert), a white French woman intent on saving the family coffee plantation amid rising chaos. Her determination clashes with the impending danger articulated by her husband Andre (Christopher Lambert), who urges evacuation. This tension forked by external threats and internal decisions propels the story with unnerving suspense, highlighting Maria's complex character grappling with survival instincts and sense of belonging.
The film’s structure interweaves flashbacks and present moments, revealing key events piecemeal, and cumulating towards a powerful conclusion. This creative non-linear storytelling draws viewers deeply into the unfolding dread. The opening scene visually depicts devastation—burned buildings and charred remains—setting a grim tone that defines the ensuing narrative. Maria's harrowing journey, juxtaposed against military and rebel activities, portrays a visceral depiction of civil unrest. Her interactions with soldiers and rebels starkly emphasize her vulnerability and the brutality surrounding her.
White Material stands out not just for its grim storyline but also for its admirable technical aspects. Yves Cape’s cinematography captures the landscape with haunting beauty, while Stuart Staples’ evocative soundtrack underscores the film’s emotional depth. Huppert's performance is predictably stellar, with her portrayal of Maria exhibiting raw resilience and desperation without ever fully exposing her inner turmoil. The film's open-ended conclusion invites contemplation rather than providing easy answers, aligning with Denis' personal and unflinching exploration of post-colonial identity and instability.
Criterion’s Blu-ray release significantly enhances these features, ensuring faithful image and sound reproduction that preserves Denis' artistic vision. Supplementary materials like interviews, a documentary short on Denis' return to Cameroon, and an insightful essay by Amy Taubin further enrich the viewing experience, making this offering a pivotal addition for serious cinephiles.
Total: 68
Claire Denis' "White Material" stands out as one of her most compelling films, a testament to her masterful storytelling and intricate exploration of complex themes. The Criterion Collection Blu-ray release of "White Material" proves to be an exemplary package, boasting superior video and audio quality that faithfully preserves the film’s visceral portrayal of post-colonial Africa's social and political fabric. The raw, unfiltered depictions of life’s multifaceted challenges are rendered with a poignant authenticity that enhances viewer engagement.
Technically, the Blu-ray disc excels. The picture quality is sharp, detailed, and maintains excellent color balance throughout, encapsulating the earthy tones and vibrant landscapes integral to the film’s setting. The sound is equally remarkable, with a clear and well-balanced mix that underscores the film’s atmospheric tension. While the core audiovisual experience holds up to the high standards expected from Criterion, some may find the special features slightly lacking in quantity. The included interviews are insightful and enriching, yet long-time Criterion enthusiasts might yearn for more supplementary material to delve even deeper into Denis' creative process and themes.
In conclusion, "White Material" is an essential watch for fans of Claire Denis and appreciators of profound cinema. This Criterion Blu-ray release effectively captures the essence of the film, rendering its multifaceted narrative and intense emotional core with exceptional technical precision. Despite a modest offering of bonus content, the release's overall quality makes it a highly recommended addition to any serious film collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
Supervised by director Claire Denis and cinematographer Yves Cape, this high-definition transfer looks very similar to the one British distributors Artificial Eye used for their Blu-ray release of White...
Audio: 90
As I mentioned in our review for the Artificial Eye Blu-ray release of White Material, Stuart Staples' dark and moody soundtrack benefits enormously from the loseless treatment....
Extras: 80
Ecrans Noirs Film Festival, 2010 - a short film documenting director Claire Denis' return to Cameroon for the 2010 premiere of White Material at the Ecrans Noirs Film Festival....
Movie: 90
White Material is something of a confession, a very personal film that allows director Denis, who grew up in colonial Africa, to reconnect with the 'dark continent'....
Total: 90
I believe that many would agree that White Material is one of director Claire Denis' best films, very much on par with Chocolate, Beau travail, and L'intrus....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Edge enhancement, DNR, artifacts, bands and noise never appear, but one shot in around the 72 minute mark reveals slight aliasing in the grate covering a fan....
Audio: 80
Imaging is also effectively used several times, like in one scene where a military chopper passes above the plantation blaring warnings over the megaphone and dropping survival kits for the soon-to-be...
Extras: 60
She not only talks casting, but explains the difficult shoot (lighting equipment was lost in transit and didn't arrive until four weeks into the shoot) and the scoring of the film....
Movie: 80
Just as you're the most involved with the film as you've been the whole time, it cuts to black and the credits begin rolling....
Total: 80
I've come to the conclusion that if you're leery of watching foreign films based on the fear of watching something unworthy, the only way to ensure a great viewing experience is by sticking to Criterion...
Director: Claire Denis
Actors: Isabelle Huppert, Christopher Lambert, Isaach De Bankolé
PlotIn an unnamed African country on the brink of civil war, Maria Vial, a resilient and determined coffee plantation owner, refuses to abandon her land despite the escalating violence. She is committed to completing the coffee harvest, believing that it is critical to her family's survival and the livelihood of her workers. Her conviction is not shared by her workers, who begin to desert the plantation as the threat from approaching rebel forces looms larger. The government army warns Maria and her family to leave for their safety, but she is adamant in her decision to stay, hoping that her long-standing relationships and her white skin will offer some protection from the surrounding chaos.
As the fighting intensifies, Maria's tenacity is put to the test. External pressures mount as she faces opposition from her family, with her ex-husband and father-in-law urging her to seek refuge. Meanwhile, her aloof son falls into a state of disarray, and uninvited danger arrives at her doorstep in the form of a wounded rebel leader seeking shelter. Maria's fixation on saving the harvest blinds her to the greater peril engulfing her world. The true extent of the threat to Maria, her family, and her land becomes increasingly evident as the country spirals further into violence and disorder.
Writers: Claire Denis, Marie N'Diaye, Lucie Borleteau
Release Date: 24 Mar 2010
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: France, Cameroon
Language: French