The Whistleblower Blu-ray Review
Score: 50
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Whistleblower offers a powerful, visually impressive Blu-ray experience, though it may be better suited for a one-time viewing rather than purchase.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
The Whistleblower's Blu-ray presentation boasts a strong 1080p/AVC encode faithfully replicating the moody 35mm cinematography with an intentionally gritty and somber palette. Details in close-ups are commendable, though blacks can obscure some elements. There's no digital noise reduction, edge enhancement, or compression artifacts.
Audio: 58
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack for 'The Whistleblower' features clear, well-articulated dialogue and dynamic sound effects, relying on the full soundstage for proper atmosphere with occasional ambient rear channel usage and impactful low frequency effects. The mix offers a balanced, immersive experience.
Extra: 16
The sole bonus feature, 'Kathy Bolkovac: The Real Whistleblower,' offers a concise 5-minute HD overview with interviews from Bolkovac, Weisz, and the film's creators, shedding light on the real-life story and performances.
Movie: 57
The Whistleblower is a gripping, albeit imperfect film that exposes the harrowing world of sex trafficking within the UN. The Blu-ray features impeccable performances, especially from Rachel Weisz, despite the film's narrative and directorial shortcomings. Technical details include a BD50 disc in a Region A locked eco-case with skippable trailers.
Video: 58
"The Whistleblower" arrives on Blu-ray with a generally satisfying 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 presentation (2.35:1). Filmed on grainy 35mm, director of photography Kieren McGuigan’s intentionally gritty and moody cinematography is well-replicated in this format. The film maintains a cooler overall palette, with primary colors appearing satisfying against the drab settings that underpin the story. Unlike many modern releases, the chunky grain structure remains untouched by digital noise reduction, and there are no evident signs of edge enhancement or compression artifacts.
The contrast curve in "The Whistleblower" is heavily weighted in the shadows, occasionally obscuring detail in darker scenes. This intentional choice complements the film’s theme, though it could be argued that slightly less intense black levels might have allowed for better visibility. The transfer features a bluish-gray overtone that drains much color; skin tones appear healthy but are intentionally not completely natural. While facial, hair, and clothing textures are adequately sharp and detailed, a few scenes exhibit a softer focus, creating minor haziness. Shadows sometimes overwhelm, leading to loss of some background information.
The overall image quality, while not strikingly glossy or razor-sharp, successfully captures the film’s intended atmosphere. Close-ups and mid-level shots demonstrate the resolve of subtle details in people and objects within the frame. Contrast is steady and stable throughout, contributing to the somber feel filmmakers aimed for. While the visual presentation may not compete with some newer releases in terms of resolvable detail and depth, it represents a faithful port to home video. This Blu-ray presentation aligns well with the film's gritty aesthetic and delivers a robust yet subdued viewing experience.
Audio: 58
The DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack for "The Whistleblower" presented on the Blu-ray by 20th Century Fox delivers a capable and clear audio experience. Dialogue is consistently clean, intelligible, and well-prioritized, ensuring clarity in both intense and intimate scenes. The front-heavy design emphasizes spoken interactions and intimate conversations effectively, although there are moments when whispered dialogue strains slightly against the ambient soundscape. Sound effects are dynamically weighted, providing full-bodied and well-placed acoustic experiences within the sound field.
While not an extravagant showcase of ear candy, the surround sound presentation leverages the rear channels for environmental ambience, such as rain, wind, and background noise in various scenes, enhancing the immersion. Effects like UN vans, exploding land mines, and helicopters are convincingly placed among speakers, with the subwoofer adding necessary dramatic oomph impressively without overwhelming the entire mix. Although the overall quality might seem unremarkable compared to more complex soundtracks, it excels in delivering the right sounds at the right levels, producing a balanced and detailed dynamic range with solid low-frequency effects.
Extras: 16
The supplementary content of "The Whistleblower" Blu-ray disc is succinct but effective, featuring a single, focused piece that offers valuable insights into the real-life persona behind the film. This extra, titled "Kathy Bolkovac: The Real Whistleblower," provides an engaging and informative overview, presenting interviews with Kathy Bolkovac herself, as well as Rachel Weisz, the film's writers, and the director. The featurette effectively bridges the gap between the dramatized portrayal and true events, offering viewers a deeper understanding of the narrative's authenticity and emotional gravity. Though concise, at approximately 5 to 6 minutes in length and presented in 1080p HD, it stands out by enriching the viewer's overall experience with its professional and insightful production.
Extras included in this disc:
Kathy Bolkovac: The Real Whistleblower: A short featurette with interviews from Bolkovac, Weisz, the film's writers, and director.
Movie: 57
"The Whistleblower," directed by Larysa Kondracki, is a harrowing exploration of institutional corruption and sex trafficking that showcases an unforgettable performance by Rachel Weisz. The narrative centers on Kathryn Bolkovac, a former Nebraska cop who takes a U.N. peacekeeping role in post-war Bosnia and becomes entangled in exposing a sex trafficking ring involving fellow peacekeepers and military contractors. The film's tone is comparable to Weisz's "The Constant Gardener," dealing with organizations exploiting vulnerable populations they are supposed to protect. Its unflinching portrayal of these issues successfully provokes moral outrage without descending into preachiness.
While "The Whistleblower" falls short as a political thriller due to some narrative shortcomings and heavy-handed dramatization, it remains a powerful piece of social issue cinema. The script co-written by Kondracki and Eilis Kirwan, while at times overly expository, provides a framework for strong performances across the board. Weisz embodies the driven passion of Bolkovac with gritty realism, and the supporting cast, including Vanessa Redgrave and David Strathairn, lend admirable depth to the story. Despite some amateurish photography techniques and depth-of-field adjustments that distract more than they enhance, the film succeeds in making viewers profoundly uncomfortable with its stark depiction of human rights abuses and the pervasive corruption that shields them.
The emotional core of the film is anchored by Bolkovac's relationship with Raya, a young girl sold into prostitution. As Kathryn's investigation deepens, the institutional obstacles and dangers she faces escalate, showcasing the extensive, top-to-bottom corruption within the U.N. The film could benefit from tighter editing and subtlety in its delivery, but Rachel Weisz's compelling performance ensures it remains an essential, if disturbing, watch. Even with its flaws, "The Whistleblower" achieves its goal of raising awareness about the abhorrent realities of human trafficking and the often-complicit systems that allow it to flourish.
Total: 50
The Whistleblower will make you angry--at institutional hypocrisy, at bureaucratic mumbo-jumbo, at the kind of men who would buy and sell women as sex slaves--and that's precisely the point. This film wants you to know that sex trafficking exists, and that something needs to be done about it. It wants you to be morally outraged, and you will be. Of course, Big Issue movies like this always run into the danger of prioritizing the social message over the storytelling, and yes, The Whistleblower could use some narrative tightening, but it avoids most of the usual didactic pitfalls and makes its case while being entertaining--if the word can be applied to a film about sex trafficking--and emotionally powerful. The film looks and sounds excellent on Blu-ray, but I might put this one in the rental rather than purchase category, as I'm not so sure it's something you'd want to watch repeatedly.
'The Whistleblower' is a well-intentioned drama inspired by the 1999 scandal involving human-trafficking and a U.S.-based contractor in post-war Bosnia. Unfortunately, the film is much too self-conscious in its aspirations to be taken seriously. Fortunately, the performance of its star keeps viewers invested and the story is one worth telling. The Blu-ray debuts with a very good audio and video presentation, but only one supplement, making the disc a decent rental.
Review:
"The Whistleblower" is a searing drama that exposes the dark realities of institutional corruption and human trafficking, reflecting on the 1999 scandal involving a U.S.-based contractor in post-war Bosnia. The film's emphasis on moral outrage is palpable, effectively drawing attention to the heinous problem of sex trafficking and the necessity for collective action. While there is a risk of the social message overshadowing the narrative, "The Whistleblower" largely avoids these pitfalls with its compelling storytelling and emotionally charged scenes.
Technically, the Blu-ray release of "The Whistleblower" excels in both video and audio quality. The high-definition presentation enhances the film’s gripping visuals, making the harrowing subject matter more immediate and affecting. However, it's worth noting that the disc contains only one supplemental feature, which is somewhat disappointing for those hoping for more in-depth insights or behind-the-scenes content.
In conclusion, while "The Whistleblower" is undoubtedly a powerful and important film, its heavy subject matter may not lend itself to multiple viewings. The excellent performance by the lead actress keeps it engaging throughout. Given the strong visual and audio quality of the Blu-ray, it is a highly recommended rental for those interested in hard-hitting dramas about significant social issues.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 80
The chunky grain structure hasn't been touched by digital noise reduction and there are no signs of edge enhancement or overt compression problems, making this a faithful port to home video....
Audio: 80
Although the experience is anchored up front, the rear channels are used fairly often for environmental ambience--like rain or wind or whore-house clamor--and occasional effects, from zipping UN vans and...
Extras: 20
The Real Whistleblower (1080p, 5:31), a short featurette that includes interviews with Bolkovac, Weisz, and the film's writers and director....
Movie: 70
As a Big Issue movie, it's engineered to provoke moral outrage--and it certainly does--but it also manages to avoid the sour preachiness of similar films by focusing intimately on a singular oppressed...
Total: 60
Of course, Big Issue movies like this always run into the danger of prioritizing the social message over the storytelling, and yes, The Whistleblower could use some narrative tightening, but it avoids...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Overall, the transfer looks great and as intended by its makers, with really good depth of field, but it's nothing that will blow your socks off....
Audio: 60
Imaging can seem quite wide and spacious during certain scenes, providing convincing off-screen effects and movement, but the overall quality is rather plain....
Extras: 0
The only supplement available on the package is a short overview of the real Kathryn Bolkovac, Rachel Weisz's performance and the plot with interviews, entitled Kathy Bolkovac:...
Movie: 40
Once Kathryn begins to slowly uncover a prostitution ring as a means for young women to pay their debts, a mystery thriller suddenly peeks through,and any argument for the last half hour's existence also...
Total: 40
The Blu-ray debuts with a very good audio and video presentation, but only one supplement, making the disc a decent rental....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
This video presentation offers little in the way of high Gloss, razor sharp imagery but it seems to represent the film's elements well....
Audio: 84
This is not a film that requires heavy use of surround sound to deliver its message but it does rely on the entire soundstage for proper atmosphere and low frequency detail from time to time....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 70
After learning that fellow peacekeepers and military contractors are involved in the ghastly practice and its cover-up, Bolkovac risks her own life to save the lives of others and expose the corruption....
Total: 65
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Larysa Kondracki
Actors: Rachel Weisz, Monica Bellucci, Vanessa Redgrave
PlotA dedicated and determined American police officer takes a job as a peacekeeper in post-war Bosnia, motivated by the promise of high pay and the opportunity to make a difference. Upon arrival, she discovers a chaotic and broken society struggling to rebuild. Her role quickly shifts from simple peacekeeping to investigative work when she uncovers a harrowing human trafficking ring operating within the country. The evidence she gathers indicates extensive corruption, implicating not only local officials but also members of the international peacekeeping community, including employees of private security firms contracted to help restore order.
Determined to bring justice to the victims and expose those responsible, she faces severe resistance and threats from every side. Her efforts to blow the whistle on the trafficking ring are consistently thwarted by the very organizations meant to assist and support her mission. As she delves deeper, she comes to realize the extent of the systemic corruption and the formidable power of those involved. Her struggle becomes one not just for justice, but also for her own survival, as she works to reveal the truth to the world and bring the perpetrators to justice, risking her career and safety in the process.
Writers: Larysa Kondracki, Eilis Kirwan
Release Date: 27 Oct 2011
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: R
Country: Canada, United States, Germany
Language: English, Romanian, Russian, Serbian, Ukrainian