The Cell Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A visceral experience with commendable audio and special features, though the video transfer shows edge enhancement and aliasing issues; a Blu-ray worth owning for fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
The new 1080p AVC-encoded Blu-ray release of "The Cell" features exceptional depth, detail, and vivid color reproduction, with impressive black levels and consistent grain rendering. The warm overall tone and lifelike fleshtones stand out, despite minor edge enhancement in early scenes and occasional speckles.
Audio: 76
The Cell's Blu-ray audio presentation, featuring a DTS-HD MA 5.1 track, excels with Howard Shore's evocative atonal score and dynamic soundscapes that blend traditional orchestration and trance music. Dialogue clarity and robust LFE add depth, while the aggressive yet immersive sound field enhances the cinematic experience.
Extra: 71
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Cell' are largely ported from the 2004 Platinum Series DVD, featuring insightful commentaries from Director Tarsem Singh and the production team, a visual effects vignette, deleted scenes including an alternate ending, and trailers, albeit upscaled and sometimes lacking true HD quality.
Movie: 66
The Cell's innovative blend of police procedural and psychological thriller, helmed by Tarsem Singh, transforms a standard serial killer plot into a grand operatic spectacle; its Blu-ray edition features the director's cut showcasing stunningly grotesque visuals and an intriguing narrative twist, set within the bizarre landscapes of the mind.
Video: 66
The video presentation of "The Cell" on Blu-ray is a standout achievement, showcasing meticulous care in both its technical execution and visual artistry. Photographed by Paul Laufer, who discussed at length in the Blu-ray's production team commentary, the film captures complex, vivid colors and intricate visual storytelling through traditional photochemical processes, later digitized for various effects. This attention to detail is evident in the 1080p, AVC-encoded master prepared by Warner Home Video, which succeeds in maintaining the film's weight and density of imagery. The transfer for this Blu-ray required scanning of a film element, resulting in an exceptionally clear and vivid image that brings Tarsem's visually striking narrative to life.
The color palette is particularly noteworthy, with vividly saturated reds, regal purples and golds, ghostly whites and blues, and intense reddish yellows that dominate scenes across Stargher’s dreamscape and the brutal desert environment. Black levels and contrast are strong with finely rendered grain patterns, although some graininess and edge enhancement artifacts are noticeable in the bright desert scenes at the film's beginning. However, these artifacts are largely confined to these sequences, with the image stabilizing considerably as the narrative progresses into more controlled environments.
Warner's rendition exhibits a warmer overall tone compared to previous releases, with significantly deeper reds and more lifelike fleshtones. This warmth adds a new depth to the viewing experience, particularly when considering MPI's access to reference materials potentially more accurate than those used by Alliance Atlantis for the 2009 edition. While minor speckles of noise are present, they are minimal and do not detract from the overall high quality of this specially crafted Blu-ray edition.
Audio: 76
The Blu-ray release of "The Cell" features an exceptional audio presentation, primarily utilizing the English DTS-HD MA 5.1 track, with Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 also available. Howard Shore’s almost atonal score is a standout element, merging traditional orchestration with trance music by the Master Musicians of Joujouka. This combination uses distinctive reed, pipe, and percussion instruments to complement both the surreal mental landscapes of Edward and the sinister fantasies within Stargher’s mind. The recurring motif of water, in various forms such as dripping and rushing, enriches the film’s soundscape, as do the classic sounds from police procedurals like cars, helicopters, and battering rams. The soundtrack's broad dynamic range and deep bass extension enhance the immersive experience, recalling Shore’s work on films like Se7en and The Silence of the Lambs.
The dialogue throughout the film is generally clear, though some of Stargher's darker utterances prioritize intensity over clarity, especially in his imperial alter ego scenes where voices defy physical laws by booming, echoing, and fading in and out. Low-frequency extension is superb; the LFE subwoofer delivers a substantial kick during scenes with deep effects or low voices, adding significant weight to key moments. Surround sound presentation is notably expansive; the rear channels inject substantial depth into scenes set in subconscious realms, making the environment feel more open and dynamic as characters navigate ethereal spaces. Overall, the sound field envelops viewers, offering an aggressive yet non-oppressive auditory experience that ranks close to reference material quality.
Subtitles are available in English SDH, French, and Spanish for accessible viewing. This lossless soundtrack marks a significant improvement, presenting "The Cell" with clarity and impact fit for a cinematic experience.
Extras: 71
The extra features on the Blu-ray release of "The Cell" are a comprehensive archive of materials previously available on the New Line Platinum Series DVD. While the transfer quality may not impress all viewers, the depth of content does. The disc includes two insightful commentaries—one by Director Tarsem Singh, rich with behind-the-scenes details and personal anecdotes, and another by the production team, offering a technical perspective. Additional highlights include a documentary on Tarsem's unique visual style, a series of multi-angle visual effects vignettes that dive into the film’s complex imagery, deleted scenes with optional commentary, and trailers. Despite the lack of new or retrospective content, these extras collectively provide a robust understanding of the film's production process and artistic vision.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary with Director Tarsem Singh: Insightful blend of personal anecdotes and behind-the-scenes details.
- Commentary with Production Team: Technically focused discussion featuring key production members.
- Style as Substance: Reflections on Tarsem: Documentary exploring Tarsem’s visual storytelling.
- Deleted Scenes (with Optional Commentary): Includes original ending and controversial scenes.
- Special Effects with Multi-Angle Vignettes: Detailed look at six major special effects sequences.
- Trailers: Includes both theatrical and international versions.
Movie: 66
The Cell
Mark Protosevich's screenplay for The Cell took a striking turn in the hands of Tarsem Singh, whose visual prowess brought a novel twist to the serial killer genre. While Protosevich's script included conventional elements reminiscent of Thomas Harris's Manhunter and The Silence of the Lambs, Tarsem elevated them with his unique cinematic vision. The basic premise, wherein investigators enter the killer's mind, is not unprecedented, sharing similarities with films like Dreamscape and episodes like Star Trek: Deep Space Nine’s "Extreme Measures." However, Tarsem's interpretation makes the brain's interior world the focal point, offering a striking visual feast and a departure from conventional narrative logic.
The storyline centers on serial killer Carl Stargher (Vincent D'Onofrio) and the desperate attempts of FBI agents Peter Novak (Vince Vaughn) and Gordon Ramsey (Jake Weber) to locate his latest victim. Their investigation leads them to an experimental procedure developed by Drs. Henry West (Dylan Baker) and Miram Kent (Marianne Jean-Baptiste) that allows Catherine Deane (Jennifer Lopez), a skilled therapist, to enter Stargher's mind. The film’s real allure lies in Tarsem's theatrical presentation of Stargher’s macabre rituals and the surreal landscapes within his psyche, overshadowing even Thomas Harris's darkest imaginings.
Tarsem’s commentary highlights that The Cell is more about elaborate spectacle than authentic dream logic, drawing from an array of artistic influences including H.R. Giger and Damien Hirst. The dream sequences are intricately tied to the narrative, making Catherine’s journey through Stargher’s mind both compelling and disturbing. Lopez’s performance, combined with masterful writing and editing, ensures these surreal images retain their narrative potency. Although Novak’s real-world pursuits keep the stakes grounded, the film ultimately serves as a grand entertainment designed to linger in memory long after viewing.
Total: 71
The Blu-ray release of "The Cell" offers a visually stunning and emotionally intense experience, capturing director Tarsem's unique aesthetic brilliantly. The audio presentation is top-notch, contributing significantly to the immersive experience with pitch-perfect sound effects and a haunting score. However, while the special features are comprehensive, they are mostly ported over from the DVD release. The video transfer is a mixed bag, with certain scenes, particularly in the desert, displaying edge enhancement, aliasing, and other visual anomalies that detract from the overall quality.
Despite its narrative simplicity, "The Cell" remains a compelling exploration of the human psyche, as embodied in surreal and often disturbing imagery. The film's duality—represented by the victimized child and the monstrous adult—offers a stark commentary on trauma and its long-lasting impacts. Even so, some viewers may find the film lacking in thematic depth and overly reliant on its visual flair.
In conclusion, "The Cell" Blu-ray dazzles and disturbs in equal measure. The blend of stunning visuals and powerful storytelling creates a visceral experience deserving of its high-definition treatment. While it may not delve deeply into its thematic content, its audiovisual presentation alone makes it a recommended addition for fans of Tarsem's visionary style.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
Laufer is one of the principal participants on the Blu-ray's "production team" commentary track, where he discusses The Cell's photography in great detail, including the challenges of obtaining the desired...
Audio: 90
The latter, with its distinctive blend of reed, pipe and percussion instruments provides an ideal accompaniment to the beautiful but alien landscapes of Edward's mind and also the sinister and vaguely...
Extras: 80
The Blu-ray version simply repeats the same narration by visual effects supervisor Kevin Tod Haug (and, in one instance, Richard "dr." Baily) while different angles play....
Movie: 80
Protosevich, who would go on to write the story for the first Thor film and to adapt the remake of Oldboy, had written a classic serial killer genre piece in the Thomas Harris vein of Manhunter, Red Dragon...
Total: 80
The debate takes physical shape in the imaginary landscape through which Catherine chases Stargher, because he can appear there simultaneously as a victimized child and as the merciless, god-like figure...
Why So Blu? review by Gerard IribeRead review here
Video: 70
Vince looks really pasty and tired but that’s a clear staple of the man is it not?Noise/Artifacts: A speckle here and there...
Audio: 90
The sound field really envelops the viewer.Low Frequency Extension: The LFE subwoofer really gives everything a big kick in the pants especially when deep effects or low voices come into play....
Extras: 70
In any event we get a couple of commentary tracks by Tarsem, the production and visual effects team, delete scenes, a Tarsem retrospective of his past work, and a visual effects vignette split into 6 sequences....
Movie: 60
Total: 70
There are several scenes, mostly in the desert scenes, where edge enhancement, aliasing, and other anomalies rear their ugly head....
Director: Tarsem Singh
Actors: Jennifer Lopez, Vince Vaughn, Vincent D'Onofrio
PlotCatherine Deane is a child psychologist who uses an experimental virtual reality therapy to enter the minds of her patients. She is recruited by the FBI to use this technology on a comatose serial killer named Carl Stargher in a desperate attempt to locate his latest captive, who is still alive but will die soon if not found. Carl's twisted psyche proves to be a dangerous and surreal landscape filled with disturbing imagery, posing a significant challenge to Catherine as she navigates through his inner world.
However, as Catherine delves deeper, she unlocks Carl's traumatic past, making it increasingly difficult to separate her own identity from his horrifying experiences. Racing against time, she must find crucial clues and bring them back to the conscious world, working alongside FBI Agent Peter Novak. The deeper she goes, the more perilous her mission becomes, risking not just her life but also her sanity while trying to rescue the innocent victim before it's too late.
Writers: Mark Protosevich
Release Date: 18 Aug 2000
Runtime: 107 min
Rating: R
Country: Germany, United States
Language: English