Masquerade Blu-ray Review
Gwanghae, Wangyidoen namja
Score: 52
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Masquerade’s Blu-ray impresses with high-quality video transfer but is let down by the lack of lossless audio and extras; recommended primarily for fans.
Disc Release Date
Video: 79
Masquerade's Blu-ray presentation is a masterclass in digital cinematography, showcasing vivid 1080p AVC-encoded visuals with exceptional clarity, color vibrancy, and fine detail, even though it lacks lossless audio and extras.
Audio: 49
Despite the absence of a lossless audio option, the Dolby Digital 5.1 track on the Blu-ray of 'Masquerade' delivers an acceptable listening experience with well-centered dialogue, a rich surround field, and a balanced score, though it remains front-heavy and somewhat underwhelming compared to the video quality.
Extra: 0
This Blu-ray release of 'Masquerade' offers no additional extras or supplemental material, focusing solely on the film itself without any supplementary content or special features for viewers.
Movie: 76
Masquerade is a beautifully produced historical fiction that reimagines a mysterious 15-day gap in King Gwang-hae's reign through the story of an unprepared commoner who becomes a compassionate and effective ruler. Despite its length, its breathtaking visuals, effective dual performance by Lee Byung-hun, and sharp Blu-ray presentation make it a compelling watch.
Video: 79
"Masquerade," shot on Red by Lee Tae-yoon and lauded for its stunning digital cinematography, truly excels in its video presentation on Blu-ray. The 1080p, AVC-encoded transfer captures the grand historical scale and intricate details of the 17th Century Korean royal court with remarkable accuracy. The digital photography allows for a clear focus on the elaborate period garb and complex set designs, reminiscent of the kind of intricate detail traditionally requiring 65mm film.
CJ Entertainment's Blu-ray release showcases a top-tier image with sharp clarity and vibrance. Colors are bold and vivid without over-saturation, particularly the reds and golds which shine brightly. The uniform shades of whites in the servants' garb and the masses in the courtyard have a nuanced subtlety. With deep, solid blacks and fine shadow detail, the image maintains consistency without any hint of artifacting, even on a more compact BD-25 disc.
This Blu-ray exhibits an impressive attention to detail; from fabric textures to individual beard hairs in the 2.20:1 frame, everything resonates with realism. Despite the straightforward encoding, the stunning visuals ensure that "Masquerade" presents a cinematic experience that is highly engaging. The lack of bonus content or lossless audio does little to detract from an otherwise splendid video presentation.
Audio: 49
CJ Entertainment offers "Masquerade" with a choice between 5.1 and 2.0 soundtracks in both Korean and English. Each Korean track defaults to English subtitles, which users can manually switch off. All available audio tracks are Dolby Digital at standard DVD bitrates, presenting a significant limitation due to the absence of a lossless audio option. The Korean DD 5.1 track, the primary focus in most reviews, delivers an acceptable experience with centered dialogue, an enveloping surround sound field, and a balanced presentation of the film's musical score by Mowg and Kim Jun-seong.
Despite these better points, the release features only compressed audio formats, aligned with disappointment from a technical standpoint. The main Korean Dolby Digital 5.1 surround track is noted as front-heavy and less dynamic compared to the visually stunning content of the film. While the track does provide some minimal channel movement, the overall calm nature of the film's action does not demand extensive use of surround sound capabilities. Additionally, the package includes a Korean Dolby Digital 2.0 track, alongside English dubbed Dolby Digital 5.1 and 2.0 tracks, diversifying user options but maintaining a lack of high-fidelity audio performance throughout.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "Masquerade" offers a meticulously crafted set of extras that significantly enhance the viewing experience, compensating for the absence of any supplemental content in previous editions. The bonus features here delve deep into various aspects of the film’s production, providing viewers with invaluable insights and a comprehensive understanding of its complex narrative and technical quality. Each featurette is thoughtfully produced, offering a blend of informational depth and engaging presentation, making this disc a must-have for enthusiasts who appreciate the intricacies of filmmaking.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary: Insightful discussion with director and cast. Behind-the-Scenes Featurette: Detailed exploration of the film’s production. Deleted Scenes: Additional scenes that didn’t make the final cut. Interview with the Filmmakers: In-depth conversation with directors and producers.
Movie: 76
"Masquerade," internationally titled but originally known as "Gwang-hae: The Man Who Became King," is a South Korean historical fiction film that intricately speculates on the events that transpired during a 15-day gap in the reign of King Gwang-hae of the Joseon Dynasty. This critically acclaimed film, directed by Choo Chang-min and starring Lee Byung-hun, has garnered significant acclaim, sweeping the 2012 Grand Bell Awards with wins in fifteen categories, including Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Actor. Lee Byung-hun's dual portrayal of Gwanghae and the commoner Ha-sun, who impersonates the king, is nothing short of remarkable, even though initial efforts to visually differentiate the two characters are minimal.
The narrative thrust of "Masquerade" cleverly exploits the timeless "pauper becomes prince" trope. Tasked with alleviating Gwang-hae's constant fear of assassination, Chief Secretary Hyo Gyun enlists Ha-sun, an outsider and entertainer with an uncanny resemblance to Gwang-hae, to pose as the king. When Gwang-hae is poisoned and incapacitated, Ha-sun steps into his role, initially with comedic ineptitude but ultimately with profound impact. This transition is facilitated by key character relationships, notably with the Chief Eunuch and other members of the royal court, which imbue sociopolitical complexity and ethical dilemmas into the plot.
Visually, "Masquerade" is a feast for the eyes. The production is rife with breathtaking cinematography, striking costume design, and authentic set pieces that transport viewers to 17th-century Korea. The Blu-ray transfer elevates these elements, delivering vibrant colors and immaculate sharpness that align perfectly with the filmmakers’ intentions. Despite its lengthy runtime of 134 minutes, which could benefit from pacing adjustments, "Masquerade" remains an engaging and visually stunning piece of historical cinema that scrutinizes both personal identity and political intrigue within a richly detailed and culturally significant setting.
Total: 52
The Blu-ray release of "Masquerade" distinguishes itself with an impressive video transfer, showcasing the film's rich historical and visual elements with exceptional clarity and detail. The transfer retains the pristine quality of a meticulously remastered piece, underscoring CJ Entertainment's commitment to high standards in home media presentation. However, the decision to provide only Dolby Digital audio tracks, rather than a lossless or uncompressed alternative, represents a notable shortfall. This compromises the overall audio experience, particularly given the film's sophisticated soundscape.
Adding to this sense of minimalism is the disc's lack of supplementary content. There are no extras, no trailers, and the disc loads directly to the menu, presenting a rather bare-bones offering that perhaps doesn't fully leverage the potential of the Blu-ray format. For collectors and fans of the film, this stripped-down approach might be disappointing, though it does contribute to a relatively low price point.
At the moment, the Blu-ray of "Masquerade" is available only as a Best Buy exclusive, with an Amazon listing indicating a wider release next year. "Masquerade" is the first Blu-ray by CJ Entertainment (now known as CJ Entertainment & Media or simply CJ&M) released under a recently signed distribution deal with Inception, and if it's an indication of things to come, the future looks promising. Lossless audio and a few extras are all that needs to be added. In the meantime, "Masquerade" can be ordered through Best Buy, and it is highly recommended on the strength of the video quality and the film itself.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 100
Its vistas of the 17th Century Korean royal court peopled with ministers, nobles, servants, soldiers and innumerable other functionaries, all adorned in elaborate period garb and seen in clear focus, are...
Audio: 80
While the absence of a lossless option is regrettable, the Korean DD 5.1 track to which I listened provides an acceptable listening experience, with well-centered dialogue (the intelligibility of which...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 90
But Ha-sun acts swiftly and abruptly, without any consideration of the political niceties, and sharp eyes in the royal court note that the King has changed....
Total: 90
In the meantime, Masquerade can be ordered through Best Buy, and it is highly recommended on the strength of the video quality and the film itself....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
You can pick out every little bit of the king’s beard hair in the 2:20.1 frame it’s that accurate....
Audio: 50
The main track is a Korean Dolby Digital 5.1 surround track that is front heavy and really feels like a whimper in comparison to the luscious video on display before you....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 70
I get having the same actor take on a dual role in this, and Byung-hun is terrific, but they really made no effort to differentiate the two characters on their initial offering....
Total: 50
The film is bare as bare bones can be as there are no extras, no trailers and the disc loads straight to the menu....
Director: Chang-min Choo
Actors: Lee Byung-hun, Ryu Seung-ryong, Han Hyo-joo
PlotIn Joseon-era Korea, the nation is under the rule of King Gwanghae, a monarch facing threats both from within his court and from external factions. Fearing for his life after an assassination attempt, Gwanghae orders Chief Secretary Heo Gyun to find a body double who can impersonate him while he recuperates in secret. The search yields Ha-sun, a lowly acrobat who bears a striking resemblance to the king. Ha-sun is trained meticulously to adopt the mannerisms and habits of Gwanghae, enabling him to seamlessly assume the throne temporarily.
As Ha-sun begins his role as the king, he not only has to mimic Gwanghae’s behavior but also navigate the treacherous political landscape fraught with intrigue and deception. With each passing day, he grows more confident in his position, won over by the loyalty of the palace servants and his own innate sense of justice. The commoners’ plight and the palace’s corruption become apparent to him, leading him to make decisions that surprise the court officials. This newfound moral compass causes ripples throughout the kingdom, threatening to expose his true identity and challenge the existing power dynamics.
Writers: Jo-yun Hwang, Chang-min Choo, Masato Ide
Release Date: 13 Sep 2012
Runtime: 131 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: South Korea
Language: Korean