Churchill Blu-ray Review
Score: 60
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Churchill's narrative is underwhelming and historically inconsistent, but Brian Cox's stellar performance and the Blu-ray's strong video and audio make it a solid purchase.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Lionsgate's Region B-locked UK Blu-ray release of Churchill delivers a strong 1080p/AVC encoded presentation in 2.40:1, capturing the film's low-key period ambiance and finer details. Utilizing Arri Alexa models, it emphasizes background action with artsy, sometimes abstract shots and robust black levels, though not demo-worthy.
Audio: 69
Churchill's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track provides clear and coherent dialogue with a sweeping emotional score, albeit with limited surround activity and effects, offering a solid but unexceptional audio experience fitting its World War II setting.
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray extras for 'Churchill' include a 22-minute featurette offering behind-the-scenes footage and insightful interviews with the main cast and crew, alongside a theatrical trailer, all presented in 1080p.
Movie: 51
Brian Cox delivers a committed performance in 'Churchill,' but the film's historical inaccuracies, melodramatic subplot, and underwhelming screenplay undermine its potential to join the ranks of classic political biopics.
Video: 74
Lionsgate's Region B-locked UK Blu-ray release of "Churchill" presents the film with a commendable 1080p/AVC-encoded High Definition video transfer, maintaining its original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.40:1 widescreen. Despite a modest production budget, the Blu-ray presentation effectively conveys the movie's period ambiance, showcasing subtle yet immersive details. Featuring a largely muted color palette that enhances the vintage feel, the film deftly handles natural environments, from smoke-filled rooms to overcast beaches. Black levels are robust and contribute to a clear and engaging image, even if the production's limited scale prevents it from being a showcase example of the format.
Shot using various Arri Alexa models by cinematographer David Higgs, the film benefits from his expert use of the wide frame, often placing out-of-focus foreground objects against sharply detailed backgrounds. The presentation excels in close-up shots, consistently highlighting fine details and textures. There is a notable dip into monochrome early in the film, adding a historical touch. However, some scenes exhibit boosted contrast that occasionally diminishes background detail due to intense light sources. While certain artistic choices might intrude visually at times, the overall video quality remains high, catering well to fans of period drama though stopping shy of being considered demo material.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "Churchill" on Blu-ray delivers a solid, yet unremarkable experience, primarily through its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track. The track's high point lies in its impassioned musical score, which sweeps across all channels, providing a strong emotional undercurrent that almost transcends the film itself. Dialogue, the primary component of the film’s audio, is clear and well-prioritized in the front and center channels, effectively maintaining coherence even when faced with the cast's inconsistent accents. Although the effects are limited, reflecting the film's wartime setting with echoing rooms, bustling offices, crashing waves, and tinny radio broadcasts, these elements do not add significant dynamism to the overall presentation.
Surround activity in "Churchill" is subtle and intermittent, evoking a sense of nostalgia reminiscent of "Patton," particularly during scenes where the general reflects on past battles. However, much of the film consists of cloistered dialogue moments which limit immersion primarily to the musical score or occasional ambient sounds. While there is no standout dynamic element beyond the score, fidelity remains stable throughout, ensuring that dialogue is always clear and comprehensible. This results in an audio experience that, while not extraordinary, competently supports the film's narrative structure.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray extras for "Churchill" are commendable, providing insightful behind-the-scenes content and engaging interviews. The 22-minute featurette offers a well-rounded look at the film's production process, with plenty of footage showcasing the on-set environment. This featurette also includes a series of interview snippets with the main cast and crew, offering valuable perspectives on the making of the movie. The presentation quality of the extras is in full HD, ensuring a visually crisp viewing experience. In addition to the featurette, the Blu-ray includes the original theatrical trailer, further adding value to this release.
Extras included in this disc:
- Churchill: Behind the Scenes: A 22-minute in-depth look at the film’s production, including interviews with cast and crew.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original 2-minute-22-second trailer for the movie.
Movie: 51
2017 witnessed a surge in cinematic portrayals of Winston Churchill, with John Lithgow, Gary Oldman, and Brian Cox each delivering their interpretations. In Jonathan Teplitzky's "Churchill," Brian Cox aims to carve his niche, focusing on the wartime leader during the build-up to D-Day. This depiction presents Churchill as a tormented and hesitant figure grappling with past failures and struggling for support from his contemporaries. While the film introduces melodramatic elements that detract from historical authenticity, Cox delivers a committed performance, capturing the idiosyncrasies and imposing presence of the Prime Minister. His portrayal, though encumbered by an underwhelming screenplay, provides the necessary gravitas and makes his character compelling.
Scripted by Alex von Tunzelmann, "Churchill" has faced criticism for its historical inaccuracies, particularly regarding Churchill's alleged opposition to Operation Overlord. This contentious narrative choice attempts to create suspense from an event with an inevitably known outcome—the successful Normandy invasion. Moreover, the added drama of marital discord between Churchill and his wife Clementine feels unnecessarily contrived and unsubstantiated by historical record. Despite these shortcomings, the film boasts standout moments, particularly scenes featuring James Purefoy as King George VI. The emotional depth in his interactions with Churchill offers a poignant counterbalance to the film’s less credible aspects and could potentially earn Purefoy critical acclaim.
Overall, while Teplitzky's "Churchill" struggles with historical fidelity and narrative cohesion, it benefits significantly from the strength of its performances. Cox's robust interpretation and Purefoy's nuanced portrayal infuse the film with intermittent poignancy and depth, albeit within a flawed script. The movie ultimately acts as a testament to its actors' capabilities rather than a definitive recounting of historical events.
Total: 60
"Churchill" on Blu-ray offers a mixed experience, featuring a compelling performance by Brian Cox that serves as the movie's main attraction. Unfortunately, the film itself falls short in delivering a meaningful and coherent narrative. The attempt to humanize Winston Churchill through dramatic embellishments feels misaligned with historical records, particularly regarding D-Day and the Churchill marriage. This dramatic approach may alienate viewers who prefer a more accurate portrayal of historical events. Nevertheless, several supporting performances stand out, adding some depth to this otherwise lackluster biopic.
From a technical perspective, the Blu-ray release by Lionsgate is of high quality. The video presentation is robust, capturing the visual nuances of the period with clarity. The audio track, although not groundbreaking, is adequately immersive and matches the film's visual fidelity. The package includes one noteworthy extra feature, providing additional value for those who appreciate behind-the-scenes content.
In conclusion, "Churchill" is ultimately an unremarkable film whose primary saving grace is Brian Cox's impressive portrayal of the titular character. While the narrative may be mundane and dramatized beyond historical accuracy, the technical aspects of the Blu-ray release make it a solid choice for fans. Whether you are an armchair historian or simply a fan of strong performances, this Blu-ray presents a decent addition to your collection, even if the film itself does not particularly stand out.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
From the (cigar)smoke-filled rooms to the grey-skied beaches, the film offers up a decent representation of natural environments, and promotes finer detailing on the backgrounds and subtler nuances that...
Audio: 80
A solid, if unexceptional, audio presentation The disc's accompanying DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track similarly has only limited material to play with, the best of which comes in the form of quite an impassioned...
Extras: 40
A single 22-minute Featurette offers some footage of the film being shot, as well as interview snippets with the main cast and crew....
Movie: 50
It's a curious tale, given that much of this appears to be utterly unfounded, but the film's saving grace is certainly Brian Cox's committed performance, not just for the important speeches, but for the...
Total: 60
The end result is fairly pointless and utterly unremarkable, but for Brian Cox Churchill feels curiously inert, as if it either had an important tale to tell but didn't do so well, or didn't have anything...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
In an interesting interview with British Cinematographer, Higgs speaks toward filling the wide frame, often placing a foreground object or character out of focus, with the "real" action taking place in...
Audio: 80
Churchill offers a somewhat subtle DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that delivers some intermittent surround activity that at times is kind of reminiscent of the sound design of Patton, when the general "hears"...
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 60
A short scene between the King and Churchill where George tries to bring the Prime Minister to his senses in terms of what people in their positions are required to do during wartime is the best written...
Total: 60
Winston Churchill is such an outsized character that this film's attempt to cut him down to "ordinary human" levels just seems like an odd decision, especially since the actual historical record doesn't...
Director: Jonathan Teplitzky
Actors: Brian Cox, Miranda Richardson, John Slattery
PlotWinston Churchill faces immense pressure and self-doubt in the days leading up to D-Day in June 1944. As the Allied forces prepare for the largest military invasion in history, Churchill battles with his own fears and the haunting memory of past military failures, particularly during World War I. The prime minister is portrayed as a complex figure, caught between his duty to lead and his emotional turmoil. He vehemently opposes the planned Normandy invasion, fearing a catastrophic loss of life. This puts him at odds with U.S. General Dwight D. Eisenhower and British General Bernard Montgomery, who are determined to proceed with the operation as planned.
Churchill's internal conflict strains his relationships with key figures, including his wife Clementine, who provides both support and a dose of harsh reality. As he grapples with the weight of his responsibilities and the mounting pressure from his allies, Churchill's resolve and leadership qualities are tested to their limits. The narrative delves deeply into his personal struggles, offering a poignant portrayal of a leader at a critical juncture in history.
Writers: Alex von Tunzelmann
Release Date: 02 Jun 2017
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English