Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines Blu-ray Review

Warner's Blu-ray release of "Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines" has traversed some rough waters due to a notable bug initially presenting the film in 1080i rather than the advertised 1080p. This issue, however, has been mostly rectified in newer pressings, with the corrected version now seemingly ubiquitous in current stock, identifiable by the UPC code 883929016938. Despite its rocky start, this release—now properly in 1080p—offers a VC-1 transfer that maintains the theatrical aspect ratio of 2.40:1, displaying a fidelity to the original HD DVD's master albeit with new encoding for Blu-ray. The overall video quality is characterized by a commendable, if not quite pristine, image clarity. Detail levels vary, generally settling on the higher side of adequate with some softness present across the board.

The 1080p transfer, while solid, does manifest fluctuations in black levels leading to scenes with noticeable crush and others with optimal depth. A sparing layer of film grain persists, affirming the film's originally intended texture without detracting significantly from the viewing experience. Colors keep a consistent tone throughout, albeit lacking vibrancy; notable scenes such as the cemetery shootout offer a glimpse of lushness but are exceptions in an otherwise muted palette. Flesh tones skew slightly warm, contributing to an image that, although technically proficient and free from major encoding flaws like banding or blocking, doesn't fully exploit the high-definition medium's potential for visual dynamism.

From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray excels with its clean print and absence of blemishes or digital anomalies, ensuring a natural and stable color reproduction despite occasional deviations in flesh tones possibly dictated by the film's creative direction. While daylight scenes boast impressive depth, contributing to the high-definition allure, darker sequences and those subjected to stylistic filtering occasionally falter in shadow detail and color accuracy. Moreover, the presencing of film grain, especially noticeable in lower-light conditions—a byproduct of the Super35 process used during filming—adheres to the movie's aesthetic yet might distract the more scrutinizing viewer. Despite these variances, this edition of "Terminator 3" achieves a commendable high-definition presentation that navigates its initial challenges to deliver a viewing experience faithful to the original cinematic vision.

The audio presentation of "Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines" on Blu-ray, while not utilizing the full potential of lossless formats, still stands out as a commendable achievement in lossy audio delivery. Maintaining the Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround track at a bitrate of 640kbps, the inclusion mirrors the precedent set by its HD DVD counterpart. This decision by Warner, although possibly seen as a missed opportunity to upgrade to PCM or Dolby TrueHD, does not significantly detract from the overall auditory experience. The sound design excels with its aggressive utilization of the surround channels, crafting an immersive 360-degree soundscape that shines during the numerous action sequences. Sound effects are meticulously placed, creating a seamless auditory environment that enhances the visual spectacle on screen. Dialog remains crisp and centered, ensuring clarity amidst the cacophony of action.

However, the track does exhibit certain limitations inherent to its lossy nature. Despite delivering a robust low-end and achieving notable dynamic range—with intense bass that promises to "move the furniture around"—the soundtrack slightly underperforms in conveying the music score's full impact. Marco Beltrami's composition, though adequate, lacks the visceral punch and haunting presence characterized by Brad Fiedel's work in the franchise's earlier entries. This results in moments where the audio feels less integrated, potentially diminishing the overall atmospheric tension and emotional depth.

In conclusion, while Warner's decision to forgo a lossless audio format for "Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines" Blu-ray release is lamentable, the existing Dolby Digital 5.1 track proves itself to be a powerhouse within its constraints. Boasting superb sound design that effectively leverages directional effects for an enveloping experience and maintaining consistently clear dialogue, this soundtrack manages to deliver exhilarating action sequences. Nonetheless, the slight underrepresentation of the musical score and the inherent advantages of a lossless option leave room for speculation on what might have been achieved with a more ambitious audio presentation.

The Blu-ray release of "Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines" delivers a substantial array of extras, effectively carried over from previous releases and maintaining a robust selection, albeit with a slightly dated feel. The presentation shines with its in-movie experience featuring Director Jonathan Mostow, offering an engaging picture-in-picture commentary. Fans are treated to behind-the-scenes footage and diverse insights spanning the filmmaking journey. Moreover, the Blu-ray includes a trio of informative audio commentaries, with contributions from Mostow, key cast members including Arnold Schwarzenegger, and various crew members, offering a mix of anecdotal details and technical dissections. The additional features such as storyboards, featurettes on costumes and toys, as well as the unique Sgt. Candy Scene, enrich the Terminator 3 experience further. While some content may mirror prior releases, the comprehensive nature and depth of these extras undoubtedly enhance the appreciation of this franchise installment for both new viewers and longtime fans.

Extras included in this disc:

• In-Movie Experience: Picture-in-picture commentary with Director Jonathan Mostow and team.
• Behind the Story (480p): A four-part feature including an introduction by Arnold Schwarzenegger, HBO First Look special, storyboards comparison, and a look at the film's costumes.
• Audio Commentary: Three separate tracks featuring insights from Director Jonathan Mostow alone, a combination of Mostow and cast (Schwarzenegger, Danes, Stahl, Loken), and a technical discussion with Mostow, writers Brancato and Ferris, production designer Jeff Mann, and director of photography Don Burgess.
• Additional Footage (480p): Includes the Sgt. Candy Scene and a blooper reel named Terminal Flaws.
• Fun & Games (480p): Explores Todd McFarlane's toy line and the making of the tie-in video game.
• Trailers (480p): Features the movie trailer and a preview for the video game.

Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines" positions itself in a unique juncture within the storied Terminator franchise, having to shoulder the immense weight of its predecessors' legacies while simultaneously forging a path into the series' daunting future. At the helm, Director Jonathan Mostow opts for a rather straightforward approach, embedding the narrative in the franchise's core thematic essence—the inevitability of destiny versus the human endeavor to alter fate. Mostow's interpretation feels less like visionary filmmaking and more like a necessary evolutionary step, blending the raw, gritty essence of the original with the blockbuster sheen of its immediate sequel to deliver a narrative that is fundamentally "Terminator" in spirit. It might lack James Cameron's pioneering flair but encapsulates the harrowing fatalism and cybernetic carnage that fans expect.

On the technical front, "Rise of the Machines" benefits from a presentation befitting its stature, with action sequences dominating the screen time, a testament to Mostow's commitment to keep the adrenaline pumping. Amid these sequences, subtle nods to its predecessors aim to embed it deeply within the Terminator lore, with Schwarzenegger's slightly diminished yet iconic presence serving as a cornerstone. However, where the film truly excels is in its audacious finale—a bold narrative gamble that pays homage to the series' overarching themes of inevitability and sacrifice. This climactic act not only serves as a crucial turning point in the Terminator timeline but also redefines the franchise by affirming the futility of escaping one's destiny, all while delivering the high-octane action set pieces expected from a summer blockbuster.

In reflection, "Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines" navigates its precarious positioning with a blend of reverence for its origins and an unwavering commitment to action. While it may not recapture the groundbreaking impact of its predecessors, it reaffirms the series' central motifs through a spectacle of destruction and a narrative that boldly confronts despair with tenacity. Despite criticisms regarding its seemingly derivative nature and a less compelling lead performance from Stahl, Schwarzenegger's iconic portrayal alongside Mostow's competent direction ensures that this installment respects its lineage while propelling the franchise into uncharted territories of apocalyptic inevitability.

Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines" may not be the crown jewel of the Terminator franchise, but it carves out its niche as an action-packed spectacle that gracefully bridges the storytelling gap between its iconic predecessors and future installments. Its embrace as a more standalone summer blockbuster does not detract from its essence as part of the Terminator narrative; instead, it amplifies its reach, delivering a hard-hitting experience with what can be argued as one of the most memorable conclusions in recent cinema history. The Warner Blu-ray edition brings this experience to the small screen with a commendable video quality upgrade, remedying previous issues and presenting a generally pleasing visual treat. However, it does fall short in offering the audiophiles among us the definitive sonic experience—retaining the original lossy soundtrack. Nonetheless, it compensates with a comprehensive suite of extras that enriches the viewing experience.

This Blu-ray release not only marks an improvement over the initial HD DVD version with its robust transfer and competent audio options but also pioneers with its inclusion of a Picture-in-Picture (PIP) track—a first for Warner, though it slightly misses the mark by not adhering to true Profile 1.1 specifications. This detail, however, likely won't deter the majority of action enthusiasts and franchise fans due to the sheer scale and thrill this edition provides. It's a testament to the film's enduring appeal and the Blu-ray format's capacity to enhance cinematic home experiences, despite some technical caveats.

In conclusion, while "Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines" may not eclipse its formidable forebears in the franchise, this Blu-ray release offers a comprehensive and enjoyable way to experience the film. With solid video quality, an extensive array of extras, and satisfactory albeit non-ultimate audio presentation, it stands as a recommended addition for both action aficionados and Terminator faithful. Despite minor shortcomings in achieving audio-visual perfection, its strengths in content and presentation make it a worthy component of any sci-fi collection.