A Haunting in Venice Blu-ray Review
Score: 78
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
A Haunting in Venice delivers Branagh’s finest Poirot film yet with impressive visuals, solid audio, and engaging surprises, though only on Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 91
A Haunting in Venice on Blu-ray impresses with its AVC encoded 1080p transfer, offering remarkable detail and vivid color dynamics, despite lacking a 4K UHD release. Captured in 6K on Sony CineAlta and finished with a 4K DI, the disk maintains consistent deep blacks, natural skin tones, and striking low-light visuals.
Audio: 90
"A Haunting in Venice" offers a compelling audio experience with its DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 mix, delivering crystal clear dialogue and robust dynamics. Although lacking the full spatial audio of Dolby Atmos, it excels in surround activity, directional effects, and LFE for immersive engagement.
Extra: 35
The Blu-ray extras for 'A Haunting in Venice' provide an engaging look at the film's production through an insightful featurette, 'Murder, Death, and Haunting,' with 26 minutes of interviews and behind-the-scenes content, complemented by 11 deleted scenes offering pacing trims, yet lacking substantial narrative impact, plus a redeemable digital code.
Movie: 73
A Haunting in Venice" marks Kenneth Branagh's most visually ambitious Poirot adaptation, blending eerie post-WWII Venice settings with a chilling whodunnit. Branagh's cinematography, marked by innovative framings and atmospheric tension, complements a stellar ensemble cast, delivering a refreshing spin on Agatha Christie's lesser-known "Hallowe’en Party.
Video: 91
The Blu-ray presentation of "A Haunting in Venice," from 20th Century Studios and Disney/Buena Vista, delivers an impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Shot digitally with Sony CineAlta cameras up to 6K resolution and finished as a 4K digital intermediate, the Blu-ray still captures exceptional levels of detail. Despite the lack of a 4K UHD physical release, the 1080p version offers beautifully secure detail levels, especially commendable in its rendering of low-light sequences, characterized by deep blacks and ominous shadows. This attention to detail extends to facial features, clothing, and the film's intricate set locations.
The film's dynamic use of color is also noteworthy. With a palette favoring dark fall-like greens, reds, and oranges, colors are bold and well-reproduced. Skin tones remain healthy and natural throughout the film. Branagh and returning cinematographer Haris Zambarloukos take advantage of digital technology with unique framing choices, including fisheye lenses that enhance the film’s visual storytelling. These techniques create extreme close-ups with exceptional fine detail, though some CGI elements might appear slightly softer.
While some early establishing shots in Venice display minor banding on specific displays, generally, the Blu-ray video presentation remains clean with no noticeable artifacts. The film's photography maintains clarity and detail in even the darkest scenes without any motion distortion issues. With strong color reproduction and deep, rich black levels that avoid crushing, "A Haunting in Venice" stands out as an excellent addition to any collection despite the absence of a 4K disc, holding up admirably on a seasoned 1080p format.
Audio: 90
The DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 soundtrack for "A Haunting in Venice" delivers an impressive and engaging audio experience, characterized by robust dynamics and spatial dimension. Dialogue is exceptionally clear and remains intelligible despite the characters' thick accents. The soundtrack artfully employs directional effects and a punchy low-frequency extension to complement the film’s thematic tone. This immersive audio presentation dynamically supports the visual elements, creating an evocative viewing experience that enhances the film's atmospheric quality.
The sound design takes center stage, with meticulous attention to ambient details and pinpoint sound effects. Frequent surround activity is apparent, effectively supporting the film's haunted house theme with chilling and unexpected sound cues. Though it lacks the height dimension of a Dolby Atmos mix, the audio track stands out through its consistent use of rear and side channels, lending depth and a full-bodied sense of presence.
Hildur Guðnadóttir’s score further elevates the experience by integrating seamlessly into the mix, utilizing various channels to create an eerie musical atmosphere. Even during quieter moments, subtle creepy effects maintain an active soundstage that keeps viewers engaged. Overall, while missing the grandeur of an Atmos soundtrack, this DTS-HD MA 7.1 mix offers a thoroughly enjoyable at-home audio experience, enriched by optional subtitles in multiple languages for additional accessibility.
Extras: 35
The Blu-ray of "A Haunting in Venice" offers a succinct yet engaging collection of extras. The standout is "Murder, Death and Haunting," a 26:08-minute featurette that provides an insightful look behind the scenes. It delves into the adaptation of Agatha Christie's 'Hallowe’en Party,' the innovative relocation to Venice, and the remarkable ensemble scenes constructed by Kenneth Branagh and team. Though somewhat concise, it effectively captures the film's production nuances. The disc also includes 11 deleted scenes, spanning 8:14 in total, which serve primarily as pacing extensions or scene trims, offering additional glimpses of Poirot and Venetian locales. Unfortunately, while intriguing for enthusiasts, these excisions do not significantly enhance the narrative. Additionally, a digital copy is available.
Extras included in this disc:
- Murder, Death and Haunting: Behind-the-scenes featurette on film adaptation and production.
- Deleted Scenes: Eleven trimmed scenes from the film.
- Digital Code: Redeemable Movies Anywhere HD copy.
Movie: 73
A Haunting in Venice marks Kenneth Branagh's return both as director and Hercule Poirot, capturing an eerie post-WWII Venice setting on All Hallows’ Eve. The film deviates from typical Poirot narratives, embedding itself in the realm of the supernatural. The narrative begins with Poirot in retirement, sequestered in Venice, before he is drawn into a seance at a haunted palazzo. Following a gruesome murder, Poirot is hurled into a labyrinth of dark secrets and shadows. Employing stylish cinematography with Dutch angles and playful lenses, Branagh crafts a visually striking experience that aligns well with the film's haunting theme.
The screenplay, adapted from Agatha Christie's lesser-known Hallowe’en Party, wrestles with the challenge of refreshing familiar plots while paying homage to Christie’s legacy. Despite being retained as a quintessential Poirot tale, the setting, narrative elements, and character portrayals notably diverge from the original. The film leverages these creative liberties to present a unique standalone story that stands out in the modern retelling of Christie’s works. The ensemble cast, featuring Jamie Dornan, Tina Fey, and Michelle Yeoh, enhances the tension and allure of the plot, contributing to this adaptation’s success.
Technically astute, the movie benefits from meticulously crafted sets and an atmospheric backdrop, eschewing excessive CGI for genuine locale fidelity. The tension-filled confines of the palazzo amplify the thriller's claustrophobic intensity — something that Branagh's previous endeavors lacked. With layered performances and a tightly wound plot riddled with red herrings, A Haunting in Venice stands as a superior entry in Branagh's Poirot trilogy. Despite minor flaws in narrative execution and theatrical release strategy, the film succeeds in delivering a captivating blend of mystery and horror, securing its place as a refined adaptation within Branagh's oeuvre.
Total: 78
"A Haunting in Venice" Blu-ray represents the pinnacle of Kenneth Branagh's adaptations of Agatha Christie's tales, blending a tightly-knit production with an engaging narrative that departs refreshingly from previous films. While it veers from Christie's original "Hallowe'en Party," it constructs a compelling plot with clever surprises. The film's photography and score, alongside an adept sound design, contribute to a genuinely atmospheric experience. Enthusiastic fans will appreciate how the film strikes a balance between a rich visual style and a meticulous blend of mystery, maintaining a captivating grip throughout its runtime.
Technically, the Blu-ray release is well-executed. The 1080p transfer effectively captures the film’s aesthetic, displaying consistently good video quality that brings out the film's intricate details and striking cinematography. The 7.1 audio track complements the visuals, enveloping viewers in a dynamic soundscape that enhances the eerie, immersive experience. Although a 4K release would have been ideal to fully showcase the film's visual prowess, the standard Blu-ray remains a commendable effort.
In conclusion, despite its absence on 4K disc, "A Haunting in Venice" is a recommendable addition to any home collection for both Christie aficionados and newcomers to Branagh's vision. Its vivid storytelling and technical competence create an entertaining viewing experience. The Blu-ray package is satisfactory with worthwhile supplementary features, making it a desirable acquisition, especially at a favorable price point. This rendition of Hercule Poirot's escapades under Branagh’s direction is distinguished as his finest yet, encouraging further anticipation for similar releases.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
That said, this 1080 presentation is incredibly appealing virtually all of the time, with beautifully secure detail levels despite a number of low light sequences and other moments that have been graded...
Audio: 100
A Haunting in Venice has an extremely robust DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track that may actually provoke laughter along with unavoidable startle scares due to a rather comical (but incredibly effective) sound...
Extras: 30
Murder, Death, and Haunting (HD; 26:08) is a fun featurette with quite a few interviews and some appealing behind the scenes footage....
Movie: 70
Michael Green, who has previously adapted both Murder on the Orient Express and Death on the Nile featuring Kenneth Branagh as Hercule Poirot, and who serves a similar function with this film, is on hand...
Total: 70
While I gave the Branagh Death on the Nile the same overall middling score I gave to the first film, it was probably at least an incremental improvement on Murder on the Orient Express, but I have to say...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
In a rare move for Branagh, he and returning cinematographer Haris Zambarloukis switched from 70mm to digital so they could have better control over the low-light photography and I have to say it’s quite...
Audio: 80
Similar to the video, there is an Atmos track out there for streaming but on disc we’re left with a DTS-HD MA 7.1 track - and it’s still very good....
Extras: 20
The deleted scenes are interesting cuts, but they ultimately feel like extensions and trims for pacing....
Movie: 80
I understand Taylor Swift’s unexpected Eras Tour release and The Exorcist: Believer was a big force in theaters at the time, but this would have been brilliant counter-programming to all of that....
Total: 80
Scaling down the production into a tight location and setting aside his tendencies to always be front and center for me made a richer, creepier, and more exciting whodunnit experience....
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 90
While the film is available in 4K from digital retailers, Disney/20th Century Studios has opted to only release the film on Blu-ray physical media....
Audio: 90
Even without the height channels that a spatial audio mix would provide, this is a very immersive mix, with frequent surround activity that adds to the haunted house theme of the story....
Extras: 40
This is a pretty entertaining featurette that covers most of the bases on the making of the film, including the decisions to use a lesser-known novel and to relocate it to Venice, as well as a few other...
Movie: 80
An old friend, American author Ariadne Oliver (Tina Fey), comes to visit and invite the retired detective to a séance to be held at the palazzo owned by Rowena Drake (Kelly Reilly) to help determine if...
Total: 80
A Haunting in Venice is a fun and often beautifully photographed film with excellent performances from is ensemble cast....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
Audio: 94
I found this to be an engaging audio presentation that complimented the video, resulting in an involving, and evocative viewing experience that enhanced the source material....
Extras: 50
Deleted Scenes: Check out these scenes that didn’t make the final cut: • Morning Routine • The Doge’s Palace • Halloween Party Extended • Desdemona’s Warning • Children’s Story • Poirot Needs Air • Guarding...
Movie: 70
Unfortunately, things take a violent turn when one of the guests is murdered, thrusting the detective into a sinister world of shadows and secrets....
Total: 79
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 100
Depth: Depth of field is quite strong here and really is able to reflect the lenses used in the film in good, three dimensional fashion....
Audio: 100
Height: N/ALow Frequency Extension: The subwoofer is here to add to music stings as well as accentuate a lot of the effects with doors slamming, things crash, impaling and more....
Extras: 40
Cast and crew take us through the production of the film with some pretty solid substance to it....
Movie: 70
He also should be commended on creating a nice sense of geography in this picture as to know and have a feel for not only the house but where the characters are in the film....
Total: 80
However, it is a top notch presentation for the format and the extras make for a decent package....
Director: Kenneth Branagh
Actors: Kenneth Branagh, Michelle Yeoh, Jamie Dornan
PlotIn post-World War II Venice, a retired detective is reluctantly drawn back into the world of intrigue when he attends a séance at a crumbling, palatial home. The event, organized by a supposed medium, aims to connect grieving family members with their lost loved ones. While the detective begins by observing with skepticism and humor, the evening turns eerie as unexplained occurrences unsettle even the hardest skeptics. A sudden violent event causes fear and panic to take hold among the guests, transforming what should have been a somber affair into a night filled with suspicion and dread.
As the guests are trapped by stormy weather in the opulent mansion, tensions run high amidst accusations and secrets laid bare. The detective finds himself caught in a complex web of deception as he delves into the haunted history of the mansion and its residents. With limited resources and growing unease, he races against time to uncover hidden motives and untangle the mystery at hand. His logical approach faces a constant battle with the supernatural elements hinted at throughout the gathering. As each stunning revelation peels back layers of tangled relationships and dark desires, the lines between reality and the otherworldly blur, leading everyone toward an unexpected confrontation with forces beyond explanation.
Writers: Michael Green, Agatha Christie
Release Date: 15 Sep 2023
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Italian, French, Latin