Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 76
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In impresses with incredible martial arts and an outstanding 4K presentation despite limited bonus features.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
Despite its 2K digital intermediate, 'Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In' delivers a visually striking 4K UHD presentation, with Well Go USA offering a high bitrate and effective HDR/Dolby Vision that enhance shadow detail and color vibrancy. Some CGI inconsistencies are present, but overall detail and depth remain exceptional.
Audio: 93
The 4K UHD audio presentation of 'Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In' features outstanding Dolby Atmos and DTS:X Cantonese tracks, delivering rich dynamics, immersive surround activity, and formidable bass. Both tracks are similarly exceptional, though the DTS:X offers slightly more amplitude and energy.
Extra: 36
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of 'Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In' lacks supplemental content, notably omitting the behind-the-scenes footage and cast interviews available in the 1080p release, leaving diehard fans possibly desiring more than just a slipcover in packaging.
Movie: 70
Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In is a nostalgic homage to 1980s Hong Kong action films, balancing exhilarating martial arts and rich character development, despite a predictable plot. The 4K UHD release captures its breathtaking action and dynamic performances, perfect for genre aficionados and casual viewers alike.
Video: 83
"Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In" offers an impressive video presentation on 4K UHD, especially considering its humble 2K digital intermediate source. Captured on Arri Alexa cameras, this release utilizes the HEVC / H.265 encoded 2160p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, with HDR and Dolby Vision enhancing the visual depth and nuances within shadowy scenes. Despite not being a native 4K, the upscale is highly effective, demonstrating remarkable detail, particularly in facial features and the intricate design of Kowloon's dilapidated sets filled with knickknacks and detailed textures. Notably, fine detail improvements are evident in the practical elements of the film, enhancing the gritty visual narrative.
The Dolby Vision HDR adds vibrancy to the generally muted brown and amber palette. The visual presentation excels in rendering dark alleyways and dimly lit scenes pivotal to the story’s ambiance. Black levels are exceptionally well-handled, offering supreme shadow details with minimal banding. However, some CGI elements remain discernible amidst the tangible set pieces, slightly detracting from the overall immersion. Yet, for a release from Well Go USA, such minor intrusions are easily overshadowed by the high praise for its stunning presentation.
Overall, "Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In" handles complex scenes with ease—from expansive fight sequences to constricted spaces—without compromising on image quality or exhibiting disruptive image noise levels. The disc maintains a consistently high bitrate, peaking impressively above 100 mbps, contributing to the disc's outstanding visual appeal. The Dolby Vision HDR not only amplifies color contrasts but also bolsters the three-dimensional perception of scenes, establishing it as a commendable transfer that substantially elevates the viewing experience.
Audio: 93
The audio presentation for "Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In" on 4K UHD Blu-ray delivers two exceptional Cantonese tracks in both Dolby Atmos and DTS:X formats, each providing a rich auditory experience. Both tracks leverage object-based sound, utilizing heights and surrounds to immerse viewers amidst the pandemonium of the film's action sequences, such as intense combat and gunfire. The Dolby Atmos track is favored by some due to its compatibility with a wider range of receivers, offering superb dynamics and clean dialogue delivery upfront. The DTS:X track, however, impresses with more amplitude and invigorating energy in the midrange and low end, presenting a palpable difference with its significant surround activity.
The intricacies of these tracks allow for an expansive multi-channel experience, effectively dropping audiences right into the turmoil onscreen. Channel spacing ensures that dialogue remains clear amidst chaos, while imaginative imaging captures the frenetic motion of action scenes from diverse angles. A comparison reveals minimal divergence between Dolby Atmos and DTS:X, making the choice largely personal preference. An alternative English DTS-HD MA 5.1 dubbed track is available but lacks the dynamic impact and richness of the Cantonese options, serving only as a basic substitute for those averse to subtitles. Despite this minor shortcoming, the original mixes offer exceptional auditory involvement that complements the cinematic experience thoroughly.
Extras: 36
The extras included in the "Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In" 4K UHD Blu-ray release seem to be quite limited, particularly when compared to prior editions. While previous releases offered a more robust selection of behind-the-scenes content such as cast interviews and making-of featurettes, these are notably absent in this latest 4K iteration from Well Go USA. This might be disappointing for enthusiasts keen on supplementary content, as this release appears to solely focus on the main feature. It's worth noting that this decision seems uncharacteristic for Well Go USA, who typically provide at least a basic trailer. Observing such an absence here may prompt dedicated fans to consider other editions like the 1080p version for a more comprehensive package. The packaging includes a slipcover but is otherwise minimal in terms of additional content.
Extras included in this disc:
- None
Movie: 70
"Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In" serves as a nostalgic throwback to the electrifying era of 1980s and 90s Hong Kong action films, encapsulating the chaotic allure of Kowloon Walled City—a historically notorious enclave fraught with crime. Drawing from the Manhua comic "City of Darkness," the film revitalizes the visceral martial arts spectacle reminiscent of classics helmed by legends such as Jackie Chan and Donnie Yen, while weaving a plot rich in conflict and intrigue. The narrative orbits around Chan Lok-kwan, who, after a botched deal with crime lord Mr. Big, finds refuge in the Walled City under Cyclone's protection. The storyline, while predictable with some clunky exposition, sets a robust stage for exhilarating action sequences that seamlessly incorporate both traditional martial arts and innovative Wuxia elements.
Technically impressive, Soi Cheang’s direction delivers an intense visual experience, focusing on crafting character and plot alongside spectacular combat choreography. The film showcases an excellent balance between narrative depth and action-driven pacing, ensuring that character development is not overshadowed by the dynamic stunt work. Although some third-act tonal shifts introduce improbable superhero elements, they contribute to the film's overall charm, amplifying its vibrant energy. Raymond Lam shines as Lok-kwan, his character growth enriching the eventual climactic gang war, raising stakes beyond mere survival to a profound personal journey.
While "Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In" may not redefine the martial arts genre, it delivers a compelling modern addition with breathtakingly staged fights and immersive cinematography that pays homage to its cultural roots. This engaging adrenaline rush ensures both genre aficionados and casual viewers find satisfaction, despite missing the theatrical grandeur which would have further elevated its captivating prowess.
Total: 76
"Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In" delivers classic Hong Kong martial arts action with a nostalgic charm. The film eschews complexity for adrenaline, providing a wealth of expertly choreographed fight scenes that evoke the golden days of 80s and 90s action flicks. The plot, while thin, cleverly sets the stage for its primary allure—the martial arts prowess on display. Notably, Sammo Hung's involvement, despite evident use of a stunt double, adds a layer of authenticity. Cinematic purists may find the numerous quick cuts slightly distracting, yearning for more single-cut scenes to truly showcase the actors' skills. But overall, the film succeeds in capturing the essence of a bygone era, making it thoroughly entertaining for enthusiasts of vintage action films.
Technically, the 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation from Well Go USA is impressive. The Dolby Vision transfer ensures vibrant and detailed visuals that enhance the film's dynamic action sequences. The audio department doesn't disappoint either, with both DTS:X and Dolby Atmos options providing immersive soundscapes, though some reviewers have preferred the DTS:X mix for its robust delivery. However, collectors might be disappointed by the absence of bonus features, missing in this edition when compared to the 1080p release. Despite this shortcoming, the disc remains a valuable addition due to its superior technical quality and engaging content.
In conclusion, "Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In" stands as a testament to old-school martial arts cinema—a joyful nod to a time when high-caliber stunts and unfiltered action took center stage. Its forthcoming sequels promise exciting developments within this resurrected universe. A must-have for fans of the genre, this release is wholeheartedly recommended for both its nostalgic impact and technical excellence on 4K UHD.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
Well Go USA has given the film a very health bitrate (it fluctuates a lot, but I saw several times where it broke 100 mbps) and the end result is really good....
Audio: 90
The mix can jump from a quiet conversation to battle roars and massive impacts in a matter of seconds, and the immersion levels are off the charts....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 90
Wilson Yip was supposedly producing, Louis Koo was taking front seat, and there were a LOT of people overseas telling people that they better watch out for this one....
Total: 80
This is a film for those of us who loved those gawd awful 80s and 90s flicks with bad acting, cheap set designs, but absolutely incredible stunts and martial arts prowess of days LONG gone thanks to CGI,...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Note: While this is a standalone 4K release without a 1080 disc, I am offering screenshots from Well Go USA's standalone Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In 1080 release as I think it actually provides...
Audio: 100
I gave top marks to the 1080's Dolby Atmos track, but, wow, what a difference the DTS:X track offers on this disc, starting with noticeably more amplitude, and I'd argue significant additional energy in...
Extras: 0
Some of those supplements have some rather good behind the scenes footage and interviews, and my hunch is diehard fans of the film may well want to pick up the 1080 release for those bonus features....
Movie: 70
If there is therefore an understandable lack of nostalgia for this overcrowded and often violent neighborhood, Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In virtually wallows in another kind of nostalgia, namely...
Total: 70
It's already been announced in the wake of the overwhelming box office this film achieved that it's going to be (at least) a trilogy, so get set for more adventures, though the fact that this film ends...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Thankfully though that’s not a serious impairment as most of the film is focused on our characters and the immediate world around them....
Audio: 100
Imaging is great as a lot of these fights will traverse any given location from a variety of angles....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
While not as balletic as a Jackie Chan classic, the scenes are captured in a way where we can appreciate the full athleticism of the cast without it being nothing but nauseating close-up quick-cut nonsense....
Total: 80
The lack of bonus features is a bummer but that’s not enough to hold back from calling this disc a Recommended addition for the collection....
Director: Soi Cheang
Actors: Louis Koo, Sammo Kam-Bo Hung, Richie Jen
PlotIn a dystopian future, Hong Kong is divided by towering walls separating the ultra-wealthy from impoverished communities plagued by crime and corruption. The government maintains order through oppressive tactics, while crime syndicates vie for control of the city's underbelly. Within this chaos, a seasoned detective known for his unyielding sense of justice becomes embroiled in a deadly power struggle. His mission is to dismantle a notorious drug cartel that has a stranglehold on the city's underground economy. Facing pressure from both sides of the law, he recruits an unlikely alliance with a former triad member trying to go straight and a cunning hacker with deep ties to the criminal underworld.
As tensions escalate, an elderly mentor with a storied history in martial arts emerges to guide them, sharing his wisdom in combat and strategy. Together, they undertake a perilous journey through Hong Kong’s most dangerous districts, uncovering layers of betrayal and deceit that blur the lines between friend and foe. The team grapples with a moral dilemma as they realize that justice may come at a devastating personal cost. As they close in on their target, they must confront personal demons and face the harsh realities of an unforgiving world battling for survival and redemption. The fate of the city teeters on the brink as they prepare for an ultimate showdown, hoping to ignite a spark of hope in a society engulfed by darkness.
Writers: Kin-Yee Au, Tai-Lee Chan, Li Jun
Release Date: 01 May 2024
Runtime: 126 min
Rating: R
Country: Hong Kong, China
Language: Cantonese, Mandarin