Promising Young Woman Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 7 reviewers
Review Date:
Promising Young Woman offers a smart debut from Emerald Fennell with stellar audio, decent video, and poignant performances, though lacks substantial extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 84
Promising Young Woman's 2.39:1 AVC Blu-ray offers striking but uneven image quality with vivid colors and high detail in well-lit scenes, contrasted by noise in darker scenes like the club. The detailed 1080p transfer captures the film's bubblegum pop aesthetic, though some may long for a 4K Dolby Vision release to fully appreciate its stunning visuals.
Audio: 85
Promising Young Woman's 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track shines as the disc's highlight, showcasing deep bass, active surrounds, and clear dialogue, with excellent tonal balance and dynamic range, providing an engaging and immersive audio experience whether in quiet moments or energetic club scenes.
Extra: 45
This Blu-ray release of 'Promising Young Woman' includes a detailed feature commentary by writer/director Emerald Fennell and three concise behind-the-scenes featurettes that explore the film's themes, Carey Mulligan's transformation, and its unique tone – insightful but leaves viewers wanting more.
Movie: 92
Promising Young Woman brilliantly reinvents the rape-revenge genre into a darkly comedic and thrilling narrative, driven by Carey Mulligan's remarkable performance. Emerald Fennell's directorial debut intelligently deconstructs the genre with depth, modern sensibility, and nuanced character construction, culminating in a shocking and satisfying conclusion.
Video: 84
The Blu-ray presentation of "Promising Young Woman" is a mixed yet captivating experience with a 2.39:1 AVC encoded image. The 1080p transfer excels in delivering a colorful palette, especially in scenes involving fantasy-like elements where bright pinks, pastel blues, and yellows radiate vibrancy. Outdoor daytime scenes, such as those at Cassie’s coffee shop, exhibit excellent detail levels and a unique cherry bubblegum color grading. The contrast in skin tones and overall color reproduction maintains a high standard without oversaturation or bleeding, adding to the visual appeal. However, the darker scenes within houses fluctuate in sharpness, switching from extremly detailed to notably soft seemingly at random.
Black levels generally perform well but suffer from digital noise and blocking issues in underlit scenes, particularly in the club and bedroom environments. Detail and clarity are sufficient but not consistently stunning across all frames. Intricate details such as facial pores, make-up applications, and textures in costumes are vividly displayed. The background props and sets also maintain their definition well. Despite its minor shortcomings, such as occasional noise and inconsistent sharpness, the image lacks common artifacts like aliasing or banding, resulting in an overall decent viewing experience.
Technically, the Blu-ray uses MPEG-4 AVC encoding on a BD-50 disc with a 2.8K Digital Intermediate basis that was initially crafted for Dolby Vision in theaters. This background suggests the potential for an even more impressive 4K HDR release in the future, which would better showcase its deeply saturated colors and fine textures. Movements remain fluid without distortions or jitter, and black levels, though digitally finite, hold up well with no crushing witnessed. While a newer 4K version might enhance the experience further, this Blu-ray presentation still offers an engaging visual display that aligns well with the film’s thematic and stylistic choices.
Audio: 85
"Promising Young Woman" offers an exceptional DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 lossless soundtrack that truly accentuates the film's diverse audio elements. From the outset, the sound design is clearly a meticulous endeavor. The club sequences deliver a potent combination of deep bass hits and expressive opening beats that create an immersive, high-energy atmosphere, with notable moments such as Charli XCX’s 'Boys' leaving a resonant impact. Throughout the film, the 7.1 mix balances ambient noise, dialogue, and music seamlessly, vividly reproducing both the nuanced and dynamic sound effects, such as footsteps on staircases and glass breaking. The score, mixing Pop songs like 'Toxic' and 'It's Raining Men,' provides a wide dynamic range that can shift from quiet introspection to startlingly loud crescendos with precision.
This soundtrack goes beyond mere background noise. The sound mixing is impeccable, ensuring dialogue and vocal clarity remain sharp and focused front and center, despite an active and immersive surround sound environment. The track’s enveloping nature shines, with ambient effects intelligently integrated, from subtle environmental sounds to the intense atmospherics of the nightclub and wedding scenes. The bass reproduction is generally tight, occasionally exhibiting robust low-end reinforcement during impactful moments without becoming overpowering.
Technical execution in terms of dialogue clarity, positioning, and prioritization earns top marks, with clean transitions across the left, center, and right channels maintaining a balanced tonal harmony. Vehicles driving by, and scenes emphasizing minor sounds like kissing or touching, demonstrate stylistic finesse. While it is disappointing that the theatrical Dolby Atmos mix was downscaled to 7.1 for this release, the 7.1 DTS-HD MA track remains impressively powerful, creating a fully engaging audio experience that heightens emotional and narrative impact throughout the film.
Extras: 45
The Blu-ray release of "Promising Young Woman" offers an insightful array of extras complementing this provocative film. Notably, the disc features a deeply informative feature commentary by Writer/Director Emerald Fennell, covering stylistic choices, thematic elements, and production insights. While the total runtime for all additional content is relatively brief, about 11 minutes, these segmented featurettes provide valuable perspectives on various aspects of the movie's creation, from character development to tonal balancing. The inclusion of a digital code adds convenience, though the absence of a DVD may slightly disappoint some collectors. Overall, despite the brevity of the extras, they enrich the viewing experience with thoughtful behind-the-scenes commentary.
Extras included in this disc:
- Feature Commentary with Writer/Director Emerald Fennell: An in-depth discussion on themes, production design, and more.
- A Promising Vision: Writer/Director Emerald Fennell discusses her inspirations for writing this bold, genre-bending film.
- Two-Sided Transformation: An exploration of Carey Mulligan's portrayal of Cassie and the use of wardrobe, hair, and makeup.
- Balancing Act: Cast members discuss balancing the film's levity and tragedy.
Movie: 92
Emerald Fennell’s Promising Young Woman serves as a groundbreaking debut that revitalizes the assault revenge genre with razor-sharp satire and compelling storytelling. The film subverts the typical tropes of graphic violence and grunge, opting instead for wit and dark humor. It stars Carey Mulligan as Cassie Thomas, a once-promising medical student whose life veers off course after her best friend Nina's traumatic experience. Cassie leads a double life, teaching lessons to potential predators by night and confronting her complex emotions during the day. The narrative evolves unexpectedly, reaching a climax that delights and shocks in equal measures, transforming a genre traditionally mired in raw brutality into an insightful social commentary.
Mulligan’s portrayal of Cassie is both dynamic and nuanced, delivering a performance that blends vulnerability with steely resolve. Fennell’s direction and screenplay shine, carefully balancing humor with moments of grim reality. The film tackles themes of justice, accountability, and the pervasive nature of rape culture. Technical prowess is on full display, from meticulous scene composition to the striking use of color. Memorable set pieces include an intense confrontation with a former dean and emotional encounters with key characters that drive the story’s underlying message.
Promising Young Woman masterfully dismantles and reassembles its genre, offering a vivid character study wrapped in satire and dark comedy. This film stands out for its bold narrative choices and intricate character constructions, providing a fresh lens through which to view issues of assault and revenge. Fennell successfully challenges audience expectations, concluding with a finale that is both unexpected and satisfyingly grim. This film is not only essential viewing but also an important social critique, ensuring its place as one of the most compelling releases in recent years.
Total: 77
"Promising Young Woman" serves as an audacious debut for Emerald Fennell, blending dark humor and palpable drama into a gripping revenge narrative uniquely punctuated by twists and social satire. The standout performance by Carey Mulligan adds exceptional weight to the film, earning it widespread acclaim and a slew of Oscar nominations, including Best Film and Director. Fennell’s deft handling of the subgenre and fearless narrative turns establish this film not only as a signature work of 2020 but as a high benchmark for future thrillers.
Universal's Blu-ray release does justice to this critical darling, featuring superb video quality with a 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio that captures the film’s aesthetic with crisp detail. The DTS-HD MA 7.1 audio track immerses viewers in the film's sonic landscape, although it’s somewhat disappointing that it did not receive an Audio Direction nomination despite being one of the best-sounding dramas ever produced. Subtitles are available in English SDH, French, and Spanish, which is a nice touch for broader accessibility. However, the mediocrity of the supplemental materials and absence of a 4K release leaves room for future improvements.
For cinephiles and casual viewers alike, "Promising Young Woman" is an essential watch that delivers a satisfyingly impactful experience. Despite Universal's Blu-ray release lacking in additional content, the impeccable audio-visual aspects ensure immediate immersion into this bold cinematic tale. Highly recommended for its narrative daring, exceptional performances, and technical presentation.
"Promising Young Woman" is a clever thriller that mixes social satire and a well-nuanced tale of betrayal and revenge in a way that is much more palatable than others in this particular genre. The story is wickedly biting, mildly humorous, and ends with a twist third act that comes out of nowhere, and leaves you with a hugely satisfied feeling. The movie is the first of Emerald Fennell’s, and she does a GREAT job for her first outing. Universal’s Blu-ray release is rather excellent as well, with good video, great audio, but a fairly mediocre set of extras. Definitely worth checking out if this review has piqued your curiosity at all.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 80
Outdoor shots such as Cassie at her coffee shop job are much sharper and more vivid, with incredible detail levels and a sort of cherry bubblegum color grading going on....
Audio: 90
It’s generally reference material across the board, with deep bass hits for the tense moments, a crushing score that feels like it can be both light and air, and oppressive at the same time....
Extras: 40
• Two-Sided Transformation – A look at why Carey Mulligan was the perfect choice to play "Cassie" and how filmmakers used wardrobe, hair, and makeup to express the balance between light and dark....
Movie: 80
It’s not PERFECT, but the Promising Young Woman takes a tired old genre, tears it down to it’s base elements, builds it up without the lewd trappings that have kept this type of films in a very niche market,...
Total: 70
Universal’s Blu-ray release is rather excellent as well, with good video, great audio, but a fairly mediocre set of extras....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
This is not the most attractive movie in the world, but the Blu-ray carries the content well enough, a few hesitations aside....
Audio: 90
Such musical strength remains for the duration as aggressive Pop songs, both in a few more club environments and as overlaid audio, all present with exceptional definition and detail....
Extras: 40
A Promising Vision (1080p, 4:03): Exploring the story and themes, its push away from violence, Emerald Fennell's direction, the Ryan Cooper character, and more....
Movie: 90
It takes the fork in the road far less traveled and does so with gumption, rawness, and a modern sensibility that uses today's tools to great effect....
Total: 70
It's smart, steady, confident, and well capable of rearranging a classic subgenre to great dramatic and darkly humorous effect and impact....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 85
There’s excellent sound mixing in the night club sequences, with dialogue, ambient crowd noise, and music balanced well to provide the atmosphere of an energy-driven club scene....
Extras: 60
Movie: 95
Emerald Fennell’s Promising Young Woman falls into this broad category, but approaches the subject more subtly, without exploitative violence....
Total: 84
The film shows the ways women are deceived, betrayed, and victimized by men, but comes to a conclusion where the main characters all face the consequences of their actions....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
The tone, themes, and story of this film is dour, scary, and ultimately very series down to its core, but Emerald gave it a dark comedy wash and therefore made what could have been something dark stylistically...
Audio: 80
The scenes where touching and kissing are front and center have an enhanced sound that is louder than normal, where the slightest kiss or touch can be heard over everything, which is a great stylistic...
Extras: 20
- The cast and crew discuss the balance of comedy, drama, and thrilling elements to the film....
Movie: 100
Fennell flawlessly tells this story and conveys these messages in a fantastic dark comedy that explores, revenge, forgiveness, and owning up to one's awful behavior and a possible redemption path....
Total: 80
It's poignant, important, highly entertaining, thrilling, and includes some top-notch performances from its cast with the spotlight on Carey Mulligan....
Home Theater Forum review by Sam PostenRead review here
Video: 90
On wonders it that wouldn’t be even more dazzling on a 4K DV uprez, but it’s not to be it seems....
Audio: 100
It was released theatrically in Atmos, bummer that it’s down to flat 7.1 here but still it’s GREAT 7.1....
Extras: 60
A 3 part behind the scenes featurette that runs about 20 minutes The featurette was good but left me wanting more....
Movie: 100
Cassie, like so many women, has decided that enough is enough and the only way things will change is to burn the whole thing down....
Total: 90
They missed audio direction, it definitely qualifies there and is one of the best sounding dramas ever....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 94
Audio: 90
The mix makes frequent use of the surrounds to reproduce the discrete and ambient sounds contained within the soundtrack....
Extras: 60
• Two-Sided Transformation – A look at why Carey Mulligan was the perfect choice to play "Cassie" and how filmmakers used wardrobe, hair, and makeup to express the balance between light and dark....
Movie: 80
But nothing in Cassie’s life is what it appears to be: she’s wickedly smart, tantalizingly cunning, and she’s living a secret double life by night....
Total: 81
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-RS2000 4K Ultra High Definition Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 90
Flesh Tones: Skin tones are natural and consistent from start to finish of the film, give or take a lighting filter for club set scenes....
Audio: 90
Height: N/ALow Frequency Extension: Most of the subwoofer’s big moments come with dropping the bass in the club music, but it also has some nice touches in making some extra bump to more naturalistic sounds...
Extras: 40
This one brushes over the themes of the film and how they’re distributed and focuses on some of the characters....
Movie: 100
Now, an unexpected encounter is about to give Cassie a chance to right the wrongs of the past in this thrilling and wildly entertaining story....
Total: 70
Even prior to the vindicated Oscar nomination glory, Promising Young Woman easily argued to be the best film of 2020 and has set a high bar for the fresh new decade of films to come....
Director: Emerald Fennell
Actors: Carey Mulligan, Bo Burnham, Alison Brie
PlotA young woman, Cassie, leads a double life. By day, she is a seemingly aimless and sarcastic barista living with her concerned parents. By night, she engages in a clandestine campaign to address past traumas. Cassie's mission is driven by a tragic event in her past, involving her best friend Nina. She frequents nightclubs pretending to be severely inebriated, allowing men to take her to their homes under the guise of concern. However, when they attempt to take advantage of her apparent vulnerability, she confronts them with sobriety and sharp rebuke, aiming to teach them a lesson about consent and predatory behavior.
As her quest for retribution continues, Cassie reunites with a former classmate, sparking an unexpected romantic relationship. This new connection begins to steer her life in a different direction, offering an alternative to her nocturnal pursuits. But the memories and unresolved grief for her lost friend, and the quest for justice on her behalf, are powerful forces. As she moves forward, Cassie must confront whether she can forgive, seek redemption, or if her path has set her toward an unavoidable and darker resolution.
Writers: Emerald Fennell
Release Date: 25 Dec 2020
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English