The Lovely Bones Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Lovely Bones: divisive, technically superb, yet not for all.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 81
The Lovely Bones' Paramount 1080p transfer is stunning, with vibrant, natural colors, remarkable detail, and perfect blacks, making it 2010's must-see, demo-worthy presentation.
Audio: 66
The Lovely Bones' DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack offers quality immersion, balancing subtle ambience with pronounced moments, complemented by Brian Eno's score, ensuring consistent dialogue clarity.
Extra: 86
The Lovely Bones’ Blu-ray extras include a comprehensive, in-depth documentary on the filmmaking process, guided by Peter Jackson, with no commentary but rich in technical and chronological detail, appealing to cinema enthusiasts.
Movie: 46
Peter Jackson's 'The Lovely Bones' mixes mastery with mess, blending stunning visuals & performances with a disjointed, surreal narrative.
Video: 81
Paramount's Blu-ray presentation of "The Lovely Bones" offers an unparalleled visual experience that sets a high standard for high-definition transfers. Every frame of the 1080p, 2.35:1-framed transfer bursts with life, showcasing vibrant, natural colors that enrich every detail, from the nuanced textures of clothing and foliage to the intimate intricacies of everyday objects. The image's heavy golden tint, while adding a stylistic flourish, does not detract from the overall clarity and depth of the picture. This depth, combined with impeccably sharp detail and spot-on black levels, creates a three-dimensional effect that is as startling as it is beautiful. Scenes are rendered with such lifelike precision and dimensionality that even mundane items stand out with stunning clarity. Despite a faint hint of banding in isolated instances, these minor flaws are easily overshadowed by the transfer's overwhelming fidelity and the pristine condition of the print.
Attention to detail is paramount in this transfer, where even the most intricate patterns and textures are displayed with absolute definition. This level of detail extends to every corner of the screen, allowing viewers to appreciate the subtlest elements of the film's visual narrative. From the realistic depiction of CGI elements to the accurate rendering of black levels and color delineation, every aspect is executed with precision, making it an exemplary demonstration of Blu-ray's potential. The landscapes of Susie's heaven, though CGI, are handled with care, maintaining the director's stylized vision without sacrificing authenticity or clarity.
Technically flawless and devoid of any distracting anomalies or source noise, this video presentation stands as a testament to Blu-ray's capability to deliver an immersive and visually spectacular experience. Whether showcasing the remarkable landscapes or the film's more intimate settings, this transfer remains consistently impressive, establishing "The Lovely Bones" Blu-ray as essential viewing for both fans of the film and aficionados of top-tier home theater presentations.
Audio: 66
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack of "The Lovely Bones" on Blu-Ray presents an audio experience that, while not achieving the pinnacle of perfection observed in the video quality, delivers a remarkably high-quality auditory journey. This soundtrack is defined by its generally reserved and contemplative nature, yet it demonstrates an ability to become more pronounced and powerful when the film’s narrative requires. Such dynamic range makes it an ideal complement to the movie's dramatic tones. The soundtrack excels in creating a vivid, immersive atmosphere, capturing the essence of environments with impressive fidelity - from the ambient sounds in a bustling mall or a school hallway to the meticulous detail heard in the background noise of a police station. The soundscape crafted here does more than just fill the room; it constructs a living, breathing world, enhancing the storytelling through meticulous sound design. Dialogue is crystal clear, ensuring that the whispered tones and voiceovers are heard with clarity and strength, underscored by Brian Eno's haunting score which is handled with meticulous care.
Attention to ambient detail contributes significantly to the audio presentation's success, affording audiences a textured auditory experience that breaks away from reliance on excessive bass or overwhelming action sequences to engage its listeners. However, the soundtrack doesn't shy away from emphasizing select moments with well-placed low-frequency effects (LFE), such as the impactful thuds of a large safe or the dramatic intensity of thunder and lightning, which punctuate the narrative at key points. This controlled use of LFE adds depth without dominating the soundtrack, maintaining a balance that complements the film's nuanced approach.
In sum, "The Lovely Bones" DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack offers a richly textured and immersive audio experience that enhances the film's dramatic landscape. Its strength lies in its ability to convey subtlety and depth, maneuvering between quiet introspection and moments of powerful sound with ease. Fans of the film will find the audio presentation engrossing, adding another layer of engagement to an already compelling story. While it may not be the go-to demonstration for sheer audio power, it stands as a testament to how a more restrained and thoughtful approach can elevate a film's overall impact.
Extras: 86
Paramount's Blu-ray release of "The Lovely Bones" packs its extras on a dedicated second disc, emphasizing the depth and breadth of the filmmaking process without the inclusion of commentary tracks. The highlight is the monumental three-hour documentary, "Filming 'The Lovely Bones'," offered in full HD with subtitles available in multiple languages. This documentary, neatly divided into three segments covering different stages and locations of the filming process, offers an unparalleled, chronological exploration inside the shoot. Initiated by an introduction from Peter Jackson, who along with Screenwriter/Co-producer Philippa Boyens, provides extensive narration throughout the view of the production. Viewers are treated to an exhaustive account, from day-to-day scheduling to intricate details of visual effects shoot, making it a captivating experience for cinephiles and fans alike. Despite the absence of trailers or commentary, the sheer scope and intricacy of these extras render this release a treasure trove for those fascinated by movie-making.
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction By Peter Jackson: The director gives an overview of the special features arranged chronologically.
- Filming 'The Lovely Bones': A comprehensive three-part documentary detailing the filming process in the USA and New Zealand, alongside the visual effects photography.
Movie: 46
Peter Jackson's adaptation of "The Lovely Bones" presents a visual and emotional journey that, while striking, straddles the lines between the mystical and the unsettling. The film's Blu-ray presentation by Paramount is remarkable for its transfer quality, enhancing the movie's captivating visuals and intricate details which are central to Jackson's storytelling technique. This movie diverges from Jackson’s familiar epic spectacles, offering instead a narrative that's deeply personal and introspective, though it retains his signature grandiosity in visual style. The portrayal of Susie Salmon's afterlife is notably vibrant, employing a plethora of colors and effects to create a world that's as enchantingly ethereal as it is hauntingly surreal.
The performances in "The Lovely Bones" are profoundly engaging, with Saoirse Ronan leading with a sensitive portrayal of Susie, enveloped in a tragedy that resonates through her narration. Stanley Tucci’s depiction of George Harvey is chillingly effective, earning accolades for his transformation into the sinister neighbor. Despite this, the film navigates through its narrative amid pacing issues and at times overly dramatic presentations, which might detract from its core emotional impact. Notably, the use of special effects to craft Susie’s afterlife, while visually impressive, has drawn mixed reactions for its digital sheen which, to some, feels at odds with the film’s darker themes.
The technical aspects of "The Lovely Bones," from its cinematography to the ethereal score, are meticulously crafted, contributing to a sensory experience that is undeniably striking. However, it’s the balance between the visually stunning and the narratively profound where the film fluctuates. It embodies a kind of reverse-psychology; its most visually fantastical elements occasionally overshadowing its narrative depth. Thus, while "The Lovely Bones" stands out for its ambitious visual tapestry and strong performances, its storytelling executions invite varied interpretations, reflecting Jackson’s audacious approach to a complex, heart-wrenching tale.
Total: 73
The Lovely Bones," directed by Peter Jackson, presents itself as a polarizing adaptation that showcases an intriguing blend of genres, albeit with mixed execution. Among its strengths, Jackson's directorial prowess shines through, as he crafts a visually striking film that balances the grim subject matter with vibrant, fantastical elements reminiscent of directors like Tim Burton or Terry Gilliam. This distinctive visual style, paired with strong performances, ensures the film commands attention. However, the narrative suffers from pacing issues, particularly in the latter half where it jostles between the earthly and the ethereal, contributing to a somewhat disjointed viewing experience. Not all viewers will appreciate this melding of the murder mystery with surreal afterlife explorations, marking "The Lovely Bones" as a film that defies simple categorization and elicits strong, divergent reactions.
Paramount’s Blu-ray release of "The Lovely Bones" is undeniably commendable, particularly in its technical aspects. The 1080p video presentation is cited as a benchmark for quality, dazzling with clarity and vividness that elevate the film's unique visual flair. The audio quality complements this visual feast well, delivering an immersive experience that fans of the movie will find gratifying. The package is further enriched by a robust selection of bonus materials, although some may lament the absence of a director’s commentary which could have offered deeper insights into Jackson’s vision.
In conclusion, while "The Lovely Bones" may navigate through its narrative with a wavering grasp, its Blu-ray release stands out for its exemplary technical presentation and supplemental features. The film itself remains a topic of debate, but for aficionados of Jackson’s work or collectors seeking top-tier Blu-ray experiences, this release merits attention. Nonetheless, prospective buyers new to the film may want to explore it first before committing, given its polarizing nature. Whether "The Lovely Bones" is a masterpiece or a misfire is subjective, but its physical release undeniably sets a high standard for home cinema enthusiasts.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
The picture also features a heavy golden tint to it that's more prominent in some sequences than in others, which somewhat influences the absolute look of the color palette and flesh tones, but never to...
Audio: 90
The track incorporates a wonderful atmosphere into many of its scenes; the ambient chatter and footsteps as heard in a mall scene in chapter one or, later, ringing telephones and the sounds of an old typewriter...
Extras: 90
Just as engaging as the first two segments' focus on the principal photography is its third, which looks at the two-week process of shooting the film's extensive visual effects sequences which are aided...
Movie: 80
Additionally, his cast members all deliver top-flight performances that lend to the movie something different while all reinforcing its themes, whether Stanley Tucci's frightening take as, externally,...
Total: 90
Supported by some standout performances, The Lovely Bones is a must-see film; that doesn't mean that it's for everybody, but with a picture that's as different and genre-bending as this, there's not much...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Perfectly presented as solid demo material, this presentation wows with its bright vivid colors, and its sharp attention to detail....
Audio: 80
LFE is subdued for the most part, but kicks in during a few parts, like when a large safe is being flipped end over end, banging on the ground....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 20
There is a time in the film where Susie acknowledges that a girl in her neighborhood that died of Leukemia didn't go to her heaven....
Total: 60
Its ugly story and choppy style give it a nearly unwatchable feeling, couple that with Peter Jackson's tendency to over-direct and you have an end product that's a bloated melodramatic mess....
Director: Peter Jackson
Actors: Rachel Weisz, Mark Wahlberg, Saoirse Ronan
PlotIn the early 1970s, in a small Pennsylvania town, a young 14-year-old girl named Susie Salmon takes a shortcut home from school through a cornfield. Tragically, she is lured into an underground den by a neighbor, George Harvey, a reclusive man who hides a dark secret. This encounter leads to Susie's untimely death, marking a heartbreaking loss for her family and throwing them into a tumultuous period of grief and quest for understanding. The tragedy shatters the family, with each member grappling with the loss in their unique ways, struggling to hold onto any sense of normalcy and justice in the wake of such a profound loss.
Susie finds herself trapped in a liminal space between life and the afterlife, a vibrant, shifting realm she refers to as her "In-Between." From this vantage point, she watches over her family and observes the investigation into her disappearance and presumed death. She experiences a range of emotions, from longing to be back with her family to a desire for revenge against her murderer. Meanwhile, her family's search for answers leads them on a difficult journey, uncovering uncomfortable truths and testing the bounds of their strength, love, and resilience. Through this process, they begin to unravel not only the mystery of Susie's fate but also the complex web of personal and communal connections that define their lives and relationships.
Writers: Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Peter Jackson
Release Date: 15 Jan 2010
Runtime: 135 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, United Kingdom, New Zealand
Language: English