Roman J. Israel, Esq. Blu-ray Review
Score: 70
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Washington shines in a flawed but captivating 'Roman J. Israel, Esq.' Recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
Roman J. Israel, Esq.'s 1080p Blu-ray shines with Denzel's intensity, boasting lifelike colors, rich textures, and flawless detail that pushes HD to its limits, albeit missing on UHD.
Audio: 83
Roman J. Israel, Esq.'s DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack excels, blending vibrant cityscapes and clear dialogue with perfect balance and immersive detail, enriching this dialogue-driven drama.
Extra: 43
Roman J. Israel, Esq. extras include a digital code, detailed making-of and character features, and 12 mins of deleted scenes, highlighting Washington and Farrell's roles.
Movie: 60
Denzel Washington shines in 'Roman J. Israel, Esq.,' embodying an eccentric lawyer's journey overshadowed by a mesmerizing performance that overshadows a somewhat unfocused narrative.
Video: 76
The Blu-ray release of "Roman J. Israel, Esq." is a testament to high-definition presentation, showcasing a 1080p transfer that masterfully mirrors Denzel Washington's commanding performance. With the transfer, viewers are treated to a visually teasing experience that rivals the clarity and depth of UHD, despite Sony's decision not to release it in that format. The film's textures stand out with impeccable detail, offering a window into the complex fabric of suits and the intricate environments from luxury law offices to gritty urban settings. Each scene is meticulously rendered, pushing Blu-ray technology to its utmost limits, presenting colors that are vibrant and natural. The absence of digital manipulation ensures a filmic look that's increasingly rare and valuable in modern releases.
Shooting primarily on film has endowed "Roman J. Israel, Esq." with a rich texture and a subtle yet consistent grain structure that enhances the authenticity and depth of the visual experience. The deliberate color timing adds an aged, almost nostalgic feel to the image, with muted hues and softened blacks that contribute to the film's unique aesthetic without sacrificing detail or depth. Sunlit offices and outdoor scenes burst with clarity, enhancing the narrative's ambiance while challenging conventional lighting schemes in drama. This decision promotes an inviting visual narrative that complements the storyline perfectly.
The Blu-ray presentation shines in its ability to balance vivid coloration with natural settings, embodying a filmic quality that never borders on being overly digitized. From the detailed depiction of individual hairs to the fine threads of high-end suits, and from the dank recesses of a prison to the polished expanse of skyscraper offices, the transfer excels in delivering a visually compelling tale. Black levels are deep and consistent, ensuring that darker scenes retain their detail without falling victim to crush, and the color accuracy—from skin tones to the brighter palette—remains faultless throughout. With no noticeable flaws such as banding or video noise, this transfer secures its position as a standout in Sony’s high-definition catalog.
Audio: 83
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Roman J. Israel, Esq." with its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack offers an immersive and detailed auditory experience that is both impressive and expansive. The mix excels in delivering a spacious and vibrant soundscape, capturing the bustling energy of Los Angeles streets through layers of well-defined and dynamically balanced sounds. From the overhead buzz of a helicopter to the subtler nuances of street-level chatter and footfalls, the sound design meticulously crafts a realistic environment. The dialogue, crucial for a film heavy on courtroom and drama scenes, remains crystal clear and perfectly anchored in the mix, ensuring that the narrative flows smoothly without any auditory distractions. Music and ambient sounds are given generous room to breathe, enhancing the overall atmosphere without overwhelming the spoken words.
Within the auditory realm of this drama, the attention to spatial detail and the effective use of rear and stereo channels stand out, bringing to life diverse settings ranging from the echoing walls of prisons to the lively ambiance of a Lakers game. The soundtrack cleverly utilizes the low-end frequencies, particularly with thunder effects and a rich musical mix featuring retro R&B, delivering clear and impactful bass that adds depth without becoming overbearing. This conscientious balance between dialogue, effects, and music across the sound field demonstrates a keen focus on immersive sound mixing rarely found in dramas.
Effortlessly pulling viewers into its world, the audio track of "Roman J. Israel, Esq." excels in creating a full immersion experience. The diverse environments, from crowded courtrooms and busy city scenes to more intimate settings, are all captured with outstanding clarity and realism through effective use of surround and rear speakers. This detail-oriented approach extends to the directionality of voices and the natural reverberation in various spaces, further enhancing the authenticity of the auditory experience. Throughout, the score underscores the film's suspenseful and dramatic moments without intruding on the clarity of dialogue, which remains free from any distortion. This meticulous care in crafting the audio presentation makes it a standout aspect of the Blu-ray release, providing an exemplary listening experience that supports and elevates the visual narrative.
Extras: 43
The Blu-ray release of "Roman J. Israel, Esq." enriches the viewing experience with a modest but insightful collection of special features. Highlights include focused character studies on Denzel Washington's transformation into Roman and Colin Farrell's portrayal of George, each meticulous in detailing the nuances of their performances and character backgrounds. A well-crafted making-of featurette goes beyond the surface, exploring the film's thematic heart and real-world pertinence, alongside a look at the cinematography by Robert Elswit and behind-the-scenes glimpses of critical scenes. The inclusion of eight deleted scenes provides additional depth, revealing facets of Roman's journey not seen in the film. A Movies Anywhere digital copy expands viewing options for fans. Although some extras lean towards promotional content, the overall package offers a genuine look into the film's creation and the collaborative process of building its unique world.
Extras included in this disc:
- Denzel Washington: Becoming Roman: A discussion on Denzel Washington's preparation for the role, including character insights and collaboration with the director.
- The Making of Roman J. Israel, Esq.: An exploration of the film's themes, production challenges, and character development, with a focus on the cinematography.
- Colin Farrell: Discovering George: Insights into Colin Farrell's approach to his character and performance nuances.
- Deleted Scenes: Eight scenes offering expanded story elements and character moments.
- Previews: Trailers for additional Sony titles.
Movie: 60
In "Roman J. Israel, Esq.," Denzel Washington delivers yet another tour de force performance, embodying the quirky genius of an unconventional attorney whose life takes a tumultuous turn. Directed by Dan Gilroy, known for his acclaimed work on "Nightcrawler," the movie crafts a detailed character study that somewhat struggles under the weight of its lead's overwhelming presence. Despite the narrative sometimes meandering in search of direction, Washington's portrayal of Roman - an eccentric lawyer with a deep sense of justice and an encyclopedic knowledge of the law - is compelling enough to keep audiences invested. The film delves into the complexities of legal ethics and personal transformation, offering a platform for Washington to shine, albeit at the cost of overshadowing other elements of the story.
The narrative arc of Roman J. Israel, Esq. navigates through the titular character's crisis of conscience, magnified by a sudden shift in his career and lifestyle. From working behind the scenes at a small firm to being thrust into the limelight at a larger, more cutthroat legal practice, Roman's journey is marked by internal conflict and societal commentary. Gilroy attempts to marry these themes with Washington's commanding performance, but occasionally loses grip on the storyline's cohesion and pace. Supporting roles, notably by Colin Farrell as George Pierce, though well-acted, are relegated to the background, unable to fully contend with Washington's dominating presence.
Technically, the movie presents a detailed and immersive experience, showcasing Roman J. Israel’s idiosyncrasies, from his refusal to modernize his office tech to his fashion choices and personal habits. These details enrich the narrative but also signify Gilroy's meticulous attention to character over plot development. As Roman's ideologies are tested and his morals questioned, the film itself undergoes a transformation, albeit one that feels uneven at times. Despite these narrative shortcomings, "Roman J. Israel, Esq." stands out for its character work and Washington's outstanding performance, offering a complex look at the inner workings of an enigmatic legal mind wrestling with the dichotomy of idealism and pragmatism.
Total: 70
Roman J. Israel, Esq." is a film that, despite its structural struggles and occasional narrative incoherence, ultimately serves as a fascinating character study, magnificently brought to life by Denzel Washington's exceptional performance. Washington's portrayal of Israel, both in his physicality and verbal delivery, elevates the movie, making it a compelling watch despite its flaws. The character’s intellectual prowess coupled with his unique personality and moral convictions are explored in depth, providing audiences with a rich, albeit sometimes meandering, storyline that gains more substance upon reflection. The Blu-ray release by Sony enhances this experience with its superior video and audio quality, although the special features are not as extensive as one might hope for, they do add value to the overall package.
Critics note that while the film shines in its exploration of Roman's character, it falters in maintaining narrative consistency, particularly in the second half where the focus seems overly concentrated on Washington's performance at the expense of story development. This imbalance, however, does not detract significantly from the overall experience, thanks to Washington's captivating portrayal which commands attention and empathy. The technical aspects of the Blu-ray are praised across the board, with both video and audio presentations being highlighted as exceptional and indicative of Sony's commitment to quality.
In conclusion, "Roman J. Israel, Esq." Blu-ray presents a compelling reason to invest time in this Denzel Washington powerhouse performance. While the film may have its narrative shortcomings, they are overshadowed by Washington's masterful acting and the high-quality technical presentation of the Blu-ray. It's a product that comes highly recommended to fans of strong character-driven stories and those who appreciate cinematic excellence both in front of and behind the camera. Despite some missed opportunities in storytelling, the emotional depth, technical prowess, and Washington's performance make this Blu-ray a worthy addition to any collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
This is Blu-ray at its peak, presenting a gorgeously textured, perfectly filmic, and organically colored presentation that's the next-best-thing to UHD (and it's a shame Sony didn't see the feasibility...
Audio: 100
Everything is well pronounced and effectively positioned; for a movie of this nature, the track's authenticity, large spacing, and seamless presentation do wonders for the movie watching experience that...
Extras: 40
A discussion of the film's title character, writing the part for Denzel Washington, character qualities as presented in the script and shaped by Denzel himself, directing Denzel, and more....
Movie: 70
Character motivations are often a little more in a gray area than they might should be, and even with Roman's screen-dominating character and characteristics the film sometimes struggles to find the man...
Total: 80
It could be a bit narratively tighter in the first half, and everything is swallowed up whole by Washington's award-worthy performance, but the film is, overall, well worth watching primarily for the acting...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Well lit offices offer unusually high lighting schemes, avoiding the often dour look used in these types of dramas....
Audio: 100
Inside prisons, the sound echoes flawlessly, and a short scene at a Lakers game fills with crowd ambiance....
Extras: 60
With some class, the making-of is given a clean aesthetic and delves into the real world issues presented in the film....
Movie: 60
There’s a wealth of information packed into this character, rich and sharply defined, if at times in his own mind....
Total: 75
Denzel Washington is perfect at Roman J. Israel Esq., but the film around him suffers in the second half as Roman’s character falls apart....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Detail is sharp and vivid as well, with every hair on Denzel's head being shown easily as well as the high end suit's stitching and threads popping up in every scene....
Audio: 80
The score always adds to the suspenseful and dramatic moments, and the dialogue is clear and easy to follow along with, free of pops, cracks, and hiss....
Extras: 40
- This discusses the themes of the film, the cast, shooting some of the bigger scenes, and the work of the cinematographer Robert Elswit....
Movie: 60
Turns out, his law partner has a heart attack, where Roman is set to step into the role, but is offered a bigger job at a larger firm, run by Colin Farrell, who is the opposite of Roman's ways of thinking....
Total: 60
It's just that Washington's performance is so good, that the director chose to focus on that solely, rather than any other part of the story....
Director: Dan Gilroy
Actors: Denzel Washington, Colin Farrell, Carmen Ejogo
PlotRoman J. Israel, Esq. is a driven, idealistic defense attorney who finds himself in a tumultuous series of events that lead to a crisis and the necessity for extreme action. Having spent decades working behind the scenes in a small law firm that tackles cases of the disenfranchised and underrepresented, his life takes an unexpected turn when his partner, the firm's front man, has a heart attack. This event thrusts him into a role he is ill-prepared for: the face of the legal practice. Struggling to keep the firm afloat while maintaining their mission of social justice, he discovers unsettling truths about what the firm has become.
Amidst this professional turmoil, he is offered a job at a prestigious, high-powered firm led by one of his former students, who represents everything he has fought against. Torn between the lure of financial stability and his core principles, he faces moral and ethical dilemmas that challenge his character and legal ethics. His journey is further complicated by his involvement with a civil rights activist who pushes him to stay true to his beliefs. As he navigates these challenges, he must decide whether to compromise for the sake of survival or stand firm in his convictions, at the risk of everything he has worked for.
Writers: Dan Gilroy
Release Date: 22 Nov 2017
Runtime: 122 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Canada, United Arab Emirates, United States
Language: English, Spanish, Armenian