Sisters & Brothers Blu-ray Review
Score: 37
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Sisters & Brothers' has scattered charm but lacks depth; mediocre Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 44
Sisters & Brothers' Blu-ray has sharp details and rich colors but suffers from compression issues, banding, and unattractive gray overtone, making it a mix of high quality and problematic visuals.
Audio: 54
Sisters & Brothers offers immersive audio with clear, detailed soundscapes utilizing Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD, featuring realistic ambient sounds and precise vocalizations, despite minor early clarity issues.
Extra: 0
Sisters & Brothers is a bare-bones release without any supplemental content, emphasizing simplicity.
Movie: 31
'Sisters & Brothers' aims to explore sibling dynamics but ends up a disjointed, superficial tale with moments of potential marred by inconsistent tone and underdeveloped characters.
Video: 44
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray presentation of "Sisters & Brothers" exhibits a mixed bag in terms of video quality. The transfer, while aiming for high-definition glory, often falls short due to significant compression issues, which at times degrade the movie's visuals to the level of a low-quality streaming service. This inconsistency is further marred by occasional shimmering, detracting from what are otherwise crisp, well-detailed scenes rich in color and texture, particularly noticeable in up-close character interviews where skin textures and makeup are rendered with appreciable clarity.
Delving into the technical makeup, the movie presents itself in a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode that strives for clarity and sharp detailing across a variety of elements from clothing stitches to background furnishings. There's an effort to bring out a three-dimensional depth through bokeh-like photography, accompanied by richly rendered colors that should be the hallmark of a high-definition experience. Yet, this presentation does not come without its faults; it suffers from minor banding, mild posterization, and noticeable aliasing at the edges of structures. Coupled with a subdued contrast that imparts a grayish, somber tone to the picture, the video quality inadvertently introduces issues with brightness levels, crush, and shadow delineation that altogether yield a product that is, at best, considered passable.
Despite these technical endeavors to showcase "Sisters & Brothers" in the best possible light, the 4K UHD Blu-Ray release is plagued by a series of visual compromises that hinder the overall viewing experience. A sterile and somewhat bland digital presentation is punctuated by sporadic technical flaws, ranging from severe compression to aliasing and contrast issues, which collectively detract from what could have been a visually striking portrayal of the film's narrative and aesthetic qualities.
Audio: 54
"Sisters & Brothers" presents an auditory experience that, while mixed, showcases a notable dedication towards delivering a quality soundscape through its 4K UHD Blu-ray release. The audio kicks off with a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack, ensuring that elements such as the interviewer's questions and background music are distinguished with sufficient clarity and spacing. Ambient sounds like the bustle of an airport add to the environment, creating an immersive setting for the viewers. However, it’s worth noting that certain segments, such as the initial chaos of Justin being swarmed by fans, fail to deliver the same level of definition, resulting in a somewhat muddled audio output. Despite this, dialogue remains predominantly crisp and well-centered, contributing to a generally solid auditory foundation.
The sonic landscape takes a leap forward with the introduction of a DTS-HD Master Audio track, which amplifies the immersion through effective use of the surround channels. Urban ambiance, including people's chatter and the hustle of traffic, is meticulously placed around the listener, creating an enveloping soundfield that's both subtle and authentically lifelike. This attention to detail extends to the soundstage at the front, where clear vocalization and excellent separation between channels shine, bolstered by Dan Moxon's original music score that shines through with remarkable clarity in the mids and highs.
Additionally, though the bass may be considered mild, it maintains enough accuracy and responsiveness to lend the soundtrack a satisfying depth and presence. This fuller and warmer acoustic profile elevates the overall listening experience, making the audio aspect of "Sisters & Brothers" arguably its most commendable feature. The skillful blend of detailed environmental sounds with dynamic, clear music ensures a richly layered and inviting audio experience for audiences engaged with this release.
Extras:
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Sisters & Brothers" has disappointed many with its lack of supplemental content, offering a bare-bones experience that leaves a lot to be desired for those interested in the finer details of the film's production, background, or any additional content that enhances the viewing experience. Its straightforward presentation strictly limits the package to the film itself, devoid of any extras or special features that are typically expected from a release in this format, which could have provided valuable insights into the creative process behind the movie or added depth to the characters and storyline.
Extras included in this disc:
- Unfortunately, this release does not include any extras.
Movie: 31
"Sisters & Brothers," directed by Carl Bessai, is a film that ambitiously sets out to explore the intricate dynamics of sibling relationships through a variety of storylines and characters. However, it falls short of achieving a meaningful exploration, instead presenting a disjointed narrative that struggles to maintain a consistent tone or direction. The film's attempt to be edgy and relevant comes across as trying too hard, resulting in a collection of superficial stories that lack the depth and development necessary to engage the viewer fully. Despite the strong performances from the cast, including notable efforts from Cory Monteith, Dustin Milligan, and Gabrielle Miller, their characters' potentials are undercut by the script's inability to delve into more profound experiences or emotional journeys.
The narrative's fragmented structure, attempting to cover too many plots without giving each the attention it deserves, contributes to the film's overall scattered feel. It flits from one set of siblings to another— from the celebrity lifestyle clash between Justin and his brother Rory to the poignant struggle of Louise with her schizophrenic brother Jerry, and the aspiring actress Nikki entangled in the complications of familial and professional relationships. Each storyline had the potential for a compelling examination of familial bonds, yet none are given enough space to evolve into something genuinely impactful. Furthermore, the visual style attempts to innovate with mixed media elements but ends up feeling gimmicky rather than enhancing the storytelling, adding to the film's sense of disconnectedness.
The film's exploration of sibling dynamics, a central theme as highlighted by its title, promised an insightful look into familial relationships' complexities but ultimately delivers an experience that feels incomplete and unsatisfactory. While it reaches for emotional resonance and dramatic depth, "Sisters & Brothers" is bogged down by its convoluted structure and superficial character development. As a part of Bessai's trilogy on family relations, it might have aimed to offer closure or a summation of thematic inquiries started in "Mothers & Daughters" and "Fathers & Sons," yet it regrettably stands out as a weak conclusion, failing to provide a coherent or engaging narrative.
Total: 37
"Sisters & Brothers," in its 4K UHD Blu-ray incarnation, leaves something to be desired in terms of both film content and home release quality. The movie itself, an attempt to navigate the intricate dynamics of sibling relationships, stumbles through a series of loosely connected vignettes featuring performances that can only be described as inconsistently engaging. The episodic nature, intended to delve into these bonds, ends up feeling fragmented, neglecting to harness any real depth or genuine emotion. This approach results in a viewing experience that is at times interesting yet ultimately unfulfilling due to its lackluster narrative and humor. On the technical front, Anchor Bay's release presents an acceptable but unremarkable video quality, accompanied by an audio aspect that, while exceeding expectations, cannot compensate for the overall mediocrity of the package.
The Blu-ray itself offers no special features, which could have provided much-needed insight or added value to the film's presentation. This absence is particularly felt in a release that could have benefited from supplementary materials to enhance understanding or appreciation of the film's intent and execution. The picture quality is described as average and somewhat problematic, failing to fully exploit the capabilities of the 4K UHD format. This oversight underscores a missed opportunity to visually elevate the material, further compounding the sense of disappointment associated with this release.
In conclusion, "Sisters & Brothers" on 4K UHD Blu-ray represents a missed opportunity to explore and elevate a potentially compelling narrative through both its cinematic execution and home release presentation. The lack of special features, coupled with only passable video and audio quality, renders this release a curiosity for completists rather than a must-have for the average viewer. Those interested in the thematic exploration of sibling dynamics are advised to manage expectations or perhaps seek out more cohesive and technically superior offerings.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 60
Though it oftentimes looks rather sharp, well detailed, and nicely colored, there are plenty of instances that show severe compression issues, to the point that the movie often looks like a low quality...
Audio: 60
There's a good bit of surround information, including interviewer questions that flow from the rear....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 50
It lacks a strong narrative substance, instead ambling between four different sets of characters that travel along fairly predictable arcs and thereby lose the opportunity for a more solid cohesion....
Total: 50
The movie as it is delivers a piecemeal, but mostly appetizing, buffet of off-the-cuff character skits....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The 1.78:1 image shows a subdued contrast, which is likely intentional and giving the picture a grayish, downcast overtone, but this effects brightness levels with lots of crush and poor shadow delineation....
Audio: 80
The majority of the design is geared towards the front where the soundstage delivers excellent, precise vocalization and terrific, fluid channel separation....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 20
Much like the characters themselves pretending to be genuine people concerned with real problems, 'Sisters & Brothers' is all over the place, walking blindly in search of a plot but managing only to bump...
Total: 40
Largely episodic and somewhat annoyingly sporadic, this supposed comedy lacks humor or any sense of genuine human emotion, draining the spirit of an audience foolish enough to watch until the predictably...
Director: Carl Bessai
Actors: Cory Monteith, Gabrielle Miller, Amanda Crew
PlotThe narrative unfolds around the complex and multifaceted relationships between siblings, delving into the lives of four groups of brothers and sisters, each facing their unique set of challenges and issues. At the heart of these intertwined stories are themes of estrangement, jealousy, rivalry, and the deep bonds that can both sustain and suffocate. The siblings navigate through their shared histories and personal demons, striving for connection and understanding amid the chaos that life often presents.
In one storyline, we follow a pair of estranged siblings who are unexpectedly thrust back into each other's lives, forcing them to confront past grievances and misunderstandings. Another segment introduces us to a pair of sisters whose seemingly perfect relationship hides a web of secrets and lies. A contrasting tale focuses on a brother burdened with the responsibility of caring for his mentally unstable brother, highlighting the sacrifices and pressures that come with such a role. Lastly, the journey of a young actress dealing with her jealous and competitive sister showcases the impact of fame and success on family dynamics. Through these diverse yet interconnected narratives, the film explores the myriad ways in which siblings affect each other's lives, for better or worse.
Writers: Carl Bessai, Jay Brazeau, Amanda Crew
Release Date: 10 Sep 2013
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: R
Country: Canada
Language: English, Spanish