Jack and the Beanstalk Blu-ray Review
70th Anniversary Limited Edition
Score: 82
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Jack and the Beanstalk's restoration by 3-D Film Archive offers stunning visuals, exceptional bonus materials, and is a must-have for Abbott and Costello fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 87
The Blu-ray of 'Jack and the Beanstalk' by 3-D Film Archive showcases a remarkable 1080p restoration using AVC codec, maintaining the original 1.37:1 ratio. This release triumphs over past versions, offering sharper detail and improved SuperCineColor fidelity, despite minor grain and color variance from the Cinecolor process.
Audio: 79
Jack and the Beanstalk's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track delivers a clean dialogue experience with minor signs of distortion and a thin sound, yet shines in musical moments with full-bodied orchestration. Remastered with excellent fidelity, it enhances the dynamic last act and humourous sound effects.
Extra: 88
The Blu-ray extras for 'Jack and the Beanstalk' feature engaging insights into the film's production and restoration, with highlights including Ron Palumbo's comprehensive commentary, rare footage of 'Who's On First?', a fascinating Cinecolor history, and captivating live TV appearances, enriching the viewing experience significantly.
Movie: 64
Jack and the Beanstalk's latest Blu-Ray release offers a vastly improved visual experience over previous editions, showcasing Abbott and Costello's first color film. Though not without budget constraints, its playful use of the SuperCineColor process and slapstick humor makes it a delightful family-friendly adventure akin to The Wizard of Oz, delighting both young fans and nostalgic adults alike.
Video: 87
The Blu-ray release of "Jack and the Beanstalk," presented by The 3-D Film Archive and ClassicFlix, is a monumental step up from previous editions, thanks to a meticulous restoration process. Utilizing an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in the original 1.37:1 aspect ratio, this release corrects many past video presentation shortcomings. The color consistency is significantly improved, staying true to the Cinecolor aesthetic despite its known limitations. Unlike previous releases, flesh tones exhibit a more natural hue, albeit sometimes leaning towards peach. The once pervasive sickly green tint has been largely eradicated. While slight color temperature variations and superficial damage remain, grain structure is more pronounced yet appropriately aligned with Cinecolor’s characteristics.
This restoration is particularly impressive considering the fragmented history of the original materials. A 4K scan of multiple 35 mm SuperCineColor prints—conducted by Bob Furmanek and the restoration artisans of the 3-D Film Archive—has revitalized the visual fidelity. Despite missing elements like the original camera negative and color separation masters, the restoration team admirably salvaged and incorporated a surviving clip. The substantial improvement in detail levels endows the film's costumes, production design, and character makeup with newfound clarity and appreciation. This Blu-ray finally offers a faithful rendition of George Robinson's cinematography on 35 mm Eastman color stock.
In comparison to past disastrous home video releases from 2008 to 2020, this version represents a revelatory transformation. The SuperCineColor process, notorious for its challenges, now yields hues that are much richer and less chalky. The sepia and color sequences exhibit balanced grain levels and inviting tonal depth, enhancing both sharpness and texture. While minor anomalies like grain heaviness in certain scenes persist, they scarcely detract from an overall commendable presentation. This release stands as a testament to the dedicated restoration efforts, providing a captivating viewing experience akin to witnessing the film anew.
Audio: 79
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release of "Jack and the Beanstalk" is anchored by a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track. Although there are minor signs of distortion, particularly noticeable in the more vibrant musical sequences, the overall sound is notably more stable than previous VCI releases. The track offers a somewhat boxy and thin overall sound, yet manages to produce a full-bodied background for choral and orchestral sections. Dialogue clarity is consistent, rendering conversations without significant issues, while optional English subtitles are available for additional clarity.
An engaging mix brings a dynamic energy to the film, especially during the song and dance numbers, where orchestral elements gain prominence. The final act is particularly active, with strong sound effect integration, such as the humorous effects accompanying the Giant's pursuit of Jack; this rounds off an already robust mix. The superbly remastered audio ensures excellent fidelity and blends dialogue effectively with musical and sound effects, demonstrating remarkable care in preserving these historic sound elements.
The track remains largely free from age-related artifacts like hiss, pops, or crackles, contributing to an experience that does justice to the film's auditory landscape. Despite its mono configuration, the mix captures an immersive feel, particularly evident in the two-minute end credits that provide a brief surround-like effect thanks to 3-D Film Archive's contribution. Overall, this release successfully restores historic audio to a clean and reliable state that enhances the viewing experience.
Extras: 88
The Blu-Ray extras for "Jack and the Beanstalk" provide a robust collection that enhances appreciation of this classic film. The disc is packed with informative and engaging content, starting with a brief, heartfelt introduction by Chris Costello, offering personal insights into her father's work. The highlight is the detailed audio commentary from Ron Palumbo, supplemented by David Stollery and Chris Costello, offering comprehensive coverage on production insights, deleted scenes, and film history. The archival features like "Who's On First?" newsreel and "Abbott and Costello Meet the Creature" TV appearance add historic value, while the restoration demo showcases the meticulous efforts in reviving this film. A rich assortment of galleries and trailers, some with commentaries, further enhances this comprehensive package.
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction by Chris Costello: Personal reflections by Lou Costello's youngest daughter.
- Audio Commentary: Expert analysis by Ron Palumbo with contributions from David Stollery.
- Who's On First?: Archival newsreel from December 1940.
- Imperfect Spectrum: Documentary on Cinecolor's history by Jack Theakston.
- Climbing the Scales: Exploration of the film's music by Ray Faiola.
- Cutting Down the Beanstalk: Examination of deleted scenes by Ron Palumbo.
- Abbott and Costello Meet the Creature: 1954 live TV skit appearance.
- Rudy Vallee Radio Sketch: 1945 radio sketch with photo gallery.
- Restoration Demo: Illustrative before-and-after restoration footage.
- Image Gallery: Behind-the-scenes photos with a children's recording soundtrack.
- Publicity Materials Photo Gallery: Collection of promotional items.
- Abbott and Costello Trailer Rarities: Compilation of 18 original trailers.
- Fireman Save My Child: Film trailer with optional commentaries.
- ClassicFlix Trailer Gallery: Includes various related trailers.
Movie: 64
The Blu-ray release of "Jack and the Beanstalk" revitalizes Abbott and Costello’s first color feature with a commendable restoration effort that addresses previously encountered video quality issues. Previously plagued with video distortions and missing frames in older editions, this version presents a much-improved visual experience, drawing from a superior source element. The narrative follows the familiar folktale with comedic twists, featuring Lou Costello as the bumbling, childlike Jack and Bud Abbott as Dinklepuss, involved in hilarious antics. The film opens with sepia tones reminiscent of "The Wizard of Oz," transitioning to vivid SuperCineColor as the fantasy adventure unfolds. Although the film was produced on a modest budget, it delights audiences with its spirited humor and slapstick comedy, particularly appealing to younger viewers while invoking nostalgia among older fans.
The production enlists key personnel from Abbott and Costello’s TV endeavors, enriching the film's comedic foundation. Despite being aimed at a juvenile audience, the film’s lasting charm lies in Costello's mastery of physical comedy, bringing amusement through his playful interactions and exaggerated gestures. Accompanying the comedy are sprightly songs, though they may not reach the memorable heights of other classics; they complement a narrative filled with fairy tale elements like giants and magic beans. While Abbott has a more subdued role, Costello’s energetic performance remains the centerpiece, offering a mélange of slapstick humor driven by crafted choreography.
The film embarks on its whimsical journey with notable performances from Buddy Baer as the giant and James Alexander portraying Prince Arthur. Although constrained by budgetary limitations evident in sparse sets and modest choreography, the entertainment value flourishes through a colorful depiction of fairy tale tropes and engaging characterizations. The Blu-ray edition, augmented by polished visuals and classic comedic timing, offers a rejuvenated viewing experience, inviting both new audiences and longtime fans to enjoy this musical fantasy caper in its most striking rendition yet.
Total: 82
The Blu-ray release of "Jack and the Beanstalk" by ClassicFlix, in collaboration with the 3-D Film Archive, marks a significant upgrade over previous home video versions. Spearheaded by Bob Furmanek and his team, this restoration offers a visually stunning representation of Abbott and Costello's whimsical take on the classic tale. The film, while perhaps not the duo's most celebrated work, benefits immensely from this meticulous restoration, presenting sharper visual quality and enriched audio fidelity that highlight Jean Yarbrough’s directorial nuances and the comedic interplay of Bud Abbott and Lou Costello.
Accompanying the restored feature is an array of bonus materials that broaden the viewing experience. Fans can delve into the film's production history and discover a host of surprises that enhance appreciation for this comedic gem. These supplements are thoughtfully curated, offering both die-hard fans and casual viewers insights into the film and its makers, thus elevating the value of this Blu-ray release.
While "Jack and the Beanstalk" may not occupy the pinnacle of Abbott and Costello's filmography, its charm is undeniable in this restored format. The restoration reveals its endearing qualities to greater effect, making a strong case for reevaluation. This release is especially recommended for collectors and aficionados who appreciate the historical significance and sheer entertainment value it embodies. Fans are encouraged to secure a copy promptly, given its limited availability. For those seeking a delightful addition to their collection, this Blu-ray is an essential purchase.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
One noticeable difference here is that the grain field is much more visible, especially in the Cinecolor sequences (I'm assuming the technique, which the featurette devoted to it documents included "negative...
Audio: 70
Jack and the Beanstalk features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track that manages to overcome some of the most blatant disruptions of the VCI release, but which admittedly still shows minor signs of distortion...
Extras: 80
Cutting Down the Beanstalk (HD; 18:30) features Ron Palumbo looking at some of the material that was deleted from the film before release....
Movie: 60
Within minutes of me posting my Jack and the Beanstalk Blu-ray review, which began with a somewhat whimsical notion that maybe someone somewhere had a better element to source a transfer of this curiously...
Total: 70
In the closing comments of my review of the VCI release I stated, "This is frankly not the kind of film that will probably ever be granted any kind of major restoration, and in a way it's kind of sad",...
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 95
Jack and the Beanstalk was shot by George Robinson on 35 mm Eastman color 5247 film stock with Mitchell BNCR cameras and spherical lenses, processed and printed using the SuperCineColor 3 color process,...
Audio: 85
Extras: 100
Palumbo discusses the careers of the cast and crew, the production of the film, facts about the locations and studios used to shoot the film, deleted and alternate scenes, where the idea to make the film...
Movie: 85
Wanting to ditch many of their older routines and make a film that was aimed more at children, they brought in many of the people responsible for producing their TV show, including director Jean Yarbrough...
Total: 91
Indeed, no stone is left unturned, and one can get absolutely stuffed on not just the history of the film itself, but on many other unrelated surprises....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Now, given age and the film’s use of the somewhat troublesome Cinecolor process there are a few small quibbles but this is an overall beautiful release....
Audio: 80
The mix picks up the heat for the song and dance numbers wither stronger orchestral accompaniment, the last act of the film is particularly active and dynamic in that regard - complete with some humorous...
Extras: 80
Audio Commentary featuring Abbott and Costello expert Rob Palumbo with recollections from actor David Stollery Introduction by Chris Costello, youngest daughter of Lou Costello (HD; 1:12)...
Movie: 60
As Lou has the little boy read him the story (because of all the big words), he drifts off to sleep and the film transitions to glorious full Cinecolor....
Total: 80
For a long time, Jack and the Beanstalk just wasn’t a favorite, but something clicked with this latest viewing....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
The grain levels present are also quite consistent throughout giving the movie in both the sepia and color sequences a well-balanced and well-defined appearance....
Audio: 100
Dialogue is always easy to understand, and it has been mixed with the songs and music (Heinz Roemheld supervised the background score) and sound effects to excellent effect....
Extras: 100
Imperfect Spectrum: A Brief History of Cinecolor (13:21, HD): film historian Jack Theakston’s featurette on the color process used in the making of Jack and the Beanstalk with examples from other films...
Movie: 60
While the production lacks charm and was obviously filmed with a small budget (as fantasy films go), it has its merits: a couple of sprightly songs, colorful fairy tale costumes, and Lou himself indulging...
Total: 70
Jean Yarbrough’s Jack and the Beanstalk may not be the most notable film ever made by Abbott and Costello, but with the outstanding restoration of the movie by the 3-D Film Archive, the film now can show...
Director: Jean Yarbrough
Actors: Bud Abbott, Lou Costello, Buddy Baer
PlotIn a whimsical reimagining of a classic fairy tale, a lively and fantastical blend of comedy and adventure unfolds. The story begins in a small bookshop where two bumbling yet good-hearted friends, salesmen by trade, find themselves inadvertently caught up in a fantastical journey. When they attempt to collect on a debt from a young girl and her brother, they are instead drawn into her world of make-believe. She begins reading the famous tale of magic beans and towering plants, transporting them into an enchanting kingdom above the clouds. As events unfold, echoes of familiar nursery rhyme elements interweave with their adventures in a seemingly timeless world where anything once imagined is suddenly possible.
In this newfound land, they encounter a sleeping giant, who alternates between being a terrifying presence and an unwitting comedic accomplice to the protagonists’ antics. Armed with their wits and reluctant bravery, the two misadventurers seek to restore order amongst chaos while remaining on the giant's watchful trail. Interactions with various enchanted characters—each with their own whimsical peculiarities—propel the story forward, creating an atmosphere rich with humor and suspense. The clever intertwining of fantasy elements with slapstick comedy ensures a merry escapade where bravery and friendship face off against dangers both real and exaggerated. As the duo navigates through these challenges, their loyalty and courage are tested against both adversity and their own clumsiness, leading them on a path that could redefine their destinies.
Writers: Nathaniel Curtis, Pat Costello
Release Date: 12 Apr 1952
Runtime: 70 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English