Shake Hands with the Devil Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Shake Hands with the Devil is an intense political thriller showcasing James Cagney's masterful performance; a must-have gem with excellent HD restoration.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
Shake Hands with the Devil on Blu-ray impresses with a 1080p transfer, sourced from a strong 2K master in its original 1.66:1 aspect ratio, offering fine detail and balanced grayscale. The visual quality, free from digital artifacts and stability issues, marks it as the most definitive home video release to date.
Audio: 87
Presented in English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, the Blu-ray delivers clear dialogue and effective sound mixing, with William Alwyn's score enhancing action scenes. Despite inherited limitations, this is likely the best audio fidelity for the film, offering a stable and clean sound experience.
Extra: 47
Don Murray's engaging interview offers intriguing insights into the film industry and the impactful real locations of 'Shake Hands with the Devil', complemented by a remastered vintage trailer, exploring Method acting and creative freedom under director Michael Anderson, amidst historical and cultural tensions surrounding the film.
Movie: 78
Shake Hands with the Devil, directed by Michael Anderson, offers a gripping portrayal of the Irish War of Independence, blending historical depth with personal drama. Featuring striking cinematography by Erwin Hillier and powerful performances, especially from James Cagney and Don Murray, the film remains a tense exploration of conflict and loyalty, now justly restored on Blu-ray.
Video: 83
The Blu-ray release of "Shake Hands with the Devil" by Kino Lorber, presented in an aspect ratio of 1.67:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, exhibits impressive visual quality, leveraging a recent 2K master. While minor fluctuations in density and clarity are occasionally apparent, they don't detract significantly from the overall presentation. The 1080p transfer maintains a pleasingly organic appearance, with a well-graded master that handles darker scenes with commendable balance between blacks, whites, and grays. Notably, no digital corrections mar the picture, and stability remains reliable throughout. This Region-A locked release requires compatible play for access.
Faithfully preserving film grain along with grayscale and fine details, this Blu-ray edition surpasses previous DVD incarnations significantly. Minor artifacts such as scratches, tears, dirt, and vertical lines are minimally present, ensuring that the image quality is largely uncompromised. Sourcing from this 2K master likely positions this release as the best visual rendition of the film available to date on home video, marking a substantial upgrade from prior full-screen formats. Overall, the meticulous attention to technical presentation makes "Shake Hands with the Devil" an exemplary showcase of restored vintage cinema on Blu-ray.
Audio: 87
The Blu-ray release of "Shake Hands with the Devil" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, accompanied by optional English SDH subtitles. Despite the film’s vintage nature, the audio presentation is decidedly crisp and faithful to the original, effectively capturing the dialogue clarity expected from a mono source. The soundscape is largely devoid of anomalies such as distortion or hissing, allowing for clear dialogue delivery. Outdoor scenes may occasionally reveal some thinness in the audio, but these inherited limitations are minor.
The sound mixing stands out particularly well in complex scenes. For instance, during a dock scene, dialogue, ambient sounds, and machine noises blend seamlessly to create an engaging audio environment. This precision reflects an effective use of available technology to bring depth to these sequences. The soundtrack composed by William Alwyn is integrated adeptly, enhancing action sequences with strategic music placement while maintaining its restraint in non-critical moments.
Overall, this audio presentation ensures an immersive experience by preserving the integrity of the original mono soundtrack. With dynamic intensity befitting a film from the late 1950s, this release represents a significant improvement over previous home video editions. It skillfully balances authentic representation with modern clarity, delivering a satisfying auditory experience for both purists and casual viewers alike.
Extras: 47
The Blu Ray extras for "Shake Hands with the Devil" offer engaging insights and historical context that enhance the film's experience. Notably, the exclusive video interview with actor Don Murray delves into his career inception and experiences on set, providing an enriching narrative of his interactions with the likes of James Cagney and reflections on Method acting. These extras capture the ambience of shooting locations and discuss historical sensitivities regarding the film's portrayal of the IRA. Another highlight includes a remastered vintage trailer that adds nostalgic value. These additions cater to both cinephiles interested in film history and those keen on contextual backstories.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: A remastered vintage trailer in English.
- Interview with Actor Don Murray: Detailed insights into Don Murray's career, filming experiences, and industry anecdotes.
- The Devil and Don Murray: A supplementary interview complementing Murray's previous discussion.
- Bonus KLSC Trailers: Featuring trailers for various classic films.
Movie: 78
Michael Anderson's "Shake Hands with the Devil" (1959) presents an intricate blend of fact and fiction, set against the tumultuous backdrop of Dublin in 1921. The narrative follows Kerry O'Shea, an American medical student played by Don Murray, who finds himself entangled in the violent struggle of the Irish War of Independence. The film navigates the complex dynamics between the Irish Republican Army and the British Black and Tans, emphasizing the personal transformation O'Shea undergoes after witnessing the brutalities of the conflict. James Cagney delivers a compelling performance as Professor Sean Lenihan, whose dual role as educator and resistance fighter adds depth to the character-driven story. While some viewers may find historical inaccuracies in the depiction of peace proposals and strategic decisions, the film's focus on individual experiences and emotional conflicts remains impactful.
The film is lauded for its powerful performances, particularly those of Murray and Cagney. Murray effectively captures O'Shea's evolution from a reluctant observer to an active participant in the fight for Irish independence. Cagney embodies Lenihan with unrelenting intensity, showcasing a nuanced portrayal that underscores his character's internal conflicts between vengeance and a quest for freedom. Dana Wynter offers a notable contribution as Jennifer Curtis, whose romantic subplot with O'Shea adds another layer to the narrative. The supporting cast, including Michael Redgrave as The General, enriches the film with their well-crafted portrayals.
Cinematographer Erwin Hillier enhances the film's authenticity with striking visuals that highlight Ireland's dramatic landscapes and intimate wartime moments. The cinematography, coupled with Anderson's adept direction, captures the era’s tension and uncertainty, resulting in a cinematic experience that is both historically resonant and visually engaging. This Blu-ray release finally allows viewers to appreciate Hillier's work in its proper widescreen format, adding a new dimension to this absorbing tale of resistance and personal sacrifice.
Total: 77
"Shake Hands with the Devil" is a profound exploration of moral ambiguity during turbulent times, set against the backdrop of the Irish 'troubles.' Tony Luraschi's direction brings to the forefront a narrative that resonates widely, emphasizing the challenge of neutrality in war. The film draws parallels with "The Outsider," featuring an American protagonist caught in a moral quagmire. This cinematic masterpiece makes a compelling addition to any collection, with its powerful universal message about conflict and allegiance.
At the heart of the film is James Cagney, whose late-career performance is nothing short of mesmerizing. Known for his indignant rage and screen command, Cagney elevates the film to remarkable heights. His portrayal is reminiscent of his best performances in classics like "White Heat" and "Public Enemy." Despite evolving perspectives on terrorism post-9/11, Cagney's performance ensures that the film remains engaging as both an action-packed thriller and a political commentary.
This Blu Ray release finally provides "Shake Hands with the Devil" the presentation it deserves. Kino’s high-definition treatment offers a pristine view in its original aspect ratio, enhancing the film’s visual experience significantly. The added interview with Don Murray offers valuable insight, adding depth to the viewing experience. This upgrade from previous DVD editions is both substantial and justified.
In conclusion, "Shake Hands with the Devil" stands as a testament to cinematic artistry and historical storytelling, making it highly recommended for its powerful narrative and exceptional performance by Cagney. This release enriches any film collection and is an upgrade not to be missed.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
All in all, even though trained eyes will recognize a few inherited limitations that an elaborate restoration would have addressed, the current technical presentation of Shake Hands with the Devil is very...
Audio: 100
Dynamic intensity is good for a film from the late 1950s, but keep in mind that there are plenty of inherited limitations....
Extras: 40
Interview with Actor Don Murray - in this exclusive new video interview, actor Don Murray, who plays the young American Kerry O'Shea, explains how he entered the film industry and discusses his involvement...
Movie: 80
However, and this is something this writer wants to make perfectly clear, because the film does not attempt to carefully deconstruct the nature of the Irish 'troubles' and the exact politics that were...
Total: 80
Shake Hands with the Devil puts the spotlight on a familiar issue, the Irish 'troubles', but its message I think is universal -- during a time of war, it is virtually impossible to remain neutral....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 80
Prof. Lenihan shows up and it turns out he’s also an IRA leader, a Jekyll/Hyde character who saves lives as a surgeon but doesn’t hesitate to snuff them out when it furthers the cause....
Audio: 80
Sound mixing is particularly effective in a dock scene, in which dialogue, ambient noise, and the sound of a crane loading baggage are nicely blended....
Extras: 60
Michael Anderson was not overly specific in his direction; he set up the scene and allowed the actors their creative freedom....
Movie: 85
Set in Dublin in 1921, Shake Hands with the Devil stars James Cagney as an Irish professor practicing and teaching surgery during the bloody conflict between Great Britain and Ireland....
Total: 76
Our view of terrorism in the wake of 9/11 may have dulled sympathy for Lenihan and his followers, but the film still works as an action/political thriller....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 100
The film is presented in its original 1:66:1 aspect ratio for the first time on home video, taken from a brand new 2K master created for this release....
Audio: 100
Again, this is likely the best the movie will ever sound on home video and another improvement over its past incarnations on home video....
Extras: 50
Theatrical Trailer (2:17) Bonus KLSC Trailers – Never Steal Anything Small, The Gallant Hours, One, Two, Three & No Highway in the Sky...
Movie: 80
Director Michael Anderson fashions a gripping drama of the fight for freedom while also presenting internal factions within the resistance – Lenihan, as the movie makes clear later on, is more driven by...
Total: 90
While it came and went without much notice upon first release, Shake Hands with the Devil is still a hidden gem in the careers of both director Michael Anderson and actor James Cagney....
Director: Michael Anderson
Actors: James Cagney, Don Murray, Dana Wynter
PlotSet against the turbulent backdrop of 1920s Ireland, the story follows Kerry O'Shea, an American medical student studying in Dublin. Despite his Irish heritage, Kerry remains largely indifferent to the political conflict gripping the nation. His peaceful life is disrupted when he witnesses the killing of a fellow student during an encounter with British forces, leading to his inadvertent involvement with the Irish Republican Army (IRA). Taken to the IRA's headquarters, Kerry is introduced to their leader, Dr. Sean Lenihan, a passionate nationalist and respected professor. Though resistant to joining the cause at first, Kerry becomes more entangled after rescuing a wounded rebel. This act of compassion puts him in grave danger, forcing him to confront his beliefs and loyalties.
As the rebellion intensifies, Kerry's interactions with Dr. Lenihan reveal a man deeply conflicted by the brutal methods he endorses for their shared goal of Irish independence. Kerry also encounters more rebels who each present different facets of dedication and sacrifice. Among them is a mysterious woman named Jennifer Curtis, whose alliances remain enigmatic but pivotal. The increasingly perilous environment compels Kerry to reassess his detached stance and weigh his personal convictions against the collective fight for freedom. With each passing moment, he is drawn deeper into a web of danger, betrayal, and moral ambiguity. As tensions escalate and choices loom, Kerry faces actions that will define not only his own fate but also that of a nation on the brink of profound change.
Writers: Rearden Conner, Marian Spitzer, Ivan Goff
Release Date: 24 Jun 1959
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: Approved
Country: Ireland, United States
Language: English