Graduation Blu-ray Review
Bacalaureat
Score: 74
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Cristian Mungiu’s 'Graduation' is a masterfully shot, engaging critique of post-communist Romania, featuring a solid Criterion release with a strong video transfer and essential interviews. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 79
Graduation's 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio from Criterion shines with excellent detail and natural color balance, despite intentionally muted and earthy tones reflecting its grim, corrupt setting. The fully digital workflow ensures outstanding clarity, stability, and absence of artifacts or noise.
Audio: 79
Graduation's Blu-ray features a Romanian DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio mix with clarity, sharpness, and depth replicating the original digital soundtrack. Dialog is crystal clear, ambience immersive, and sound effects like breaking windows and starting vehicles are deep and sturdy, offering a well-balanced and layered experience.
Extra: 51
Graduation's Blu Ray extras feature an insightful interview with director Cristian Mungiu, a Cannes Q&A panel, seven deleted scenes, the original trailer, and an illustrated Criterion booklet with an essay by Bilge Ebiri; these elements, though modest in quantity, offer valuable and engaging insights into the film.
Movie: 81
Graduation's Blu-ray release by Criterion highlights Cristian Mungiu's masterful direction, showcasing a raw depiction of post-communist Romanian society. Enhanced by interviews, deleted scenes, and an essay by Bilge Ebiri, the film captures the harsh realities of corruption and familial sacrifice without spoon-feeding the audience.
Video: 79
Presented in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, Cristian Mungiu's Graduation delivers an impeccable 1080p transfer on Blu-ray through Criterion. Completed through a fully digital workflow, the film's high-definition presentation is exemplary. The detail and clarity are particularly striking, offering a rock-solid visual experience that showcases the benefits of current digital technology. Colors are natural and balanced, contributing to overall image stability and depth.
The film adopts a cold, visually muted palette, reflecting the somber moods and settings of the storyline. The aesthetic leans heavily towards decayed and moldy colors, with greens, blues, and browns creating a melancholic atmosphere. This stylistic choice highlights the grim and corrupt environment in which the narrative unfolds. Detail is sharp and intense; individual hairs, elemental fabrics, and the textures of run-down housing are rendered with precision. Although skin tones appear somewhat muted, this is intentional rather than indicative of any shortcomings in the transfer. Notably, there are no issues with aliasing, artifacts, or video noise. The earthier tones, while subdued, result in a highly impactful visual presentation.
Audio: 79
The Blu-ray release of "Graduation" features a Romanian DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, paired with optional English subtitles for the main feature. This fully digital soundtrack essentially mirrors the original studio mix, preserving its clarity, sharpness, and depth impeccably. One notable example is the scene where an apartment window gets broken early in the film—this instance showcases the robust depth and clarity of the mix. The dialogue is consistently stable and easy to follow, with no audio dropouts or digital distortions present.
Criterion's meticulous mastering of the original digital audio master files delivers a well-balanced, layered audio mix. The DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio track may not be explosive but excels in subtlety and detail. For instance, ambient sounds such as students walking to class or hospital environments are well-rendered through the surrounds, enhancing immersive experience. Moreover, specific sound effects, such as breaking windows or vehicle engines starting, exhibit sturdy depth and solidity. The score adeptly complements the emotional tones of various scenes, and the dialogue remains crystal clear without any audible imperfections like pops, cracks, or hiss.
Overall, the audio presentation in "Graduation" is meticulously executed, providing a sharp and compelling listening experience that enhances the subtleties of the film's narrative environment.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray extras for "Graduation" provide a comprehensive and insightful look into the film's production and thematic underpinnings. The standout feature is the 30-minute interview with Cristian Mungiu, where he meticulously discusses his method of selecting stories, the integration of social and emotional themes, and his non-judgmental approach to character portrayal. Additionally, the Cannes Film Festival press conference offers a 42-minute session with the director and principal cast members discussing their experiences and creative processes during production. The package also includes seven deleted scenes that, while not crucial to the main narrative, offer extra depth to character development. The original trailer and a meticulously crafted booklet featuring critic Bilge Ebiri's analysis further enrich the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: Original IFC Films trailer for Graduation with English subtitles.
- Cristian Mungiu: Director's interview on his storytelling approach and thematic focus.
- Deleted Scenes: Seven scenes providing additional character insights.
- Cannes Film Festival: Q&A with the director and cast discussing the film.
- Leaflet: Illustrated booklet with essay by critic Bilge Ebiri and technical credits.
Movie: 81
Winner of the Best Director Award at the Cannes Film Festival, Cristian Mungiu's "Graduation" (2016) is an incisive exploration of the socio-political landscape of post-communist Romania. The film centers around Dr. Romeo Aldea (Adrian Titieni) and his efforts to secure a better future for his daughter Eliza (Maria Dragus). Faced with deteriorating living conditions and a pervasive sense of stagnation, Romeo hopes that Eliza's success in her final exams will earn her a stipend to study at a prestigious British university. Mungiu captures the raw and unembellished realities of life in contemporary Romania without overdramatizing or politicizing the narrative.
Set in a provincial town plagued by decaying infrastructure and creeping darkness, Graduation paints a vivid picture of systemic corruption and disillusionment. Romeo's journey is complicated by external forces when Eliza is assaulted just days before her exams, prompting Romeo to confront the corrupt political system in a bid to salvage her future. Mungiu's masterful direction keeps the narrative grounded and authentic, eschewing dramatic resolutions for a more contemplative approach. The film's open-ended finish effectively mirrors the uncertainties that characteristically define real lives, compelling audiences to engage with the film's deeper themes.
Mungiu's ability to weave characters from diverse backgrounds into a coherent narrative is particularly commendable. The film subtly critiques the idealistic aspirations held by many Romanians, revealing how these ambitions can perpetuate cycles of disillusionment across generations. This nuanced portrayal strengthens the film's impact, offering insightful commentary on the ongoing struggle for societal transformation. "Graduation" is a somber yet intellectually engaging film that employs its characters as vectors to expose the unsettling persistence of old political habits amid modern-day Romania’s evolving landscape.
Total: 74
Cristian Mungiu's "Graduation" stands as a poignant exploration of generational disillusionment in post-communist Romania. Embracing a narrative imbued with realism, Mungiu deftly weaves a tale that examines the cyclical nature of societal pressures and the pursuit of Western ideals. The film's central theme focuses on the older generation, disheartened by the unfulfilled promises of post-revolutionary reforms, compelling their children to seek better opportunities abroad. This underlying despair is excellently captured through naturalistic performances and authentic character portrayals.
Visually, "Graduation" benefits from Criterion’s dedication to excellence, with a robust master that maintains the visual integrity of the original. The run-down neighborhood settings are captured vividly, reflecting both the physical and metaphorical decay following the fall of communism. Audio-wise, the mix is balanced and enhances the immersive experience without overshadowing the film's subtle intricacies. The limited bonus features, including an insightful interview with Mungiu, provide valuable context and are well worth the investment despite not being as extensive as some may hope.
The generation of older Romanians that witnessed the fall of Nicolae Ceaușescu and then gradually became disillusioned with the reformation of their country as they realized that they are running out of time to have the lives that they had dreamed of are doing just about everything right to ensure that their sons and daughters have pretty much the same miserable lives. In this new cycle, the only difference will be that the majority of these young Romanians will suffer away from their home country. Cristian Mungiu is absolutely right to highlight the problem in his latest film because he understands that the people of his generation are operating with the same damaging idealism while pushing their children to 'make the right choice' and go West as did those of the generation before them when they guaranteed the emergence of a prosperous democracy only a few years after the collapse of the communist regime. Criterion's recent release of Graduation is sourced from a very solid master and has a wonderful exclusive interview with director Mungiu. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
The following text appears inside the leaflet that is provided with this Blu-ray release: "The film was completed in a fully digital workflow....
Audio: 100
Because the film uses a fully digital soundtrack, what you are getting on the Blu-ray is essentially a replica of the original mix that was created in the studio....
Extras: 70
Cristian Mungiu - in this new video interview, director Cristian Mungiu explains how he chooses the right story/project that is consequently developed into a feature film, the important connection between...
Movie: 90
The alternative, which is to have Eliza stay in Romania for the rest of her life, is unacceptable to Dr. Aldea because over the years he has seen enough and is fully convinced that even a few generations...
Total: 90
Cristian Mungiu is absolutely right to highlight the problem in his latest film because he understands that the people of his generation are operating with the same damaging idealism while pushing their...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
While this might not be a colorful image, it still looks fantastic in every way with varying layers of the earthier tones....
Audio: 80
The score always adds to emotional note in each scene, while the dialogue is always crystal clear and exquisite without any pops, cracks, or hiss....
Extras: 40
- This is the Q&A with the director and actors of the film at the Cannes Film Festival, in which they answer questions about making the movie....
Movie: 80
This is where Mungiu sets the final act in motion, displaying the still-corrupt Romanian political system while Romeo tries to keep his family and house from falling apart....
Total: 80
The film is beautifully shot in a run-down neighborhood that is trying to still mend the fences from the fall of communism and the characters are all universally engaging and real....
Director: Cristian Mungiu
Actors: Adrian Titieni, Maria Dragus, Lia Bugnar
PlotRomeo Aldea, a physician living in a small Romanian town, is determined to secure his daughter Eliza's future. Eliza, a promising student, is on the cusp of receiving a scholarship to a prestigious UK university, contingent upon her performance in final exams. However, just as the exams approach, Eliza becomes a victim of an assault that leaves her emotionally and physically shaken. Faced with his daughter’s trauma, Romeo must decide whether to prioritize her emotional well-being or push her to excel in her exams to ensure her future opportunities remain intact. As the assault investigation unfolds, Romeo grapples with his professional responsibilities and personal ethics.
Romeo’s desperate measures to aid Eliza’s success bring him into contact with corruption and moral ambiguity. He navigates a complex web of favors and questionable decisions, entangling himself with local influential figures. The pressures of these morally dubious choices weigh heavily on him, and he begins to evaluate the cost of his aspirations for his daughter against the erosion of his principles. The events compel Romeo to reevaluate not only the immediate dilemmas but also the broader implications of integrity and sacrifice in a flawed social system. His journey reveals the profound impact of personal choices on their lives and each other.
Writers: Cristian Mungiu
Release Date: 20 May 2016
Runtime: 128 min
Rating: R
Country: Romania, France, Belgium
Language: Romanian