Chicago Blu-ray Review

The "Chicago: Diamond Edition" Blu-ray release by Lionsgate Films graces our screens with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in an aspect ratio of 1.85:1, boasting of a master prepared in Dolby Vision. This cutting-edge technology promises a groundbreaking improvement in detail and contrast, setting a new standard for home cinema experience. However, it's crucial to note that to fully leverage the benefits of Dolby Vision, one needs Dolby Vision compatible equipment - a caveat that may temporarily dampen the excitement for those without the latest hardware. Despite this, the Diamond Edition offers a visible upgrade over its predecessor, with enhanced detail and contrast particularly noticeable in darker scenes, though the improvements are more evolutionary than revolutionary.

The debate over grain in the film’s original presentation continues with this release. Director Rob Marshall and Director of Photography Dion Beebe deliberately utilized film grain to stylistically enhance certain scenes, a decision that remains consistent in this edition. Viewers who previously found the grain levels excessive might not find solace here, as the enhanced clarity and contrast tend to emphasize grain structures even more, particularly in those intentionally “pushed” or filtered scenes.

Nonetheless, colors in the Diamond Edition appear richer and more vibrant, meticulously balanced to convey the 1920s setting with striking authenticity. Scenes dazzle with an array of beautifully saturated hues, presenting "Chicago" in possibly the best light we've seen thus far. Although the full potential of this release hinges on future Dolby Vision-compatible home entertainment systems, it's clear that this edition marks a commendable step forward in honoring the visual allure of the beloved musical. It stands as a testament to what modern technology can achieve in preserving and enhancing the cinematic experience, pending the widespread availability of Dolby Vision-enabled viewing setups.

The audio presentation of the Blu Ray for "Chicago" has undergone a notable transformation, moving from the previously acclaimed LPCM 5.1 mix to a Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix that captures the essence of the musical's dynamic range with an even greater depth. This upgrade is not simply a nominal increase in channels but constitutes a tangible enhancement in the audio’s spatial distribution, particularly benefiting rear channel separation and overall action within the soundscape. The result is a more immersive experience that brings the viewer closer to the vibrancy and complexity of both the orchestral arrangements and the ensemble’s vocal performances, laying down a new benchmark for audio quality in home cinema.

The introduction of the Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix appears to have been executed with meticulous attention to detail, ensuring that all aspects of the soundtrack are presented with crystal clarity and without any hint of distortion. This is noteworthy in how it manages to not only enhance the separation of musical components but also significantly improve upon the representation of Foley effects, with moves and environmental sounds benefiting from panning effects and discrete channelization that are more viscerally engaging. Particularly, the handling of complex layered sounds and the subtle nuances in the musical performances demonstrate an audio mix that does not merely aim to be louder but rather strives for a richer, more enveloping auditory experience.

In closing, while the existing LPCM 5.1 mix provided an already exceptional auditory experience, the update to Dolby TrueHD 7.1 on the Blu Ray release of "Chicago" elevates it further, offering both subtlety and power in its delivery. This mix enhances every nuance of the movie's iconic score and ambient sounds, ensuring that each musical number and scene transition is experienced with utmost clarity and presence. The new audio mix reaffirms the title's status as a reference-quality release, setting a high standard for home entertainment audio presentations.

The Blu-ray release of "Chicago" delivers a notably trimmed selection of extras compared to its predecessor, dropping several features but compensating with a hefty retrospective and a bevy of extended musical performances. The centerpiece, "Chicago in the Spotlight: A Retrospective with the Cast and Crew," is an expansive collection of featurettes spanning over two hours. It dives deep into the film's production, from adaptation and casting to rehearsals and shooting, featuring fresh interviews with key cast and crew members. While some might lament the omission of previously included supplements, this edition's inclusion of extended musical numbers, presented in standard definition, along with informative commentary by Director Rob Marshall and Screenwriter Bill Condon, adds value for aficionados seeking a richer understanding of the film's creation and nuances.

Extras included in this disc:

• Chicago in the Spotlight: A comprehensive retrospective featuring new interviews with the cast and crew.
• Extended Musical Performances: Including hits like "And All That Jazz," "Cell Block Tango," and several others in standard definition.
• Feature Commentary with Director Rob Marshall and Screenwriter Bill Condon: Insightful audio commentary shedding light on the filmmaking process.

Lionsgate's decision to re-release "Chicago" on Blu-ray, complete with a remastering that some might argue was unnecessary given the original's positively received presentation, embodies the spirit of risk that often drives the entertainment industry forward. This new edition aims not only to attract fresh eyes but also to entice those who have already experienced the film's razzle-dazzle to revisit it, thanks in part to an enticing bonus documentary. Before delving into the specifics of this release, it's worthwhile to revisit the show and film's historical standing, an endeavor that unearths Bob Fosse's indelible influence on Broadway and the unique journey of "Chicago" from stage to screen.

The transformation of "Chicago" from a critically acclaimed Broadway show to a major Hollywood film is a testament to the enduring appeal of Fosse's work and the narrative's intrinsic allure. Despite being overshadowed at its inception by other landmark productions, "Chicago" saw a resurgence that not only revived its theatrical fortunes but also paved the way for its cinematic rendition. The film, under Rob Marshall's direction, sought a delicate balance between staying true to the show's vaudevillian roots and leveraging cinematic techniques to convey its story. However, the decision to anchor the musical sequences within the protagonist Roxie Hart's imagination, while innovative, dilutes some of the source material's satirical bite, signifying a shift that may divide audiences based on their affinity for traditional film musicals.

Marshall's editorial choices, particularly the rapid pacing of dance sequences, might stir nostalgia for Fosse’s more visually transparent choreography, highlighting a generational divide in the appreciation of musical storytelling. Yet, "Chicago" as a film largely succeeds in recapturing the spectacle and vibrancy of classic film musicals. Stellar performances from Catherine Zeta-Jones, Renee Zellweger, and Richard Gere, alongside standout roles by Queen Latifah and John Reilly, showcase the cast's ability to navigate both the cinematic and theatrical demands of their characters. In reflecting upon what Fosse might have brought to such a project, one can't help but admire Marshall's efforts to bridge the gap between Fosse’s theatrical brilliance and the expansive possibilities of modern cinema.

The new Blu-ray release of "Chicago" strives to capture the magnetic essence of its theatrical predecessor, albeit with a modern twist that might not sit well with staunch traditionalists of the stage. The transfer achieves a remarkable feat visually and sonically, presenting the film’s iconic razzle-dazzle with commendable clarity and vibrancy. Though it mildly diverges from Bob Fosse's distinctive, more cynical perspective, this rendition still manages to offer a substantial slice of the original's charm and dynamism. It's worth noting, however, for those considering an upgrade from a previous version, that there is a slight drawback in terms of the completeness of special features.

The video and audio quality of this edition are undeniably its crowning glory, rendering it a tempting proposition for fans and newcomers alike. The Blu-ray boasts an impressive visual upgrade, nurturing every scene with a vividness that significantly enhances the overall viewing experience. The audio track complements this perfectly, ensuring that the film's infamous musical numbers leap out with all the intended panache and fervor. While the shortfall in bonus material compared to its predecessor might deter some collectors, the sheer quality of the movie's presentation makes this a lesser concern for the average viewer looking to immerse themselves in the spectacle of "Chicago".

In conclusion, despite its deviations from the original stage interpretation and the slightly diminished array of extra content, the "Chicago: Diamond Edition" on Blu-ray stands out as a beautifully crafted release that breathes new life into the beloved musical. Its exceptional video and audio presentation more than make up for any deficiencies, firmly securing its place as a highly recommended addition to any film aficionado's collection. Whether you're a seasoned fan or discovering its allure for the first time, this version promises an enriching cinematic experience that captures the essence of "Chicago" with unmatched elegance and style.