Malcolm X 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review

Criterion’s 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Malcolm X" on a 100GB triple-layered disc stands as a significant upgrade over Warner Bros.' 2012 release, boasting a 2160p resolution, an aspect ratio of 1.85:1, and HDR enhancements through Dolby Vision and HDR10. Encoded in HEVC/H.265 and derived from the 35 mm original camera negative scanned in 4K 16-bit resolution, this transfer dazzles with its clarity, detail, and color fidelity. The film’s journey through Malcolm X's life, from the vibrant streets of Boston to the stark environments of prison, and the more naturalistic tones of his later years, is rendered with exceptional precision. Every frame showcases improved fine detail and contrast levels, with a nuanced color reproduction that breathes life into Spike Lee’s vision. Fine film grain is present, enhancing the cinematic texture without overpowering, while specific scenes, like the black-and-white newsreel footage, intentionally display a heavier grain to evoke a distinct period feel.

Despite the overall acclaim for the visual treatment, the use of blue filtering in the prison sequences marks a discernible departure from previous releases, potentially stirring discontent among purists. This choice slightly flattens the image, contrasting with the otherwise robust color saturation and deep, inky blacks that contribute to a rich visual depth throughout the rest of the film. Flesh tones across the board are handled adeptly, staying true to natural hues without succumbing to over-saturation.

The HDR enhancement further elevates this 4K presentation, smartly leveraging Dolby Vision and HDR10 to deliver a striking differential in color saturation and brightness levels. Highlight scenes — from Malcolm’s vibrant zoot suits to the radiant scenery during his pilgrimage — pop with vitality, showcasing meticulous attention to lighting and shadow detail that maintains integrity even in the darkest scenes. The visual language of "Malcolm X," characterized by its varied palette and intricate production design, is celebrated in this transfer with a fidelity that underscores Criterion’s commitment to preserving and elevating cinematic artistry.

The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track present in the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Malcolm X" is an exercise in auditory finesse, providing an audio experience that, while largely front-driven, doesn't shy away from utilizing its rear channels to envelop the listener into Malcolm's world. The handling of ambient sounds in crowded scenes, such as Malcolm's speeches in auditoriums and outdoor gatherings, demonstrates a keen attention to sonic detail, allowing the listener to be fully immersed in these moments. Terence Blanchard's soul-stirring score is given ample room to breathe, offering a dynamic and richly textured backdrop that enhances the cinematic journey. The mix, remastered from the original 35 mm magnetic track, although not new, retains a quality that does justice to the film's powerful narrative, ensuring that dialogue cuts through clearly and effectively against the film's broader soundscape.

Furthermore, the audio track's capacity to handle lower frequencies with precision marks a noteworthy mention, allowing moments of action and musical depth to resonate well with the audience. However, despite these achievements, the absence of a Dolby Stereo option to replicate the theatrical experience may be felt by some purists. Additionally, while the film's dialogue remains intelligible and crisp throughout, indicating a well-calibrated balance between speech and background score, one cannot help but wish for more consistent use of the surround channels to further enhance atmospheric elements.

Despite these minor caveats, the 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Malcolm X" stands out for its audio presentation. Whether it's leveraging the DTS Neural:X function for an expanded atmospheric feel or simply relishing in the meticulously remastered sound, the audio track successfully complements the visual restoration to bring forth an engaging viewing experience. Although it mirrors its Warner Bros.' 2012 Blu-ray release in some respects, the depth and clarity afforded by this version underscore an enhanced listening experience that admirers of the film will surely appreciate.

The Criterion Collection's 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Malcolm X" enhances its appeal with a substantial assortment of special features, blending enlightening archival content with fresh interviews crafted specifically for this edition. The extras meticulously explore the film's production, its historical context, and the collaborative process behind its creation, providing an immersive experience that complements the main feature. Noteworthy among these extras are the in-depth 2005 audio commentary by key production members and three exclusive interviews from 2022 with Spike Lee, Delroy Lindo, and Terence Blanchard, offering personal insights and reflections. The inclusion of "By Any Means Necessary: The Making of Malcolm X," deleted scenes, and the compelling 1972 documentary directed by Arnold Perl significantly contributes to an overarching understanding of Malcolm X's legacy and the film's impact. This collection strikes an excellent balance, delivering both technical details and the personal stories that shaped the movie.

Extras included in this disc:

Audio Commentary: A 2005 commentary featuring Spike Lee, Ernest Dickerson, Barry Alexander Brown, and Ruth E. Carter.

Spike Lee in Conversation: A 2022 interview revealing fascinating insights into Lee’s career and experiences directing "Malcolm X."

Actor Delroy Lindo: A reflective 2022 conversation about Lindo's role and connections to the story.

Terence Blanchard: Blanchard discusses his score for "Malcolm X" and his collaboration with Lee.

By Any Means Necessary: The Making of Malcolm X: A featurette focusing on the film’s production.

Deleted Scenes: A collection of nine deleted scenes, introduced by Spike Lee.

Malcolm X 1972 Documentary: A comprehensive look at Malcolm X’s life, serving as a companion piece to his autobiography.

Theatrical Trailer: The original trailer for "Malcolm X.

Celebrating its 30th anniversary, the Criterion Collection has honored Spike Lee's "Malcolm X" with a 4K UHD restoration that breathes new life into this monumental film. Supervised by cinematographer Ernest Dickerson, the restoration boasts Dolby Vision / HDR10 enhancement and lossless audio, enriching the visual and auditory experience for audiences. This release also compiles new interviews with cast and crew, alongside all the vintage extras from Warner Bros.' 2012 edition, making it a definitive package for both cinephiles and newcomers to Lee's oeuvre. The impeccable transfer and inclusion of both previous and new special features underscore the film's enduring legacy and the meticulous care taken in its presentation.

Spike Lee’s portrayal of Malcolm X remains unparalleled in its depth and complexity. Denzel Washington’s portrayal of the titular character is nothing short of electrifying, capturing Malcolm X's evolution from a small-time criminal to a pivotal civil rights leader with unmatched fervor and nuance. This biopic distinguishes itself by refusing to shy away from the intricacies and controversies of Malcolm X’s life, offering viewers a comprehensive look at his journey without succumbing to the simplification often seen in biographical films. The support cast, including Angela Bassett, Al Freeman Jr., and Delroy Lindo, among others, brings vibrancy and depth to this historical narrative, further elevated by Lee's dynamic direction and Ernest Dickerson’s captivating cinematography.

Spike Lee utilizes a mosaic of film styles to tell Malcolm X's story, advancing beyond typical biographical portrayals to present an all-encompassing view of his subject. From the vibrant scenes of Malcolm’s early life to the intense drama of his political activism, Lee balances entertainment with a keen insight into the societal impacts of Malcolm's philosophy. The film's meticulous attention to historical detail, combined with Terence Blanchard’s emotive score, provides a rich backdrop against which Washington’s performance shines brightly. Through its ambitious scope, "Malcolm X" not only celebrates the life of one of America’s most complex figures but also invites audiences to reflect on the film’s cultural and historical significance, ensuring its place in cinematic history.

Spike Lee's "Malcolm X" stands as an unparalleled cinematic journey, interweaving historical gravitas with compelling narrative finesse, brought to life by Denzel Washington's performance, arguably his career-best. Commemorating its 30th anniversary, Criterion has meticulously crafted a 4K UHD Blu-ray release that not only enhances the film’s visual and auditory experience but also enriches the viewer's engagement with this seminal work. The package boasts a new 2160p transfer, supervised by the cinematographer, ensuring that each frame presents Spike Lee's vision with utmost clarity and fidelity. Accompanied by a crisp lossless audio track, the film’s dynamic sound design is rendered with precision, further immersing the audience in this powerful biopic. Exclusive to this release, the remastered edition is augmented with a plethora of high-quality bonus features, including new documentaries and commentaries that provide a deeper understanding of the film's historical context and production intricacies.

The Criterion Collection's release elevates "Malcolm X" beyond its filmic achievements, transforming it into an essential archive of American history and filmmaking prowess. The Dolby Vision transfer exemplifies the pinnacle of home video viewing, with its luminous highlights and deep, resonant blacks showcasing the film's rich palette and intricate lighting. Moreover, the comprehensive array of bonus content—ranging from behind-the-scenes insights to scholarly analyses—offers both newcomers and longtime fans invaluable perspectives on the film’s enduring impact and relevance.

In conclusion, Criterion's 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Malcolm X" is an exemplary homage to Spike Lee's masterpiece and Denzel Washington's iconic portrayal. It sets a benchmark for home entertainment releases, providing an audio-visual feast that complements the film’s powerful narrative. This release is not merely a technical upgrade but a tribute to the film's cultural significance, making it an indispensable addition to any cinephile's collection. Highly recommended, it is a testament to the lasting legacy of Malcolm X and an invitation to experience his story with renewed intensity and clarity.