Glee: The 3D Concert Movie Blu-ray Review
Score: 43
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Glee: The 3D Concert Movie Blu-ray is a fan-centric release with decent audio and video quality; ideal for die-hard Gleeks but offers little new content.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 43
Digitally filmed 'Glee: The 3D Concert Movie' on Blu-ray presents an inconsistent 1080p image with noticeable noise, micro-blocking in dark scenes, and occasional heavy post-processing. Color reproduction is realistic with saturated tones, though some edge enhancement and milky blacks detract from visual quality.
Audio: 48
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track on the Blu-ray of 'Glee: The 3D Concert Movie' offers clear, intelligible vocals and some dynamic moments, but overall, it lacks an immersive quality with underutilized rear channels and a one-dimensional sound design that diminishes the concert experience.
Extra: 31
The Blu-ray extras provide fans with extended and unseen performances in HD, brief behind-the-scenes cast interactions, and innovative Shazam connectivity for unlocking additional mobile content, with an exclusive 3D tour booklet enhancing the 3D set value.
Movie: 51
Glee: The 3D Concert Movie is a treat for diehard 'Gleeks', offering an engaging 84-minute pop spectacle with stellar performances from the entire cast, enhanced by high-quality Blu-ray presentation. However, its heavy-handed inclusion of real-life vignettes and mostly commercial music may not resonate with all viewers.
Video: 43
The video presentation of "Glee: The 3D Concert Movie" in its 2D Blu-ray format exhibits both strengths and weaknesses typical of concert films. Filmed with Red Epic and Arri Alexa high-definition digital cameras mounted on 3D rigs, the concert’s 1080p image occasionally feels excessively processed. Outdoor fan interviews often display an oddly smoothed look, likely aimed at providing a shiny glow to the youthful audience. Furthermore, concert footage seems to suffer from slight edge enhancement, resulting in a superficially sharp yet somewhat unrealistic image quality.
Noise and low-light artifacts are prominent during many performance and audience shots, diminishing the viewing experience. Darker scenes, such as those featuring the stage curtains, betray noticeable micro-blocking and a general crawling noise. Color representation remains a relative strength, with bright costumes appearing vibrant and natural skin tones well-rendered. However, blacks frequently take on a grayish hue, possibly a compromise to preserve shadow detail, which further affects the overall consistency of the video presentation.
In summary, while possessing moments of visual clarity and vibrancy, "Glee: The 3D Concert Movie" on Blu-ray is marred by inconsistent image quality, heavy post-processing, and prevalent noise artifacts in darker scenes. The result is an acceptable but far-from-definitive concert film presentation.
Audio: 48
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track on the "Glee: The 3D Concert Movie" Blu-ray provides a serviceable yet underwhelming listening experience. Although the mix allows for clear and easily discernible vocals, which maintains the lyrical integrity throughout the performance, it falls short in creating an immersive audio environment. Listeners will hear the music primarily from the front channels, leaving the rear channels sparingly utilized and failing to envelope the audience in a true concert atmosphere. This can lead to a somewhat one-dimensional sound field where fans' cheers and instrumental elements do not fully transport the viewer into the live performance setting.
For particular tracks like “Fat Bottomed Girls” and “Firework,” the surround mix does hit a higher note with punchier and more dynamic output when played at higher volumes. However, overall, the instrumentation tends to sit too quietly in the background, making the musical experience feel distant and less engaging. Despite these shortcomings, there are no noticeable technical flaws such as hisses, dropouts, or pops. The disc also offers a comprehensive selection of dub and subtitle options, adding a layer of accessibility for diverse audiences.
In summary, while listeners will find the vocal clarity commendable and some tracks notably dynamic, this audio presentation stops short of delivering the fully immersive concert experience one might expect from a high-definition Blu-ray release.
Extras: 31
The Blu-ray extras for "Glee: The 3D Concert Movie" offer fans a deeper dive into the concert experience with both extended and unseen performances, as well as additional on-stage and backstage footage. This content is presented in 1080p, 2D HD quality, providing high-definition visual clarity. Highlighting this package, Jane Lynch's humorous interactions and character-driven banter between Blain and Brittany enrich the viewing experience. For tech-savvy fans, the Shazam Connectivity feature adds an interactive element, allowing viewers to unlock bonus material via a smartphone app. Note that this functionality is exclusive to the 2D version. The 3D set also includes a 30-page tour booklet replica, offering tangible memorabilia.
Extras included in this disc:
- Unseen Performances: Dog Days Are Over and Friday.
- Extended Performances: Ain't No Way and Happy Days Are Here Again.
- On Stage with the Cast: Jane Lynch heckles the crowd; Blain and Brittany banter.
- Backstage with the Cast: Additional in-character interview snippets.
- Shazam Connectivity: Unlock extra material on your mobile device.
Movie: 51
"Glee: The 3D Concert Movie" captures the energetic and vibrant experience of the "Glee Live! In Concert!" tour, providing ardent fans with a visually and audibly rich tribute to the beloved TV series. Performed by the show's main cast at the IZOD Center in East Rutherford, New Jersey, the movie delights with lively renditions of iconic tracks such as Journey's "Don't Stop Believin'", Michael Jackson's "P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing)", and Queen's "Fat Bottomed Girls". While some performances like Kurt's (Chris Colfer) "I Want to Hold Your Hand" and Artie's (Kevin McHale) "Safety Dance" may fall flat, standout numbers such as Rachel's (Lea Michele) explosive "Firework" and Santana's (Naya Rivera) soulful "Valerie" invigorate the audience, encapsulating the heart of what makes "Glee" a phenomenon.
Beyond the music, the concert film intersperses feel-good vignettes featuring real-life teens who have found inspiration and self-acceptance through "Glee". These stories, aimed at resonating with themes of inclusivity, tolerance, and empowerment, enhance the movie's narrative texture. However, some viewers may find these segments overly sentimental and somewhat disruptive to the concert's pacing. Nonetheless, these vignettes underscore the show's central message: everyone deserves a place in the spotlight, regardless of their background or struggles.
Time is equally divided amongst the principal cast, ensuring each character has shining moments. The Warblers led by Blaine (Darren Criss) deliver a peppy trio of "Teenage Dream", "Silly Love Songs", and "Raise Your Glass". Performances are meticulously choreographed and brimming with enthusiasm, further solidifying "Glee: The Concert" as an exhilarating viewing experience for dedicated fans. However, those unfamiliar with the series might find it challenging to fully grasp the fervor behind this musical celebration.
Total: 43
Glee: The 3D Concert Movie on Blu-ray offers a uniquely enjoyable experience for ardent fans of the series, albeit one that treads familiar territory. The musical performances capture the energy and charisma of the beloved characters, presenting hits in a live concert setting that aligns well with the show's vibrant spirit. The Blu-ray's transfer is commendable, delivering vivid visuals that bring the concert to life, complemented by a high-quality audio track that ensures every note and cheer is crystal clear. However, those unfamiliar with or indifferent to "Glee" may find little new here, as the content closely mirrors what is seen on television.
Despite its underwhelming performance at the box office, primarily due to marketing missteps and public reluctance towards the 3D format, this Blu-ray release succeeds in providing an engaging home viewing experience. Technically speaking, the disc excels; color saturation is on point and detail is maintained even in dynamic concert scenes. Audio fidelity is robust, capturing both the musical performances and audience interactions effectively. Yet, it's worth noting that the value of this release is predominantly sentimental and tailored to its existing fan base, rather than showcasing any groundbreaking new content.
In conclusion, "Glee: The 3D Concert Movie" on Blu-ray is undeniably crafted for the dedicated Gleek. Although it may not attract casual viewers or the uninitiated, it serves as a joyful celebration for Finn-o-philes, Rachel-wannabes, and Kurt-oholics alike. Fans will appreciate seeing their favorite numbers performed with gusto in a new environment. Given the solid audio-visual presentation, it is recommended for any enthusiastic supporter of the series. Those on the fence may want to consider a rental first to gauge its merit for their personal collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 60
Color is realistic and nicely saturated, but you will notice that blacks sometimes take on a milky grayish quality during some scenes, possibly in order to save shadow detail....
Audio: 70
You'll hear the clapping and screaming of the fans and notice that some of the music has been bled into the back speakers, but the mix just isn't as aggressive as it could be, immersion-wise....
Extras: 50
Shazam Connectivity: Download the Shazam app to your smartphone, and when you see the Shazam icon appear on screen during the film, you can "tag" these moments to unlock additional bonus material on your...
Movie: 70
The concert opens, no surprise here, with Glee's signature number, Journey's "Don't Stop Believing," a song that's seen an impressive spike in iTunes sales�for the both the original version and the cover�ever...
Total: 70
The Glee concert movie bombed at the box office due to poor marketing and a public unwilling to shell out extra bucks to see it in 3D, but I suspect many a Gleek will find this Blu-ray release nestled...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Whenever there is a dark background the picture crawls with noise – for example check out the dark areas of the curtains whenever they're down....
Audio: 60
Much of the music seems trapped in the center speaker and unable to travel throughout the rest of the sound field to create a more engrossing experience....
Extras: 20
On Stage with the Cast (HD, 5 min.) – We get some Jane Lynch antics here along with chitchat between Blain and Brittany....
Movie: 40
The stories are every bit as cheesy as the storylines in 'Glee,' but that's what they're going for here....
Total: 40
However, if you're worried about the quality of the video and audio I'd say at least rent it first to see if you really should be adding it to your collection....
Director: Kevin Tancharoen, Jennifer Arnold
Actors: Cory Monteith, Dianna Agron, Lea Michele
PlotThe film showcases a live concert experience featuring cast members from a popular musical television series performing a selection of their most popular songs. The concert footage intersperses high-energy performances with backstage moments, giving fans a glimpse into the personalities of their favorite characters. The songs include various hits from different genres, highlighting the cast's vocal talents and the series' signature mix of energetic choreography and emotional depth. The performances are dynamic, with elaborate staging, lighting, and costumes that bring the TV show's beloved musical numbers to life for the audience.
Throughout the film, the narrative also focuses on the impact of the TV show on its devoted fans, featuring personal stories and interviews that illustrate the series' influence on their lives. These segments, filled with heartfelt testimonies, emphasize themes of acceptance, perseverance, and the power of music to bring people together. The concert experience, therefore, is not just a showcase of musical talent but a celebration of the community and positive messages fostered by the series. The combination of live performances and fan interactions creates an immersive experience that captures the essence of the show's cultural significance.
Writers: Ian Brennan, Brad Falchuk, Ryan Murphy
Release Date: 12 Aug 2011
Runtime: 84 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English