Mrs. Miniver Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Greer Garson's nuanced, emotive portrayal anchors 'Mrs. Miniver,' exuding quiet patriotism and resilience.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Warner's Blu-ray of 'Mrs. Miniver,' one of the four Oscars-winning works by master cinematographer Joseph Ruttenberg, showcases superb, detailed visuals with natural grain, crisp blacks, and fine grays, reflecting the studio's commitment to quality transfers.
Audio: 54
Mrs. Miniver's DTS-HD MA 1.0 soundtrack delivers powerful aerial sequences and clear voices despite thick accents requiring subtitles. Limited dynamic range and an old-fashioned score by Herbert Stothart, yet heartfelt.
Extra: 31
The Blu-ray features historical and satirical content, improving upon the 2004 DVD by including all but a photo gallery and adding the Blitz Wolf cartoon, alongside a diverse mix of old cinematic and informational pieces.
Movie: 81
William Wyler's 'Mrs. Miniver,' a film of enduring British resilience against Nazi blitz, won him an Oscar, inspired a nation at war through personal stories and patriotism, amidst both front-line and home-front battles.
Video: 74
Warner's release of "Mrs. Miniver" on 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray is an exemplary showcase of the studio's dedication to preserving and presenting classic cinema with the reverence it deserves. As a film that highlights Joseph Ruttenberg's unparalleled contributions to black-and-white cinematography—earning him one of his four Oscars—the Blu-ray transfer does justice to his artistry. The video quality is impressively sharp and detailed, revealing the meticulous care taken in the film's photography. The source material's excellent condition is apparent, as the transfer is free from any signs of artificial sharpening, grain reduction, or other digital interferences. The presence of a very fine, natural grain pattern enhances the filmic quality, ensuring that viewers experience the movie as intended, albeit with a closer inspection required to fully appreciate this subtlety.
In terms of visual depth and texture, "Mrs. Miniver" stands out remarkably on this Blu-ray edition. The crispness and solidity of blacks contribute significantly to the image's clarity, while a sophisticated array of grays adds layers of nuance to each scene. This delineation of gray scales not only enriches the viewing experience but also brings a nearly tactile dimension to the visuals. The handling of contrast is careful and understated, avoiding any overstated enhancements that could detract from the original look of the film. Furthermore, the absence of noticeable artifacts or digital anomalies speaks volumes about the transfer's quality, ensuring an unmarred viewing experience that pays proper homage to Ruttenberg's masterful cinematography and the enduring legacy of "Mrs. Miniver.
Audio: 54
The audio presentation of the "Mrs. Miniver" Blu-ray features the film's original mono soundtrack converted into a DTS-HD MA 1.0 format, which offers the best possible experience given the age and nature of the original recordings. The conversion process respects the integrity of the source material, delivering a sound that is as authentic as possible. Despite its mono foundation, the soundtrack provides an engaging audio experience, particularly during intense scenes such as aerial bombardments and moments involving downed aircraft, which are conveyed with a surprising depth and nuance that belies the single-channel limitation.
However, there are inherent limitations associated with the original recording's dynamic range. The soundtrack doesn't offer the breadth of audio experienced in modern recordings, which could potentially detract from the overall viewing experience for some audiences accustomed to a more immersive sound presentation. Additionally, the clarity of dialogue varies across the film, with certain English regional accents proving challenging enough to necessitate subtitle reference for clearer comprehension. This minor setback, however, does not significantly impair the auditory experience.
The score by Herbert Stothart, known for his work on "The Yearling," carries emotional weight even through a mono presentation. While contemporary techniques could potentially enrich its fidelity, the existing delivery retains a heartfelt resonance that complements the film's narrative and emotional arc. Despite technological limitations, the DTS-HD MA 1.0 track admirably preserves the film's auditory essence, ensuring that "Mrs. Miniver" remains as moving and effective in its sound design as it was upon its original release.
Extras: 31
The Blu-ray release of "Mrs. Miniver" not only preserves the essence and historical context of the original film but also enriches the viewer's experience with a carefully curated selection of special features. These extras collectively delve into various facets of the World War II era, blending educational content with entertainment. The inclusion of "Blitz Wolf," an animated piece by Tex Avery, provides a satirical yet poignant view on Hitler's tyranny, complemented by a disclaimer addressing its portrayal of ethnic and racial stereotypes. Other features like "Mr. Blabbermouth!" and "For the Common Defense" offer insights into wartime propaganda and international police cooperation, respectively, embodying the spirit and concerns of the era. Notably, the Blu-ray maintains most supplemental materials from the 2004 DVD edition, excluding only a photo gallery, and introduces these timeless pieces to a new generation with enhanced quality, despite some content like "Blitz Wolf" being sourced from standard definition.
Extras included in this disc:
- Mr. Blabbermouth!: A satirical dramatization refuting rumors about the U.S. navy post-Pearl Harbor.
- For the Common Defense: Illustrates the importance of international cooperation between police forces.
- Blitz Wolf: Tex Avery's take on The Three Little Pigs, portraying the Big Bad Wolf as Hitler.
- 1942 Academy Awards Newsreel: Features Garson's record-setting best actress acceptance speech.
- Trailer: Provides a glimpse into the film's original promotional efforts.
Movie: 81
William Wyler's "Mrs. Miniver," a cinematic tour de force, emerged in June 1942 as a stirring portrayal of British resilience amidst the Nazi blitz. Directed by Wyler, a German-Jewish immigrant who had garnered his first Oscar for this film, "Mrs. Miniver" aimed to rally American support for the Allied efforts during World War II. Its narrative, largely detached from its original source – a series of columns by Jan Struther for The Times of London – was meticulously crafted by four screenwriters, presenting an intimate look into the life of the Miniver family and their small village as they navigate the harrowing changes brought about by war. With Greer Garson’s compelling portrayal of Kay Miniver, the film succeeds in delivering a deeply personal yet universal message about the impact of war on ordinary lives, enhanced by Wyler's renowned perfectionism in production.
The film introduces us to the Minivers, who reside in the riverside village of Belham, as they grapple with pre-war normalcy and the looming threats on the horizon. Central to its plot is the evolving romance between Vin Miniver and Carol Beldon amidst a backdrop of increasing tensions and societal upheaval. As England declares war on Germany, we witness the transformation of everyday life – air raid precautions come into immediate effect, and characters like Clem Miniver play pivotal roles in events such as the Dunkirk evacuation. Moreover, Wyler masterfully blends domestic narratives with wartime realities, notably in sequences that encapsulate the claustrophobia and anxiety of air raids, creating a vivid tableau of resilience.
Parallel to the war's overarching narrative is the film’s subplot involving a floral competition, symbolizing perseverance and hope through the character of Mr. Ballard and his rose, named after Kay Miniver. This seemingly trivial event juxtaposes against the broader calamity of war, encapsulating the film's central theme – the indomitable spirit of the community. "Mrs. Miniver" not only served as propaganda that bolstered Allied morale but also provided audiences with a compelling story of courage, unity, and resistance against adversity. Through its impeccable direction, performances, and poignant storytelling, it stands as an iconic piece of cinema that continues to resonate with audiences today.
Total: 59
In the world of classic cinema, few performances shine as brightly as Greer Garson's portrayal of the titular character in "Mrs. Miniver." The Blu-ray presentation of this wartime drama not only highlights the technical excellence of its era but also brings into sharp relief the nuances of Garson's performance. While Walter Pidgeon's name may precede hers in the credit roll, it is unmistakably Garson's film. Her interpretation of Mrs. Miniver transcends the stoic resilience often characteristic of English wartime spirit, injecting a palpable range of emotions that are as compelling as they are subtle. Particularly in scenes where her strength is quietly showcased—like the tension-filled moment by the riverbank, waiting for her husband—Garson’s ability to convey complex emotions without words stands out, making the film not just a story of war, but a deeply personal journey.
The Blu-ray edition does justice to this pivotal performance and the film's historical significance, presenting it with unparalleled clarity and attention to detail. The restoration team has evidently worked tirelessly to ensure that every frame reflects the original quality, preserving the cinematic experience for modern audiences. Additionally, the extra features included provide a richer understanding of the film's context and its impact upon release. Through interviews and behind-the-scenes footage, we gain insights into the creation of a film that Winston Churchill famously credited with boosting British morale during a dark time in history.
To conclude, the Blu-ray presentation of "Mrs. Miniver" is an exemplary case of how technology can breathe new life into classic films. It not only showcases Greer Garson's unforgettable performance with unmatched clarity but also enriches our appreciation for the film through a comprehensive collection of special features and restorations. This edition is highly recommended for both longtime fans and newcomers alike, promising an immersive experience that captures the essence of what made "Mrs. Miniver" a cornerstone of wartime cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 100
The source material is in excellent shape, and images are sharp and detailed without any evidence of artificial sharpening, grain reduction or other electronic manipulation....
Audio: 60
Although the dynamic range is somewhat limited, the various sequences of aerial bombardment register with surprising power, as does a sequence involving several downed aircraft....
Extras: 50
For the Common Defense (480i; 1.33:1; 21:36): This entry in MGM's "Crime Does Not Pay", series is intended to illustrate the value of international cooperation between police forces, in this case those...
Movie: 90
Refuge in the basement is no longer sufficient, and a shelter has to be built outside Starlings, where Wyler stages an impressively tense and claustrophobic sequence using only the sound of planes, ordnance...
Total: 90
Her Mrs. Miniver remains unflappable, even when she's staring down the barrel of a German pistol, but she also brims with emotion that the camera can see passing across Garson's face, even if no one else...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There's something about the black-and-white photography of the 1940s that's so seductive and entrancing, it makes color seem unnecessary....
Audio: 80
Whistles are the star of this sonic show, whether they be the spritely toots of a train engine, the delicate warbles of an approaching figure, or, most notably, the ear-splitting whines of cascading bombs....
Extras: 20
This topical, edgy, and often hilarious Tex Avery cartoon uses the Three Little Pigs tale as a springboard for a satire on Hitler's aggression and the iron nerve of the Allies....
Movie: 80
William Wyler's understated, sensitive, and utterly involving portrait of a British family and their day-to-day struggles during the German Blitz brings the homefront to the forefront, and with keen perception...
Total: 60
William Wyler's firm yet sensitive direction coupled with a gallery of first-rate performances and impeccable production values combine to produce a film that's as involving and affecting today as it surely...
Director: William Wyler
Actors: Greer Garson, Walter Pidgeon, Teresa Wright
PlotIn the idyllic pre-World War II English village of Belham, life flows at a leisurely pace for the Miniver family. Kay Miniver, a kind and graceful housewife, and her husband Clem, a successful architect, navigate the day-to-day pleasures and minor disruptions of their upper-middle-class existence with their three children. The Miniver household embodies the tranquil stability of British country life, untouched by the looming threat of conflict. Their interactions with the community, from the local stationmaster Mr. Ballard to the aristocratic Lady Beldon, paint a portrait of a society interwoven with tradition and class distinctions, yet united by common values and aspirations.
As the shadow of war creeps closer to their doorstep, the Miniver family and their fellow villagers are forced to confront the changing landscape of their lives. The onset of World War II transforms their reality, as they move from a state of blissful ignorance to one of direct engagement with the global conflict. The community's resilience is tested, and the family's peaceful existence is upended by the imminent challenges of war. Personal sacrifices, the rallying of community spirit, and the strength found in unity become central themes, as the villagers adapt to a new normal where the home front becomes a significant battleground in the defense of their country and values against adversity.
Writers: Arthur Wimperis, George Froeschel, James Hilton
Release Date: 29 Jul 1942
Runtime: 134 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, German