Strangers on a Train Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A nearly perfect Hitchcock thriller, 'Strangers on a Train' shines on Blu-ray with superior image quality, decent audio, and extensive supplements.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 71
Strangers on a Train showcases a nearly perfect 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer, enhancing Robert Burks' cinematography with well-defined shadows, luscious black levels, solid contrast, and natural grain. Minor blemishes and occasional graininess are present but do not detract from this filmic, crisp, and deep presentation.
Audio: 46
Strangers on a Train's DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track, while exhibiting a bit of thinness and occasional surface noise, delivers clear dialogue and decent fidelity. Dimitri Tiomkin's orchestral score benefits from good tonal depth, and the front-based mix maintains a strong dynamic range, enhancing the film's suspenseful atmosphere.
Extra: 77
The Blu-ray extras of 'Strangers on a Train' provide an impressive array of meticulously curated and highly engaging content, featuring an extensive commentary track with numerous luminaries, a preview version of the film with subtle variations, and insightful featurettes including personal accounts from Hitchcock's collaborators and family members.
Movie: 92
Strangers on a Train's Blu-ray release showcases Hitchcock's mastery in a supremely crafted thriller, characterized by its ingenious plot, beautifully shot imagery, and compelling performances, especially Robert Walker's chilling Bruno. The Blu-ray offers excellent 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 video with DTS-HD Master Audio 1.0, enhancing the nuanced psychological intensity and classic set pieces that mark the film's enduring impact.
Video: 71
Warner Brothers presents "Strangers on a Train" in a stunning AVC encoded 1080p transfer with a 1.36:1 aspect ratio, displaying a beautifully crisp and filmic quality. The gray scale is variegated with brilliance, showcasing both luminous whites and profound blacks, reinforcing the film's noir aesthetics. The contrast is remarkably solid, adeptly balancing both garish lighting and profound shadows without compromising the integrity of the image. Grain is naturally integrated, maintaining the celluloid feel, although a few inconsistently rough scenes momentarily break this harmony without substantially detracting from the overall presentation.
The clarity throughout is exceptional, with deep shadow detail that avoids any crushing even in the dimmest scenes. The myriad shades of gray provide texture and dimensionality, enriching background elements and foreground details alike. Noteworthy is the precision in close-ups, highlighting intricate facial features and minute on-screen details such as tennis doubles. Despite some minor physical imperfections like hairline scratches, these blemishes are sparse and have a minimal impact on the viewing experience.
Processed shots, more noticeable in high-definition, benefit from the high-quality black-and-white photography, which integrates them seamlessly into the narrative. The transfer is devoid of digital anomalies such as noise reduction or edge enhancement, maintaining the authenticity of the original film print. This meticulous attention to detail results in a near-perfect visual experience for this Hitchcock classic, only narrowly missing a flawless rating due to minor inconsistencies.
Audio: 46
The DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track for "Strangers on a Train" provides a serviceable audio experience, albeit with certain limitations due to the recording's age. Notably, the dialogue, while generally clear, often suffers from a noticeable boxiness and hollowness, especially in the midrange. Dimitri Tiomkin's score, a hallmark of Golden Age cinema, occasionally comes across as thin and anachronistic, yet retains decent fidelity and dynamic range. Despite these issues, the track balances dialogue and effects competently, ensuring conversations remain intelligible amidst the movie's dramatic orchestral backdrop.
Technical execution exhibits strengths and occasional flaws. The front-based mix achieves an adequate balance between dialogue clarity and atmospheric effects, enhancing the viewing experience. Occasionally, some surface noise, pops, and crackles remind listeners of the track’s vintage nature. Tiomkin’s score benefits from notable fidelity and tonal depth, successfully conveying the film’s emotional gravity. Dynamic scaling affords high-pitched strings and climactic moments sufficient range to impact the viewer effectively, even in the absence of a designated LFE channel.
In summary, while the audio quality presents some age-related artifacts and idiosyncrasies, it adequately captures the film's suspenseful atmosphere. The DTS-HD Master Audio track remains faithful to the original mono recording, integrating well with Hitchcock's cinematic style and ensuring that critical dialogue and musical cues are delivered with satisfying clarity and presence. Overall, this presentation accurately reflects its era, offering modern audiences a credible auditory experience anchored in historical authenticity.
Extras: 77
The Blu-ray edition of "Strangers on a Train" excels in its supplemental features, offering an extensive collection of insightful and meticulously crafted content that enhances the viewing experience. The commentary track stands out with contributions from an impressive lineup of film historians, actors, and even Hitchcock himself, delivering an engaging and informative exploration of the film's intricate details and production nuances. The inclusion of the British preview version, although in SD, is a crucial addition for enthusiasts interested in the director's editing evolution. Supporting featurettes delve deeper into the film's significance within Hitchcock's oeuvre, his unique directorial style, and provide personal anecdotes from those who worked closely with him, making this Blu-ray a treasure trove for classic cinema aficionados.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: Insights from actors, historians, and Hitchcock himself.
- Preview Version of 'Strangers on a Train': Alternate British version with different cuts.
- 'Strangers on a Train': A Hitchcock Classic: Detailed exploration of the film's production.
- 'Strangers on a Train': The Victim's P.O.V.: Kasey Rogers shares her experiences.
- An Appreciation by M. Night Shyamalan: Admiration from the renowned director.
- The Hitchcocks on Hitch: Intimate home movies and family insights.
- Alfred Hitchcock's Historical Meeting: Uncommon silent newsreel footage.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original film preview.
Movie: 92
Alfred Hitchcock's "Strangers on a Train" is an exemplary thriller that showcases the director at the pinnacle of his craft. Adapted from Patricia Highsmith's novel, the film's ingenious plot begins with a chance encounter between two men on a train, leading to a discussion about exchanging murders to rid themselves of their problematic acquaintances. This seemingly casual conversation spirals into a suspenseful narrative that explores duality, sociopathy, and latent homosexual and oedipal subtexts. Robert Walker delivers a standout performance as Bruno Anthony, a charismatic yet psychopathic character who believes he has a pact with tennis star Guy Haines, played by Farley Granger. While Guy dismisses the murder-swapping as mere fantasy, he soon finds himself ensnared in Bruno's nefarious plan.
Hitchcock's direction showcases his unparalleled visual storytelling prowess, employing innovative camera angles and brilliant set pieces that maintain a palpable tension throughout the film. The opening sequence cleverly introduces the protagonists through their shoes, establishing their distinct personalities even before their first interaction. Notable scenes include the carnival encounter between Bruno and Miriam and Bruno’s desperate attempt to retrieve a crucial item from beneath a sewer grate, each moment reflecting Hitchcock's masterful use of light and shadow.
While some critics have noted that Granger’s portrayal of Guy lacks the compelling nature of Walker’s Bruno, it is this imbalance that intensifies the film’s intrigue. Technical aspects of the film, such as its stunning cinematography by Robert Burks and the meticulously constructed climax involving an out-of-control carousel, elevate "Strangers on a Train" to an intellectual and visual feast. This blend of psychological intensity and classic Hitchcock themes, such as the innocent man on the run and elaborate chase sequences, ensures that "Strangers on a Train" remains a deeply involving classic that continues to captivate audiences decades after its release.
Total: 66
'Strangers on a Train' stands as one of Alfred Hitchcock’s most intricate and thrilling masterpieces. This Blu-ray release hones in on the elements that make it exceptional: a captivating plot, top-tier performances, and Hitchcock’s unparalleled directorial skill. Despite sometimes being overshadowed by more iconic titles such as 'Psycho' or 'Vertigo', 'Strangers on a Train' delivers some of the most sophisticated psychological suspense in the director's catalog. The high-quality transfer ensures brilliant image clarity and immersive audio, which significantly enhance the viewing experience.
Hitchcock's first film for Warner Bros. marks a high point in his career, restoring his prominence in Hollywood following the lukewarm reception of 'Under Capricorn' and 'Stage Fright'. The meticulously restored Blu-ray print breathes new life into this 1951 classic, ensuring it remains relevant and engaging for contemporary audiences. The home release also features a comprehensive supplemental package, offering valuable insights into the film's production and lasting legacy.
'Strangers on a Train' remains a near-perfect entertainment, excelling as a terrifying study in sociopathy while rewarding deeper study with its nuanced layers. This rare thriller retains its visceral intensity across multiple viewings. Whether you are new to Hitchcock or a long-time fan, this Blu-ray edition delights with its superior image quality, decent audio, and a wealth of supplements from the DVD. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
There are a couple of very minor (as in very minor) issues with the elements, including some hairline scratches and other blemishes that show up from time to time (strangely on the left side of the frame...
Audio: 70
(Tiomkin, certainly one of the greatest Golden Age composers, and a particular favorite of mine, nonetheless never really "clicked" with Hitch, and his scores for Hitch's films are rather odd, anachronistic...
Extras: 80
This includes lots of great home movies; Alfred Hitchcock's Historical Meeting (SD; 1:08) is a weird little snippet without sound that shows Hitch interacting with actors made up as historical characters....
Movie: 90
The basic plot conceit of Strangers on a Train, namely that two people "trade murders" so that neither can be implicated, is such an iconic foundation that it has passed into the annals of all time classic...
Total: 90
Strangers on a Train remains a near perfect entertainment, one that works perfectly on its surface level as a terrifying study in sociopathy but then rewards deeper study with any number of slightly hidden...
The Digital Bits review by Joe MarcheseRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 55
The crisp 1080p, AVC-encoded 1:36:1 transfer is one of the best yet for a Hitchcock film on Blu-ray, with its natural grain and gorgeous blacks and whites bringing to life the film’s suspense....
Extras: 80
Movie: 95
For the theatrical release Hitchcock, Anthony Hopkins has filled the familiar silhouette as a Psycho-era portrait of an auteur....
Total: 80
It also restored Hitchcock to a place of prominence in the Hollywood firmament following the less well-received Under Capricorn and Stage Fright....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Background elements are easily discernible (the picture is so clear you can even see the face of Granger's tennis-playing double) and shadow detail is excellent, with no incidents of crush even in the...
Audio: 60
A strong dynamic scale allows screams and high-pitched strings free rein, and despite the lack of a designated LFE track, lows possess good weight and power, especially during the cacophonous climactic...
Extras: 80
Audio Commentary – A vast array of personalities, comprising actors, historians, biographers, Hitchcock family members, even the Master of Suspense himself (courtesy of recorded interviews with Peter Bogdanovich),...
Movie: 100
Common Hitchcock themes are also present - the innocent man on the run, the train as a vessel of intrigue, the element of coincidence, the everyman caught up in extraordinary circumstances, real or perceived...
Total: 80
Though bigger name Hitchcock films often overshadow it, this superior suspense yarn, marked by a fascinating plot, excellent performances, and, above all, impeccable direction, stands on its own as one...
Director: Alfred Hitchcock
Actors: Farley Granger, Robert Walker, Ruth Roman
PlotGuy Haines, a tennis player, meets Bruno Antony, a stranger, on a train. During their conversation, Bruno proposes a chilling idea wherein two complete strangers exchange murders to solve their respective problems without getting caught. He suggests that Guy kill his father and in return, Bruno will murder Guy's troublesome wife, Miriam. Guy dismisses the conversation as a sick joke, but Bruno takes it seriously and goes on to execute his half of the "deal," killing Miriam.
Guy is horrified when he learns of Miriam's death and realizes Bruno expects him to reciprocate. Bruno relentlessly pressures Guy to fulfill his end of the bargain, threatening to implicate him in Miriam’s murder if he refuses. Tension escalates as Guy grapples with the horrifying situation Bruno has thrust upon him, while simultaneously trying to clear his own name and find a way to stop Bruno. The film builds up to a dramatic confrontation, testing the limits of Guy’s morality and resourcefulness as he tries to extricate himself from Bruno's deadly scheme.
Writers: Raymond Chandler, Czenzi Ormonde, Whitfield Cook
Release Date: 30 Jun 1951
Runtime: 101 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English, French