Gamer Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'Gamer' is visually chaotic and lacks depth, but its 3D Blu-ray boasts strong video quality and reference-grade audio, making it a decent pick for genre fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
Gamer's Blu-ray presentation offers a stylistically gritty visual experience with excellent resolution, striking shadow delineation, and vivid primary colors in both its high-definition 2D and somewhat uneven 3D formats. The image is clean with dynamic highlights and contrasting aesthetics for its unique game worlds.
Audio: 75
Gamer's DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 soundtrack is an involving, immersive, and bombastic mix, offering exceptional directionality, seamless channel integration, and a dynamic range that spans from quiet atmospherics to floorboard-shaking LFE. Dialogue is crystal-clear, and the low-end provides serious impact with clean, deep resonation.
Extra: 50
"Inside the Game: Controlling Gamer" (HD, 80 min) is an in-depth, multi-part documentary from the previous release, featuring comprehensive cast and crew interviews and abundant behind-the-scenes footage, offering an exhaustive look at the film's production and the significant talent involved.
Movie: 40
Gamer offers viscerally exciting battle scenes and an intriguing premise of video game mind control, but suffers from haphazard execution, derivative plot elements, and excessive visual gimmickry. The Blu-ray release boasts commendable audio and video quality, though it may leave viewers longing for the originality and coherence of its antecedents.
Video: 66
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Gamer" showcases a distinct visual style that aligns with the film's narrative needs. Employing a predominantly sepia-toned aesthetic, the film intersperses vivid primary colors, crimson, and warm golden accents to create diverse visual layers. Bold use of contrast and rich blacks deliver scenes that display high gradational satisfaction, with punchy whites and dynamic dark highlights. The presentation excels in shadow delineation, revealing intricate details within darkened backgrounds and low-light wide-angle shots. The high-definition source material ensures zero artifacts or extraneous noise, rendering a whistle-clean image with heightened definition in brightly lit sequences.
The 3D presentation, provided through an even MVC (3D) and AVC (2D) encoded 1080p transfer, brings mixed results. The non-traditional 1.73:1 aspect ratio retains excellent sharpness and object detail despite an aggressively color-graded environment. Notably, sequences shot in well-lit conditions, such as Society scenes, exhibit commendable depth and clarity, foreground elements distinctly separating from backgrounds, punctuated by vivid color saturation and deep shadow detail. However, rapid-fire editing and quick camera movements compromise the 3D dimensionality in darker scenes, particularly battle sequences where insufficient lighting undermines depth perception. Despite some fuzziness due to these "jiggly cam" effects, the 2D transfer remains sharp with well-defined details amidst aggressively tweaked contrasts.
The Blu-ray offers a layered visual experience with specific strengths and weaknesses across its different settings. The video game-inspired cinematography benefits from impeccable fine object detail, layered effects, and independent motion of debris and objects enhancing the immersive experience. While the post-conversion to 3D can feel inconsistent, with certain scenes appearing flat or unspectacular, the real world contrasts more convincingly with accurate skin tones and lifelike textures in close-ups. The unique aesthetics and color palettes of the two in-game universes—Society’s vibrant yet metallic feel versus Slayers’ drab appearance—are effectively contrasted by intentionally varied contrast levels, contributing to the overall engaging visual narrative.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 soundtrack of "Gamer" is a standout feature, providing an engaging and immersive auditory experience. The sound staging is exemplary, seamlessly integrating both front and rear channels to create a theater-like atmosphere. Sound effects traverse the room dynamically, ensuring an energetic impact that resonates with clarity. The mix maintains an aggressive tone, leveraging the subwoofer for deep, clean low-frequency energy that enhances the impact of action sequences. Dialogue is presented with excellent clarity and presence, cutting through the chaos with discernable vocal character.
Dynamic range in the audio presentation of "Gamer" is notably wide, delivering a rich and detailed sonic landscape. The soundtrack handles prioritization smartly, even during quieter sequences where subtle sounds, such as those in Kable's jail cell, penetrate the room’s acoustics effectively. The directional quality of the dialogue adds to the immersive experience, complemented by robust LFE that shakes the floor during intense battle scenes. Action sequences are enriched by exceptional panning effects that create a remarkable 360° soundfield, putting viewers in the midst of chaotic yet controlled audio mayhem.
The front soundstage deserves special mention for its expansive imaging and flawless channel separation, offering a splendid sense of spatial presence. Cars and helicopters move convincingly across and above the listeners, contributing to the engaging soundfields. The mix balances instrumentation with grandiose action, ensuring clarity across mids and highs while bringing serious impact to crashes and explosions with commanding low-end frequencies. Throughout this high-octane audio mix, dialogue remains precise and crystal-clear, demonstrating the technical prowess of this DTS-HD Master Audio presentation.
Extras: 50
The Blu-ray edition of "Gamer" offers an elaborate and insightful deep dive into the film's production with its primary extra feature. The disc includes a comprehensive making-of documentary, Inside the Game: Controlling Gamer, which runs approximately 80 minutes. This extensive feature provides an in-depth look at the entire filmmaking process, featuring numerous interviews with the cast and crew, as well as abundant behind-the-scenes footage. It stands out as an exhaustive exploration of the talents and efforts that went into creating the movie, giving viewers a rich understanding of its production intricacies.
Extras included in this disc:
- Inside the Game: Controlling Gamer: A thorough 80-minute making-of documentary with cast and crew interviews and behind-the-scenes footage.
Movie: 40
"Gamer," starring Gerard Butler, plunges audiences into a dystopian future where the lines between video games and reality blur beyond recognition. The film introduces Kable (Butler), a condemned inmate turned global super-soldier, in a deadly multiplayer game controlled by human players. As Kable nears his tentative freedom, game creator Ken Castle (Michael C. Hall) unleashes obstacles to maintain his twisted empire. While "Gamer" rides on the coattails of predecessors like "The Running Man" and "Death Race," it presents a unique fusion of action and satire that examines society's fascination with violence and control.
Despite its compelling premise, "Gamer" suffers from several execution flaws. Directors Mark Neveldine and Brian Taylor, known for the frenetic "Crank" series, saturate the film with rapid cuts and dizzying camera work that can disorient viewers. This relentless visual style, combined with risible dialogue, often undercuts the impact of otherwise thrilling battle sequences. Furthermore, while the film’s exploration of mind control through nanotechnology offers intriguing commentary, it frequently succumbs to a cacophony of clichés and predictability, diminishing its potential to stand out as a groundbreaking sci-fi thriller.
The performances reveal a mixed bag: Butler’s portrayal of Kable is suitably intense but ultimately one-dimensional. Michael C. Hall’s Castle morphs from an industrialist tycoon into a near caricature of a Bond villain, complete with absurd musical numbers. Secondary characters like Kyra Sedgwick's investigative host and Ludacris' hacker rebel offer minimal depth to the storyline. The film alternates between heavy-handed social commentary, exemplified by satire in Society's hedonistic manipulation, and pure action spectacle, appealing to die-hard fans of first-person shooters but leaving others cold. "Gamer" presents sporadic moments of brilliance amidst a sea of chaotic and often derivative storytelling.
Total: 63
"Gamer," directed by Neveldine/Taylor, delves into themes of autonomy and individuality within a chaotic future world dominated by social networking and multiplayer video games. Though it aims for deeper commentary, it often misses the mark, sacrificing subtlety and elegance for sheer mayhem. The narrative is barely held together by frenetic pacing, quick cuts, and bombastic dialogue, resulting in a visually stimulating yet ultimately hollow experience. The post-conversion 3D adds mild depth but is far from impressive, not strong enough to justify an additional purchase for those already owning the standard edition.
The 3D Blu-ray presentation of "Gamer" shines in areas of video and audio fidelity, offering a robust viewing experience. The 3D visuals showcase strong depth and dimension, albeit with occasional inconsistencies stemming from its post-conversion process. Nevertheless, the reference-quality lossless audio delivers an immersive experience with powerful bass and clear dialogue, ensuring that the action sequences impact viewers as intended. Complementary features are sparse, with a lone featurette about the production failing to add significant value to the package.
In conclusion, "Gamer" on 3D Blu-ray is a mixed bag; while it hits the mark in audiovisual presentation, it falters in narrative cohesion and depth. The film's chaotic style may appeal to fans of high-octane action, but its lack of substantial plot or character development limits broader appeal. For existing fans, the Blu-ray's technical merits may enhance their collection, but newcomers might find it lacking in storytelling nuance.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
This digitally shot feature offers the clean, relatively textureless, appearance that is a hallmark of the Red One camera, but offsetting that aspect are some vividly saturated colors and commendable amounts...
Audio: 70
LFE is really impressive throughout this feature, most obviously in the really floorboard shaking battle scenes where nonstop barrages of gunfire and explosions almost punch at the listener with air pressure...
Extras: 100
Inside the Game�Controlling Gamer (1080p; 1:19:41) is a good in-depth making of feature that has lots of interviews with the cast and crew, behind the scenes footage and snippets from the finished film....
Movie: 40
Gamer takes "a little this-a, a little that-a" approach in terms of borrowing any number of elements from previous properties, including films as disparate as The Running Man to Battle Royale to Death...
Total: 40
The film has the kernel of a good idea, albeit one that's been done to death already, but with nonstop quick cutting, ridiculous dialogue and absolutely no character development whatsoever, there's not...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Depth is often astounding with terrific clarity of small objects in the far distance, creating a wonderfully layered effect where debris, bullets, and even a car move independently from their surroundings...
Audio: 100
Dynamic range exhibits a detailed richness and distinctness between the mids and highs, providing the lossless mix with superb clarity in the instrumentation and the grandiose action with equal measure...
Extras: 20
Inside the Game: Controlling Gamer (HD, 80 min) — The same multi-part documentary from the previous release, showing the entire production of the movie from beginning to end....
Movie: 40
The control of Kable through 'Slayers' is neat, with entire rooms dedicated to putting one in another man's shoes, controlling his every aspect (and damn would I kill for that setup!), though later in...
Total: 60
Sporting a fairly obvious message about autonomy and individuality, 'Gamer' fails at subtlety and elegance as it envisions a disturbing future for social networking and multi-player videogames....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 94
This is stylized video presentation that makes use of darker color schemes and grittier textures that provide the look that the filmmakers strive for to drive the story’s components....
Audio: 100
The quality of the bass is first rate as it is fills the room with clean, hard hitting, and deep resonating low frequency energy....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 50
But when Kable suddenly decides he wants out, his rebellion threatens the twisted plans of game creator Ken Castle (Michael C. Hall, TV's Dexter) who will stop at nothing to crush the renegade commando...
Total: 71
16x9 Screen Marantz AV8801 11.2 Channel Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-103 Universal Disc/3D...
Director: Mark Neveldine, Brian Taylor
Actors: Gerard Butler, Michael C. Hall, Ludacris
PlotIn a dystopian future, mind-control technology has taken society by storm. The technology, engineered by the reclusive billionaire Ken Castle, allows players to control human avatars in a massive multiplayer online game called "Society", a disturbing reflection of the real world where anything goes. But Castle's true masterpiece is "Slayers", a more sinister game that recruits death row inmates as the avatars, with the promise of freedom to any convict who survives thirty sessions. Each inmate is controlled by a player from the outside world, turning real-life combat into entertainment for the masses.
Among these inmates is Kable, controlled by the young gamer Simon. Regarded as a true warrior within the game and a celebrity among the gaming community, Kable is only a few victories away from earning his freedom. Outside of the game, movements begin to rise against Castle's twisted creations. A group called the "Humanz" opposes the dehumanizing aspect of Castle's technology and seeks to expose his underlying agenda. As Kable attempts to navigate through the deadly games, keeping his reflexes sharp and his wits sharper, he must also unravel the complexities of his own past and the system that holds him captive. All the while, Castle continues to manipulate events to his advantage, maintaining control over his empire of games and players.
Writers: Mark Neveldine, Brian Taylor
Release Date: 04 Sep 2009
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English