Black Angel Blu-ray Review
Arrow Academy
Score: 71
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Black Angel’s Blu-ray features an engaging, lesser-known noir with solid audio-visual quality, substantial supplements, and a rewarding 2K restoration.
Disc Release Date
Video: 71
Black Angel's Blu-ray restoration by Arrow Academy showcases an AVC encoded 1080p transfer with a 1.37:1 aspect ratio, delivering impressive fine details and vibrant contrast, despite minor brightness and grain variations due to dual original sources. Enhanced clarity and a film-like feel make it an essential upgrade over previous releases.
Audio: 76
The LPCM Mono track on the Black Angel Blu-ray offers clear, well-modulated sound without distortion, featuring a dynamic range for Frank Skinner's score and clean dialogue, devoid of age-related issues, making this a significant upgrade over previous releases.
Extra: 62
The Blu-ray extras for 'Black Angel' provide a rich, informative experience with a conversational yet detailed audio commentary by Alan K. Rode, insightful featurettes by Neil Sinyard, and extensive photo galleries, all complemented by Arrow's meticulously crafted insert booklet featuring an essay by Philip Kemp.
Movie: 68
Directed by Roy William Neill, 'Black Angel' is a twisty film noir bolstered by Dan Duryea’s versatile performance as Martin Blair. The film upends typical noir tropes with unconventional characters and features strong support from Peter Lorre and June Vincent. Shot in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 with LPCM mono audio, it engages with inventive visuals and an engrossing plot that deviates intriguingly from Cornell Woolrich's novel.
Video: 71
Arrow Academy has presented "Black Angel" on Blu-ray with a meticulous 1080p AVC encoded transfer in the original but somewhat unusual aspect ratio of 1.37:1. The restoration was done using original nitrate combined 35mm fine grain positive and dupe negative scans in 2K resolution at NBC Universal. The grading and restoration were undertaken at Pinewood Studios employing DaVinci Resolve and PFClean software respectively. The transfer's attention to detail is significant, showcasing fine elements like the checks on suit jackets and the textured fabrics worn by characters. The intermittent variations in grain and brightness, attributed to the dual source elements, do not detract from the generally well-modulated grayscale and appealing contrast.
The transfer ensures "Black Angel" exudes a film-like vibrancy with crisp, well-resolved grain. Despite occasional softness, particularly in scenes derived from the dupe negative, the overall clarity and contrast are commendable. Deep blacks, bright whites, and well-graded grays enhance the viewing experience. The film exhibits some minor age-related wear and tear, such as faint vertical lines and nicks. Special effects shots stand out impressively given the film's age. Though there was an issue with slight vertical compression on some discs, Arrow Films has addressed this through a replacement program. In sum, this is likely the best visual representation of "Black Angel" to date, offering a significant upgrade over previous releases.
Audio: 76
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray for "Black Angel" features a commendable LPCM Mono track. The remastered audio maintains a clear and well-modulated soundscape, offering a wide dynamic range that adeptly handles all highs and lows without distortion. Frank Skinner's score is beautifully rendered, sounding rich and full, preserving the romantic and dramatic elements pivotal to the narrative. The musical elements, including compositions and singing, are presented with a depth that would be expected from a mid-1940s soundtrack. Dialogue throughout the film is robust and precise, devoid of any significant signs of wear and tear, ensuring clarity for viewers.
This release marks a substantial improvement over previous Universal DVD versions, with meticulous efforts to erase any age-related hiss, pops, and crackle, resulting in a pristine listening experience. The careful restoration ensures that every sound from the original mono track is captured with fidelity, making this likely the best auditory representation of "Black Angel" on home video. While the track may not be particularly active, its quality presentation seamlessly complements the visual elements, creating an immersive and coherent viewing experience.
Extras: 62
The extras on the Blu-ray release of "Black Angel" provide a rich and engaging exploration of the film's history and production. The Audio Commentary by Alan K. Rode is an informative track filled with anecdotes, production details, and humorous moments, although there is a minor slip where he mistakenly identifies Constance Dowling by her sister Doris' name. The featurette A Fitting End features Neil Sinyard delivering a thoughtful appreciation of the movie and its director Roy William Neill. The Original Trailer and comprehensive Image Gallery including Production Stills and Posters and Lobby Cards bring additional depth to this classic film noir's presentation. Accompanying these extras is an insert booklet from Arrow Films that includes an essay by Philip Kemp and excerpts from original reviews, further enriching the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Alan K. Rode: Informative commentary peppered with production tidbits and humorous quips.
- A Fitting End: A 20-minute featurette by Neil Sinyard offering an appreciation of the film.
- Original Trailer: The film's re-release preview highlighting its tension.
- Image Gallery: Includes two galleries of production stills and poster/lobby cards.
- Production Stills: 15-minute slideshow of black-and-white images telling the film’s story.
- Posters and Lobby Cards: 2-minute display of 16 color reproductions.
- Booklet: Featuring an essay by Philip Kemp and original review excerpts.
Movie: 68
"Black Angel," the final directorial work of Roy William Neill, stands out as a captivating and distinctive entry in the film noir canon. The 1946 film intricately melds noir motifs with a murder mystery plot, deftly navigating narrative twists and visual flourishes. As Martin Blair, a once-promising songwriter now mired in alcoholism, Dan Duryea delivers a standout performance that challenges his usual roles as an on-screen villain. His relationship with Catherine Bennett (June Vincent), who is devoted to proving her husband's innocence, introduces intriguing dynamics and moral ambiguity. The plot takes a different route from typical noir expectations, with roles such as a supposed femme fatale dying early and the protagonists engaging in unconventional detective work.
The film's suspense is heightened by the involvement of Peter Lorre as a shady club owner suspected of the crime, adding an additional layer of intrigue and menace. Broderick Crawford's portrayal of a police detective following up on the case complements the main investigative efforts spearheaded by Martin and Catherine. Roy Chanslor’s screenplay, adapted from Cornell Woolrich’s novel, deviates significantly from its source, particularly in its resolution. This creative freedom enabled some refreshing diversification from standard noir elements while retaining essential genre tenets, such as shadowy, moody aesthetics and morally complex characters.
"Black Angel" is visually and narratively engaging, featuring highlights like inventive camera work and a memorable psychedelic sequence. Despite working within budget constraints, the film proficiently maintains tension and rhythm. The performances, particularly Duryea's nuanced take on Martin, lend gravitas to the story. While it didn't gain widespread acclaim during its time, "Black Angel" remains an underrated gem that brings together elements of both film noir and classical murder mystery to create an exciting cinematic experience that deserves greater recognition.
Total: 71
"Black Angel," though not one of the most iconic entries of the film noir genre, brings a unique and distinctive flavor to the table. The film excels in skewing several well-worn noir tropes to its own ends, making it a worthwhile watch for aficionados of the genre. Dan Duryea's performance is quite commendable, navigating a complex role with skill, while the story includes a couple of intriguing twists that will keep even seasoned armchair detectives engaged. This Blu-ray edition from Arrow Academy presents the 1946 classic in an upgraded 2K restoration, accompanied by lossless audio, ensuring an enveloping viewing experience.
The visual presentation on this Blu-ray release is largely commendable, albeit slightly variant in quality. The audio remains consistently fine throughout, adding to the enjoyment of the film. Perhaps one of the most significant highlights of this release is its extensive supplemental content. It features an informative commentary track, an insightful featurette, and a handsomely constructed substantive booklet. Additionally, the image gallery is divided into production stills and promotional materials, offering a visual treat that complements the film’s narrative. These supplements provide an appreciable depth to the viewing experience and enrich our understanding of "Black Angel."
In conclusion, "Black Angel" may not reach the same level of renown as some of its film noir counterparts, but it possesses its unique appeal, brought to life by a solid cast and an engaging plot. Arrow Academy has succeeded in delivering this film in a superior format that honors its original essence while enhancing the overall experience for modern audiences. With its thoughtful restoration, quality supplements, and sleek presentation, this Blu-ray edition is certainly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
With an understanding that the somewhat heterogeneous on display here is probably unavoidable due to the two source elements listed above, this presentation offers some very appealing levels of fine detail...
Audio: 70
The film has an above average amount of music courtesy of the subplot involving Martin's playing and composing (and Mavis', and later Catherine's, singing), and the musical elements sound decently full...
Extras: 50
A Fitting End (1080p; 20:53) is an engaging appreciation of the film and Neill by Neil Sinyard....
Movie: 70
Black Angel manages to turn a number of noir tropes pretty much squarely on their heads, beginning with the fact that the focal hero of the piece is not some initially stalwart male led down a path of...
Total: 70
As some of the supplements on this release get into, Black Angel will probably never be thought of as being in the same league as the most iconic of film noir entries, but it still has its own really distinctive...
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 80
Director Roy William Neill’s “stylistic flourishes” are evidenced in the opening shot, in which the camera looks up as it goes up a tall building, stops at a window, and enters the apartment of Mavis Marlowe....
Extras: 95
Movie: 80
Catherine’s husband Kirk (John Phillips) was having an affair with Mavis and was seen entering her apartment just before her death....
Total: 84
The production stills section contains studio-posed photos and pictures taken during the actual filming....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Contrast and clarity are quite good, with deep blacks, bright whites, and beautifully graded grays combining to create a pleasing, balanced image....
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale handles all the highs and lows of Frank Skinner's romantic music score without a hint of distortion, although fidelity seems a bit muted....
Extras: 40
The first includes 94 black-and-white images, spanning studio portraits and an extensive array of production stills that basically tell the story of the entire movie....
Movie: 60
Peppered with some inventive camera shots, one pivotal psychedelic sequence, and a mix of glitzy and grimy locales, the film excites the senses as it tells a well-constructed, engrossing story that keeps...
Total: 80
Black Angel may be a little-known film noir, but hopefully this excellent Blu-ray release from Arrow Academy will expose this slick, engrossing mystery to a wider audience....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 80
There’s minimal instances of problems like dirt, scratches or print damage (such as tears and distortion) present, which means that this is likely the best the movie will look on home video and an upgrade...
Audio: 100
There’s next to no issues like distortion, hissing or crackling present here, which makes this an improvement over the Universal DVD and likely the best the movie will ever sound on home video....
Extras: 70
Production Stills (94) (15:40) & Posters/Lobby Cards (16) (2:40) Booklet featuring an essay by author Philip Kemp and excerpts from original reviews (1st printing only)...
Movie: 70
Working from the novel by Cornell Woolrich (who reportedly hated the way movie altered his source material), a lot of the elements of film noir are in place here – the wronged man, the femme fatale, etc....
Total: 80
Arrow has done a solid job of giving the movie its Blu-ray debut, with solid marks for both audio and visual quality as well as an informative commentary track and an insightful featurette for bonus features....
Director: Roy William Neill
Actors: Dan Duryea, June Vincent, Peter Lorre
PlotCatherine Bennett's husband is accused of murdering singer Mavis Marlowe, and in desperation, she teams up with Martin Blair, Mavis's former husband, to prove his innocence. Catherine and Martin navigate the seedy underbelly of the city, encountering various shady characters, including nightclub owner Marko. Their investigation leads them through a series of suspenseful and dangerous situations as they uncover secrets that reveal Mavis's hidden life, painting a picture far different from her glamorous public persona.
As they dig deeper, Catherine and Martin find themselves entangled in a web of deceit and misdirection that challenges their determination and trust in one another. Each clue brings them closer to the truth, yet also places them in increasing jeopardy. Marko's enigmatic behavior and connections to the case become more questionable as they close in on identifying the real killer. Catherine and Martin's efforts to clear her husband’s name build up to a climactic confrontation that will test their resolve and bravery as they set out to expose the real murderer, forever altering their lives.
Writers: Roy Chanslor, Cornell Woolrich
Release Date: 02 Aug 1946
Runtime: 81 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English