Selma Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Selma" delivers an AVC MPEG-4 encode framed in its original 2.40:1 aspect ratio, remaining true to the film’s intentional stylization and dramatic compositions. Shot digitally, the transfer aims for a naturalistic aesthetic, heavily influenced by the darkness and desaturated color palette similar to the original "Godfather." Director of Photography Bradford Young emphasizes natural lighting and period-appropriate tones, whether it means underexposed portions or an overall muted look. Facial details and textures in building façades and interiors are adequate, with medium- and long-distance shots occasionally showing some smudginess around the edges.

However, the image suffers in areas critical to high-definition presentations. The color palette is notably pale, with drained colors and black levels that lack depth. Darker backdrops render more gray or brown than true black, contributing to a generally fatigued appearance. Despite moderate baseline definition in dimly lit settings and daylight splashes of brightness, the image is marred by a lack of contrast and dynamic range, leading to a prevalent flatness. There are moments of moderate to severe banding and occasional anamorphic lens focus issues, though no perceptible aliasing or blockiness. Overall, while "Selma" effectively uses its visual tools to convey the period setting and emotional tone, it falls short in delivering a robust and vibrant high-definition experience.

The audio presentation of "Selma" on Blu-ray is commendable, featuring a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack that effectively delivers the film's auditory experience. The sound design focuses primarily on dialogue, delivering both intimate discussions and powerful public speeches with crystal-clear, front-center placement. This meticulous attention to spoken word ensures every syllable is articulated with natural clarity and prominence, which is critical for a dialogue-driven narrative. The soundtrack also incorporates music and ambient sounds judiciously, offering an enveloping yet subtle surround support that enhances the storytelling without overwhelming it.

While the film does not necessitate extravagant sound effects, select moments showcase the track's potential for heavier sonic impact. An explosion early in the film sends substantial waves through the soundstage, though gunshots and other violent moments may lack an exceptionally authentic punch. Nevertheless, these elements are well-balanced within the overall mix, contributing to a realistic auditory environment without distracting from the main narrative. The use of mild surround content, such as applause and atmospheric background noise, is well-integrated and adds to the immersive quality of the soundtrack.

Despite its lack of aggressive panning or intense low-frequency effects (LFE), with the exception of the noted explosion, the audio track of "Selma" excels in fulfilling its primary task. It enhances the viewer's experience through its precise dialogue reproduction and modest yet effective use of music and sound effects, making it a solid and well-rounded offering in terms of audio presentation.

The Blu-ray extras of "Selma" provide a comprehensive, in-depth look into the production and historical significance of the film. Encompassing two insightful audio commentaries, one with Director Ava DuVernay and Actor David Oyelowo, and another featuring Director of Photography Bradford Young and Editor Spencer Averick, the extras delve into both narrative and technical aspects. Featurettes like "The Road to Selma" and "Recreating Selma" offer behind-the-scenes insights into script development, historical context, actor preparation, cinematography, and set design. The deleted and extended scenes provide additional narrative depth, while the music video for "Glory" and the historical collection of newsreels and stills enhance understanding of the era. Special pieces dedicated to the Selma Student Ticket Initiative and the National Voting Rights Museum add layers of appreciation for the film’s impact on audiences and historical preservation.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Insights from Director Ava DuVernay and Actor David Oyelowo.
• Audio Commentary: Technical analysis by DuVernay, Bradford Young, and Spencer Averick.
• The Road to Selma: Behind-the-scenes during pre-production.
• Recreating Selma: Detailed look at characters, shooting locations, and production design.
• Deleted and Extended Scenes: Multiple additional scenes not included in the final cut.
• Music Video: Performance of "Glory."
• Historical: Vintage newsreels and images.
• Selma Student Tickets: Donor Appreciation: Acknowledgment of the student ticket initiative supporters.
• National Voting Rights Museum and Institute: Overview of the museum’s dedication to civil rights history.
• Selma Discussion Guide: Talking points about the film and historical context.

"Selma," directed by Ava DuVernay, offers a profound depiction of the pivotal civil rights events in 1965, with David Oyelowo's masterful portrayal of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. as its standout feature. Oyelowo's character embodies King's historical stature, capturing his oratory brilliance, vulnerability, and tenacity. His performance transcends mere imitation, inviting viewers to grasp King's essence and heartrending struggles. However, the critique that “Selma” sometimes lacks a profound connection with the audience is valid. The film provides an engaging yet occasionally disjointed narrative, failing to fully immerse the viewer into its historical context despite the emotionally charged storyline and vivid character portrayals.

On a technical level, while the film excels in its depiction of key events like the iconic marches across Edmund Pettus Bridge, the overall execution could have used more finesse to elevate the barren historical recitation. The film navigates a myriad of perspectives—King’s personal tribulations, his complicated relationship with LBJ, and the broader experiences of other movement members—effectively humanizing these historical figures. Yet this extensive focus sometimes results in insufficient character development and a difficulty in maintaining narrative cohesion.

The controversy surrounding the portrayal of President Johnson does not overshadow the film’s profound impact but adds to its rich tapestry of perspectives. Despite some critics arguing about historical veracity, the film presents a multifaceted examination of its characters' motives and actions. Indeed, LBJ’s complex arc underscores the broader political machinations of the time. "Selma" succeeds in portraying the raw power and emotional gravitas of the civil rights movement, even if it occasionally falls short of delivering a consistently polished narrative experience.

"Selma" delineates one of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr's pivotal battles, delivering a contemplative recreation with lasting themes and ideas. Despite some visual mundaneness, the movie's essence and Oyelowo's stellar performance elevate it beyond typical historical narratives. Oyelowo's depiction of King is a masterclass in embodying both the physicality and inner complexities of such an iconic figure, creating a compelling portrayal that resonates deeply. The film transcends controversy, offering a nuanced account that should captivate audiences seeking more than a surface-level history.

The Blu-ray release provides a solid, if not spectacular, video presentation, hindered slightly by the film's inherent drab cinematography. The sound quality is robust, complementing the film’s critical scenes effectively. The supplemental materials are extensive, furnishing additional context that enriches the viewer's understanding and appreciation even if the high-definition quality isn't always pristine.

In conclusion, "Selma" is an emotionally charged and thought-provoking film that oscillates between being very good and near-brilliant. It offers a multifaceted exploration of history, culture, and heritage that is both inspirational and educational. The Blu-ray release, while not a visual standout, remains a valuable addition for fans due to its comprehensive special features. Highly recommended for viewing, and suggested for rental prior to purchase for those unsure about its replay value.