The Umbrellas of Cherbourg 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review

Criterion’s 4K UHD Blu-ray of The Umbrellas of Cherbourg furnishes the film in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, sourced from a 2024 4K digital restoration conducted by Ciné-Tamaris, supported by CNC, Chanel, and SACEM, from the original 35mm camera negative. The 4K UHD Blu-ray disc houses this new restoration in native HDR, while the accompanying Blu-ray contains the earlier 2K restoration and presents the film in SDR. The UHD presentation demonstrates excellent fidelity to film grain, color palette, and fine detail, delivering significantly more natural skin tones compared to prior HD versions. The persistent yellowish tint identified in the earlier HD transfer is eliminated in this new restoration. Minimal scratches, tears, and other artifacts are present, indicating thorough care in the remastering process.

Between the two restorations in the combo pack, subtle differences emerge. The 4K restoration (viewable exclusively on the UHD disc) does not feature Dolby Vision or advanced HDR grading beyond native HDR, but still displays striking visual clarity. Notably, several reviewers observe that, despite advances in resolution, the 2K Blu-ray restoration can appear more vibrant and occasionally even sharper in direct A/B comparisons—this especially holds true on large screens. Slight fluctuations in gamma levels and differences in color grading may account for these observations, suggesting possible inconsistencies during 4K mastering. On balance, the UHD presentation represents an impressive and meticulous visual upgrade over previous editions, yet some aficionados may find elements of the earlier 2K master comparatively appealing in select areas. Nonetheless, both transfers capture the film’s lush palette and textures admirably, with the UHD leaning toward greater authenticity in color and overall image integrity.

The Umbrellas of Cherbourg 4K UHD Blu-ray release presents two primary audio options: a French DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 (or 5.0, reflecting the original three-track mix used for the 1963 soundtrack album) and the original French LPCM 1.0 monaural track. Both tracks have been beautifully restored, showcasing the film’s iconic sung dialogue and Michel Legrand’s renowned score with clarity and fidelity. The 5.1 surround track provides an expansive soundstage and dynamic range, enhancing immersion and highlighting musical richness, although it originates from the album mix rather than the theatrical film’s original mix.

The inclusion of the original LPCM 1.0 mono track on the UHD disc is a significant upgrade over previous releases, providing purists with a more authentic audio experience. While the mono presentation faithfully reproduces the film’s audio with minimal distortion—exhibiting very limited crackling, popping, or hissing—its sonic field is naturally narrower, and certain scenes feel less open compared to the surround option. Nonetheless, both tracks serve the film exceptionally well, allowing users to alternate and appreciate the distinctive qualities of each restoration.

Optional English subtitles are available, supporting accessibility for non-French speakers. The dual audio configuration represents a substantial improvement from earlier editions, delivering both a richly immersive modern sound as well as a port of the period-authentic monaural mix. This release firmly establishes itself as the definitive home video presentation of The Umbrellas of Cherbourg’s audio to date.

The extras on the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "The Umbrellas of Cherbourg" offer a comprehensive and thoughtfully curated collection that delves deeply into both the making and enduring legacy of the film. The primary feature, a 2008 documentary, provides valuable insight through extensive interviews with Demy, Deneuve, Legrand, and others, contextualizing the film’s cultural resonance. Scholarly analysis from Rodney Hill situates the film within both the French New Wave and mainstream French cinema traditions, while vintage interviews and audio recordings with key creative figures add depth and historical perspective. The set is further enhanced by a technical restoration demonstration, offering a glimpse into the meticulous care given to preserving this classic, and supplemented by an evocative essay by Jim Ridley.

Extras included in this disc:

• Once Upon a Time… “The Umbrellas of Cherbourg”: In-depth documentary on the film’s creation and impact.
• 2014 Interview with Rodney Hill: Scholarly discussion on the film’s cinematic context.
• Excerpt from Cinépanorama (1964): Archival interviews with Jacques Demy and Michel Legrand.
• Audio Interview with Michel Legrand (1991): Insights into the composer’s collaboration with Demy.
• Audio Interview with Catherine Deneuve (1983): Reflections on working with Demy across multiple films.
• 2013 Restoration Demonstration: Overview of the restoration process.
• 2013 Re-release Trailer: Preview of the restored release.
• Foldout with Essay by Jim Ridley: Critical analysis of the film.

Jacques Demy’s "The Umbrellas of Cherbourg" (1964) stands as a singular achievement in the musical genre, notable for its entirely sung dialogue which transforms the film into an operatic narrative. Set in Cherbourg between 1957 and 1963, the story follows young lovers Geneviève (Catherine Deneuve) and Guy (Nino Castelnuovo), whose relationship is challenged by societal disapproval, financial strain, and ultimately, by Guy’s conscription for military service during the Algerian War. The love triangle is complicated further by the wealthy Roland Cassard's interest in Geneviève and the silent longing of Madeleine, who cares for Guy’s ailing aunt. Demy’s commitment to seamless musical storytelling eschews traditional spoken interludes, allowing Michel Legrand’s iconic score to flow uninterrupted and elevate both mundane exchanges and pivotal dramatic moments.

Visually, the film is renowned for its vibrant, meticulously designed mise-en-scène. Cinematographer Jean Rabier captures intensely saturated colors and deliberate lighting that evoke the feel of high-art oil paintings, crafting a dreamlike, stylized Cherbourg reminiscent of MGM’s golden-era musicals. Bernard Evein’s production design further enhances this effect, supporting Demy’s vision of a hyperreal world where every frame is visually arresting. Performances are emotionally resonant, particularly from Deneuve and Castelnuovo—though notably, the actors do not perform their own singing, a choice that does not diminish their impact. The bittersweet story, anchored by these strong performances and Legrand’s memorable themes, continues to inspire filmmakers decades later. "The Umbrellas of Cherbourg" is not only a radical reimagining of musical conventions but also an enduring work whose innovative approach to music, color, and storytelling remains influential and emotionally affecting.

The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Umbrellas of Cherbourg" brings Jacques Demy's enduring classic to new visual heights thanks to a recent 4K restoration by Eclair in France, supervised by Mathieu Demy. This edition includes both the new 4K restoration on UHD Blu-ray and the previous 2K restoration on standard Blu-ray, offering viewers an opportunity to compare both versions. The HDR transfer on the UHD disc is particularly noteworthy, delivering vibrant color reproduction and refined image clarity that showcase the film’s unique visual palette. However, some viewers may find the earlier 2K Blu-ray restoration to appear more natural and convincing depending on display calibration and personal preference.

This Criterion Collection release retains the film’s original monaural soundtrack as an alternate audio option, ensuring the preservation of Michel Legrand’s iconic score in its authentic form. The package also consolidates previously released special features, creating a comprehensive edition for collectors and new audiences alike. Technically, the HDR grading reveals added depth and nuance to the lush color schemes central to Demy's vision, further enhancing Catherine Deneuve’s luminous presence and complementing the film's singular musical storytelling.

In conclusion, this UHD release is an impressive upgrade for fans seeking the most thorough rendition of "The Umbrellas of Cherbourg" on home video. While some may prefer the aesthetic of the earlier 2K restoration, the UHD presentation’s enhancement in dynamic range and color fidelity make it a compelling choice for those passionate about film restoration and preservation. As always, potential buyers are encouraged to preview the 4K version where possible to determine personal preference before purchase.