Hugo Blu-ray Review
Score: 76
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Hugo's 3D Blu-ray mesmerizes with its top-tier lossless audio, stunning 3D visuals, despite minor crosstalk, delivering a heartfelt cinematic tribute.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 84
The 1080p Blu-ray presentation of 'Hugo' impresses with a theatrically correct widescreen 1.85:1 3D and 2D transfer that excels in its native 3D filming, boasting stunning depth and immersion, razor-sharp details, vibrant color grading, deep blacks, and minimal digital artifacts, solidifying it as a new benchmark for 3D visuals.
Audio: 73
Hugo's DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track delivers an immersive soundscape with exceptional clarity, precision, and detail. This technically refined mix balances subtle ambient effects, clear dialogue, and rich bass seamlessly, fully engaging all speakers. It's a sonic treat matching the visual splendour.
Extra: 58
Hugo's Blu-ray extras provide an insightful exploration of the film's production, featuring detailed looks at 3D filming challenges, historical influences such as Georges Méliès, the crafting of intricate automatons, and dedicated miniature effects work, interspersed with humorous moments from Sacha Baron Cohen.
Movie: 93
Hugo is a masterfully crafted film by Martin Scorsese that celebrates cinema's history and magic. The Blu-ray edition excels with its breathtaking 3D visuals and stunning DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track. Though extras are limited, the package includes both 2D and 3D versions, making it a worthy, future-proof addition for film enthusiasts.
Video: 84
The Blu-ray release of "Hugo" is an exemplary showcase of what high-quality home video presentation should aspire to, particularly in the realm of 3D. The disc boasts a theatrically correct widescreen 1.85:1 1080p transfer, offering both 3D and 2D versions, with the 3D presentation being a strong contender as the best ever. Filmed natively in 3D, every frame is meticulously designed to leverage the format, producing a fully immersive experience. Layers of depth in scenes like the bustling train station or the intricate clock tower highlight the exceptional foreground, middle ground, and background separation. The clarity extends to minute details such as skin pores, fabric textures, and clock cogs, all rendered with sublime definition.
The color palette adjusts dynamically to the film’s thematic and visual requirements. Post-production manipulation lends a bronze hue while maintaining vibrant primary colors, notably in Hugo's eyes and the inspector's uniform. Contrast and black levels are impressive, contributing to the impressive depth without sacrificing detail in darker scenes like the clock tower interiors or shadowy alleyways. The 3D effects are masterfully integrated, moving beyond mere gimmickry into artistic expression that enhances spatial perception and engagement with the story. Noteworthy are scenes with flying snowflakes, steam, and shattered glass that dramatically extend out of the screen, coupled with a seamlessly smooth camera movement lending a natural feel to the dynamic depth.
Despite minor crosstalk issues noted in some instances, this presentation is largely devoid of visual distortions like banding or compression artifacts. Paramount’s effort results in an AV marvel that leverages both positive and negative parallax for a stunningly immersive visual treat. Whether viewed in 2D or 3D, the robust detailing, contrast management, and sophisticated use of CGI elements epitomize a reference-quality transfer, making "Hugo" a standout in both technical execution and visual impact.
Audio: 73
The DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track for the Blu-ray presentation of "Hugo" is nothing short of spectacular. Its ability to create an immersive and detailed soundstage is evident from the very beginning, as the sounds of ticking clocks and mechanical gears immediately envelop the listener, setting the tone for the cinematic journey ahead. The sound mix is meticulously balanced, ensuring that dialogue remains clear and natural while seamlessly integrating with Howard Shore’s captivating score. Surround channels are utilized to their fullest, providing a rich tapestry of ambient effects that enhance the feeling of being in the bustling Parisian train station. Viewers will find themselves surrounded by the rhythmic clicks of moving gears, the hum of conversations, and the occasional roar of a train, all meticulously placed to deliver a lifelike auditory experience.
This presentation stands out with its ability to handle a wide range of sonic details. The bass is expertly controlled, delivering ample low-frequency effects when necessary, such as during the memorable runaway train sequence, without ever overwhelming the other elements of the mix. Highs and mids are equally well-managed, offering a dynamic range that accommodates both the subtle inflections of dialogue and the grand swells of the musical score. The accurate placement of sound effects within the sound field enhances the visual narrative, making each scene more engaging and immersive. Whether it’s the delicate rustling of papers or the thunderous crash of a train, every sound is rendered with precision and clarity.
Overall, the DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track on "Hugo" delivers a richly detailed and enveloping audio experience that matches the film's stunning visuals. With its exceptional fidelity, dynamic range, and immersive qualities, this track is exemplary in its execution and stands as a reference-quality presentation that impeccably complements one of cinema’s beautiful narratives.
Extras: 58
The Blu-ray extras for "Hugo" provide an insightful and comprehensive look into the film's production, offering a well-rounded view of both the technical processes and the creative inspirations behind the movie. The collection includes featurettes that delve into various aspects such as the adaptation of the book to film, the meticulous set designs, and the innovative use of 3D technology. Additionally, they explore historical elements pertinent to the film, like the life and work of Georges Méliès and the history of automatons, while also showcasing the humor through a spoof interview with Sacha Baron Cohen. Each featurette offers unique perspectives and detailed information, making them invaluable for fans and film enthusiasts alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Shoot the Moon: The Making of Hugo: Overview piece featuring cast and crew discussing adaptation, set design, and special effects.
- The Cinemagician George Méliès: Retrospective on Méliès' influence, career, and life with original clips.
- The Mechanical Man at the Heart of Hugo: History of automatons and an examination of the film's automaton.
- Big Effects, Small Scale: Examination of the train crash scene's model work.
- Sacha Baron Cohen: Role of a Lifetime: Humorous spoof interview with Cohan acting as a diva.
Movie: 93
Martin Scorsese's film "Hugo," an adaptation of Brian Selznick's novel "The Invention of Hugo Cabret," marks the director's first foray into children's cinema and 3D filmmaking. This cinematic marvel fuses a poignant tale of a twelve-year-old orphan, Hugo Cabret (Asa Butterfield), with a rich tapestry celebrating the history and artistry of film. Living in the clandestine passages of a Paris train station, Hugo maintains the station's clocks while grappling with solitude following his father's death. His quest to repair a mechanical automaton intertwines his fate with that of Georges Méliès (Ben Kingsley), a forgotten pioneer of early cinema. Scorsese's expert storytelling, paired with breathtaking visual effects, crafts a movie that is as emotionally resonant as it is visually stunning.
"Hugo" excels in merging digital effects with live-action seamlessly, a testament to Scorsese's dedication to authenticity and storytelling precision. The 3D presentation is masterful, enhancing the narrative without overshadowing it, much like Méliès' innovative effects did for early cinema. Scorsese's direction shows a profound respect for classic film techniques while pushing the boundaries of modern technology, resulting in a visual spectacle that honors its historical inspiration. The Parisian settings, both grandiose and hidden, are brought to life with meticulous detail, blending practical and digital elements so intricately that one cannot easily distinguish between reality and artifice.
This Blu-ray release is distinguished by its exceptional 3D transfer, setting a benchmark for the format, complemented by an impressive surround sound track delivering an immersive auditory experience. Although sparse on extras, the inclusion of both 2D and 3D versions ensures a versatile viewing option, solidifying this Blu-ray set as a vital addition for enthusiasts of both historical and cinematic profundity. "Hugo" is not only an exploration of human connection and purpose but also a heartfelt homage to the magic and enduring power of film itself.
Total: 76
Martin Scorsese's "Hugo" is a cinematic masterpiece that showcases his exceptional directorial prowess. As a heartfelt homage to the art of filmmaking, this film exudes warmth, sincerity, and meticulous attention to detail. Seamlessly blending stunning visuals with a powerful narrative, "Hugo" offers an authentic and complete cinematic experience. The story remains engaging throughout, supported by stellar performances and Scorsese's deft hand at storytelling. Paramount's Blu-ray 3D release, though slightly marred by crosstalk issues, still captures the magic of Scorsese's vision, ensuring viewers are thoroughly mesmerized from beginning to end.
The Blu-ray 3D edition of "Hugo" features a remarkable 7.1 lossless audio track that greatly enhances the viewing experience, providing clear and immersive sound. The 3D transfer is impressive, though not without its flaws; some viewers might experience consistent crosstalk, which can detract from the overall experience. Despite this minor setback, the combination of top-of-the-line 3D video quality and exceptional audio makes it a compelling purchase for home viewing. For those who may prefer a flawless visual experience, the 2D version offers the same narrative richness without the crosstalk.
In conclusion, "Hugo" is a must-own for any film enthusiast, both as a standout piece of contemporary cinema and as a touching celebration of the movie-making craft. While the 3D Blu-ray version is highly recommended for its immersive qualities, even with its occasional technical hiccups, the film shines in any format. "Hugo" is more than just a film; it is a heartfelt tribute to the magic of movies, promising an unforgettable viewing experience.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 100
Brightness and contrast are set to give wonderfully deep blacks that help to bring out the 3D, there is no flattening of the image at all in the darker areas, which shows how lighting and composition can...
Audio: 90
Bass is well managed, though never plumbs the depths of the big actioners, but it’s not that type of film, the swinging of the pendulum and low thump of the steam trains providing some light LF effects,...
Extras: 50
Shooting the Moon (The Making of Hugo) (19.48, HD) – A brief making of featurette that covers all the basics; interviews with all the main cast and crew, including the author of the book, and looks at...
Movie: 90
The story is concerned with the titular character a twelve year old boy coming to terms with his place in the world, the examination of loneliness and acceptance of family – through Hugo’s eyes we witness...
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
It greatly interferes with the film and, for all the good the remainder of the 3D visuals do, at this time the standard 2D version proves to be the best option for pure visual perfection....
Audio: 70
Dialogue is steady and accurate as it plays from the center channel, with a few playful moments of expert reverberation capturing the size and scope of the station....
Extras: 100
A solid overview piece that features cast and crew -- including Author Brian Selznick -- discussing the process of adapting the book to screen, the work of Director Martin Scorsese, the story's themes,...
Movie: 100
That's a nod to the quality of effects work but also to Scorsese's quality of storytelling; he absorbs his audience not just into the movie, but into an entirely different world where authenticity and...
Total: 50
Here's hoping Hugo is awarded the Best Picture Oscar; after all, how could a movie about the beauty of movies, a picture that so lovingly celebrates the medium, be denied?...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Details like snow, ash, steam, mist, and fireworks gently dance before us; a swinging pendulum cuts through the screen; the glistening snout of a growling Doberman Pinscher protrudes forward; sheets of...
Audio: 100
From the opening frames, featuring the rhythmic interlocking of mechanical gears exquisitely apportioned among all the room's speakers, it's evident we're in for an aural treat, and the track never backs...
Extras: 20
Featurette: "Shoot the Moon: The Making of 'Hugo'" (HD, 20 minutes) – Scorsese, screenwriter John Logan, members of the cast, and other creative personnel examine various aspects of the film's production...
Movie: 100
And no other film encapsulates the essence of Scorsese - who he is and what he does - better than 'Hugo,' which ties together the director's passion for motion pictures (spawned from a lonely, challenging...
Total: 80
At once an endearing family film and a fabulous 3D experience, 'Hugo' is most importantly a love letter to movies - those who make them and those who watch and revere them - produced by a man who does...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 96
This is a stellar high definition presentation that boasts rich, delineated primary colors, beautifully lush pastels and vibrant hues that are vivid, bold and striking in high definition....
Audio: 92
This film uses a complex sound design that has to maintain a delicate balance so the plethora of sound effects, music and dialogue within the soundtrack can be clearly and easily interpreted by the audience....
Extras: 70
Disc 1: 3D Blu-ray - Hugo Disc 2: 2D Blu-ray - Hugo (plus the following bonus features) : (HD) Shoot the moon: The making of Hugo – 19 minute featurette (HD) The cinemagician George Melies – 15 minute...
Movie: 90
The teaser trailer for Hugo, which seemed to be the one that I saw most, revealed very little about it which always elicited the same reaction from me, what is Hugo about?...
Total: 87
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Martin Scorsese
Actors: Asa Butterfield, Chloë Grace Moretz, Christopher Lee
PlotIn 1930s Paris, an orphan boy named Hugo lives within the walls of a bustling train station, maintaining the clocks and keeping his presence hidden from the station inspector. Prior to his father's death, Hugo and his father had been restoring an automaton, a mechanical man designed to write with a pen. The key to its function, a heart-shaped lock, remains elusive to Hugo. Driven by the belief that the automaton contains a message from his late father, Hugo is determined to fix it. He steals mechanical parts from the station's toy booth, run by the grumpy toy merchant Georges, to aid in the repair of the automaton.
One day, Hugo is caught stealing by Georges, who confiscates Hugo's notebook containing the automaton's blueprints. The threat of losing the notebook and the automaton's secret devastates Hugo, but a chance encounter with Isabelle, Georges' goddaughter, provides hope. She is intrigued by Hugo's project and decides to help him. The two form an unlikely friendship as they embark on a quest to solve the mystery of the automaton. Sharing a love for literature and adventure, they get swept up in an adventure that takes them through the hidden wonders of the train station and the dusty memories of the past. Together, they dive deep into the world of early cinema, where they uncover the forgotten treasures of a bygone era and the beauty of the dreams encapsulated within it.
Writers: John Logan, Brian Selznick
Release Date: 23 Nov 2011
Runtime: 126 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, United Kingdom, France
Language: English