My Life in Ruins Blu-ray Review
Score: 48
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"My Life in Ruins' Blu-ray offers decent video of beautiful Greece, but a lifeless plot and average audio make it a rental at best, a mess at worst."
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 61
My Life in Ruins on Blu-ray delivers a visually pleasing 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer, showcasing vivid and saturated colors with excellent clarity and fine detail. Despite minor aliasing and slight contrast issues, the clean source material and naturalistic color palette, enriched with a thin layer of grain, provide a vibrant and engaging viewing experience.
Audio: 46
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'My Life in Ruins' provides clear, intelligible dialogue and a decent front-channel spread but limited subwoofer engagement and surround usage, fittingly serving the film's modest audio demands without impressing.
Extra: 36
The Blu-ray extras for 'My Life in Ruins' include three lackluster commentary tracks, with Mike Reiss’s anecdotes providing the only occasional highlights; a set of deleted scenes with optional director commentary; a redundant and brief 'Everybody Loves Poupi' mid; and some standard trailers—nothing that adds substantive value to the release.
Movie: 31
My Life in Ruins, marketed as a romantic comedy, lacks romance and suffers from overdone stereotypes and stale jokes, despite picturesque shots of Greece and a standout performance by Richard Dreyfuss.
Video: 61
The Blu-ray presentation of "My Life in Ruins" is a visual feast, featuring a 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer that is both vivid and crisp. The film's Greece-centric backdrop comes alive through a bold color palette dominated by striking blues, from Georgia's eye-catching blazer to the expansive vistas of the Aegean Sea. Flesh tones also appear natural and sun-dappled, maintaining consistency throughout. The immersive experience is enhanced by well-balanced black levels and a generally pleasing contrast, although a few scenes edge towards overexposure. Aliasing is minimal, with only a slight shimmer noted during an aerial shot of an amphitheater. Importantly, the print is exceptionally clean, boasting a light grain that lends warmth and texture to the overall image.
Detail clarity is commendable, both in close-ups and wide shots, allowing individual strands of hair and background objects to be easily discerned. Night scenes feature solid black levels and good shadow delineation without any noticeable crush. The transfer is free of common digital artifacts such as banding, mosquito noise, or macroblocking, and no digital enhancements like edge sharpening or noise reduction appear to have been applied. This meticulous care results in an engaging visual experience that captures the natural beauty and rough charm of Greece with striking authenticity.
Overall, "My Life in Ruins" on Blu-ray delivers an exemplary visual performance, balancing vivid colors, accurate flesh tones, and fine detail with minimal technical faults. This makes it a suitable choice for visually-driven travelogue enthusiasts and film lovers alike.
Audio: 46
The Blu-ray release of "My Life in Ruins" comes equipped with a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that performs competently within the typical expectations of a romantic comedy. The dialogue is pristinely clear, ensuring every line is comprehensible even with the presence of various foreign accents. Most notably, the film's dialogue prioritization is flawless, making it easy to follow the script without straining to catch any nuances. Meanwhile, the front channels effectively distinguish the different elements of David Newman's score, integrating it seamlessly into the audio presentation without overpowering the other sound elements.
The use of surround speakers is minimal but adequate for the film's needs, providing ambient environmental sounds such as wind through ancient ruins, water sounds in marinas, and occasional traffic and party chatter. These ambient effects, while subtle, are detectable with attentive listening. The dynamic range of the audio track covers the limited spectrum of sounds presented, although subwoofer engagement remains minimal except for a mild rumble during a roadside mishap. Overall, while not sonically ambitious or overly immersive, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track serves "My Life in Ruins" well, handling the film's audio requirements with professional precision.
Extras: 36
The Blu-Ray extras for "My Life in Ruins" provide several standard supplemental features that lack substantial depth. The three separate commentary tracks by Nia Vardalos, director Donald Petrie, and writer Mike Reiss fail to fully engage or provide cohesive insights. While Reiss' commentary stands out with his humorous anecdotes—until he runs out of material and shifts topics—the others fall short; Vardalos' track is sparse, and Petrie's technical focus doesn't engage for such a film. Deleted and alternate scenes offer some mildly interesting additional context, especially an alternate ending that wisely was cut for its somber tone. The “Everybody Loves Poupi” segment is amusing but trivial, remixed for quirky humor. Although there are some worthwhile moments, overall, the extras feel superfluous given the film’s nature.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentaries: Three separate tracks by Nia Vardalos, Donald Petrie, and Mike Reiss. Reiss' is the most entertaining.
- Everybody Loves Poupi: A humorous, edited segment making it appear everyone is infatuated with Poupi.
- Deleted and Alternate Scenes: Eight scenes with optional director commentary, including an alternate ending.
- Bride Wars Trailer: Standard promotional trailer in HD.
Movie: 31
"My Life in Ruins" attempts to replicate the success of "My Big Fat Greek Wedding" but ultimately falls short. Starring Nia Vardalos, the film follows Georgia, a disillusioned history professor who resorts to leading lackluster bus tours across Greece. The plot is laden with stereotypes—including over-the-top American tourists and various international caricatures—that detract from any meaningful character development. Mike Reiss, known for "The Simpsons," delivers a script that mingles humor with shallow depictions, failing to capture the charm of Vardalos' previous work.
Despite its picturesque settings and the endearing performance by Richard Dreyfuss as Irv Gordon, a widower who breathes life into his character, the movie is bogged down by its cliched narrative and unoriginal jokes. The romantic subplot involving Georgia and the bus driver, Poupi (Alexis Georgoulis), lacks authentic chemistry and feels forced. The dramatic conflict is minimal, and any semblance of tension dissipates swiftly, resulting in a formulaic story arc.
In essence, "My Life in Ruins" provides fleeting entertainment with its scenic views of Greece but fails to deliver a compelling or memorable storyline. The film’s cardboard stereotypes and predictable plot renders it an innocuous but ultimately forgettable rom-com. Despite a handful of humorous moments and Vardalos’ innate charisma, it does little to advance her career or enrich viewers’ cinematic experience.
Total: 48
"My Life in Ruins" Blu-ray delivers a visually satisfying experience, bringing the picturesque landscapes of Greece to life with above-average video transfer. The vibrant and lush vistas are portrayed with clarity and detail that highlight the region's natural beauty and historical grandeur. However, the technical prowess of the video is undermined by an audio presentation that feels lackluster, failing to provide an immersive soundscape that complements the visual fidelity. Additionally, the supplemental content is rather average, offering little to enhance the overall package.
The film itself stumbles where it matters most. The storyline, much like the scenic bus tour it portrays, is predictable and uninspired. Nia Vardalos leads a cast through a plot that struggles to maintain engagement, often feeling like an extended episode of an unremarkable sitcom. The attempts at humor and romance feel heavy-handed, rendering many scenes lifeless and devoid of genuine charm. While fans of romantic comedies and those with a penchant for travel films might find some moments enjoyable, the narrative lacks the depth and originality required to appeal to a broader audience.
In conclusion, while "My Life in Ruins" offers a decent Blu-ray presentation with praiseworthy picture quality, its inherent flaws in storytelling and audio execution make it tough to recommend wholeheartedly. Greece may shine on screen, but the film itself fails to capture the essence and vitality of its backdrop. Ultimately, it's advisable to skip this cinematic tour unless you're an ardent fan of the genre or have a specific interest in Greek scenery.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 80
The print itself is very clean, and no one will take issue with the thin layer of grain that adds some warmth and texture to the image....
Audio: 70
As you might expect, there's no real subwoofer engagement, but the track's dynamic range has enough breadth to encompass what little audio diversity the film musters....
Extras: 40
Vardalos' track is spotty throughout, and while Petrie offers up loads of technical details about set design and scene construction, there are few people who would actually care about that kind of discussion...
Movie: 50
Unfortunately, for her and us, this would-be follow up to Greek Wedding is a trite rom-com that fails to recapture the magic, story-wise and financially, not quite recouping the $17,000,000 bankroll needed...
Total: 50
Greeks and Greece-o-philes may get a kick out of seeing their favorite country back on the silver screen, but My Life in Ruins is ultimately as lifeless and empty as the ancient stone monuments it features....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Both close-ups and wide shots exhibit a good amount of fine detail, and textures, on the whole, are aptly represented....
Audio: 60
Front channel separation is limited, too, but dialogue is well prioritized and always easy to understand despite the various foreign accents....
Extras: 40
His manic energy and irreverent attitude perk up the proceedings, and because the film is largely based on his own experiences (and was not – contrary to popular belief – created as a quasi-sequel to 'My...
Movie: 20
She comes to Athens to teach at a university, but when cutbacks force the elimination of her position, she takes a job with a second-rate tour outfit, carting around rude, whiny, disinterested travelers...
Total: 40
Like the tour bus that transports the characters, this predictable, undistinguished Nia Vardalos vehicle sputters and stalls throughout, and can't shake the feel of a sitcom pilot the network didn't pick...
Director: Donald Petrie
Actors: Nia Vardalos, Richard Dreyfuss, Rachel Dratch
PlotGeorgia, an American tour guide living in Greece, is disillusioned with her life and job. Once passionate about sharing Greece's rich history and beauty, she now finds herself guiding disinterested tourists who seem more interested in ice cream and souvenirs than cultural landmarks. Her employer, a cutthroat tour company, doesn't make things any easier. Georgia's current group is a quirky mix that includes a boisterous couple, a kleptomaniac, and a perpetually bickering elderly duo. To make matters worse, she is assigned a lackluster bus driver named Poupi Kakas, adding to her frustrations.
Struggling with her uninspired career and loveless personal life, Georgia reaches a breaking point as her attempts to ignite excitement within her group fall flat. Amidst the chaos, she forms an unlikely friendship with one of her elderly passengers, who imparts wisdom and encouragement that starts to shift her perspective. She slowly learns to embrace the present moment and discover joy in the little things, which reinvigorates both her personal and professional life.
Writers: Mike Reiss
Release Date: 05 Jun 2009
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Spain
Language: English, Greek