The Man from Laramie Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"The Man From Laramie," a thrilling revenge Western with James Stewart, offers excellent entertainment and strong visuals, despite minor audio and image inconsistencies.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 75
The Man from Laramie Blu-ray presents a 4K scan of the original camera negative in 1080p, showcasing stunning colors and details in its 2.55:1 CinemaScope aspect ratio. Despite minor issues like occasional grain, muted colors, and slightly warped panoramas, it overall delivers a visually impressive, high-definition experience.
Audio: 70
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix for 'The Man from Laramie' offers excellent ambient environmental sound and dynamic range, with a clear and precise score that shines, despite occasional dialogue balance issues during action scenes.
Extra: 21
Extras on the Blu-ray include a 1080p teaser, a 1080p original theatrical trailer, and an isolated music and effects track in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, providing a nostalgic and high-quality viewing experience with insightful audio enhancements.
Movie: 81
"The Man from Laramie" Blu-ray is lauded for its fascinating characters and complex narrative. The film's psychological depth, memorable Stewart-Mann collaboration, and Charles Lange's exquisite cinematography contribute to a compelling viewing experience that reinvigorates the Western genre with dark, nuanced storytelling and familial drama.
Video: 75
'The Man From Laramie' is presented in a pristine 1080p transfer with an AVC encoding and a 2.55:1 aspect ratio, sourced directly from the original camera negative and meticulously scanned at 4K. The CinemaScope format showcases expansive vistas and meticulous details, reflecting Mann and Charles Lang’s cinematic vision of the American southwest. Colors are vividly saturated with good accuracy and consistent contrast, albeit with some minor nuances in day-for-night shots. The grain structure remains natural and adds an authentic vintage feel, enhancing the film’s historical charm.
Notwithstanding its visual splendor, the transfer exhibits occasional anomalies. There are moments where the frame transitions from green-tinged images to the remastered clarity, creating a somewhat uneven viewing experience. Certain lap dissolves appear ragged, and darker sequences show a traditional ringing effect, notably visible in scenes such as Barbara's helper climbing the ladder post-Lockhart's attack by Boldt. These imperfections, likely inherent in the original negative, are brief and do not significantly detract from the overall high-quality presentation.
In summary, while 'The Man From Laramie' does reveal its age with certain technical blemishes, the restored 4K transfer predominantly provides a rich, visually captivating experience. The good far outweighs the minor distractions, making this a commendable effort from Grover Crisp and Sony-Columbia that will satisfy both new viewers and long-time fans.
Audio: 70
The audio presentation for "The Man from Laramie" on its Blu-ray release is handled with a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix that delivers a generally high-quality sound experience. The mix effectively recreates the original four-track stereo with great fidelity and dynamic range, incorporating environmental sounds like the prairie breeze and the thundering hooves of horses into the surround channels for an immersive auditory atmosphere. Additionally, George Duning's melodic and memorable score is gracefully blended into the surround channels, though occasionally overshadowed by the almost humorous theme song by Lester Lee and Ned Washington.
Dialogue is predominantly channeled through the center speaker but occasionally travels through other speakers during more intense scenes, which can sometimes cause issues with clarity. The sound effects and score are emphasized through the front channels, providing clear and precise instrumentals, especially notable during climactic scenes. Although there are moments where balancing dialogue with other elements falters, particularly during busier sequences, sound effects like gunshots and punches deliver a convincing and full-bodied listening experience.
While background elements are sparse, they do make subtle yet effective appearances in the rear channels, adding to the overall pleasant mix. Despite occasional inconsistencies in balancing dialogue and other audio components, the track remains dynamic and engaging throughout, elevating it above an average listening experience. This DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix succeeds in making "The Man from Laramie" an enjoyable auditory component of its Blu-ray release.
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray extras for "The Man from Laramie" provide a nuanced and robust supplement to the main feature, aimed at enthusiasts and collectors. Highlights include an isolated music and effects track presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, offering an immersive audio-only experience of the film's distinctive score and sound design. The inclusion of the original theatrical trailer and teaser in high-definition (HD and 1080p) helps contextualize the movie within its original promotional framework. These extras are well-curated, preserving the authenticity and historical resonance of the film while enhancing the viewing experience through high-quality audio-visual materials.
Extras included in this disc:
- Teaser: Brief promotional footage in 1080p.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional trailer in 1080p.
- Isolated Music and Effects Track: Presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0.
Movie: 81
The Man From Laramie, the final collaboration between director Anthony Mann and star James Stewart, rejuvenates the Western genre with exceptional complexity and depth. Set in Coronado, New Mexico—not the titular town of Laramie—the film excels in layering traditional Western themes with intriguing psychological undertones. Screenwriters Philip Yordan and Frank Burt craft a narrative rich in familial discord, focusing on Will Lockhart's (Stewart) relentless pursuit of justice for his brother's death. Lockhart's mission involves encounters with Alec Waggoman (Donald Crisp), his vile son Dave (Alex Nicol), and surrogate son Vic (Arthur Kennedy). Stewart's portrayal of Lockhart balances honor and obsession, juxtaposed against Mann's depiction of darker, flawed characters.
The film’s screenplay delves into the nuanced relationships between Alec Waggoman, caught between his blood-related but unworthy son Dave, and the capable Vic. This tension is skillfully expressed through both action and dialogue, particularly highlighting Mann’s ability to weave intricate character studies within a traditional Western framework. Lockhart’s conflict with Dave catalyzes a chain of events that disrupts the apparent tranquility of Coronado, leading to violent confrontations and personal reckonings.
Cinematographer Charles Lang’s work is noteworthy, rendering the vast landscapes breathtakingly and emotionally poignant. The perennial themes of duty and vengeance are explored with an unexpected depth, making it not only a compelling Western but also a profound meditation on human motivations and moral dilemmas. The Man From Laramie transcends genre conventions of its time to offer a timeless story, making it as engaging today as it was upon its release.
Total: 63
"The Man from Laramie" stands as a distinguished example of the Western genre, featuring a compelling performance by James Stewart. Directed by Anthony Mann, the film intertwines elements of Shakespeare's King Lear with the rugged aesthetics of the American frontier. This narrative fusion results in an emotionally potent exploration of family dynamics, vengeance, and loyalty amidst the backdrop of range wars. While it dips occasionally into hyperbole, these instances only add to its engrossing nature.
The Blu-ray release of "The Man from Laramie" boasts an impressive visual presentation, despite some minor inconsistencies in the image quality. The transfer captures the expansive landscapes and intricate details effectively, enhancing the overall viewing experience. However, the audio mix, although delivering robust action sequences, falls slightly short in balancing dialogue clarity against background sound, which can intermittently affect coherency.
The technical enhancements provided by this Blu-ray edition undeniably uplift this classic Western, ensuring that both aficionados and new viewers can enjoy it in a manner befitting its cinematic stature. The blend of robust visuals and an action-oriented soundtrack makes any shortcomings negligible.
In conclusion, "The Man from Laramie" offers a stalwart James Stewart surrounded by a gaggle of emotionally desperate characters in a somewhat roiling stew of family dysfunction, range wars, and a good old fashioned search for vengeance. If the film strays a time or two into hyperbolism, it's a small price to pay for such an invigorating viewing experience. This new Blu-ray looks and sounds great and comes Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
According to materials accompanying this release, this was sourced off the original camera negative and granted a 4K scan, and the results are really gorgeous, with the exception of a couple of somewhat...
Audio: 90
The Man From Laramie's original four track stereo mix is nicely recreated via DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 on this Blu-ray, with excellent use of the surrounds to help establish the ambient environmental sounds...
Extras: 30
Original Theatrical Trailer (1080p; 2:16) Isolated Music and Effects Track is presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0....
Movie: 90
That in turn reveals the second plot strand, which has Vic vying for the attention of Alec, clearly thinking he's the more able individual to take over The Barb once Alec, who is infirm, isn't able to...
Total: 90
The Man From Laramie offers a stalwart James Stewart surrounded by a gaggle of emotionally desperate characters in a somewhat roiling stew of family dysfunction, range wars and a good old fashioned search...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
While many other shots do look good as well, and feature some nice detail, color, and texture, there are enough instances where the frame jumps from a slightly green-looking image to that of the more pristine...
Audio: 80
The film has been given a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix that delivers a gorgeous sounding score and some surprisingly full-bodied sound effects, but can sometimes drop the ball when it comes to balancing...
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 80
'The Man From Laramie' is Mann's vision of the West, as a vast – as made apparent by the exquisite cinematography of Charles Lange – and unforgiving place where freedom is abundant and the only law that...
Total: 60
The image is good despite some inconsistencies and although the sound doesn't balance the dialogue as well as it could have, the mix still delivers robust, action-oriented audio....
Director: Anthony Mann
Actors: James Stewart, Arthur Kennedy, Donald Crisp
PlotWill Lockhart, a determined and stoic stranger from Laramie, arrives in the isolated town of Coronado, New Mexico. He is driven by a personal vendetta to find the men responsible for the death of his younger brother at the hands of Apaches armed with repeating rifles. Lockhart’s quest for justice leads him to clash with influential local rancher Alec Waggoman and his fiercely loyal yet volatile son, Dave. Suspicion arises when Lockhart discovers that the Waggomans’ vast cattle empire might be involved in the illegal gun trade fueling the Apache raids. His arrival disrupts the fragile balance of power and ignites deep-seated tensions within the community.
As Lockhart delves deeper into the web of rivalry and deception that grips Coronado, he finds an unexpected ally in Vic Hansbro, the foreman with ambitions of his own. The tension escalates as family secrets surface, and motives become murky. With every confrontation and revelation, Lockhart moves closer to uncovering the truth behind his brother’s murder while navigating dangerous alliances and facing mounting threats. The journey for truth and vengeance entangles Lockhart in a complex and perilous struggle where trust is scarce, and danger is omnipresent. The ensuing conflict forces all parties to confront their pasts and their fates in a land where honor, loyalty, and survival are relentlessly tested.
Writers: Philip Yordan, Frank Burt, Thomas T. Flynn
Release Date: 31 Aug 1955
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English