College Blu-ray Review

Kino-Lorber's Blu-ray release of "College" offers a 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer that captures the essence of the original 35mm source. The new master is strikingly faithful, presenting the print with minimal digital restoration. Consequently, viewers will encounter white specks, small scratches, and occasional contrast fluctuations. Nevertheless, these artifacts are relatively minor for an 85-year-old film and do not detract significantly from the viewing experience, especially for aficionados of silent cinema. Importantly, there is no evidence of digital noise reduction, edge enhancement, or other filtering techniques, ensuring that the natural film grain is preserved and providing a more authentic viewing experience.

The film's presentation does have some peculiarities. Notably, a persistent horizontal line near the bottom of the frame results in a slight brightness shift, possibly due to source-related issues. Despite this, the overall high-definition presentation stands out, offering enhanced clarity, refined textures, and appreciable detail. While inconsistencies in contrast between scenes are evident, generally solid black levels and stable whites contribute positively to the visual experience.

In summary, while Kino-Lorber's approach leaves certain imperfections intact—such as frame scratches, stains, and sporadic light flickering—the transfer overall delivers a pleasing rendition that honors the film's original qualities. The monochrome gradation and depth in exterior shots offer moments of visual satisfaction, making it a compelling choice for enthusiasts seeking an unaltered presentation of this classic work.

Kino's Blu-ray release of "College" features a single, yet notable, accompaniment track by the late John Muri, performed on the organ. Presented in uncompressed Linear PCM 2.0 stereo, the audio quality is commendable. The arrangement adeptly aligns with the film's visuals, enhancing the viewing experience without overshadowing it. The sound is clear and free from defects or wear, delivering an experience true to the original recording.

The LPCM 2.0 track showcases the full dynamic range of the organ, with both high and low notes resonating effectively through the speakers. Despite its limited scope, focusing solely on the organ, it creates an engaging atmosphere that remains consistent throughout the film. This vintage organ arrangement, recorded by Muri before his passing in 2000, seamlessly echoes through the presentation, ensuring historical authenticity and emotional depth.

The extras on the Blu-ray for "College" provide a comprehensive and engaging insight into Buster Keaton's work. Audio Commentary by film historian Rob Farr meticulously dissects the film from multiple perspectives, discussing behind-the-scenes aspects, thematic elements, and its role in Keaton's oeuvre. The Tour of Filming Locations, led by John Bengston, author of "Silent Echoes," provides an informative exploration of the Los Angeles locations where the movie was shot. Additionally, "The Scribe," Keaton's final film performance produced in 1966 as a semi-silent short for the Construction Safety Association of Ontario, showcases his iconic gag-heavy style while serving as an industrial safety PSA.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Rob Farr offers in-depth observations on the creation and themes of "College."
• Tour of Filming Locations: John Bengston guides viewers through the film's Los Angeles locations.
• The Scribe: Keaton's final film performance in a 1966 construction safety PSA.

Buster Keaton's film "College," released in 1927, is often overshadowed by his grander works like "The General" and "Steamboat Bill, Jr.," yet it remains a testament to his subtle yet brilliant comedic talent. Made in the wake of the commercial disappointment of "The General," "College" exemplifies Keaton’s mastery in low-key character comedy and physical humor. The film opens with Keaton’s character, Ronald, delivering a hilariously disastrous commencement speech on the evils of athletics. This sets up the central irony of the film: Ronald, a bookish scholar, attempting to transform himself into a collegiate athlete to win the heart of his crush, Mary.

Keaton’s physical comedy prowess shines as Ronald bumbles through a series of sporting events with increasingly absurd failures. His ability to turn his actually impressive athleticism into clumsiness is highlighted through various escapades like disastrously holding a baseball bat, knocking down hurdles, and performing high jumps and pole vaults with spectacularly comic missteps. Despite his ineptitude on the field, Keaton's impeccably timed stunts and nuanced bodily expressions are a masterclass in comedic performance.

Interspersed with these athletic endeavors, Keaton takes on part-time jobs that provide additional comedic fodder. His stint as a soda jerk and an ill-advised venture into blackface—while controversial today—are notable for showcasing his adeptness at slapstick and physical precision, even if certain aspects are cringeworthy by modern standards.

"College" may lack the high-concept set pieces seen in Keaton’s most famous films, but it compensates with its dedication to character-driven humor and inventive gags. While it might not stand as Keaton's magnum opus, it offers an engaging exploration of his comedic range and remains a compelling watch for those appreciative of silent film artistry.

College on Blu-ray presents a quintessential yet often overlooked Buster Keaton film. Nestled between the more renowned The General and Steamboat Bill, Jr., College might seem to lack the big-budget spectacle that defines those works; however, it compensates with a plethora of clever gags and the endearing portrayal of Keaton's inept athlete—a character filled with charm. From a technical standpoint, Kino's Blu-ray release is exemplary. The visual restoration is executed with notable precision, ensuring that the film appears as sharp and clean as possible given its age. The inclusion of an insightful commentary track adds significant value for aficionados and makes this release a delight to view.

For casual viewers, the film’s relatively short runtime and engaging humor make it a worthwhile rental. Despite being considered a minor Keaton film, College still outshines many contemporary comedies. The clarity of the audio and video further enhances the viewer's experience, proving that Blu-ray remains the superior format for classic film preservation. However, dedicated fans of Buster Keaton or silent comedies will find ample reason to purchase this Blu-ray. Kino's evident care in restoring College translates to an exceptional home viewing experience that is hard to match.

Overall, while College may not hold the iconic status of some of Keaton's other works, it showcases his talent for physical comedy and storytelling in a more intimate setting. Kino's Blu-ray release magnifies these strengths through meticulous restoration and enriching commentary. Highly recommended for Keaton enthusiasts and a solid option for a delightful rental for everyone else.