The General Died at Dawn Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The General Died at Dawn Blu-ray offers a stunning 4K restoration, top-notch cinematography, and excellent performances, making it a highly recommended upgrade.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
The General Died at Dawn's Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber features an exceptional 1080p MPEG-4 AVC presentation from a new 4K master, maintaining its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio with organic film grain and crisp black-and-white cinematography, making this the definitive home video edition despite minor imperfections.
Audio: 81
The Blu-ray release of "The General Died at Dawn" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio mono soundtrack that delivers crisp, clear dialogue and faithfully rendered sound, including Werner Janssen's Oscar-nominated score, with minimal issues, making it a significant improvement over past editions.
Extra: 51
Featuring insightful commentary by Lee Gambin and Rutanya Alda, the Blu-ray of 'The General Died at Dawn' provides a deep dive into the film's themes and cast, complemented by a selection of classic movie trailers, enhancing the historical value for cinephiles.
Movie: 81
The General Died at Dawn is a masterfully crafted, fast-paced thriller by Lewis Milestone, featuring top-notch performances from Gary Cooper and Madeleine Carroll, a suspenseful score by Werner Janssen, and stunning noire-style cinematography by Victor Milner, making it an underrated classic ripe for rediscovery.
Video: 76
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "The General Died at Dawn" boasts a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded high definition presentation in the original 1.37:1 aspect ratio. This video transfer, derived from a freshly completed 4K master, is truly remarkable. The black-and-white cinematography is exceptionally well-preserved, displaying an incredibly hypnotic and immersive visual experience. An authentic film grain layer remains intact throughout, contributing to a genuine cinematic feel. The transfer shows no significant signs of print degradation, such as warps or burns, ensuring a crisp and pleasing viewing experience from start to finish.
The recent 4K scan has injected new vitality into the film, enriching fine details and grayscale while maintaining a natural, organic film grain appearance. Although minor imperfections like scratches and dirt are occasionally noticeable, they are not overly distracting and do not significantly detract from the overall presentation quality. This Blu-ray transfer represents the best that this classic film has ever looked on home video, making it a top-notch effort guaranteed to satisfy fans and collectors alike.
Audio: 81
The Blu-ray release of "The General Died at Dawn" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio mono sound track that provides an impressive auditory experience. The high-resolution encode ensures that dialogue is crisp, clear, and consistently easy to understand, with no significant issues such as hiss, crackle, pops, or clicks disrupting the presentation. From start to finish, the audio quality is commendable, highlighting the fidelity and strength of the original recording. Optional English subtitles are also provided for added accessibility.
Particularly noteworthy is Werner Janssen’s Oscar-nominated score, which is rendered with great strength and fidelity on this track. The sound mix is faithfully reproduced, allowing the musical composition to shine alongside the film’s dialogue and other audio elements. Minor problems such as cracking and distortion are present but minimal, making this presentation a marked improvement over the previous Universal DVD release. Kudos to Kino for delivering what is likely the best this classic film will ever sound on home video.
Extras: 51
The extras on the Blu-ray of “The General Died at Dawn” are impressively curated with a mix of insightful commentary and promotional content. Lee Gambin and Rutanya Alda provide an engaging and informative audio commentary, discussing film elements, themes, cast, and crew intricacies, offering both depth and breadth to enhance viewers' understanding of the movie. The included theatrical trailer retains its original charm, preserving the historical essence of the film's initial release. Additionally, a selection of trailers for other HD and SD films from Kino Lorber adds value, illustrating the high-quality offerings available from the distributor. These extras offer a comprehensive and immersive experience for film enthusiasts and historians alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by author/film historian Lee Gambin and actress/film historian Rutanya Alda: Insightful discussion on themes, cast, and crew.
- The General Died at Dawn Theatrical Trailer: Original preservation of the film’s initial release.
- Bonus KLSC Trailers: The Lives of a Bengal Lancer, Beau Geste, Man of the West, The Great McGinty & The Black Sleep.
Movie: 81
"The General Died at Dawn," directed by Lewis Milestone, stands as a masterclass in suspenseful storytelling, enhanced by remarkable technical craftsmanship. Set in war-torn China, the fast-paced thriller follows American agent O'Hara (Gary Cooper) on a perilous mission against the ruthless General Yang (Akim Tamiroff), with Madeleine Carroll excelling in the role of Judy Perrie, the femme fatale-turned-romantic interest. Cooper and Carroll's palpable on-screen chemistry heightens the tension and urgency inherent in their characters' dynamic. The screenplay by Clifford Odets is tightly woven, imbuing each scene with suspense and depth, thereby maintaining the audience's engagement throughout the runtime.
The film's technical elements significantly elevate its narrative. Victor Milner’s lush black-and-white cinematography captures the dark, noir aesthetic that lends the film its atmospheric tension. The innovative use of shot composition—including transitions like a doorknob fading into a billiard cue ball—and early split-screen techniques demonstrate Milestone's forward-thinking directorial approach. Edited with precision by Eda Warren, the film boasts an impeccable pace, further emphasized by Hans Dreier and Ernst Fegté's art direction. The shadowy train settings create a claustrophobic environment, amplifying the suspense. Werner Janssen’s original score complements the visuals, resonating with the film’s emotional and narrative beats, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
The performances are uniformly excellent. Gary Cooper delivers a solid portrayal of O'Hara, modeled after real-life adventurer Morris "Two-Gun" Cohen, while Madeleine Carroll shines as Judy Perrie. However, Akim Tamiroff's portrayal of General Yang stands out, earning him a nomination for the first Oscar award for Best Supporting Actor. The supporting cast, including Dudley Digges, Porter Hall, and William Frawley, rounds out the ensemble, adding depth and nuance to the story. Overall, "The General Died at Dawn" remains an under-the-radar classic worthy of rediscovery, showcasing superb direction, innovative cinematography, and notable performances.
Total: 73
"The General Died at Dawn" receives a significant boost with this Blu-ray release, which thoroughly enhances the viewing experience of this classic suspense film. The 4K restoration is exceptional, bringing unprecedented clarity to the stunning cinematography and meticulously crafted art design. With vivid visuals and sharp contrasts, the richly detailed imagery makes it evident that this restoration was handled with great care. The inclusion of lossless audio tracks enriches the sound quality, ensuring that viewers can fully appreciate the powerful performances and the intricate soundscapes that accompany the narrative.
Gary Cooper and Madeleine Carroll deliver exquisite performances—with Cooper’s stoic intensity perfectly complementing Carroll’s enchanting presence. The chemistry between the lead actors elevates the storytelling, making the suspense and drama even more engaging. Kino’s Blu-ray release also includes a highly informative commentary track, adding valuable context to the film and enhancing the overall appreciation of this Golden Age Hollywood treasure. This new transfer marks a considerable improvement over previous DVD releases, presenting "The General Died at Dawn" in a quality that does justice to its enduring legacy.
In conclusion, "The General Died at Dawn" is an entertaining, fast-paced, and exciting suspense film that deserves to be seen. The production is well-mounted on so many levels: the art design and cinematography are top-notch. The performances by Gary Cooper and Madeleine Carroll are exquisite. There is great chemistry between the actors. I found the film exciting and worthwhile from start to finish. The Blu-ray release features a stunning restoration: a brand new 4K scan. The Kino release also includes an excellent lossless audio track. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 90
The transfer is of a new master completed in 4K. The 4K scan looks terrific and brings with it a new sense of life and vitality to the film....
Audio: 80
The Blu-ray release for The General Died at Dawn is presented with an English DTS-HD Master Audio mono sound track....
Extras: 60
The release includes a selection of trailers promoting other releases available from distributor Kino Lorber: The Lives of a Bengal Lancer (SD, 1:42), Beau Geste (SD, 1:28), Man of the West (HD, 3:02),...
Movie: 90
There is something creative going on in each scene of the film and the costumes help the film excel is all of these arenas by giving the characters the appropriate aesthetic to their respective roles....
Total: 80
The production is well mounted on so many levels: the art design and cinematography are top-notch....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 80
Minor problems like scratches and dirt are present, but aren’t too distracting; overall, this is likely the best the movie will ever look on home video....
Audio: 100
Problems like cracking and distortion are fairly minor, making this another improvement over the previous Universal DVD and likely the best the movie will ever look on home video....
Extras: 50
Commentary by film historian Lee Gambin and actress/film historian Rutanya Alda – Recorded for this release, Gambin goes over some of the elements and themes of the movie while Alda talks about the cast...
Movie: 80
Add in some very solid performances as well as a taut script by Clifford Odets and The General Died at Dawn stands out as one of Paramount’s premier productions of the decade, one that’s a bit overlooked...
Total: 80
Go ahead and upgrade from the previous DVD release of the movie (The Gary Cooper Collection), as this release is highly recommended....
Director: Lewis Milestone
Actors: Gary Cooper, Madeleine Carroll, Akim Tamiroff
PlotIn the war-torn provinces of China, a mercenary named O'Hara is on a mission to deliver a large sum of money to Chinese rebels fighting against the tyranny of General Yang, a ruthless warlord determined to seize control. O'Hara's journey is fraught with danger as he navigates through Yang's territories, relying on his cunning and combat skills to avoid capture. During his quest, O'Hara encounters Judy Perrie, a foreign woman entangled in her own troubles. Their paths cross in unexpected ways, and Judy becomes an essential participant in O'Hara's efforts, inadvertently pulling her deeper into his perilous mission.
As O'Hara and Judy attempt to outmaneuver Yang's forces, they face numerous challenges that test their resolve and resourcefulness. They encounter a myriad of characters, from allies to adversaries, each adding layers of complexity to their mission. With escalating tension and danger, their objective of supporting the rebels becomes increasingly difficult. Together, they must navigate betrayal, deception, and the ever-present threat posed by General Yang as they strive for victory.
Writers: Clifford Odets, Charles G. Booth
Release Date: 28 Oct 1936
Runtime: 98 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English