Frankenstein 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 84
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Universal's Frankenstein UHD excels in quality, retaining rich details and deep blacks, making it a must-have.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 89
Frankenstein's 2160p/HDR UHD release enhances visuals with deeper blacks, brighter whites, and sharper details, offering a near flawless, filmic experience that outshines its Blu-ray predecessor.
Audio: 84
Universal retained the original 2.0 mono soundtrack without updating to Dolby Atmos or DTS:X, preserving the film's age-appropriate sound quality, including studio sounds and dialogue clarity, with its analog warmth and minimal distortion.
Extra: 71
Frankenstein's UHD pack includes 2013 Blu-ray extras, digital code, features on horror history, Karloff, and Universal's horror legacy, two expert commentaries, and archival materials.
Movie: 91
Universal's release of 'Frankenstein' on UHD enhances the 1931 classic with 2160p/HDR, carrying legacy features and soundtrack, reflecting Karloff's nuanced portrayal amid Gothic sets and societal critique.
Video: 89
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Frankenstein" offers a significant leap forward in visual fidelity when compared to its 2013 Blu-ray predecessor, mirroring the strides seen in Universal's UHD reissue of "Dracula." From the opening sequences, viewers are immediately treated to stunning improvements, particularly noticeable in the grayscale's balance, enhanced whites, and deeper blacks. The introduction of HDR brings an added depth to every scene, enriching the viewing experience with brilliant whites, such as those outlining the film’s title, that leap from the screen. The handling of black levels impresses, offering deep and detailed shadows that contribute greatly to the gothic atmosphere of "Frankenstein", whether it be in the creature’s menacing attire or the engulfing shadows of Frankenstein's laboratory.
The upgrade to 2160p resolution is equally commendable, not only for its enhancement of overall sharpness but also in the preservation of filmic grain that gives "Frankenstein" its authentic, period-appropriate texture. Despite some inherent softness in certain shots, the increase in detail is astonishing, especially visible in close-ups of the creature's makeup and in the meticulously detailed laboratory settings. This resolution boost benefits from a cleaner source, free from previous blemishes, and an encode free from issues, ensuring that viewers can appreciate the finer details without distraction.
Moreover, HDR grading doesn't just serve as a visual enhancement; it actively contributes to the film's mood and storytelling. Highlights such as electricity sparks and other bright elements strike with intensity against the moody, darker backgrounds, providing a dynamic visual contrast that aligns with the thematic contrasts at the heart of "Frankenstein." The preservation of details is thorough, allowing textures like facial expressions and environmental elements to shine through in a way previously unseen, showcasing Universal’s commitment to honoring the film’s legacy with a pristine and meticulously crafted transfer that both respects and revitalizes this classic piece of cinema.
Audio: 84
Universal's approach to the audio presentation for the 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Frankenstein" opts for authenticity over modern reconfiguration, maintaining the original 2.0 lossless mono soundtrack. This decision ensures that the audio stays true to its historical context, preserving its legacy without attempting to retrofit it into a Dolby Atmos or DTS:X setup. The fidelity of this vintage sound design, considering the film's era, surprisingly stands its ground, effectively conveying the movie's atmospheric nuances without distortion or significant loss of clarity.
Listeners will find themselves immersed in a genuine early sound era experience, with the DTS-HD mono track revealing subtle studio artifacts like camera motors whirring and a hint of static—echoes of the production environment of yesteryears. Despite these inherent characteristics of early sound recordings, such as a slightly dampened treble and an occasionally wobbly score, the track retains a certain warmth that feels both nostalgic and precise. This analog-like quality contributes positively to the overall viewing experience, providing a seamless blend of dialogue, effects, and music.
The preservation of the original sound mix, without any alteration, allows for a clear and undistorted auditory journey through "Frankenstein." The dialogue remains front and center, easily intelligible amidst the film’s signature ambient sounds. While some might perceive the lack of a multi-channel remix as a missed opportunity for immersion, this faithful reproduction serves as a testament to the film’s enduring impact, ensuring that every hiss, groan, and scream is delivered with an authenticity that honors its cinematic significance.
Extras: 71
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Frankenstein" includes a comprehensive collection of extras that enhance the viewing experience by delving deeply into the film’s legacy, its star Boris Karloff, and Universal's broader horror lineage. Notably, it carries over all special features from the 2013 Blu-ray edition, ensuring longtime fans and newcomers alike have access to a treasure trove of documentary content and insightful commentary. Highlights include two engaging audio commentaries, one by film historian Rudy Behlmer and another by historian Sir Christopher Frayling, enriched with a trivia track for an added layer of information. The extensive 44-minute documentary, "The Frankenstein Files," offers a thorough historical overview of the monster's cinematic journey, while "Karloff: The Gentle Monster" provides a touching 38-minute tribute to the actor’s career. Additional documentaries like "Universal Horror," which expands the focus beyond Frankenstein to other studio classics, alongside various archives, promotional material, and a unique comedic short film, round out an exceptional package for fans of classic cinema and horror alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Frankenstein Files: How Hollywood Made a Monster: Documentary on the monster's creation.
- Karloff: The Gentle Monster: A look at Boris Karloff's horror career.
- Universal Horror: Explores Universal's legacy of horror films.
- Frankenstein Archives: A compilation of posters and materials related to the film.
- Boo!: A Short Film: Comedic take on Universal's horror films up to 1932.
- Trailer Gallery: Collection of trailers.
- 100 Years of Universal: Restoring the Classics: Overview of Universal's restoration efforts.
- Monster Tracks: An interactive pop-up trivia track.
- Audio Commentary: By film historian Rudy Behlmer.
- Audio Commentary: By historian Sir Christopher Frayling.
Movie: 91
Universal's 4K UHD release of the 1931 version of "Frankenstein," starring Boris Karloff, ushers a classic into the modern age with striking visual and audio upgrades, including a 2160p/HDR presentation that breathes new life into the film's gothic aesthetic and surreal sets that pay homage to German expressionism. This edition, which also includes previously released extras from the 2013 Blu-ray edition and the original lossless soundtrack, comes as part of the UHD Classic Monsters Collection, alongside other seminal works like 'Dracula,' 'The Invisible Man,' and 'The Wolf Man.' Available in collectible SteelBook packaging, this release not only appeals to classic horror aficionados but also marks a significant step in preserving cinema history with cutting-edge technology.
Boris Karloff's portrayal of the Monster stands as a testament to his nuanced acting ability, conveying a depth of emotion and empathy for this misunderstood creation through subtle gestures and expressions. The interplay between Karloff and Colin Clive, who plays his master Henry with a loud and manic intensity, anchors the film’s narrative tension. Director James Whale crafts a story that is as much about societal fears and prejudices as it is about the horror of Frankenstein's creation, with themes of alienation and the consequences of unfettered scientific ambition woven throughout. The film’s visual language, characterized by its use of shadow and light within the confinements of a gothic castle and its surroundings, complements the story's exploration of these themes.
At its core, "Frankenstein" is a poignant exploration of the fine line between creator and creature, science and monstrosity. Whale skillfully uses the film to critique the social elite's unchecked experimentation and its impact on those who are caught in its wake, embedding a deeper commentary on class and otherness within the horror genre. The 4K UHD presentation highlights these elements, making "Frankenstein" not just a visual spectacle but also an enduring narrative about the monster within us all, begging for empathy and understanding in a world that is quick to judge and condemn.
Total: 84
Universal's 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Frankenstein" is an exemplary showcase, bringing this classic monster tale to life with remarkable clarity and depth. The 2160p/HDR visuals enhance the original filmic experience, preserving the intended grain structure while offering sharp details throughout. The grayscale benefits immensely from this upgrade, displaying intensely bright whites, deep blacks, and a nuanced midrange that truly honors the source material. This release not only respects but elevates the visual storytelling, allowing both the horror and compassion of Frankenstein's story to resonate with viewers anew. Moreover, the audio quality remains faithful to the original, with the core soundtrack meticulously preserved. All legacy extras from the 2013 Blu-ray are included, ensuring that fans have access to a comprehensive collection of content.
Universal has treated "Frankenstein" with the care it deserves, seamlessly blending the old with the new by enhancing visual and audio elements without compromising the original integrity of the film. This release stands as a testament to the timeless appeal of "Frankenstein," offering audiences both old and new the chance to experience the film in unparalleled quality. Whether purchased individually or as part of the Universal Classic Monsters Collection, this edition is undoubtedly a must-have, offering a definitive viewing experience that remains true to the essence of the classic horror genre.
In conclusion, Universal's 4K UHD presentation of "Frankenstein" is an absolute triumph, capturing the heart of this iconic film while presenting it in a quality hitherto unseen. The painstaking effort to preserve and enhance both the visual and auditory elements of the original film pays off, making this release an essential addition to any collector's library and earning it our highest recommendation. This release not only highlights the enduring legacy of "Frankenstein" but also sets a new standard for the preservation and enjoyment of classic cinema in the modern age.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
As with Dracula, improvements are readily evident right out of the gate, with the opening presenter and the film's title card, the latter of which is of particular delight for its far more balanced grayscale,...
Audio: 100
Rather than reconfigure the film's soundtrack to the Dolby Atmos or DTS:X configuration, Universal has simply recycled the existing 2.0 lossless mono soundtrack, which holds up just fine for a movie of...
Extras: 70
As it ships within the 4K Classic Monsters Collection a Movies Anywhere digital copy code is included....
Movie: 90
Note that this release is currently available in a four-film UHD Classic Monsters Collection with 'Dracula,' 'The Invisible Man,' and 'The Wolf Man' and individually in collectible SteelBook packaging....
Total: 80
While the Blu-ray remains a very viable presentation, this 2160p/HDR presentation only amplifies the filmic roots, retaining a handsome grain structure, revealing sharp details, and bringing out the finest...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 100
The period’s cinematography often drifts toward hazier romanticism, but when unobstructed by that aesthetic, resolution explodes....
Audio: 80
There remains some warmth within this vintage track, almost soothing in its analog-like precision....
Extras: 80
Universal Horror takes a more expanded approach as it delves into all of the studio’s monster mashes for 90-minutes....
Movie: 100
And knowing Whale never revealed his sexuality publicly, it’s easy to read the monster as somewhat personal – persecuted for who he is, and unable to freely express his feelings....
Total: 90
Bested only by its sequel, Universal’s Frankenstein capably conveys the story’s horror and compassion in a masterful way....
Director: James Whale
Actors: Colin Clive, Mae Clarke, Boris Karloff
PlotIn the shadows of an imposing Gothic castle, a driven and ambitious scientist, Henry Frankenstein, toils away alongside his hunchbacked assistant, Fritz. Frankenstein is obsessed with his groundbreaking experiment: to create life from death. He believes that through the power of science, he can animate a body, pieced together from the remains of the deceased. His quest for this unnatural achievement isolates him from his concerned fiancée Elizabeth, his best friend Victor, and his mentor, Dr. Waldman. Despite their worries, Frankenstein’s obsession only grows, driving him to grave-robbing and the harnessing of a powerful lightning storm to give his creation the spark of life.
As the storm rages, Frankenstein succeeds in his experiment, giving life to a creature of his own making. The Creature, an imposing figure with a frightful countenance, first reveals signs of gentle misunderstanding but quickly becomes confused and frightened by the world around it. Fear and mistreatment from its human creators begin to paint its experiences, leading to unforeseen and troubling consequences. The town below the castle remains ignorant of the scientist's forays into playing god, but as tensions and odd occurrences pile up, the line between creator and creation is strained, and Frankenstein’s moral and ethical boundaries are put to the test.
Writers: John L. Balderston, Mary Shelley, Peggy Webling
Release Date: 21 Nov 1931
Runtime: 70 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English, Latin