A Simple Favor 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 79
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A Simple Favor dazzles with humor and visuals, despite its flaws.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 84
A Simple Favor shines in 4K UHD with vivid details and textures, enhanced by Dolby Vision and a unique 2.00:1 ratio, despite its 2K DI origin.
Audio: 77
The Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track shines with clarity in dialogue, atmospheric effects, and engaging source cues, making for an immersive experience despite a few underutilized moments.
Extra: 80
Lionsgate's A Simple Favour release is packed with extras, including three audio commentaries, insightful featurettes on its making, style, and alternate endings, plus a gag reel, all emphasizing director Paul Feig's involvement.
Movie: 69
A Simple Favor blends light and dark humor in a suburban mystery, leaning on Kendrick and Lively's dynamic to navigate its twists and whimsical tone, despite some tension-defusing contrivances and underdeveloped elements.
Video: 84
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "A Simple Favor" by Lionsgate Films showcases an outstanding visual quality that closely mirrors the excellence of its theatrical release, despite an unfortunate deviation from an 8K source to a 2K Digital Intermediate (DI). This edition maintains a native 3840 x 2160p resolution, framed in the film's original widescreen 2.00:1 aspect ratio. It leverages 10-bit video depth along with a wide colour gamut (WCG), High Dynamic Range (HDR), and Dolby Vision, encoded through the HEVC (H.265) codec to bring vibrant and nuanced visuals. The review conducted on a premium LG setup confirms an exceptional viewing experience, further validated by comparisons with visual textures and detailing captured uniquely at this higher resolution.
Technical intricacies of the 4K presentation highlight a considerable improvement over its 1080p counterpart, offering finer detail across the board—from the intricate patterns on Stephanie's animal socks to the textures of Emily's provocative painting—all rendered more noticeably palpable. The application of Dolby Vision enhances the film's appealing palette, elevating the color richness of luxurious costumes and set designs. Despite slight deficiencies in shadow detail during darker sequences, the 4K resolution manages to alleviate some of the banding issues noted in the 1080p version. Also noteworthy is the film's unique application of digital grain, adding a layer of visual texture that enriches the overall cinematic quality.
The treatment of color and light in "A Simple Favor" sets a distinctive aesthetic tone that stands out in 4K UHD. Flesh tones receive a meticulous balance, and the naturalistic yet vibrant color grading accentuates everything from lush landscapes to the nuanced interiors of Lively’s modernist home. While some color deviations are noted, they are minor and do not detract significantly from an otherwise stellar visual presentation. The mild Dolby Vision pass enhances depth and dimensionality, maintaining high visual fidelity throughout the runtime. Lionsgate's encoding efforts manage to preserve the film's sharpness and texture immaculately, contributing to a visually dazzling experience that testament to its advanced technical execution, even under the limitations of a 2K DI finish.
Audio: 77
The Dolby TrueHD 7.1 audio track of the "A Simple Favor" 4K UHD Blu-ray offers a comprehensive and detailed audio experience that matches and, at times, elevates the on-screen action. With a special focus on dialogue, which is rendered with clarity and prioritization across the front channels, the track ensures that conversations are effortlessly intelligible. Additionally, the soundstage enjoys the playful yet deliberate use of a varied score, including French source cues that add an engaging layer to the overall audio presentation. These musical pieces, alongside the film's more raucous moments, are spread thoughtfully through the surround channels, enhancing scenes with energetic vibrancy and creating an immersive viewer experience.
Environmental sounds and effects are given meticulous attention, contributing significantly to the ambiance and sensory depth of the film. Starting with understated atmospheric sounds, the audio progressively incorporates more dynamic elements, such as schoolroom chatter and park playdates, which fill the surround channels with life. The pragmatic use of ambient noises in outdoor scenes further enriches this landscape, providing a seamless and natural audio backdrop that supports and amplifies the narrative. Even in quieter moments, such as rainfall or background music within the house, the track maintains its precision and ambiance, subtly utilizing the available speakers to full effect.
Although the TrueHD 7.1 track does not overwhelm with continuous sonic bombast, its strength lies in its ability to deliver sonically significant moments with finesse and accuracy. From a spirited car chase to the detailed environmental effects, it boasts a balanced mix where dialog remains king, supported by a light score and well-placed effects. This thoughtful mix reflects high production values, ensuring that each audio element, whether foreground or background, is treated with importance, thus honoring the film’s vibrancy and enhancing its storytelling.
Extras: 80
Lionsgate's release of "A Simple Favor" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray is a treasure trove for fans of the film and director Paul Feig, encapsulating an array of extras that enhance the viewing experience significantly. The package impressively ports over all supplementary materials from the Blu-ray edition, maintaining both 1080p and 2160p formats. Highlighted by a trio of engaging audio commentaries—each featuring Feig with a different cohort (solo, with stars Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively, and with the crew)—the extras delve into the creative process behind the film. Additionally, eight featurettes explore various aspects from the making-of (Gravestone Martinis) to specific elements like the visual style, production design, costume design, and even a jettisoned ending. A set of deleted scenes with optional introductions, a gag reel, and a focus on certain characters provide a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look. Despite a seemingly pointless introduction by Feig, every extra adds value, making this release a must-have for enthusiasts eager to explore the depths of "A Simple Favor".
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Director Paul Feig: Insightful solo commentary.
- Audio Commentary with Director Paul Feig, Actors and Crew: Collaborative commentaries offering diverse perspectives.
- Gravestone Martinis: A making-of featurette with engaging interviews.
- Suburban Noir: The Visual Style of A Simple Favor: Exploration of the film’s production design and cinematography.
- Dapper Director Diaries with Paul Feig: Behind-the-scenes fun focused on Feig.
- Love Triangle: Insight into the film’s central relationships.
- Style by Paul: A tribute to Feig's distinctive fashion sense.
- Flash Mob Making Of: Behind-the-scenes look at an alternate ending.
- Dennis Nylon: Extra screentime for a minor character.
- A Simple Playdate: Featurette focusing on the younger cast members.
- Flash Mob: Alternate Ending: An optional intro by Feig precedes this alternate conclusion.
- Gag Reel: Uncensored bloopers and fun moments.
- Deleted Scenes: Additional scenes with an optional intro by Feig.
Movie: 69
"A Simple Favor" presents a curious blend of dark comedy and suspenseful mystery, led by the winning combination of Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively. Director Paul Feig, known for his comedic work, takes a semi-serious turn here, melding whimsical elements with a narrative that’s reminiscent of "Gone Girl," albeit with a lighter touch. The contrasting personalities of Kendrick's endearing, if not slightly naive, single mom Stephanie and Lively's enigmatic, perfectionist Emily create a fascinating dynamic, initiating an unlikely friendship that spirals into a labyrinth of secrets, deception, and murder.
The film thrives on its slow-burning mystery and the allure of its character's secrets, unraveling in a suburban setting that juxtaposes ordinary life with extraordinary circumstances. The narrative cleverly exploits and satirizes suburban culture and the roles of women within it, using Stephanie’s mommy vlog as a vehicle for commentary and connection. While Feig's direction keeps the tone surprisingly buoyant given the subject matter, this balancing act sometimes falters, especially towards the film’s overwrought conclusion which layers twist upon twist, occasionally straining credulity.
Technically, "A Simple Favor" dazzles with its stylistic choices, from the gorgeous cinematography to the fashion-forward wardrobe that becomes an extension of the characters’ personalities. The screenplay adeptly incorporates humor into the mystery, maintaining engagement even as the plot veers into far-fetched territory. Despite its flaws – an occasionally disjointed plot and a finale that leans too heavily into the absurd – the film's strength lies in its lead performances and its ability to entertain and intrigue in equal measure. Its reflection on identity, friendship, and the facades we maintain is compelling, making "A Simple Favor" an audacious and stylish piece that combines genres to mostly effective ends.
Total: 79
In the 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of "A Simple Favor", viewers are treated to a visual feast that showcases the film’s gorgeous aesthetics and its equally captivating cast. The film itself, a blend of comedy and thriller, oscillates between moments of sharp wit and suspenseful drama, primarily driven by Anna Kendrick's spirited performance, which lends a unique tone to the narrative. Despite a few narrative inconsistencies and moments that may test the suspension of disbelief, the film’s charm largely prevails, thanks in part to the dynamic between Kendrick and Blake Lively. Their chemistry not only anchors the film’s plot but elevates it, making for a highly engaging watch. Additionally, the 4K video transfer enhances the viewing experience with notable improvements in saturation and detail levels over its 1080p counterpart, complemented by an effective audio track that remains unchanged but satisfactory.
Technical merits of this release are commendable; the transition to 4K UHD brings with it a significantly sharpened image quality that enriches the film’s visual style, from its characteristically stylish outfits to the detailed suburban settings. Furthermore, the inclusion of comprehensive extra features on the 4K disc itself is a welcomed addition, adding value to the overall package for fans and newcomers alike. While some may find the film's twists somewhat excessive and its tone occasionally uneven, the overall package benefits from a self-aware humor and a narrative that keeps the audience guessing, supported by strong performances.
Conclusively, "A Simple Favor" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray emerges as a highly recommended release that does justice to its source material. It seamlessly combines technical brilliance with a story that’s as engaging as it is visually striking. Despite its minor storytelling lapses, the film delivers a refreshing take on the thriller genre, underpinned by commendable technical enhancements and an array of extras that enhance its replay value. This Blu-Ray is a must-have for aficionados of cleverly crafted cinema that both entertains and visually captivates, ensuring a delightful viewing experience.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
A Simple Favour comes to UK Ultra HD Blu-ray courtesy of Lionsgate, who afford it the same excellent presentation that their US release was blessed with, not quite making the most of the reportedly 8K...
Audio: 90
With the focal feature of dialogue getting clear and coherent prioritisation across the frontal array, and a somewhat slight - and occasionally even whimsical - score keeping up the rear, the real breadth...
Extras: 80
A series of Deleted Scenes, that Flash Mob Alternate Ending, and a Gag Reel round out the extras....
Movie: 60
With some gender-reversed Hitchcock vibes and a few not-so-subtle misdirections, the whole mystery part works reasonably well, although it's frequently brought crashing back down to earth by the more whimsical...
Total: 80
A Simple Favour struggles a little with a jarring goofiness almost completely revolving around Anna Kendrick's unsurprisingly kooky character, who appears to have stepped out of Pitch Perfect and landed...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
There's also a much more noticeable textural quality to the vlog material that Stephanie provides, with a kind of crosshatched appearance at times that is more marked in this version than on the 1080p...
Audio: 90
Several non-musical sequences also offer good surround activity, including some noisy schoolroom moments, a playdate at the park, and, later (if somewhat briefly), what seems to be turning into a car chase...
Extras: 90
Both the 1080p and 2160p discs in this package share the same bountiful supply of bonus features: Special Features Introduction by Paul Feig (1080p; 00:17) is a completely pointless excercise, kind of...
Movie: 70
While there is a missing persons element to A Simple Favor, the trailers I personally saw pretty much completely missed the fact that this outing is considerably cheekier than the Gillian Flynn adaptation,...
Total: 80
The film may offer just a few too many ostensible twists for its own good, but it seems to have a sense of humor about itself, something that is often sadly missing in contemporary comedies....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 100
Depth and dimension maintain a spectacular high point for the entire runtime, helped with a mild Dolby Vision pass....
Audio: 80
...
Extras: 80
All extras appear on the UHD and Blu-ray, including a pointless bonus feature introduction with Feig, all 17 seconds of it....
Movie: 86
A Simple Favor is in total understanding of what it’s riffing, begging women to break from preordained roles....
Total: 87
Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively satirize suburban America in the wickedly funny A Simple Favor, a dark and morbid tale with a wink....
Director: Paul Feig
Actors: Anna Kendrick, Blake Lively, Henry Golding
PlotStephanie Smothers, an enthusiastic yet lonely single mother and vlogger, befriends Emily Nelson, a sophisticated and mysterious public relations director. Their sons attend the same elementary school in Connecticut, and this connection sparks an unlikely friendship between the two contrasting women. Stephanie is captivated by Emily's glamorous lifestyle and unabashed confidence, while Emily is amused and intrigued by Stephanie's willingness to help and naive nature. The duo's bond deepens as they share secrets over martinis, and Stephanie admires Emily's seemingly perfect life with her husband, Sean, and their child.
One day, Emily asks Stephanie for a simple favor: pick her son up from school due to a work crisis. Stephanie obligingly agrees, but Emily's sudden disappearance thereafter throws her world into disarray. Concerned, Stephanie uses her vlogging platform to seek information about Emily's whereabouts. Meanwhile, she begins to dig into her friend's past, uncovering layers of complexity and secrets. As Stephanie becomes entrenched in the mystery, her relationship with Sean takes on a new dimension, leading her to question not only Emily's life but her own understanding of family, love, and trust.
Writers: Darcey Bell, Jessica Sharzer
Release Date: 14 Sep 2018
Runtime: 117 min
Rating: R
Country: Canada, United States
Language: English