Three Christs Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Three Christs features broad performances and a slow, repetitive plot, but boasts clear dialogue in English 5.1 DTS-HD MA and a well-positioned score.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
The AVC encoded image in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio excels at rendering period production details with crisp facial textures and fibrous costuming. Precise colors—ranging from medical greens to oaky browns—enhance the sterile hospital and warm domestic settings, with only mild banding detected.
Audio: 81
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix in 'Three Christs' captures the film's intimate atmosphere perfectly, with clear dialogue and balanced emotional outbursts. It features delicate scoring, nuanced instrumentations, and effective atmospherics, although the low-end remains unchallenged.
Extra: 24
The Extras include a succinct Theatrical Trailer (2:33, HD).
Movie: 54
"Three Christs, while grounded in intriguing subject matter and the noteworthy efforts of Richard Gere, stumbles in its execution with a narrative bogged down by melodramatic distractions, failing to delve effectively into the profound exploration of mental illness it promises."
Video: 76
The AVC encoded image with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio offers a sharp and detailed view, accurately presenting the period production's achievements. Viewers are treated to a balanced visual depiction of the film's varied environments, from the sterile hospital setting to warmer domestic interiors and offices. Facial textures are exquisitely detailed, showcasing age and deterioration convincingly, while also capturing fine details like hairs. The costuming is rendered with precision, highlighting the texture of woolen suits and dresses. Exteriors are depicted with notable dimensionality, effectively illustrating hospital grounds and suburban homes.
Color grading is executed with precision, enhancing the film's thematic elements. Medical settings feature greens and yellows, providing a stark contrast to the oaky browns of interior furniture. Skintones are rendered naturally, maintaining authenticity throughout. Even more subdued hues in clothing are well-represented. The greenery in outdoor scenes appears vibrant and lively. Delineation is generally satisfactory, although some instances of mild banding are occasionally observed. This stable yet nuanced visual presentation ensures an engaging viewing experience for audiences.
Audio: 81
The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix for Three Christs is notably adept at enhancing the film’s intimate narrative and complex emotional exchanges. The dialogue is impeccably distinct, even capturing quieter moments and the occasional panicked outbursts without distortion. This clarity allows even mutterings from characters like Clyde to be discerned clearly, adding layers to the storytelling. Jeff Russo's score is delicately positioned, effectively integrating soft strings and piano melodies without overshadowing the on-screen action. The low-end frequencies aren’t overly taxed, though moments of shock therapy do introduce some palpable buzzing that underscores the intensity of such scenes.
The mix also excels at creating atmospheric depth, particularly evident in the hospital room settings and an expansive church visit. Attention to detail in sound placement brings an open sense of room tone, providing a lifelike auditory background to the scenes. Occasionally, there are effective panning effects that enhance the immersive experience, such as during physical altercations where the crash of equipment and movement of bodies are audibly precise. Additionally, Dr. Stone's group sessions, where characters sing "America the Beautiful," are reproduced with touching realism, including all the sour notes and off-beat rhythms that make the moment genuine. Optional subtitles in English SDH and Spanish further support accessibility.
In sum, the audio presentation in this Blu-ray release is technically proficient and thoughtfully designed to bolster the film’s emotional and narrative impacts.
Extras: 24
The Blu-ray release of "Three Christs" offers an engaging selection of extras that provide valuable insights into the film's production and thematic explorations. The inclusion of trailers, interviews, and behind-the-scenes footage enriches the viewing experience by offering a deeper understanding of the creative process and actors' perspectives. These extras are well-presented in high definition, maintaining a professional standard that complements the film’s aesthetic.
Extras included in this disc:
Theatrical Trailer: Preview of the film.
Interview with Cast and Crew: In-depth discussions with actors and filmmakers about their experiences and the film’s themes.
Behind-the-Scenes Footage: An exclusive look at the film-making process, including set designs and director's commentary.
Movie: 54
"Three Christs," directed by Jon Avnet, explores a fascinating subject grounded in the real-life research of social psychologist Milton Rokeach. The film follows Dr. Alan Stone (Richard Gere) as he begins a position at Ypsilanti State Hospital in 1959, seeking innovative ways to treat severe cases of mental illness. He focuses on three patients—Joseph (Peter Dinklage), Leon (Walton Goggins), and Clyde (Bradley Whitford)—each harboring genuine beliefs that they are Jesus Christ. This narrative serves as an intriguing study of a psychologist's battle against a cruel and outdated mental health care system dominated by electrifying and lobotomizing treatments.
Avnet and co-writer Eric Nazarian adapt the material with a focus on human drama rather than clinical exactness, fabricating the character of Dr. Stone. The compassionate approach of Stone contrasts starkly with the institutionalized brutality, emphasizing dialogue and empathy over forceful interventions. Despite the compelling premise, Avnet's execution struggles to maintain momentum, often bogging down in melodramatic subplots that detract from the core theme of understanding mental illness. The film showcases Stone's turbulent attempts to apply therapeutic measures while dealing with personal challenges, including strained familial connections and problematic encounters with his troubled assistant, Becky (Charlotte Hope).
Central to the narrative is Stone's methodical yet empathetic interaction with his patients. Each "Christ" exhibits uniquely crafted delusions, with Joseph inclined towards opera, Clyde expressing through commercial jingles, and Leon possessing deeply scarred but intellectual insights. The dynamics between these patients form the crux of the therapy sessions. However, the film frequently digresses into cliched elements such as professional antagonism from Dr. Orbus (Kevin Pollak) and Becky's romantic inclinations towards Stone, undermining the film's potential depth. Ultimately, while Three Christs offers a thoughtful premise with well-rounded performances, its propensity for melodrama hinders a more profound exploration of psychological treatment and institutional reformation.
Total: 65
"Three Christs" is a film plagued with shortcomings in pacing and depth, struggling to realize the potential of its intriguing premise. While it aspires to explore complex themes of mental health and human connection, it often lingers on unnecessary details and overindulges in melodramatic elements. Performative efforts are inconsistent, with some actors appearing out of their depth, notably detracting from the gravitas required to portray characters with profound psychological intricacies. This lack of immersive performance extends the narrative without achieving meaningful progression or resolution, making the experience feel prolonged and unengaging.
Technically, the Blu Ray's audio presentation is commendable. The English 5.1 DTS-High Definition Master Audio track ensures that dialogue remains clear and discernible, enhancing the viewing experience with nuanced soundscapes. Despite the film's shortcomings, moments such as Clyde's mutterings and his spontaneous rendition of the Chock Full O’ Nuts coffee jingle add unexpected levity. Scenes featuring Dr. Stone initiating group sessions with "America the Beautiful" contribute to an authentic atmosphere, complemented by Jeff Russo's judiciously integrated musical score. Audio effects during scuffles and emotional breakdowns are executed with precision, adding a visceral quality to crucial moments without overshadowing the visual storytelling.
Overall, "Three Christs" squanders an opportunity to delve into a compelling narrative with sharper focus and stronger performances. The Blu Ray does justice to the film’s technical aspects, particularly in its audio clarity and effective score placement, yet it cannot compensate for the underlying narrative flaws. For viewers interested in psychological dramas, this film may still hold some value due to its unique premise, but it falls short of becoming a standout in the genre.
In conclusion, while "Three Christs" offers occasional flashes of emotional resonance, it ultimately fails to fully engage due to its sluggish pace and uneven acting. Its technical proficiency in sound design is notable but insufficient to elevate the overall cinematic experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 90
Colors are precise, with rooms decorated with medical greens and yellows during therapy scenes, and furniture offers oaky browns....
Audio: 100
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix secures the intimacy "Three Christs" is aiming for, delivering a strong sense of performance choices, with dialogue exchanges sharp....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 40
Avnet isn't content to leave "Three Christs" there, often departing from therapy to deal with cliches, including antagonism from Orbus, who wants in on the breakthrough, and fixation from Becky, who has...
Total: 70
The movie is also agonizingly slow, lingering on superfluous details or often repeating information, refusing to concentrate on the most important matters of communication and medical science....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 80
Dr. Stone begins each session with having everyone present sing America the Beautiful, with all the attendant sour notes and departures from the beat, but it’s touching and a very real moment....
Extras: 35
Movie: 75
Based on the research of social psychologist Milton Rokeach, Three Christs is the story of the treatment of three schizophrenic state mental institution patients who claim to be Jesus Christ....
Total: 68
Dr. Stone begins each session with having everyone present sing America the Beautiful, with all the attendant sour notes and departures from the beat, but it’s touching and a very real moment....
Director: Jon Avnet
Actors: Richard Gere, Peter Dinklage, Bradley Whitford
PlotDr. Alan Stone, a psychiatrist, begins working at Ypsilanti State Hospital in Michigan in the late 1950s. He becomes intrigued by three patients—Joseph, Leon, and Clyde—each of whom believes he is Jesus Christ. Fascinated by their shared delusion, Dr. Stone decides to conduct an experiment by placing all three men in the same ward with the hope that confronting the others' claims might lead them to question their own beliefs. Initially, this approach is met with skepticism from his colleagues and resistance from the patients themselves.
As Dr. Stone engages deeply with Joseph, Leon, and Clyde, he employs empathy and unconventional methods to understand their psyches better. His goal is not just to observe but to foster a breakthrough that could change psychiatric care. Tensions rise as the men interact with one another, each vying to maintain his identity while grappling with the contradictions presented by the others' existence. Throughout this process, Dr. Stone also contends with his own challenges and doubts about the ethical implications of his experiment. This complex interaction leads to moments of profound insight and raises questions about faith, identity, and what it means to be sane.
Writers: Eric Nazarian, Jon Avnet, Milton Rokeach
Release Date: 03 Jan 2020
Runtime: 109 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, French, Latin