Phantasm II Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Phantasm II" by Scream Factory delivers a visually engaging experience with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The initial moments exhibit telecine wobble, notably impacting the Universal logo, but this is brief and does not detract from the overall viewing experience. Once past this, the visual elements are well-preserved. The color saturation is pleasing, although the inherent softness of 1980s low-budget productions is noticeable. Close-ups, however, are impressive with fine detail, especially evident in extreme close-ups. Contrast issues do subtly affect shadow details in darker scenes, though these are relatively minor concerns.

The transfer showcases significant improvements over previous editions, offering well-defined detailing in various elements such as furniture, architecture, and numerous wide shots. The clarity in shadows during poorly-lit sequences and nighttime scenes is commendable, adding depth to the visual narrative. Facial complexions appear natural and highly detailed, which enhances character-driven moments. Colors are vibrant, with primary hues standing out effectively. The contrast remains consistent, providing crisp whites and deep black levels that enhance overall image quality. An ultra-fine layer of grain is present throughout, contributing to the film's texture and authentic presentation. This high-definition transfer ensures that "Phantasm II" looks excellent on Blu-ray, making it a satisfying watch for fans and new viewers alike.

The audio presentation of "Phantasm II" on Blu-ray offers both DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and 2.0 mixes, providing an array of auditory experiences to suit varying listener preferences. The 5.1 mix delivers a widened soundstage, particularly shining during sequences involving the iconic silver spheres, which demonstrate impressive panning effects and add a dynamic element to the viewing experience. However, it's worth noting that the 5.1 track can feel somewhat front-heavy, with limited engagement of the rear channels, and occasional discrepancies in balance. Despite this, the clarity of dialogue remains robust and clear, ensuring an immersive cinematic journey marked by a wide dynamic range.

In contrast, the 2.0 DTS-HD stereo track appears to hew more closely to the film's original audio design, potentially offering a more authentic audio experience reflective of its era. Fans may find this option preferable for its naturalistic rendering of the front soundstage, where off-screen effects widen the soundfield effectively. Both the musical score and sound effects come through with excellent fidelity, although the 5.1 mix's immersive feel might tempt those seeking a modernized audio experience.

Overall, while the 5.1 mix provides a broader atmospheric quality, it occasionally suffers from imbalanced aspects such as low dialogue levels and overemphasized high-frequency moments. The bass is deep and effective for key scenes but may lack consistent oomph across the board. On the other hand, the 2.0 track offers straightforward clarity with a steady balance across all elements, proving satisfactory for those emphasizing audio authenticity and naturalism. Whether opting for the enhanced dynamics of the 5.1 mix or the nostalgic fidelity of the 2.0 track, "Phantasm II" on Blu-ray caters well to diverse listener preferences, ensuring a potent auditory experience.

The extras on the "Phantasm II" Blu-ray offer an engaging and technically sound look into the film’s production, peppered with entertaining anecdotes and insightful interviews. The commentary featuring director Don Coscarelli and actors Angus Scrimm and Reggie Bannister stands out as a highlight due to its conversational tone and depth of detail about the movie-making process. The feature-length documentary, "The Ball is Back," provides comprehensive coverage, including interviews with cast and crew. Makeup artist Greg Nicotero's segment in "The Gory Days" delves into special effects, albeit with lower visual quality due to upconversion. Fans will appreciate the deleted and workprint scenes, though the latter has noticeable technical limitations. Additionally, the inclusion of "Behind the Scenes" featurettes, trailers, and extensive still galleries further enriches this release, despite some navigation inconveniences.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Engaging discussion with director and actors.
• The Ball is Back: In-depth interviews and retrospectives.
• The Gory Days: Focus on makeup effects by Greg Nicotero.
• Deleted Scenes: Archived 35mm scenes.
• Workprint Scenes: Alternate and extended scenes.
• TV Spots: Series of promotional clips.
• Behind the Scenes: Makeup and effects work, on-set footage.
• Trailers: Promotional trailers from franchise films.
• Still Galleries: Behind the scenes, makeup & effects, posters & stills.
• Rare Short Film: Angus Scrimm as Abraham Lincoln.

"Phantasm II," a sequel to the 1979 cult classic "Phantasm," navigates its horror through a dreamlike narrative that often feels disjointed. While the film’s intention is to pick up where its predecessor left off, it recasts the central role of Mike with James LeGros instead of A. Michael Baldwin, introducing an immediate sense of disconnection for fans. The storyline, which involves the enigmatic Tall Man (Angus Scrimm) returning to torment Mike and new character Liz Reynolds (Paula Irvine), is muddied by continuity issues and convoluted plot points. This lo-fi horror entry tends to leave viewers puzzled, as it introduces numerous unanswered questions akin to a half-remembered nightmare.

Director Don Coscarelli, known for his eclectic ventures outside the horror genre, seems aware of the original's impact yet struggles to seamlessly integrate old and new footage. Mike's telepathic connection with Liz propels him from a psychiatric facility to reuniting with Reggie (Reggie Bannister), forming a makeshift team against the Tall Man's macabre schemes. Despite its rough edges, "Phantasm II" shifts into an entertaining mix of action-comedy and horror in its latter acts. Notable set pieces include weaponized metallic spheres and a humorous homage to Sam Raimi’s "Evil Dead," featuring chainsaw fights and inventive gore.

While not as creepy or tight as its predecessor, "Phantasm II" provides enough gory satisfaction and quirky humor to engage audiences familiar with the first film. Its final act delivers rewarding chaos and comical action, though the film's initial lack of coherence might challenge newcomers. This sequel remains an enjoyable albeit flawed experience, deeply rooted in the bizarre and nightmarish aesthetics that defined the original “Phantasm.”

"Phantasm II" Blu-ray, brought to you by Scream Factory, makes for an essential addition to any horror aficionado's collection. While the film may not boast the highest-grade video and audio quality, it compensates with its robust array of supplements. Writer and director Don Coscarelli returns to offer a fun, action-packed sequel to the cult classic, despite it not matching the strength or scares of the original. The sequel still delivers an engaging blend of action, comedy, and cartoony yet entertaining violence.

The Blu-ray presentation features a good, if unspectacular, video quality that remains enjoyable despite some evident logical inconsistencies in the film’s plot. Audio-wise, it's robust, enhancing the viewing experience significantly compared to previous releases. Remarkably, the package is filled with superb extras that eclipse even the Region 2 release, making for a comprehensive experience aimed at pleasing long-time fans.

In conclusion, while "Phantasm II" may never reach the benchmark set by its predecessor in terms of sheer terror, it excels in delivering a fun revisit to Coscarelli's unique world. The release might not be perfect due to its moderate audiovisual fidelity but shines with its supplementary content. This Blu-ray is a commendable revamp that successfully stays true to the spirit of the film and is heartily recommended for any horror cinema collection.