The Three Stooges Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray video presentation of "The Three Stooges" is commendable with its 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode, rendered in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The transfer boasts a well-defined image quality, featuring clear lines around the actors' hair and clothing. The film's grain structure remains unobtrusive, preserving the original cinematic feel without any digital noise reduction or overt edge enhancements. Notably, foliage and surrounding architecture are sharply detailed, and facial complexions appear naturally rendered. While some sequences are marginally softer, they are not detracting. Skin tones are stable and consistent throughout, maintaining a natural appearance.

Color wise, the Blu-ray presents the film with vibrant primary colors that add to its slapstick comedy charm, though occasionally verging on oversaturation, especially with the bright golf course greens. The transfer includes bold, richly-saturated primaries and secondary hues that contribute to an energetic appeal. Contrast levels are generally consistent with deep blacks and highlights that maintain detail without peaking, although some scenes exhibit slightly wavering brightness levels. These variations can result in occasional flattening of the image, but they do not significantly impact the overall viewing experience.

In sum, while not perfect, the high-definition presentation of "The Three Stooges" on Blu-ray is effective and faithful to the source material. Despite minor inconsistencies in sharpness and brightness, the transfer offers detailed and richly colored visuals that will satisfy fans of the film and provide an enjoyable viewing experience.

The audio presentation of the Blu-Ray edition of "The Three Stooges" showcases a proficient DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track. This mix ensures various audio elements collaborate effectively to create an engaging auditory experience. Rear channels, though not heavily utilized, present a subtle ambient layer with instances of directional effects such as cars moving between speakers and quiet background sounds from settings like orphanages and zoos. The iconic sound effects from the original Columbia-era Three Stooges shorts have been meticulously cleaned up and integrated, enhancing the authenticity of slapstick sequences. The score by John Debney, along with selective pop/rock inserts, provides adequate heft and clarity without overpowering the mix.

The dynamic range of the soundtrack is commendable, ensuring room-penetrating clarity and excellent channel separation in the front speakers, which create a warm and welcoming soundstage. Every distinct audio cue from physical comedy—thumps, bonks, slaps, and pings—is sharply rendered, contributing significantly to the humor and action on-screen. Moreover, the dialogue is neatly prioritized and consistently intelligible at the center, ensuring that every comedic line and sound is audible. While the low bass might not dominate, it delivers appropriately punchy responses fitting the genre's demands. Overall, this audio mix serves to enhance viewer engagement through a blend of nostalgic sound effects, clear dialogue, and well-balanced music.

For those requiring assistance or prefer alternative languages, the disc includes optional English SDH and Spanish subtitles, in addition to Spanish and French Dolby Digital 5.1 dubs. This comprehensive audio presentation underscores the mix's attention to detail and respect for the Three Stooges' legacy in creating an aurally appealing experience for both fans and new audiences alike.

The extras on the Blu-ray edition of "The Three Stooges" provide a compact yet insightful addition to the home viewing experience. The collection offers a mix of historical context, behind-the-scenes looks, casting insights, and an amusing montage of the hallmark slapstick humor synonymous with the iconic trio. Each featurette is presented in 1080p, ensuring high-quality visuals. Key highlights include a featurette on the meticulous effort to recreate the original sound effects and interviews with the cast and creators shedding light on the film’s development. The supplements are ported directly from the DVD release, ensuring all previously available content is preserved for this edition.

Extras included in this disc:

• Deleted/Extended Scenes: A collection of trimmed scenes.
• What's the Big Idea? A History of The Three Stooges: Historical context and justification for the film.
• Knuckleheads: Behind the Scenes of The Three Stooges: Production insights from the Farrellys.
• Did You Hear That? The Three Stooges Sound Effects: Exploration of sound effects creation.
• Poifect! Casting The Three Stooges: Interviews and casting process insights.
• The Three Stooges Mash-Up: Montage of slapstick moments.
• Original Screen Test: Actors' screen test footage.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original preview.

The Farrelly brothers' reboot of "The Three Stooges" has sparked mixed emotions among fans and critics. The film's premise of updating a classic slapstick trio in a contemporary setting seemed unnecessary to some, especially considering the cherished status of the original Moe, Larry, and Curly. While loyalists may fear a tarnishing of the Stooges' legacy, the film isn't without its redeeming qualities. The Farrellys have managed to deliver a few genuine laughs amidst a sea of gags, though some are cringeworthy. For instance, the cameo of "The Jersey Shore" cast appears as an awkward attempt to appeal to younger audiences unfamiliar with the original Stooges. The narrative, revolving around the trio's efforts to save an orphanage, serves merely as a vehicle for slapstick sequences, which include elements ranging from chainsaw mishaps to outrageous maternity ward antics.

Casting is one area where the film succeeds, with Chris Diamantopoulos (Moe), Sean Hayes (Larry), and Will Sasso (Curly) delivering commendable performances that capture the essence of their iconic characters. Their portrayals evoke a sense of nostalgia, even if the material they're given doesn't always hit the mark. Sofia Vergara and Craig Bierko's subplots add unnecessary distractions but are partially redeemed by Larry David's hilarious turn as Sister Mary-Mengele. Despite these performances, the film's humor often feels forced and fails to reach the timeless quality of the original Stooges' antics.

In an attempt to modernize, the film introduces gimmicks such as Moe's ill-fated stint on "Jersey Shore" and various social media puns that fall flat. The decision to shoot in color rather than opting for a retro black-and-white aesthetic may have cost the film some of its potential charm. However, one clever touch is the structuring of the movie into three segments resembling the original short films, complete with title cards and iconic music. This element provides a heartfelt homage to the legendary trio, though it can’t quite compensate for the rest of the film’s shortcomings. Ultimately, while the film pays tribute to The Three Stooges, it struggles to balance respecting their legacy with making them relevant for new generations.

The Farrelly brothers' contemporary rendition of "The Three Stooges" is an attempt to bring classic slapstick comedy to a new generation. While this reboot may not fully satisfy diehard fans of the original trio, it offers a few moments of genuine humor likely to appeal to families seeking lighthearted entertainment. The production excels in high-definition, delivering crisp visuals and robust audio, although the accompanying special features are somewhat lacking, despite being predominantly high-definition exclusives.

The film itself presents as a well-intentioned homage to the iconic comedy act, surpassing initial low expectations for many viewers. While it might not attain the genius of the original shorts, there are instances of charm and comedic timing that provide intermittent amusement. However, many will find it difficult to justify more than a single viewing, given its uneven pacing and occasionally tedious narrative.

In conclusion, "The Three Stooges" on Blu-ray is best approached with tempered expectations. It provides a capable blend of nostalgia and modern film quality, albeit falling short in supplemental content and depth. Ideal for a one-time family rental, it offers brief respite and a nostalgic nod without the enduring appeal of its namesake.