Someone Is Bleeding Blu-ray Review
Les seins de glace
Score: 68
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Kino Lorber's release of 'Someone Is Bleeding' is a technically flawed 4K master, though insightful commentary reveals depth in Lautner's adaptation.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
A 4K restoration of 'Someone Is Bleeding,' presented on Blu-ray in 1080p MPEG-4 AVC with a 1.67:1 aspect ratio, struggles with muted colors and low contrast due to light diffusion, yielding an anemic look. Image stability is excellent, yet some details appear overly crushed, marring its potential vibrancy.
Audio: 75
Someone Is Bleeding's Blu-ray audio presentation offers French and English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 tracks with optional English subtitles; while both suffer 1970s-era limitations, the dialogue remains clear, and Philippe Sarde's impactful, though unsubtle, score maintains tension in the film.
Extra: 56
The commentary track, led by Lautner enthusiast Berger alongside Mitchell and Thompson, delivers an engaging exploration of Georges Lautner's work, the unique adaptation of Richard Matheson's story in French cinema, and the innovative use of humor and cinematography, enriched by intriguing interpretations of narrative perspectives.
Movie: 69
Icy Breasts on Blu-ray offers a complex narrative with unexpected character dynamics, featuring Delon in a less dominant role. Lautner's direction and the adaptation from Matheson's novel struggle to weave together murder mystery and psychological depth, yet the intrigue remains compelling. Region-A only, with new commentary.
Video: 67
The Blu-ray release of "Someone Is Bleeding," presented in a 1.67:1 aspect ratio and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC for a 1080p transfer, offers an intriguing look at the film's visual presentation. While it boasts a 4K restoration from the original camera negative, the results are mixed. Certain scenes exhibit muted colors and less contrast due to the original cinematographic choices, such as the use of light diffusion filters, which invoke a softer image with varied grain appearance. While some shots shine in sharp detail and well-defined grain, others suffer from heavy crushing and a flat appearance, possibly due to problematic grading decisions that might contradict the benefits of a 4K remastering.
In terms of technical specifics, despite the meticulous restoration process undertaken, primary colors appear desaturated and the dynamic range appears lackluster, which might suggest a need for further remastering. On occasion, the visuals convey a falsely applied denoising effect, detracting from potential vibrancy. This dynamic is particularly disheartening as some scenes hint at the breathtaking visual potential achievable through a more refined approach.
Despite these concerns, it should be noted that the image stability is commendable throughout most of the feature, with minimal scratches and only minor instability issues observed during the closing credits. Ultimately, this Blu-ray edition remains a true reflection of its original artistic intent, albeit without the dazzling impact that might have been anticipated given its high-resolution restoration pedigree. However, to access this Region-A locked edition, users must utilize a Region-A or Region-Free player.
Audio: 75
The audio presentation of the "Someone Is Bleeding" Blu-ray incorporates two main tracks: French DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, with the option for English subtitles on the French track. Both tracks exemplify the typical fidelity constraints expected from their 1970s origin. Unfortunately, this results in an overall underwhelming auditory experience. The French track, considered the original, exhibits uneven and weak sound quality, raising questions about its production choices. The English dubbing is similarly average, struggling to deliver a compelling aural performance.
Despite these limitations, dialogue clarity is consistently maintained, ensuring that pivotal verbal exchanges are not lost to poor mixing. A notable element of the audio is Philippe Sarde's score, which resonates with a more vibrant presence, enhancing the film's tension. Though it lacks subtlety, this score contributes significantly to the atmospheric immersion. While audio purists might find the tracks lacking in warmth and depth, the clear dialogue and dynamic scoring represent redeeming aspects of the presentation.
In essence, this Blu-ray's audio tracks reflect their historical context, embracing both the strengths in dialogic articulation and the weaknesses inherent in their period-specific mixing techniques.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "Someone Is Bleeding" provide a comprehensive and enlightening addition to the viewing experience. The standout feature is an exclusive audio commentary by critics Howard S. Berger, Steve Mitchell, and Nathaniel Thompson. Berger, a known Lautner aficionado, leads an engaging discussion, exploring the film’s conception, the influence of Michel Audiard on Georges Lautner, and Alain Delon's career trajectory. They delve into the nuances of French humor and its translation challenges, and examine the unique adaptation of Richard Matheson's work in French cinema. Noteworthy is a discussion on the film's narrative structure, with Thompson offering a provocative interpretation of the opening scenes that may illuminate the cinematography's distinct aesthetic. Overall, this commentary is both insightful and entertaining for genre enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: Exclusive track by critics Berger, Mitchell, and Thompson covering film conception, influences, and structural analysis.
- Cover: Reversible cover featuring vintage poster art.
Movie: 69
Georges Lautner's "Icy Breasts," also known as "Les Seins de Glace" (1974), comes to Blu-ray with a minimalist set of features, notably an engaging audio commentary. This psychological thriller, adapted from Richard Matheson's novel "Someone is Bleeding," intricately crafts its narrative around the enigmatic character dynamics and perplexing murder conspiracies. Although Alain Delon's popularity is exploited in vintage promotional materials, the film concentrates on an elaborate relationship triangle involving Francois Rollin (Claude Brasseur), Peggy Lister (Mireille Darc), and her lawyer, Marc Rilson (Alain Delon).
Delon's casting was a strategic choice due to his European box office appeal in the 1970s, despite him not serving as the central figure in this production. The film relies heavily on Brasseur's portrayal of a solitary, lovelorn writer entangled with the elusive Peggy, whose tragic past and questionable actions draw Delon’s Rilson into the fray. This plot constructs a theatrical tension where Delon's presence is utilized not to dominate the narrative but to intensify its complexity.
The adaptation shifts significant focus from the dissociative identity aspects of Matheson's novel to a more conspicuous murder subplot. This pivot complicates character engagement and may dilute thematic intent, ultimately challenging mainstream expectations of Delon's overpowering screen presence. Lautner's direction grapples with harmonizing the murder and psychological threads, inadvertently sidelining Delon’s lawyer character until it is almost too late, leading to a convoluted resolution. Consequently, "Icy Breasts" is a peculiar blend of cerebral disturbance and thriller archetypes, maintaining intrigue yet hampered by narrative cohesion issues.
Total: 68
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "Someone Is Bleeding," also known as "Icy Breasts," presents a compelling though flawed piece from Alain Delon's 1970s filmography. The adaptation is marred by mishandling, possibly by director Georges Lautner, who seems to have struggled with Richard Matheson's original material. The 4K master sourced from StudioCanal lacks conviction, affecting the visual presentation. The narrative, while rich with potential, does not match Delon's typical role selection quality from the era, hinting at a disconnect between the actor's prowess and the film’s final execution.
The accompanying commentary features insights from film historians Berger, Mitchell, and Thompson. Their expertise enriches the viewing experience by exploring Michel Audiard's influence on Lautner's screenplay, specifically noting the challenges in translating its humor. They highlight how this humor exposes the protagonist’s vulnerabilities, providing a unique juxtaposition in the film’s serious tone. Their discussions on shifting viewpoints throughout, and potential intentions behind Lautner's cinematographic choices, offer viewers an intriguing lens through which to reassess the work.
In conclusion, while "Someone Is Bleeding" might not be the pinnacle of Alain Delon's 1970s ventures, it remains a point of interest for devoted followers of his film legacy and French crime cinema enthusiasts. Approach with tempered expectations; although the film itself might not reach its full narrative potential, the packaged insights from seasoned commentators make this Blu-ray release worth engaging with for a deeper understanding of its place within both Delon’s career and Lautner’s directorial repertoire.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 60
Predictably, the native dynamic range of the visuals is unconvincing as well, with some areas actually creating the false impression that some heavy denoising has been applied (see screencapture #20)....
Audio: 80
But the French track, which ought to be considered the original track, is pretty uneven and anemic as well....
Extras: 40
The bulk of the information addresses the film's conception and the original material that inspired it, the drama that is chronicled in it, Georges Lautner's body of work, and Alain Delon's career....
Movie: 60
Lautner's direction bridges the murder conspiracy and the mental overlapping in a very unconvincing manner and ultimately creates the impression that Delon's character is welcomed only because he is needed...
Total: 60
Even if you are a very forgiving admirer of Alain Delon's work, approach Icy Breasts with caution because it is the weakest film he made during the 1970s....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 90
Much of Icy Breasts was shot with light diffusion filters, so the image is often softer with less contrast, and the appearance of the grain can vary somewhat....
Audio: 85
While the fidelity shares the typical limitations of the era, the dialogue is always clear and the striking score by Phillipe Sarde really stands out....
Extras: 80
They talk about the way that French screenwriter Michel Audiard influenced Lautner in using humorous dialogue which doesn’t always translate well into other languages, including the untranslatable double...
Movie: 85
Since Rilson is also obsessed with her and uses all of the means at his disposal to keep her under his control, her actual guilt or innocence remains an open question even as more bodies begin to pile...
Total: 85
They talk about the way that French screenwriter Michel Audiard influenced Lautner in using humorous dialogue which doesn’t always translate well into other languages, including the untranslatable double...
Director: Georges Lautner
Actors: Alain Delon, Mireille Darc, Claude Brasseur
PlotFrançois, a novelist seeking inspiration for his next book, crosses paths with the enigmatic Peggy, a beautiful and troubled woman haunted by her past. Their chance encounter blossoms into a passionate affair, and François finds himself drawn into her complex world. Peggy confesses to François her fears of being pursued by a mysterious figure, leaving François to grapple with how much of her paranoia is imagined versus real. As he delves deeper, his own world begins to unravel. Disturbing events, including threatening phone calls and attacks, escalate tensions as François teeters between disbelief and the gravity of Peggy’s claims. The people around François become entangled in this dark web when his acquaintance Marc—a journalist known for his sharp instincts—decides to help investigate. Though skeptical, Marc suspects there is more to Peggy's troubles than meets the eye.
François becomes increasingly fixated on uncovering the truth about Peggy’s past, a dangerous obsession that drives a wedge between him and those who care for him. The tension builds as hidden motives begin to emerge, painting a tangled picture of manipulation, fear, and death. As the lines blur between fiction and reality, François must choose whether to trust his instincts or the cautionary warnings from those who doubt Peggy's story. With each revelation, he edges closer to a perilous discovery, risking not only his sanity but also his life as he races against time to uncover the jarring truths shadowing Peggy’s frantic life and his.
Writers: Richard Matheson, Georges Lautner
Release Date: 28 Aug 1974
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: R
Country: France, Italy
Language: French