Peter Pan Blu-ray Review
Diamond Edition | Three Disc
Score: 79
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Peter Pan's Blu-ray release is a must-have, offering stunning video, strong DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1, and extensive special features, brilliantly remastering a timeless classic.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 77
Peter Pan’s Blu-ray 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer shines with vibrant colors, deep blacks, and excellent detail, thanks to meticulous digital restoration. While the near-total removal of grain and subtle tweaks to the original presentation may irk purists, the transfer remains a visual delight that retains the spirit of 1950s animation.
Audio: 76
Disney’s DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track for 'Peter Pan' superbly balances dialogue, sound effects, and music, broadening the soundstage with seamless integration of rear channel atmospherics while retaining the original audio's integrity; however, the lack of a lossless mono option is a missed opportunity.
Extra: 83
Packed with enriching extras such as Diane Disney-Miller's heartfelt introduction, Roy Disney’s comprehensive audio commentary, and the delightful 'Growing up with Nine Old Men' documentary, this edition features HD versions of new and classic content, offering an immersive and nostalgic dive into every facet of 'Peter Pan.'
Movie: 90
Peter Pan's timeless magic, hand-drawn artistry, and beloved adaptation of J.M. Barrie's tale continue to captivate, despite dated racial depictions; the Blu-ray release highlights its vibrant animation and enduring appeal, solidifying its place in Disney's golden age canon.
Video: 77
Disney's Blu-ray release of "Peter Pan" presents a 1080p/AVC-encoded video transfer that's both a marvel and a point of contention among enthusiasts. The new transfer is notably clean, thanks to a meticulous digital restorative process. This decision to significantly reduce the film grain results in an exceptionally pristine picture that showcases vibrant color saturation and striking blues. Whites appear crisp and dynamic, while black levels are deep and robust, enriching the visual depth of the 1.33:1 framed image. The line work of the animators is precise, with stable color fills and preserved detail in the brushstroke textures of the hand-painted backgrounds. However, this grain removal has sparked debate among purists who feel that some original texture and authenticity might have been lost.
Despite these concerns, the benefits of the high-definition restoration are evident. London's night sky now displays a sumptuous blue, and the greenery of Neverland comes alive in rich, lush hues. Detail enhancement allows viewers to appreciate the meticulous design of each animated character. Additionally, contrast and brightness levels are well-balanced, providing excellent dynamic range with luminance and chromatic elements properly delineated. Notably absent are digital artifacts and compression issues, ensuring a clean viewing experience free from banding or aliasing. While Disney's choice to prioritize a 'renewed' visual experience over a 'classic' preservation might not satisfy all, it undoubtedly offers an impressive and visually stunning presentation for modern audiences.
Audio: 76
Disney has delivered an exceptional audio experience for the "Peter Pan" Blu-ray with a new DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 channel surround mix. This presentation highlights the fine details in dialogue, sound effects, and music while maintaining a balanced frontal perspective. Rear channel atmospherics are skillfully integrated, broadening the soundstage naturally. The film's musical numbers take center stage in this enriching surround experience, supported perfectly by the crystal-clear audio. Notably, the encoding shows no residual edginess or signs of age, speaking volumes about the care put into this restoration.
The DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track excels in precision, rarely deviating from the film's original sound design. Directional effects are subtle yet effectively playful, with environments like caves rendered immersive through acoustic flourishes. Low-frequency effects (LFE) are restrained but impactful, adding weight where needed. Dialogue remains clear and intelligible despite the film's age, and the score and songs envelop the listener beautifully. However, while a 192kbps Dolby Digital mono mix is included, the absence of a lossless mono option disappoints purists.
In expanding the soundscape to an eight-channel setup, Disney has created an environment where directionality shines. Dialogue and sound effects move seamlessly through various channels, offering realistic auditory cues that enhance key sounds such as cannon blasts and Hook’s menacing crocodile tick-tocks. Action sequences come alive with ambient noise filling the rear and side channels, making scenes like Hook skipping across water particularly impressive. Regardless of its mono origins, Disney's 7.1 mix is remarkably well-executed, though the lack of a lossless mono option remains a noticeable omission for audiophiles.
Overall, Disney's perfectionist restoration efforts extend beyond visuals to deliver an immersive and lively audio experience. While purists may miss a lossless mono option, the 7.1 mix offers an incredibly engaging and superior audio experience that brings new life to this classic film.
Extras: 83
The Blu-ray edition of "Peter Pan" delivers an extensive and high-quality collection of extras, including both new content and classic features from previous releases. Diane Disney Miller's introduction provides a personal touch, while Roy Disney's audio commentary offers in-depth insights, enhanced by interviews with the animators and voice actors. The 41-minute documentary "Growing Up with Nine Old Men" is a compelling exploration of Disney's legendary animators through the eyes of their children. Deleted scenes and songs offer additional context to the production. Classic DVD features such as behind-the-scenes documentaries, music selections, and sing-along tracks further enrich the viewing experience. Notably, the Disney Intermission feature adds interactive fun with mini-games whenever the movie is paused. High-definition presentations elevate these extras, ensuring both technical excellence and engaging content for all fans.
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction by Diane Disney Miller: Brief introduction to the film.
- Audio Commentary: Roy Disney with interviews and insights.
- Growing Up with Nine Old Men: Documentary on Disney's pioneering animators.
- Deleted Songs and Scenes: Includes storyboard presentations and concept art.
- Backstage Disney Features: Five behind-the-scenes featurettes from the Platinum Edition DVD.
- Music & More: Song selections and music videos.
- Disney Intermission: Interactive games and activities during movie pauses.
- Peter Pan Sing-Along: Optional subtitle feature for singing along.
- DisneyView Side Bars: Artwork fills black side bars in the classic 1.33:1 aspect ratio.
Movie: 90
Walt Disney’s "Peter Pan" remains an enduring classic of animated cinema, showcasing the legendary craftsmanship of the Nine Old Men. This film transports audiences to the whimsical world of Never Land, where Peter Pan (Bobby Driscoll), Wendy Darling (Kathryn Beaumont), and Tinker Bell (Margaret Kerry) embark on an adventure brimming with magical escapades and colorful characters. Released in 1953, during Disney's golden age of animation, the movie features beautifully expressive hand-drawn animation and lushly painted backgrounds that frame exhilarating scenes of flying, singing, and swordplay. This adaptation takes creative liberties with J.M. Barrie's original story, particularly regarding characters' dynamics and motivations, but it captures the timeless wonder and childlike innocence integral to the tale.
Despite its age, Peter Pan's animation and storytelling continue to captivate new generations. The character designs and rich settings—ranging from London to the captivating Never Land—are brought to life with meticulous detail and vibrant artistry. The conflict between Peter Pan and Captain Hook (Hans Conried), along with the involvement of the Lost Boys and Tiger Lily (Corinne Orr), delivers a narrative filled with thrilling action and readily recognizable heroes and villains. Though some elements—such as the depiction of Native Americans—are now viewed through a more critical lens, these aspects offer an opportunity for historical discussion rather than being grounds for censorship.
The film’s influence extends beyond its release, setting a standard for subsequent adaptations of Barrie’s work. Its memorable characters and adventurous spirit make it a beloved tale that continues to resonate. For those revisiting or experiencing it for the first time, Peter Pan’s heartwarming story and enchanting visuals ensure it endures as one of Disney's most cherished animated features—a testament to the magic of traditional, hand-drawn animation in an age dominated by CGI.
Total: 79
Disney's "Peter Pan" on Blu-ray remains an enduring marvel in the animation world, retaining its charm as a timeless spectacle that has captivated audiences for decades. This Diamond Edition offers a brilliantly remastered video presentation, made slightly different from its original source material, but enhanced to breathtaking levels. The 1080p transfer brings vibrant colors and sharp details that do wonders for the film's classic animation. Complemented with a strong DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track, the audio experience is fully immersive, capturing every whimsical sound and musical cue with pristine clarity.
The Blu-ray release of "Peter Pan" also shines in its special features, which total over four hours. These extras provide an in-depth look into the making of the film, showcasing the creative processes and historical context that brought this beloved story to life. Additionally, Disney has wisely chosen to preserve certain controversial elements of the film, rather than revising them entirely, offering a product that remains authentic to its original vision.
In conclusion, this Blu-ray edition of "Peter Pan" is essential for any Disney aficionado or animation enthusiast. The combination of top-notch video and audio quality with expansive special features ensures a delightful viewing experience. This release serves as a beautiful reminder to cherish our youthful imagination and embrace the joy inherent in classic storytelling. Don’t miss out – this is a must-own piece of cinematic history. Order your copy today!
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
The results will delight most and mildly irritate a few; the few being those who feel the complete absence of grain and the slight (stress on slight) alterations made to the film's original color and contrast...
Audio: 90
Though the rear speakers wrap the sounds of Never Land around the listener, it doesn't feel like a betrayal and is always executed with the utmost respect for the audio elements....
Extras: 80
Deleted Songs and Scenes (HD, 15 minutes): Unearthed from the Disney Vault, two deleted scenes and two deleted songs, presented via original storyboards, concept art, rough cel elements and key frames:...
Movie: 90
It's a high-flying, swashbuckling adventure in the true spirit of the original and, in many ways, was the first production, on stage or off, to lend a thrillingly palpable sense of magic, grandeur and...
Total: 90
Backed by a stunning video presentation (albeit one slightly altered from its source), a strong DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track, and well over four hours of special features, the new Diamond Edition...
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 90
Despite the fact that they take the time to not just restore but erase the film grain from the images as well as alter some of the colors, it looks marvelous nonetheless....
Extras: 100
Movie: 95
Almost none of the latter adaptations of the story aren’t influenced at least a little by the film, which is a real testament to how much it has endured....
Total: 95
It reminds us all to be young and have fun once in a while, and with this Blu-ray, you’re bound to have plenty of fun....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There may be arguments that Disney has tinkered a bit too much with the original look of the film – for example the clean picture exhibits little to no grain – so be warned that you may feel differently...
Audio: 80
Culled from a mono source Disney creates a realistic surround sound environment like it has with other movies like 'Snow White.'...
Extras: 60
"The Pirate Song," "Never Land: The Lost Song," a music video featuring Paige O'Hara for "Never Land," and a really terrible music video featuring T-Squad singing "The Second Star to the Right."...
Movie: 80
Looking back on the movies that came before, 'Peter Pan' is definitely one of the most exciting....
Total: 80
They could have easily recolored the redness of the Indians in the film and decided not to....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
This film has undergone a digital restorative process and the results may very well depend on your point of view....
Audio: 88
I utilized the surround mix which is a well balanced presentation that features high level detail in a resplendent blend of dialogue, sound effects, and music that maintains a frontal perspective with...
Extras: 80
Optional film introduction by Diane Disney Miller Disney view Disney intermission Sing-a-long with the movie (with lyrics) feature (HD) Growing up with nine old men – 41 minute documentary hosted by Ted...
Movie: 90
The classic tale that taught us all “to believe” and first introduced us to the Darling children – Wendy, John and Michael - as they flew with Peter Pan and Tinker Bell past the second star to the right...
Total: 87
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-103 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The film’s grain has been pretty much removed which will no doubt infuriate purists, but honestly, it has only helped the overall picture quality and hasn’t had any detrimental side effect to the rest...
Audio: 100
While Disney has included a Dolby Digital mono mix for the purists, I’d recommend listening to the stellar 7.1 mix instead as it is incredibly good and offers a better audio experience....
Extras: 100
As usual, this Diamond Edition is jam-packed with extras, some new and some carried over from the previous DVD, all combined to cover just about every aspect of the film....
Movie: 100
Peter orders Tink to take the others to their secret hideout while he distracts Hook, but Tink has other plans as she abandons the kids and races home to tell Peter’s followers, The Lost Boys, to attack...
Total: 100
The audio and video quality is stellar and the extras are also excellent and do just what they should do – they give you a look at how much work went into making the movie and the evolution of its production....
Director: Clyde Geronimi, Wilfred Jackson, Hamilton Luske
Actors: Bobby Driscoll, Kathryn Beaumont, Hans Conried
PlotIn the heart of London, the Darling family children—Wendy, John, and Michael—entertain themselves with stories of Peter Pan, a boy who refuses to grow up. One starry night, Peter himself flies into their nursery, seeking his rebellious shadow that Wendy had found earlier. Accompanied by his feisty fairy companion Tinker Bell, Peter is enchanted by Wendy's storytelling and invites her and her brothers to join him in Neverland, a magical place where children can remain young forever. With a sprinkle of pixie dust, Peter gives the children the ability to fly, and they set off on an adventure across the London sky.
Upon arrival in Neverland, the Darling children are introduced to a fantastical world full of mermaids, Native Americans, and pirates led by the notorious Captain Hook. Hook bears a grudge against Peter for cutting off his hand and feeding it to a crocodile. As Peter navigates the Darling siblings through the wonders and dangers of Neverland, they meet Peter's band of Lost Boys and engage in playful escapades. However, tensions rise as Tinker Bell becomes jealous of Wendy's presence, and Hook plots his revenge against Peter, leading to thrilling confrontations and heroic rescues.
Writers: J.M. Barrie, Ted Sears, Erdman Penner
Release Date: 05 Feb 1953
Runtime: 77 min
Rating: G
Country: United States
Language: English, American Sign