My Samurai Blu-ray Review
Score: 37
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
My Samurai is a low-budget Karate Kid wannabe with subpar writing and performances, though MVD Rewind's Blu-ray extras may appeal to nostalgic viewers.
Disc Release Date
Video: 51
My Samurai on Blu-ray by MVD Rewind presents a mixed quality AVC 1080p transfer in 1.78:1—vivid colors and sharp resolution clash with significant grain, fading, and mosquito noise, especially in darker scenes and dojo sequences, likely due to the use of a secondary, cheaper film stock.
Audio: 12
The audio presentation of 'My Samurai' Blu-ray is significantly lacking, with persistent hiss, static, and muffled dialogue buried beneath noise despite its PCM format, resulting in one of the worst audio experiences on this format and necessitating subtitles due to poor fidelity and noticeable echo.
Extra: 66
The 'My Samurai' Blu-ray extras include insightful interviews, notably a 24-minute session with Jim Turner, and a 45-minute discussion featuring Julian Lee and Mark Steven Grove. A unique VHS cut and comprehensive photo galleries enhance this rich offering.
Movie: 21
My Samurai, clearly a nostalgic cash-in on The Karate Kid's success, lacks major star power and depth. Despite the presence of actors like Terry O’Quinn and Mako, it falters with clunky fight scenes and forgettable performances, rendering it more a curiosity piece than a martial arts gem.
Video: 51
The Blu-ray presentation of "My Samurai" by MVD Rewind offers an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, showcasing a duality of visual quality. On one hand, the film’s color palette pops with elements like bright blues and resolute reds, particularly in well-lit sequences, and it reveals commendable facial details in close-ups as well as urban textures in exterior shots. The contrasting and depth attributes are generally satisfactory, bringing out impressive visual energy reminiscent of the '90s. However, the transfer is not without its notable drawbacks.
The primary issue lies in the source material, which appears faded and skewed towards a brownish tint. Graininess is present throughout the film; while a common trait for lower-budget films utilizing cheaper stocks, the grain presents here with a distractingly dense and noisy quality. This results in inconsistent visual fidelity, where dimly lit scenes suffer from blocky and near pixellated disturbances due to the overwhelming grain field. In particular, dojo scenes exhibit pronounced mosquito noise that significantly detracts from overall image clarity. Furthermore, red hues often shift to orange due to the aging material, and this color drifting bears mentioning for those particularly sensitive to color accuracy.
In summary, the video quality of "My Samurai" on Blu-ray oscillates between moments of striking detail and frustrating noise issues, largely determined by the varying conditions in each scene. While certain well-lit sequences demonstrate impressive contrast and depth, the pervasive grain and color inconsistencies will be noticeable to discerning viewers. Fans of the film may appreciate the nostalgic presentation despite these technical challenges.
Audio: 12
The audio presentation of "My Samurai" on Blu-ray is notably subpar for an MVD Rewind release. It is marred by significant audio defects that detract from the viewing experience. The track is plagued with a pervasive hiss and other noise artifacts, which severely impinge on dialogue clarity and overall fidelity. Much of the dialogue is buried beneath this audio interference, to the point of being nearly unintelligible. Occasional surges in the synth-laden score manage to rise above the background noise, but these moments are few and far between.
Despite the PCM format, the track fails to deliver a coherent audio experience. There is a persistent static that obliterates fidelity and makes dialogue sound echoey and unclear. The need for subtitles becomes necessary due to strong accents and the muffled nature of the audio. High frequencies are either overly strained or dulled, and there is a notable absence of any substantial low-end frequencies, making the overall audio presentation feel flat and lifeless. This release would have benefitted significantly from a thorough audio restoration process to address these glaring issues.
Extras: 66
The extras on the Blu-ray release of "My Samurai" offer a substantial look behind the scenes and expand on the movie’s context. Key features include an insightful 45-minute interview with stars Julian Lee and Mark Steven Grove, where they delve into their careers and share Lee’s compelling story of leaving Korea. Actor Jim Turner’s 24-minute feature stands out as he watches his scenes for the first time, providing genuine reactions. Christophe Clark provides an additional 28-minute interview. The disc includes engaging photo galleries that advance automatically, though viewers may want their remotes handy to linger on specific images. Fans will also find value in the alternate original VHS cut, presented in 480i, along with trailers for "My Samurai" and other MVD releases. The package is further enhanced by the inclusion of a folded mini-poster.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Stars Julian Lee and Mark Steven Grove: Career highlights and personal stories.
- 'Watching My Scenes' with Actor Jim Turner: Actor's first-time reactions to his scenes.
- Interview with Actor Christophe: In-depth discussion about the movie.
- Photo Gallery: Automatically advancing images.
- Julian Lee Personal Photo Gallery: Additional images from Julian Lee.
- Alternate Original VHS Cut: An extended version of the film.
- Trailers: "My Samurai" and other MVD releases.
Movie: 21
"My Samurai" is a curious homage to 80s martial arts films, seeking nostalgia reminiscent of "The Karate Kid." However, having been shot well before its 1992 release, it sometimes feels more like an opportunistic follow-up than an organic tribute. The movie features John Kallo as Peter McCrea, a young boy who witnesses a gangland murder and is subsequently protected by his martial arts mentor Young Park (Julian Lee). While the plot sets up an intriguing dynamic between mentor and student, it lacks the depth and character development found in its more famous predecessors. Instead, the film opts for a series of frenetic battle scenes, which while energetic, struggle to compensate for the hollow emotional core and underdeveloped characters.
The cast includes some familiar faces like Terry O'Quinn and Mako, yet their roles are surprisingly underutilized. Mako's portrayal of an Asian mafia leader and O’Quinn’s depiction of a largely absent father add minimal substance to the movie. The supporting cast, including Lynne Hart as Deborah, fails to elevate the film beyond its low-budget trappings. Some attempts at humor, including a recurring gag where Deborah dismisses Taekwondo as "too violent," fall flat amidst the chaotic action sequences. Although the film throws in social commentary about Japanese corporate influence in America, these moments feel tacked on rather than integral to the plot.
The technical execution of "My Samurai" leaves much to be desired. Action scenes are clumsily staged, with poorly executed stunts and evident missed punches that detract from any intended thrills. The use of dated elements, such as colorful wigs on street gang members, feels anachronistic and disconnected from the film's more serious undertones. Ultimately, despite its attempts at martial arts choreography and cultural relevance, "My Samurai" more closely resembles a quaint relic of early 90s direct-to-video releases rather than a cherished classic.
Total: 37
MVD Rewind's Blu-ray release of "My Samurai" offers a nostalgic look at a lesser-known 90s martial arts film. This title, often overshadowed by more prominent releases of the era, attempts to ride the coattails of fan favorites like "The Karate Kid" and "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles." Unfortunately, it struggles to capture the charm and energy that made those films enduring classics. The narrative feels contrived, with a storyline hampered by a shoestring budget and subpar writing. Performances across the board fail to lift the script, leading to many scenes that lack the emotional impact they strive for.
From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray transfer is a mixed bag. Video quality is uneven, with certain sequences suffering from grainy textures and faded colors indicative of the original source material's condition. Audio clarity is passable, but it doesn't offer the robust experience that modern audiences might expect from high-definition media. However, MVD Rewind deserves commendation for their commitment to preserving these cult films with care and diligence. The included supplements—though perhaps not enough to sway casual viewers—provide additional value for serious collectors and those fond of this niche genre.
In conclusion, "My Samurai" is an oddity that will likely appeal to a narrow audience nostalgic for early 90s martial arts films. Its attempt to emulate more successful franchises results in a diminished product that lacks vitality and coherence. Though its technical merits are spotty, MVD Rewind has gone the extra mile by supplying some engaging supplements for enthusiasts. Despite these efforts, it remains difficult to foresee significant demand for this title beyond hardcore collectors and those with specific affection for this period in cinema history.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 60
While some aspects of this transfer look at least relatively decent, including elements of the palette like bright blues, the source looks fairly faded, skewed toward brown, and also appears to be a secondary...
Audio: 40
I'm not sure what source was used, since this release doesn't offer the provenance of technical aspects, but this track is slathered in hiss and other noise, to the point that actual dialogue seems to...
Extras: 60
Interview with Actor Christophe (1080p; 28:40) Photo Gallery (1080i) is authored without a timecode, but does advance automatically so have your Pause button on your remote handy if you want to linger...
Movie: 30
There's little doubt that My Samurai probably wants to trade on what was even in its early 90s theatrical and home video premieres a certain nostalgia for 1984's The Karate Kid, but the fact that My Samurai...
Total: 40
I've frankly been kind of surprised at times to see how many people actually remember and are excited by the Blu-ray releases of any number of these cult outings that MVD Rewind has been "excavating",...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
Goofy ‘90s wear produces great visual energy, and Lee spends a chunk of the movie in a Freddy Krueger-like sweater with outstanding reds....
Audio: 2
PCM or not, the persistent static buries fidelity, and dialog is echo-y enough to be rendered unintelligible....
Extras: 80
He gives a 24-minute interview where he watches his scenes (playing one of the lead gang members) for the first time – he never saw the movie before....
Movie: 20
So here, the Korean Lee battles Mako’s thugs and inspires a young boy (John Kallo) to concentrate, the closest thing to an actual martial arts lesson anywhere in My Samurai....
Total: 41
Patterned after (or just plain ripping off) Karate Kid and Ninja Turtles, My Samurai lacks zest, energy, or logic....
Director: Fred H. Dresch
Actors: Julian Lee, Tupper Cullum, C. Edward McNeil
PlotPeter McCrea, an ordinary teenager, becomes an unwitting witness to a brutal crime involving a powerful mob boss. His life is suddenly thrown into chaos as he finds himself targeted by the mob. With his life in jeopardy, Peter finds an unlikely protector in Toru, a martial arts master who has taken a vow to protect the innocent. Toru decides to take Peter under his wing, not only to shield him from danger but also to teach him the ways of self-defense and discipline. They both embark on a journey filled with rigorous training sessions where Peter's physical and mental limits are continuously pushed.
As they grow closer, Toru and Peter form a strong bond, becoming more like family than just student and teacher. Along the way, their loyalty and courage are challenged as they face numerous confrontations with the mob's ruthless henchmen. Toru must put his formidable samurai skills to the test in order to thwart the relentless pursuers and protect Peter. The duo's resolve and solidarity are eventually tested in a climactic battle that promises significant consequences for both their futures.
Writers: Richard Strahle
Release Date: 24 May 1992
Runtime: 87 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English