Whiskey Tango Foxtrot Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot impresses with Tina Fey's stellar performance and strong audio-visual quality, but suffers from a scattered plot and underwhelming extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS:X
DTS-HD MA
Video: 78
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot's Blu-ray presents a generally solid 1080p transfer. Colors are generally neutral and balanced, with vibrant visuals in daytime scenes. Noise is occasionally bothersome. Black levels and shadow details are commendable, while resolution and texture detailing—especially of skin, fabrics, and backgrounds—are exceptional.
Audio: 85
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot's DTS:X and 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio soundtracks deliver an exceptionally immersive and robust experience, featuring powerful low-end effects, clear dialogue, and expansive surround sound that adeptly captures both action-packed sequences and quieter character-driven moments.
Extra: 37
The Blu-ray extras for 'Whiskey Tango Foxtrot,' including featurettes on casting, creating an authentic military environment, and cultural sensitivity, provide valuable behind-the-scenes insight and showcase Tina Fey's growth, enriched by Kim Barker's real-life experiences.
Movie: 63
'Whiskey Tango Foxtrot' provides an intriguing yet uneven look at the life of a war correspondent, bolstered by Tina Fey's outstanding dramatic lead. The film combines vignettes of humor and peril, capturing the surreal experiences in Afghanistan, but suffers from pacing issues and a scattershot narrative.
Video: 78
"Whiskey Tango Foxtrot" presents a solid, if not extraordinary, 1080p Blu-ray transfer, boasting a first-rate MPEG-4 AVC encode. Replete with exceptional definition and resolution, this transfer consistently captures intricate details. Skin and makeup textures are rendered with lifelike precision, while fabrics in military vests and women's headscarves exhibit remarkable clarity. The New Mexico landscape (standing in for Afghanistan) unveils a detailed and exotic terrain; every pebble, rock pockmark, and distant rock formations are crisply defined.
Video quality maintains a superior contrast balance, especially impressive during nighttime and poorly-lit interior scenes, offering crystal-clear visibility of background elements like tapestries and decorations. Daytime sequences are intentionally hot, with whites blooming slightly without clipping or washing out details. An inky richness characterizes the blacks, delivering luxurious gradations and deep shadows that enhance the film's cinematic allure. The film’s earthy color palette—from browns and golds of the dusty terrain to occasional vibrant primaries—presents a neutral yet flavorfully warm aesthetic.
Depth, spacing, and smoothness are also on point across the board. The video demonstrates great spacing between objects and people, with movements displayed cleanly and smoothly. Skin tones appear lifelike throughout, detailing makeup, wrinkles, stubble, blood, and sweat convincingly. While background noise is generally light, it spikes occasionally but does not significantly detract from the experience. With its sharp image and vibrant color reproduction, "Whiskey Tango Foxtrot" offers a generally splendid high-definition presentation optimized for the Blu-ray format.
Audio: 85
"Whiskey Tango Foxtrot" delivers an exceptionally potent DTS:X soundtrack, adding overhead channels to the standard 7.1 mix, resulting in a rich and immersive auditory experience. Reviewed on an 11.1 setup with four height channels, the opening sequence features "Jump Around," aggressively positioned on the soundstage and dominating the low-end. The sound design crafts a vivid sense of place, with overheads enhancing explosions, plane rattles, and helicopter buzzes. Clarity remains consistently high through intense moments, and the aggressive, seamless spacing of sound across speakers adds to the thrilling ambiance. Dialogue is impeccably presented with excellent front-center positioning and seamless prioritization, even during demanding scenes.
For systems not supporting DTS:X, the track defaults to a highly satisfying 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio. This front-heavy presentation transforms when the setting shifts to Afghanistan, with expansive imaging of city chatter, horns, and blowing dust effortlessly moving between channels and height channels. Action sequences showcase rumbling explosions and debris spread across the entire soundstage and overhead, creating a terrifically engaging wall of sound. The mid-range clarity and definition are superb, with exceptional separation between mids and highs. Vocals maintain distinctness and precision throughout, never overshadowed by the action, while the low-end delivers deep, powerful bass waves that provide palpable weight to gunshots, explosions, and helicopter engines.
The audio design amazes audiophiles with its believable three-dimensional space; atmospherics echo throughout random Afghan street noises and bursts of action, keeping the sound field lively and active. Helicopter blades smoothly move from corner to corner, bullets whiz realistically across the room, and vehicles exhibit flawless panning. Demonstrating demo-worthy moments, especially in military base scenes, this DTS:X track expertly creates an immersive dome-like effect that will impress both casual viewers and audiophiles alike.
Audio Format(s): English DTS-X, English 7.1 DTS-HD MA, English DTS-Headphone X, English Descriptive Audio, French 5.1 Dolby Digital, Spanish 5.1 Dolby Digital, Portuguese 5.1 Dolby Digital. Subtitles: English, English SDH, French, Spanish, Portuguese Dynamics: Seamlessly blends realistic quiet scenes with bombastic action sequences. Low Frequency Extension: Deep bass waves from explosions, gunfire, crashes. Surround Sound Presentation: Engaging use of all channels with accurate placement and movement. Dialogue Reproduction: Clean and crisp with clear diction amidst action.
Extras: 37
The Blu-ray extras for "Whiskey Tango Foxtrot" provide an insightful and comprehensive look into the making of the film. The behind-the-scenes features are rich in detail, exploring a range of topics such as the authenticity of the military environment, the cultural sensitivities surrounding its Afghan setting, and the real-life experiences of Kim Barker, the journalist on whose memoirs the film is based. Interviews with cast and crew offer a deeper understanding of the film's thematic elements and production challenges. The inclusion of extended and deleted scenes supplements the main feature, giving viewers a broader context. Each featurette is thoughtfully curated to enhance the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- All In: The Making of Whiskey Tango Foxtrot: Cast and crew discuss the film's origins, casting choices, military authenticity, respect for Afghan culture, and set designs.
- War Reporter: The Real Kim: Kim Barker discusses her real-life experiences and involvement with the film.
- Embedded In Reality: A look at creating a realistic military setting with actual military experts and assets.
- Wedding Party: Exploration of Afghan cultural elements in the wedding scene.
- Laughing Matters: Insights into the guest house atmosphere for journalists in Afghanistan.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes "Kim and Iain," "Daymare," "Prison," and "Kabul Zoo."
- Extended Scene: An extended look at "The Wedding."
Movie: 63
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot, directed by Glenn Ficarra and John Requa, adapts Kim Barker's memoir, "The Taliban Shuffle: Strange Days in Afghanistan and Pakistan," with Tina Fey taking on the lead role as journalist Kim Baker. The film offers a sprawling narrative that attempts to balance the chaotic realities of war journalism with moments of humor and personal growth. Fey's portrayal of Baker showcases her versatility as she navigates the tumultuous landscape of early 2000s Afghanistan against a backdrop of helicopter noise, gunfire, and cultural missteps. Despite numerous poignant instances throughout its run time, the film struggles to establish a consistent rhythm, often feeling more like a collection of vignettes than a tightly-knit narrative.
Tina Fey's performance stands out as a significant strength, blending her well-known comedic timing with a deeper, more dramatic range appropriate to the gravity of the setting. Her character’s interactions with a diverse supporting cast—including Stephen Peacocke, Christopher Abbott, Martin Freeman, Margot Robbie, Billy Bob Thornton, and Alfred Molina—provide a textured glimpse into the life of a war correspondent. These relationships lend authenticity but also highlight the somewhat scattershot nature of the screenplay by Robert Carlock. The film oscillates between moments of light-heartedness and stark reminders of the inherent dangers, creating an uneven yet compelling depiction of life in a war zone.
The film's examination of Baker's journey is less a linear tale and more a series of episodic experiences that reflect the unpredictable and often surreal nature of her environment. This approach offers both benefits and drawbacks; while it allows for varied explorations of Baker's struggles—cultural assimilation, professional rivalry, romantic entanglements—it sometimes detracts from narrative cohesion and pacing. Nonetheless, Fey’s performance elevates these scenes, combining her characteristic wit with a palpable vulnerability. Whiskey Tango Foxtrot ultimately provides an engaging look at the behind-the-scenes realities of war journalism, albeit one that could have benefitted from a more focused and streamlined script.
Total: 71
"Whiskey Tango Foxtrot," an adaptation of journalist Kim Baker's memoirs, offers a compelling yet somewhat scattered portrayal of life as a war correspondent. Tina Fey delivers one of her strongest dramatic performances, bringing depth to both Kim's professional journey and personal growth. Although the film traverses through several years of dynamic experiences in a war-torn foreign land, it sometimes struggles with pacing and cohesion. The episodic structure can feel choppy and risks diluting the emotional impact. Despite this, the film maintains a heartwarming quality, punctuated with endearing and memorable moments that add significant value.
Technically, the Blu-ray release excels in both audio and video quality, providing an immersive viewing experience. The reference-grade audio brings the film's explosive sequences and subtle dialogues to life, effectively enhancing the viewer's connection with the story. Similarly, the high-quality video presentation captures the diverse and often harsh landscapes with remarkable clarity and detail. However, the supplementary material offered on the Blu-ray is somewhat lackluster and generic, falling short of providing deeper insights or added value to the core content.
In conclusion, "Whiskey Tango Foxtrot" is a well-made film that, while occasionally lacking focus, showcases Tina Fey in an exceptional role that is worth watching. The Blu-ray release's top-notch audio and video make it a worthy addition for fans and those interested in contemporary war narratives. Although the bonus content is not particularly noteworthy, the overall package merits recommendation, especially for those looking to see Fey’s most distinct and notable performance to date.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
The more raw, somewhat run down Afghan backgrounds -- buildings, rocks -- present with a fair sense of realistically tangible textural surface definition....
Audio: 90
Dialogue is the other core driver here, and it's presented with excellent front-center positioning and seamless prioritization, even through the track's more demanding moments....
Extras: 50
All In: The Making of Whiskey Tango Foxtrot (1080p, 14:12): Cast and crew discuss the film's origins in the life of reporter Kim Barker, casting decisions, Tina Fey's growth as an actress in a new style...
Movie: 60
A far cry from her SNL appearances and tied-at-the-hip partner Amy Poehler, Fey's performance finds a personal depth, removed from yuck-yuck laughs and fights to uncover the truth of who her character...
Total: 70
It's too scattered and lacking in focus, trying to cram years worth of experience in a foreign land, life amongst a smorgasbord of personalities, living each day in harm's way, and amplified personal growth...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
A great deal of the palette is generally geared towards the warmer yellow-orange colors, but primaries still pop with intensity and energy while the softer hues add variety, making this a splendid high-def...
Audio: 100
From the random noise of the Afghan streets to the sudden, unexpected bursts of action, atmospherics continuously echo throughout, keeping things lively and active while nicely adding to a satisfying soundfield....
Extras: 20
Wedding Party (HD, 5 min) — A brief discussion on the cultural differences while remaining focused on shooting a wedding scene that takes place halfway into the film and its significance....
Movie: 60
Along with also having to adjust to military conduct while on the field, these moments make up the majority of the comedy, but of more interest is how the script by Fey's long-time collaborator Robert...
Total: 80
Although a bit choppy and episodic without really taking many risks with its predictable plot, the film, in the end, accomplishes its mission and as intended with several endearing moments that make it...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
Shading is well done and detail still shimmers through on dark hair surfaces and clothing....
Audio: 100
Its a well rounded mix, featuring good layers and full sounding effects woven in with good balance to the vocals and music....
Extras: 50
All In: The Making of Whiskey Tango Foxtrot (HD, 14:12) – A safer making of that has interviews with cast and crew that goes over the tone, the source material and keeping it authentic on set....
Movie: 80
No, this isn’t 13 Hours level of intensity or action, but its enough to counter the light hearted tone at times and really get your attention and concern for the safety of the characters involved raised....
Total: 70
Both Kim’s arc and Tina Fey’s performance are reason enough to see the film and in a just world, would be commended with some Academy notice next year....
Director: Glenn Ficarra, John Requa
Actors: Tina Fey, Margot Robbie, Martin Freeman
PlotKim Barker, a disillusioned American journalist, takes on a risky assignment in Afghanistan during the early 2000s, hoping to escape her mundane life. Thrust into the chaotic and unfamiliar environment of Kabul, she struggles to adjust but gradually finds her stride through the guidance of seasoned journalists and local contacts. Amidst the turmoil, Kim's newfound camaraderie with fellow reporter Tanya Vanderpoel and Scottish photographer Iain MacKelpie helps her navigate the dangerous landscape, while also highlighting the absurdities and dark humor inherent in war reporting.
Kim's dedication to uncovering stories brings her closer to the harsh realities faced by both soldiers and civilians. Her experiences not only reshape her professional perspective but also challenge her personal ideals. Through the myriad dangers and unpredictable events, Kim's journey becomes one of self-discovery and resilience, as she learns what it truly means to report from the front lines.
Writers: Robert Carlock, Kim Barker
Release Date: 04 Mar 2016
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Pashtu, Dari, French