Nim's Island Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Nim's Island delivers stunning visuals and engaging family-friendly fun, although it may not fully captivate adults; the Blu-ray presentation is top-notch with impressive picture quality and strong audio.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 59
Nim's Island on Blu-ray offers a 1080p high-definition transfer with vibrant colors and exceptional detail, though some reviews noted oversaturation and contrast issues affecting realism. The source remains sharp and clean, with rich black levels and minimal compression artifacts, making it a visually engaging but imperfect presentation.
Audio: 64
Nim's Island offers an engaging DTS-HD MA 5.1 track with well-prioritized dialogue, immersive ambient effects, and smooth directional sound, capturing natural nuances vividly and featuring strong, balanced bass, effectively creating a lively and immersive audio experience.
Extra: 51
"Nim's Island" Blu-ray offers a robust array of extras, including engaging audio commentaries, insightful featurettes on production and characters, and interactive games. Highlights are two commentary tracks—one kid-friendly with Jodie Foster and Abigail Breslin, and another informative track with directors Levin and Flackett. Video materials are standard-definition, complemented by deleted scenes and trailers.
Movie: 61
A visually stunning children's adventure with charming performances and appealing characters, 'Nim's Island' combines whimsical storytelling with elements of fantasy and family bonds, despite uneven narrative execution and some questionable casting.
Video: 59
The Blu-ray release of "Nim's Island" delivers a mixed visual presentation. The film is presented in 1080p high definition with a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, resulting in an image that showcases both strengths and weaknesses. Positive aspects include impressive sharpness and well-defined textures, from the rugged rock faces to intricate details on clothing. The lush and vibrant colors beautifully encapsulate the scenic beauty of the island, although some hues appear oversaturated, leading to inconsistencies with flesh tones occasionally appearing unnaturally orange. Black levels are commendably deep and accurate, contributing to a generally pleasing overall visual experience.
However, the transfer does exhibit a few notable shortcomings. While the AVC MPEG-4 codec ensures sharpness and minimal compression artifacts, there are instances of noise and oversaturation that detract from the film's realism. Contrast levels are sometimes overly hot, which impacts finer details and tonal balance. The high levels of noise in certain scenes and sickly appearance of flesh tones further mar the otherwise strong presentation. Despite these issues, the Blu-ray remains clean and free from major compression issues, maintaining consistent sharpness throughout the viewing experience.
In conclusion, while "Nim's Island" on Blu-ray offers a generally fine presentation with lush scenery and brilliant colors, there are certain technical drawbacks that prevent it from achieving the highest tier of video quality. Its vivid imagery and detailed landscapes make it suitable for demonstrating home theater capabilities, yet the issues with contrast, noise, and color balance may leave discerning viewers feeling underwhelmed. Nonetheless, it remains an enjoyable visual treat for fans of the film.
Audio: 64
Nim's Island" is presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 (48kHz/24-bit), providing an active and engaging sound design that consistently complements the high-quality visuals. Dialogue prioritization is superb, with no noticeable placement or volume issues, even during understated sequences. Surround channels are utilized effectively for both ambient sounds and action sequences, enhancing the immersion. The sounds of nature on the island and discrete effects are particularly notable, such as the subtle background noises when Nim speaks with her father about Alex Rover in chapter two.
The audio track boasts a commendable dynamic range, demonstrated through various atmospheric elements. A quintessential example is the all-encompassing rainstorm in chapter three, which delivers an immersive experience with natural sounding rain and thunder from every direction. The bass presence is balanced and impactful without being overpowering, particularly during intense sequences like the mini-disaster on the volcano in chapter eight.
Action scenes benefit from precise directionality and smooth pans, creating an enveloping soundstage that significantly enhances viewer engagement. The low-frequency effects are employed judiciously, with foundation-rattling impact during a later volcanic eruption in chapter 18, accentuating the on-screen action effectively without overwhelming it. Finally, the climactic storm sequence in chapter 19 showcases the vivid sound design, where the downpour and thunder transport listeners into the heart of the scene. Overall, this DTS-HD MA 5.1 track provides a polished, lively, and immersive audio experience well-suited for "Nim's Island.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray edition of "Nim's Island" provides a comprehensive suite of supplemental features that caters to both hardcore fans and younger audiences. The standout features are two distinct commentary tracks. The first, an adventure commentary, features Jodie Foster and Abigail Breslin, with Foster providing factual insights while Breslin brings a child's perspective, creating an engaging, tour-guide-style discussion. The second track by director/writers Mark Levin and Jennifer Flackett offers in-depth observations on the film's story, production challenges, and effects, making it highly informative and enjoyable. Additional extras include behind-the-scenes glimpses, deleted scenes, featurettes, interactive games, and educational pop-ups, all presented in 480p video quality with English and Spanish subtitles. Overall, this well-rounded package enriches the viewing experience significantly.
Extras included in this disc:
- Adventure Commentary: Jodie Foster and Abigail Breslin discuss the film.
- Director Commentary: Insights from Mark Levin and Jennifer Flackett.
- Nim’s Spyglass: Picture-in-picture behind-the-scenes feature.
- Deleted Scenes: Three scenes with occasional commentary.
- Nim’s Friends: A look at the movie's creatures.
- Abigail’s Journey: Interviews and character discussions.
- Working on Water: Behind the aquatic scenes.
- Interactive Games: Write Your Own Island Adventure!, Coconut Soccer, Seaside Shuffle.
- Island Explorer Mode: Pop-up trivia during the film.
Movie: 61
'Nim's Island' is an endearing family adventure that brings together themes of bravery, imagination, and the importance of overcoming one's fears. Highlighted by remarkable performances from Abigail Breslin, Gerard Butler, and Jodie Foster, the film resonates with viewers of all ages. Breslin brings boundless energy and charm to the role of Nim, while Butler's dual portrayal of Jack and fictional hero Alex Rover adds depth. Foster's performance as the reclusive Alexandra Rover, despite some criticism for overacting, still contributes to the humor and growth presented in the story. The picturesque island setting, vibrant cinematography, and ingenious mix of traditional animation with CGI truly bring the narrative to life.
While 'Nim's Island' excels in visual appeal and instills a feel-good sentiment, narrative coherence and casting choices leave something to be desired. The storyline successfully combines elements reminiscent of 'Robinson Crusoe,' 'Home Alone,' and 'Romancing the Stone,' crafting a nostalgic yet unique experience. However, the film sometimes stumbles due to its chaotic structure and less-than-stellar chemistry between characters. Foster's performance as Alexandra often overshadows her character’s serious undertones, making some pivotal scenes feel forced. Nevertheless, Breslin’s spirited performance compensates for these shortcomings, allowing audiences to remain emotionally invested in Nim’s plight and enjoy her imaginative world.
Overall, 'Nim's Island' triumphs in delivering wholesome family entertainment through its eclectic blend of genres and memorable characters. It strikes a balance between juvenile fantasy and action-adventure while touching upon adult themes of loneliness and courage. Despite its few inconsistencies, the visual splendor and heartfelt performances make it a delightful watch. The film successfully brings viewers into Nim's magical universe, underscored by vivid tropical landscapes that serve as a character in their own right.
Total: 59
"Nim's Island", now available on Blu-ray, presents a delightful adventure tailored for younger audiences. The film features a vibrant visual style that is highly captivating, and the transfer to Blu-ray only enhances its appeal, delivering reference-grade picture quality. The island setting, richly detailed and vibrant, comes alive with stunning visuals that set a high bar for family-friendly eye candy.
The audio quality complements the visual splendor, providing an engaging auditory experience. Dialogue is crisp, and the ambient sounds of the island are immersive. While the soundtrack doesn’t quite overshadow the picture quality, it still offers a robust and enjoyable listening experience. The supplemental features, primarily aimed at a younger demographic, are also commendable, adding value with entertaining and informative content.
In conclusion, while "Nim's Island" may not break new ground in cinematic storytelling, it excels in delivering an engaging and harmless family adventure. The Blu-ray presentation by 20th Century Fox is outstanding, with impeccable picture quality and a strong audio track. Younger audiences will be enthralled, and adults open to light-hearted entertainment will also find enjoyment in this film. For those seeking a charming and visually spectacular family movie night, "Nim's Island" on Blu-ray comes highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
There is some subtle film grain over the image, but it is neither distracting nor a hindrance to the lush scenery and beautiful colors that inhabit the island and now this wonderful Blu-ray disc....
Audio: 90
Another volcano sequence later in the movie in chapter 18 featured a foundation-rattling low end, but it was presented in such a way so as not to overwhelm but to compliment to great effect the action...
Extras: 70
This track, too, has an easygoing feel to it, almost like they are reading a children's story to a group of young children, and this approach works very well for this style of movie....
Movie: 70
First of all, it's a charming, yet predictable, little picture that, despite its kid-oriented style, is a pleasing enough watch for adults who care to lose themselves in the adventure and spirit of the...
Total: 80
If for no other reason, Nim's Island is worth watching for the lavish, stunning visuals that represent the peak of eye candy, and they are only all the more stunning on Blu-ray....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Hues appear plugged up, noise is obvious, and fleshtones are rather sickly -- this is not a flattering look for the actors....
Audio: 80
Directionality is quite sharp during action scenes which creates a very nice "wall of sound" effect, with smooth pans and a consistent bleed....
Extras: 40
All the insight and detail I hoped that Foster would bring to the party is here, with Levin and Flackett discussing the main story and plot points at length, recalling some fun location stories, and dissecting...
Movie: 60
It has a charming child star as its lead, a classic kid-flick plot of the orphan who must go on a grand adventure to repair her idealized family unit, and some wonderfully picturesque locations that always...
Total: 60
'Nim's Island' is a charming little adventure film for the pre-teen set, though it fails to really cross the age barrier and engage us adults as equally....
Director: Jennifer Flackett, Mark Levin
Actors: Jodie Foster, Gerard Butler, Abigail Breslin
PlotA young girl named Nim lives on a remote island with her marine biologist father, Jack. They share the island with various animal friends and lead a content, adventurous life. Nim's favorite pastime is reading books, particularly those featuring Alex Rover, a fictional hero created by an agoraphobic author named Alexandra. When Jack sets out on a scientific expedition and becomes lost at sea, Nim finds herself alone and in trouble. Desperate, she reaches out to the only person she believes can help—Alex Rover.
Back in San Francisco, Alexandra receives Nim's plea for help and, despite her debilitating fears, decides to venture out to assist her. As Alexandra makes her perilous journey to the island, she battles her own insecurities and phobias. Meanwhile, Nim must summon all her courage and resourcefulness to protect her home and itself. The story unfolds in a series of thrilling and heartwarming moments, exploring themes of bravery, friendship, and the strength of the human spirit.
Writers: Joseph Kwong, Paula Mazur, Mark Levin
Release Date: 04 Apr 2008
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English